Yes, we know the title is a bit bold, but after doing some research along with a little math we came to this conclusion. Scroll down for our top 3 reasons why you should not buy a locked cell phone. Love locked handsets and disagree? Let us know in the comments!

While the United States may be the "land of the free and the home of the brave," in some areas, the motto seems to have skipped the mobile phone market. When it comes to how we buy cell phones we lag behind other developed nations in a huge way. Take for example, the iPhone. In Apple Stores across the world, UK, Australia, and Canada, to name a few, the phones are sold unlocked. This means you can go in and throw down full price and walk out with an iPhone. You don't need to sign the next two years of your life away to AT&T, but can choose the type of commitment you want to make with a carrier.
Do you get the handset at a reduced cost should you commit to certain carriers? Sure, but you at least have the choice to buy without committing. While you can find a few handsets straight from manufacturer's that don't require a carrier contract to buy, most phones, especially most wanted models, are tied to one and only one carrier that you can't own without signing on the dotted line. Here are our top 3 reasons why you might want to pick up your new iPhone 4 the next time you travel to Canada or Europe:
- Price Today vs Long Term Cost:After doing some currency conversions while at the UK Apple Store, we were at first blown away by how expensive it was. We have been so used to seeing the subsidized price from AT&T that we had forgotten just how much the phone actually costs. However, once we compared monthly savings if we switched to another GSM carrier, we discovered we would pocket over $1000 over the course of the 24 month AT&T contract, which more than makes up for the difference in cost in the handsets. The savings became even more significant when we compared the larger unlimited minute and family plan offerings.
- Coverage: In our apartment one carrier has much stronger service than the other and because we have no landline, choosing the right carrier is crucial. When you have an unlocked phone, you can choose the carrier that best fits your needs, and should they change you can take your handset with you to your new carrier. The investment you have made is with the handset and not with your carrier, so if their service is not up to snuff, switch!
- Traveling: We travel frequently and we have to say there is nothing easier than switching out sim cards. Long distance and roaming fees are no fun, which is why we love being able to remove our American sim and plug in a local card to kiss those fees goodbye.
If you are in the market for a new mobile handset, here are a few things to keep in mind while shopping:
- Legitimate Unlocks Matter: Since unlocked phones are such a great idea, why not just unlock the phone yourself? In the case of the iPhone, doing so pretty much nixes your warranty. While the iPhone does have an international warranty, you can have your iPhone that you purchased in Canada serviced in the UK (exceptions being Chinese and Egyptian iPhones) this warranty does not cover jailbreaking or unlocking the phone yourself. Can the Apple Store tell if your phone was unlocked by Apple/carrier or a jailbreak? Yes, once the phone is plugged in at the Genius Bar, the technician can tell if the unlock was legitimate. If the issue you have with your iPhone could be considered caused as a result of your jailbreaking, good luck getting Apple to repair that.
- Just Say No to eBay: Avoid buying your unlocked phone on eBay or from anyone but the manufacturer or the carrier due to differences in international handsets and the importance of a legitimate unlock. Sure, the seller might say that the phone is a British or Canadian handset, but there is no guarantee that it is not from Egypt or China. For example, Egyptian iPhones do not have GPS and Chinese iPhones lack wifi. Is saving a few hundred dollars worth purchasing a phone that does not have all the features it purports to or a warranty in the country you live in? That is a call only you can make, but for this writer, the risk is nowhere near worth it.
Is this the right choice for you? Ultimately that is a decision that you will need to make, for us it was a no brainer. Will we miss visual voicemail? Yes, but we are very money conscious and cannot justify the additional cost we are paying each month for sub-par service, even though it includes voicemail that we know and love. We hope that the United States will soon join the mobile freedom ranks, but until then we will continue our practice of buying phones while out of the country.
For more posts on saving money on tech and home office bargains, check these out:
(Image: Flickr user Ninja M. under license from Creative Commons.)
Comments (9)
Actually, here in the UK it's CHEAPER on contract, and you can get a 12 month contract.
For example:
Tesco 12 month £20 contract (250 mins, unlimited texts, 1GB data) iPhone 4 16GB = £240 £349 = £589
giffgaff 30 day rolling £10 sim (100 mins, unlimited texts, true unlimited data) iPhone 4 16GB (from Apple) = £120 £499 = £619
If you wanted the 32GB iPhone it'd be an extra £80 and £100 respectively.
The Tesco network is actually the O2 network, which has some of the best coverage in the UK.
So you'd save between £30 and £50 for being tied to a 12 month contract.
@ chirho, the post is talking about reasons why those living in the United States should opt for the unlocked phone option. The price comparison that was comparing the cost of the unlocked phone vs a contract with AT&T.
Ah, I meant to say "The price savings of over $1,000 was the result of comparing the cost of another carrier vs AT&T over the length of the contract."
You forgot to mention that while both ATT and Tmobile use GSM their 3G frequencies are different so you'll be stuck with 2g if you get an iPhone and use it with Tmobile.
This article has bad advice all over it.
First off, let me tell you how to save money on an iPhone. You buy it the day it comes out. Then after one year, when you're eligible for an upgrade with ATT, you buy it at the upgrade price. Then you unlock / jailbreak your old iPhone, eBay it, and you end up making a slight profit. So yes... you can get a free iPhone every year.
