It's no secret that many of us here at Unplggd are fans of the iPhone 4, and will probably be purchasing an iPhone 5 when it comes out (in October?). But being the minority within the Unplggd team, personally, these are some reasons that I'd still pick an Android over an iPhone.
10. Google Maps Navigation. If a navigation system is a must in your life, this will probably be the only reason you need to get an Android phone. The Google Navigation app is an excellent navigation that will rival most navigation systems on the market. The best part... it's FREE!
9. Wide selection of devices/carriers. The iPhone is an excellent phone with superb build quality, but not everyone digs the brittle all glass body. Since Android is an open platform, various top-end manufacturers have a wide range of high-quality and well-designed selection. And although the iPhone is on two of the four major carriers (maybe soon to be three?), AT&T along with Verizon have the highest priced monthly plans. If you want to pay less for your phone plans, Android will be your best bet with the lower end carriers.
8. Alternative Keyboard. Sure, iPhone has a great keyboard that probably trumps the much improved Android keyboard. But the beauty of being an open platform is the ability to customize the system, and this includes the keyboard. There are various options for getting better thumb typing options on Android phones, and they are as easy to install as an app. Our favorite Android alternative keyboard is the Swype keyboard, it will revolutionize the way you think of typing on a touchscreen phone, even if you are a die-hard iPhone fan.
7. Alternative App Markets. We love the ability to install different app markets on Android. This is good news to you because different markets, means more competition, and more discount for you. For example, the Amazon appstore has a free app per day feature for high-quality paid apps, and often post discounts on some of the most popular apps.
6. Customizable Home Launcher and Home screens. This is where Android shines over the iPhone. Android puts all your apps under a separate menu option, which gives you the ability to customize the home screens. Personally, I love having a clean look that will actually show off my background and only the few essential apps on the home screen, something I won't be able to do on an iPhone even with Jailbreaking.
5. Flash compatible. This will likely forever be an advantage that Androids have over iOS, at least until Flash is fully phased-out. And although Adobe has recently announced a solution to iOS's ban on all things Flash, it is not a universal solution that will make your iPhone fully Flash capable. Android has Flash built-in and you won't ever see those annoying spaces that asks you to install Flash to see the content.
4. Widgets. This is another software feature that Android has over iOS, the ability to put useful information on the home screen of your phone, instead of having rows and rows of apps. And widgets is a widely supported feature that many app developers utilize. Get your Facebook and Twitter updates or see your day's event laid out in front of you right when you turn on your phone.
3. Expandable memory. It is slightly absurd in the age of super cheap memory that it costs $100 to get 16GB of memory on an iPhone. Most Android smartphones have the ability to expand its storage through micro SD cards, which cost significantly less than the $100 that Apple charges.
2. True Google Voice Integration. We love Google Voice, we love how we can send messages through online, having a unified voicemail that we can access anywhere, we love the super low international call rate. Sure, there is an iPhone Google Voice app but it is not as deeply integrated as it is on Android. On Android, you are able to click the call button or the message button and Google Voice will launch.
1. Custom ROMs. This is definitely our number one reason for choosing Android over iPhone, and it especially appeals to our inner nerds. This is the epitome of an open platform, and where developers truly shine. Custom ROMs are basically a different version of Android that is built upon the stock OS that adds more integrated features, unlike an app. Our favorite of the bunch is CyanogenMod but there are plenty of great ROMs by both domestic and international developers that impresses us.
Comments (31)
This bored me. Is that so wrong? Like with anyone phone decision, it's what you use. None of these things matter to me as I don't/wouldn't use them. All apps are largely released on both platforms anyway so it's not liking you're missing much. How many people REALLY use voice anything?
This is great. It's the first non-iphone biased article I've read on this sight. Can Eric write all the reviews on the Android devices.
Wow, who hacked unplugged and posted a pro-Android article.
Ok, I get it.. the iPhone users are bored by the reasons someone chose the Android phone. I don't care about all 10 of these reasons either, personally..
That being said, I would like an iPhone user to post the reasons they chose an iPhone. I am willing to bet we'd also get a lot of yawns.
Best of all, NO ITUNES!
I don't get why iPhone users get so mad that someone else wants to use an Android phone. Eric likes Android, you may like Android or iOS. Why does everyone always get their panties in a bunch when someone recommends one over the other?
