This chair had a few donuts on the way to the altar. Months ago we announced the impending arrival of Frank Gehry's new Superlight Chair by Emeco, and we were so happy. The design was spare and elegant: thin tendrils upholding a thin curved seat of aluminum. It was shiny. It really was a cool new design. Then the real production model came out, and we want to lodge a protest.
Featured on the cover of DWR's new catalogue, the Gehry Superlight that is being sold - indeed the real, final production model - is not the same chair. It has lost the thin, elegance of the original model we saw, and looks far more like a thick, clumsy institutional chair. Are we crazy for thinking this? Are we the only ones who feel there has been some sleight of hand going on here?
Take a look at the final model (top) and then at the previous press pictures (all following). The final model has lost the articulation and superlight feeling of the original, particularly at the feet, where the corners used to be square. These are different fish, and we aren't happy about it. MGR
Comments (5)
I'm with you on this one. If "God is in the details", somebody changed deities along the way...
I wasn't super-duper in love with the "press" design to begin with, and was thoroughly unimpressed by the final.
For (less of) my money, I'd go with CB2's Aluminum Lilly chair:
http://www.cb2.com/family.aspx?c=206&f=84&q=chair%20silver&fromLocation=Search
or stick with Emeco's ubiquitous and classic Naval chair, or the Phillippe Starck reinterpretation, the Hudson.
I never saw the original press photo, and didn't even like the chair much in the DWR catalog, but I saw it in person and it does have an minimal elegance to it. Perhaps it's changed, but I think the end results still works.
I saw and sat in one of these at a friend's house recently. I never saw the original photos so I couldn't make that comparison at the time, but I will say while it is a bit thick in the legs it doesn't look too bad.. It's also pretty comfy in short doses, with a not-unpleasant give to it.
Another alternative in the minimal, silvery vein:
Karim Rashid's Alo chair, via Moss:
http://www.mossonline.com/asp/productshow.asp?pc_parent_id=21&prd_id=2995
And The Terrence Conran Shop and Conran.com also have the Gehry Superlight, even though DWR says it's their exclusive...
Hi -
Just wanted to write in to address the question of Superlight at The Conran Shop: Our stores in Europe have the product now; our shop in New York does not due to the exclusivity arrangement with DWR. We do, however, have the Alo chair Patrick mentions.
david branham
buyer
The Conran Shop, NYC