Second, "avoiding" eBay is stupid. Of course you should be careful, read descriptions carefully, and check the seller rating and feedback. If a seller has sold hundreds of items or more, and their feedback is over 99%, there is no cause for concern. Furthermore, Paypal & eBay's buyer protection policies are top notch (often to the chagrin of the seller).
And third, an unlocked iPhone in the USA can only work on two networks: ATT & T-Mobile. T-Mobile and ATT, however, use different 3G bandwidths so your iPhone will NOT get 3G service if you use T-Mobile. So you can unlock your phone and enjoy the sweet joy of EDGE data on T-Mobile.
So yeah... real genius... Pay a huge premium to get an unlocked iPhone... And then use it on T-Mobile. Great freaking idea.
totally agree with hungarianhc.
I had the original iphone on launch day and kept it until the 3GS came out. Sold it for $325 which almost covered the cost of the 32GB 3GS (damn you CA tax!). This year I preordered the iPhone 4 and sold my 3GS for $400! That more than covered the upgrade.
I always jailbreak/unlock my phones for my own personal pleasure as well as to get the most amount of resale value out of them. I also keep the original box/accessories and take care of my phone so it looks practically new.
Pre-paid people in the US probably benefit the most from unlocked phones. TMO service is no better than ATT and you don't get 3G. when traveling abroad it's nice to have an unlocked phone to use prepaid sim cards.
Cheers,
M
I'm from the UK so I don't know much about the frequencies that the US uses, but T-Mobile USA supports 1700Mhz and 2100Mhz (according to http://support.t-mobile.com/doc/tm23715.xml ). The iPhone supports 2100Mhz. There appear to be other phones on TMobile's website that don't list the 1700Mhz frequency on their specs page but do have 2100Mhz (just like the iPhone) - so if they work…?!?
In response to some of the other comments - speaking as someone who's been jailbreaking ever since it first started on the iPhone (back when it was all manual SSH'ing rather than all this automated jailbreaking malarky) one thing I can say is that whilst jailbreaking can provide additional functionality, it's still not necessarily something that I would advise to most people for a number of reasons;
The first obvious one is that it voids your warranty. You have a nice shiny iPhone which you could end up not being able to have replaced by Apple should something go wrong as they would have a right to refuse service.
There's also more processes running (including the BSD Subsystem) which does two things - firstly it affects performance and as a result it drains your battery more, including reducing the overall lifespan of the battery. This is one of the reasons (besides violating the terms and conditions / licence agreements) as to why it voids your warranty.
It also introduces new issues and more risk of software problems. I've seen jailbroken iPhones which have faults which work fine when restored to the default .ispw file.
The problem for people who purchase jailbroken or unofficially unlocked iPhones and don't know/understand will have problems if they need a replacement and Apple agree to replace the handset. The replacement would be locked to the original carrier and they'd be stuck with a phone which wouldn't work (i.e. can't even be activated for use even like an iPod Touch) with their SIM.
I personally don't Jailbreak now as the software now does the majority of stuff that I wanted it to be able to when I originally started jailbreaking, and I find that the overall performance is better when not jailbroken.
As for eBay - I'd tend to agree that even if the seller is a good seller - you don't know where the iPhone is from. It's true that iPhones from China don't have wi-fi built-in because of government restrictions etc. You also don't know if Apple can service iPhones from all countries - there are some countries where Apple can't even provide warranties for their products (including Macs) and unless you can guarantee the original origin of the handset, it could be a risky manoeuvre - especially as you may not find out if it's eligible for support until you need it.
The other thing is that you never know the history of the handset. A friend of mine bought one off eBay and the home button was a little bit glitchy (not much, but slightly). The problem later got worse and it turned out to be a result of liquid damage and something inside had slowly corroded.
I'm not saying that eBay is a bad thing as yes, there are a load of decent deals out there, but having known a few people with a few horror stories to share (beyond the usual scam attempts) with it it's just one of those things where I personally wouldn't want to take the risk. As such, I agree with the writer who simply advises against it to give you better peace of mind whilst also keeping down costs. When the iPhone is new (i.e. you're it's only owner) and/or you know exactly where it comes from and what you're dealing with - that's always a better option. There's always ways of getting things cheaper and cheaper, but that can sometimes come with additional risks that can end up costing you more in the long run.
Sometimes a cheap iPhone from eBay can be a false economy.
I think i know why we can buy unlocked phones here in Australia.
In Ye Olde Times, before about 2003, phone contracts used to have really huge termination fees in them. Then the regulation changed, and now companies are very limited in the break fees they can charge. The rationale is that it reduces healthy competition when consumers are effectively prevented from changing to better phone rates (and they call us relatively Socialist!). So the break fees are limited to the costs the company incurrs in establishing the contract- the cost of the iPhone, in this case. It removes the premium that companies make when you sign a contract, so it's just as profitable to sell the iPhone on its own.
So go on over to Consumerist and start bleating on about free competition or monopolies or something.
Cheers!
Or you can buy an unlocked phone based on Android that will offer quite the same features for a much cheaper price.
739 € for an iphone 4: http://store.apple.com/fr/browse/home/shop_iphone/family/iphone?mco=OTY2ODA2OQ
that's definitely ridiculous.