#edit - not referring to the review, but haters (both Android and iOs alike) in general. :)
Here's why I'm switching to an iPhone after my OG Droid is scheduled to be replaced in November:
1. There are accessories EVERYWHERE for iPhone. You're lucky to find a replacement battery for an Android phone, and if you do, you'd better buy it within 6 months, because you may never see it again, except maybe on Ebay.
2. I want full-on integration with everything, from my home stereo to my car, and iPhone just has Android beat on that. It seems like everything, from loveseats to steak knives have iPhone integration.
3. I know that when Apple upgrades to the latest and greatest iOS 3 months from now, my iPhone won't get left in the dust. My Droid went obsolete about a year ago, and it practically forces you to root or get left behind.
2. If, by full-on integration, you mean a cable for your car... those will work with android phones. Heck, it'd probably work with my Sony Walkman tape player.
3. Yes, you may get an update, but just remember that, the older your iPhone gets, the less features of that update your phone will actually get. Older iPhones get updates, but not full updates.
1. This one I can agree on. But, hey, at least you can buy a backup/replacement batter for your android phone...
I think you could've pared this list down by at least half. I'll give you Google Nav, and Google Voice as an advantage to the iPhone. I'm willing to bet the rest of the list didn't factor into your decision.
I was interested to read the post, and grateful that its tone was reasonable. Eric's reasons have nothing to do with me, so it confirmed my choice of an iPhone. But I have no interest in persuading him to use an iPhone; I just want Apple to stay in business so I can keep using mine.
Don't get my wrong guys, I love both platforms and think both have it's ups and downs. Do I wish my phone last more than a day on a single charge, yes. But being a techie, I also love customizing my phone, simply jaillbreaking an iPhone just doesn't do it for me.
Now, if any of my friends come up to me and ask me what their first smartphone should be, I'd probably recommend an iPhone as a good starter phone. Its performance and easy of use are simply unrivaled.
Thanks everyone for the awesome feedback and keeping the discussion civilized!
interesting read. i am impressed by Swype, I admit. I'll save this article to think about again when my iPhone contact expires.
as for those who complain this was too long: Ten points with a small amount of elaboration. Seemed just right to me.
I never realized how great the widget/home screen options were until I got my Android.
For as much as Mac users (disclaimer: I love my Macbook) seem to worship cleanliness and minimalism (ex. the "how to have nothing on your desktop" post a few days ago), it's shocking to me how ugly and rigid the iPhone's display is.
Hah! I just got myself a Blackberry Torch 9850 on Sprint. I upgraded from SERO, for non-smartphones, to SERO-Premium to have a smartphone. SERO is $30/month for 500 min. + unlimited txt, data, Sprint mobile-2-mobile, nights&weekends @ 7 PM. SERO-Premium changes mobile-2-mobile to any mobile-2-any mobile and adds turn-by-turn navigation, but raises the price to $40/month. The fast/responsive Android phones on Sprint are all 4G. The 3G ones are laggy. The Blackberry Torch 9850 is smooth and fast. The iPhone isn't an option on Sprint yet, and even when it becomes available, I doubt it'll have a user replaceable battery. I don't upgrade my phone often and will extend the life of my phone by dropping in a new battery in two years time, the typical lifespan of a lithium battery.
Go Android! When I got my first smartphone a few years ago, I did tons of research and Android came out on top. I compare notes from time to time with coworkers who have different platforms (iphone and Blackberry) and I am always pleased with my choice to go with Android. I also got an Android tablet earlier this year and am quite happy with it. For the things that I do, Android is the best value. I never feel like I am paying too much for the devices and services related to my Android devices and their performance exceeds my expectations. I am glad to see a post about the platform on Unplugged.
Great reason to go Android: T Mobile! Our family operates three smartphones for roughly what one iphone costs per month, with terrific customer service. I also notice my iphone friends having to take their phones in for emergency service at pretty frequent intervals. Don't know what that's all about. Never had an issue with our Androids ( G2Xs by LG ). By the way, I'm a devoted Apple computer user!
I am on my second Android phone (and unless ATT buys T-Mobile, which I am dreading, I will never have the option of buying an iPhone). Swype is nice, but can be frustrating at times for commonly used words that have the same pattern (the/three, or/of/if/I'd/off, etc). I find myself sending text messages that make no sense sometimes when I am typing fast. I like my phone though, especially compared to my first Android phone.
Ability to change the beeping alert for texts besides the six default noises on your phone.
Okay, you got me there, I have Apple, but of all the disadvantages that one blows my mind the most. Most nice things androids have were invented now, in the present day.
My damn "feature" phone in high school that only played tetris could change its text message alert sounds. I now have this amazing smartphone at yet this one single part of it is stuck in the stone age.
Kaete: Apple doesn't want you to change those alerts. Ever been in a crowded place and heard the "Glass" alert sound? You instantly knew someone else was using an iPhone. I'm convinced this is part of a brand awareness strategy.
I've owned the iPhone, the iPhone 3GS and now the iPhone 4 and I've loved them all. I've had a few quibbles with some of the things Apple does, but most of them are being fixed in iOS 5. I can live with the rest.
If you can live with Android, then I'm happy for you, too. I know a lot of people who've bought them and like them a lot. However, among my friends who have switched from an iPhone to Android, the majority are not pleased. Not all, but most. The level of polish just isn't there, according to them. Not in the hardware or the OS itself. I, personally, just have no interest.
All of that is great, but the battery life sucks. Which means, you can't use all of these wonderful features without being tethered. I took my Droid 2 to NYC last year, one data push an hour, and I still had to sit in a pizza joint midday to recharge.
My Droid Incredible is 2 yrs old and I still love it. Thanks for the pro-droid article! I know lots of people are big fans of the iPhone, but my Droid phone is perfect for me, and if I had to replace it tomorrow I'd pick another Droid. Your Mac articles are helpful, but more Droid articles would be very welcome -- not all of us own Apple everything.
I would have liked this to be more specific; 10 reasons why YOU picked an Android over an iPhone, not 10 reasons why somebody out there might want to. Which carrier and device interested you? Which keyboard, and why is it better than iPhone's? What does a custom ROM actually GET you? Otherwise, it reads like marketspeak, and not the article I expected from the title.
I love my android phone. I use google navigation and voice everyday.
I have a Motorola Droid X on Verizon. Had a Blackberry Storm as my first smartphone. Like the DX better than the Storm. Chose DX because iPhone not available on Verizon at the time and had no desire to change carriers for a variety of reasons. I'm still trying to take best advantage of the smartphone, regardless of which phone I have. Feels like a Swiss Army knife and I only use a couple of the blades. On the battery issue, I can go all day without issues unless I watch videos on youtube or downloaded movie. I read books, listen to music and surf the web without needing to recharge midway through the day.
I don't see anything on here that my jailbroken iphone doesn't do/have except for the widgets and a micro sim... which I'm not a fan of anyway.
LOVE my Samsung Captivate Android. A great many of the items on this list are why I went with it over iPhone (that, and most of the smartphone users I asked recommended Android over iOS. That surprised me, but I haven't regretted taking their advice).
Eric, thanks for posting this article ... it was succinct, comprehensive & welcome since I am upgrading my cell tomorrow. Been knee-deep in iPhone, Motorola Atrix, Samsung Captivate & HTC Inspire. Leaning toward the Atrix while wishing it had the HTC's metal body. I had eyes for the iphone 4; but, was blinded by the $200 pricetag (esp with 5 on the horizon) ... pretty steep considering the fact that I plan to insure this phone (since I just lost my old phone on a trip). Don't understand all the yawn complaints here ... of course, tech specs aren't the most riveting reads; but, they are necessary for an informed decision. You & Jason articles were opposites ... you both provided helpful info! Thank you!
@lifeabundant Glad to help! Check out the Smartphone upgrade guide from yesterday, and maybe a WP7 will be thrown in the mix for you.
@Eric C, just now saw your note. I bought a Motorola Atrix (unbelievably $30 at Target! ... you know I loved that! ;-). So far, so good ... except for the awkward fumbling with No need for the GPS I bought two months ago ... cha-ching (I returned the GPS)!
Oops didn't mean to post in the middle of my sentence ... I meant to type "So far, so good ... except for the awkward fumbling with a new phone that's all touch-screen" LOL!
Ive just switched over from iphone 4 to android samsung note and i am loving the phone but finding it a bit confusing to use - im not that great with technology. anyone got any good leads on where to find android 101 or an idiots guide to android phones?