Renovating a home, a change in residence, or even the beginning of a new calendar year — these are usually the times when we're seeking a fresh start and end up rushing out to buy just the right little thing to bring our home to the next level. I'm all for the idea of fresh start, but I think sometimes we don't put much thought into these purchases, often buying on a whim, simply because they aren't our expensive, big-ticket items. Here are some thoughts on when to save — and what it's okay to splurge on.
For my situation, I was renovating and moving, from an apartment we'd outgrown to a house we could barely furnish. But instead of running out to buy things to fill our new space, I knew we were on a tight budget and decided we would have to prioritize. Pricey furniture was out of the question, and we'd already decided we were fine living with what we had, so we could save for what we really wanted. Deciding not to buy furniture allowed me to think long and hard about the smaller items we'd need to buy or replace, the items you usually don't give much thought to at all. And now that I've been living here for a few years, I've had a chance to reflect on what has worked for me, what hasn't, and why. Here are 5 things I'm glad I splurged on.
1. Door Mat - Because it's the first thing you see when you walk into someone's home! That's probably the main reason anyone ever puts much thought into the doormat, but I urge you to consider function over beauty. My coir doormats drove me crazy by tracking in unwanted coir fibers, but yet I kept buying them. Not to mention, I would usually go through at least two a year. I did my research and decided on the Cape Cod Doormat, a little more money from the start, but way cheaper in the long run. After countless pretty doormats failed me, I finally got it right. My Cape Cod mat comes with no mess and has been going strong for over two years!
2. Entryway Rug - This is one area I always thought it was smart not to splurge on. I mean it's heavily trafficked, gets dirty and needs constant washing or replacing. Years practicing this theory proved I was dead wrong. The Problem: I have gone through about five different rugs in my entryway. With one pitiful rug pad and two dogs that rush the front door every time they hear a noise, I was forever straightening, fixing and flattening the front rug. The Solution: Modular carpet tiles by FLOR. Yes, they were way more expensive from the start, but they stay in place and their modular tile design allows them to be hosed off, cleaned, and replaced whenever necessary.
3. Powder-Coated Boot Tray - My Martha Stewart powder-coated boot tray has been with me for the long haul. It's the first and only boot tray I've ever bought and it's still going strong. I remember doing quite a bit of research for such a small investment, and eight years ago when I bought it, dropping $100 on a boot tray was not really in my budget. But I didn't have an entryway and knew I wanted something simple, attractive and most of all, functional. To this day, I can still say it has never once leaked and has no rust spots.
4. Dish Rack - My dish rack also survived the move from the apartment to the house and is still with me today. I remember combing The Container Store and other big box stores for a stainless steel rack before eventually settling on one from Williams Sonoma. Now that I live in a house with a dishwasher, I would eventually like to replace it with one that doesn't take up as much counter space, but I imagine it will still be here serving its purpose for a couple more years.
5. Cutlery Organizer - When we renovated, we were able to splurge on a nice kitchen cabinets. It was such a luxury and such a step up from my apartment's gritty, rusted steel cabinets that I thought putting in plastic drawer organizers would be a shame. I splurged on beautiful bamboo ones that complemented the interior of my cherry drawers and every time I open them, I love what's inside. I've never thought much more about them until the other day when a friend was over and commented on how nice my drawers were. The same comment would have never been made if I rushed to fill them with their ugly plastic counterpart, which I would have eventually replaced anyway.
The message I'm hoping to communicate is not to run out and buy everything I recommend, but rather think about what you already have and how it works for you or works against you. By arming yourself with that knowledge, you can research what might be a better product for you — improving upon the flaws of your last one — and leaving you to make a more thoughtful decision (where you'll actually spend less in the long run).
(Image: Jill Slater for Doryn's Glamorous Return to the City)

Sheex Bedding
Great advice. In the end, it's about what's important to you. Everyone's splurge list will be different, but doing research and paying more for quality items that you love is something everyone should try to do when their budget allows it.
Switchplates and plug plates...changing out my old/painted-over-50x plates made a huge difference...I found a set of 10 fancy vintage ones on eBay for $5, and I wallpapered or handpainted some of the builder grade ones I couldn't replace--they just make a room look sharp.
Also a big fan of the right light bulb...I like a natural-vintage light quality, and there are a few specific brands that deliver on that--dim pantry light: gone...overly bright desk lamp: handled.
Also have to say that spending $5 more on a good quality toilet seat is worth every penny--no more creaky/cracky/flimsy/cheap looking seat.
I love this. For me, the best splurge items are always things that I use every.single.day. I'm still sad we didn't splurge when our kitchen faucet needed to be replaced, because I use it all the time, and I *really* enjoy our bathroom faucets, which were much more thought-out and are really nice. I am on the lookout for a really fabulous welcome mat, and/or boot tray.
Ugh. I LOATHE dishracks. Awful, ugly, hulking, clutter-gathering space hogs. For years, I just put a cloth down to set any drying dishes on, but that was not so good on my butcher block counters. So, I finally settled on a cookie sheet topped with a dish cloth and then a cooling rack that fits perfectly in the sheet. I change out the cloth regularly so it never ooks grungy. This solution is nice and low-profile.
I do think I need to get a boot try...
I will be looking into a "cape cad" doormat because mine is also falling apart and was bought as a cheap afterthought when we moved into our house.
Your $100 powdercoated boot tray really has me thinking DIY though:
Take this
http://www.therestaurantstore.com/18-x-26-18-Gauge-Full-Size-Aluminum-Bun-Pan-Sheet-Pan/407BUNFULL.html
Spray it with any color of this
http://www.lowes.com/pd_239873-90-258199_4294720379__?productId=3728807&Ntt=rustoleum&pl=1¤tURL=%3FNtt%3Drustoleum&facetInfo=
And boom, it'll look just like the tray in your picture. By the way those pans are great for baking too, I have 4.
This is apropos as I am buying my first apartment, estate condition, and am planning a nearly-full reno. Things like 'nice switchplates' keep coming on and off the list as I try to prioritize what's important.
ugh, i just made this mistake yesterday. i bought a cheapo tv tray to try some diy crap on instead of buying the compact console table i need for my entryway
One of the first things that we replaced in our "original 1973" estate house were the all of the light switches and outlets. Made me feel a little safer, plus we tossed the ivory plastic and got bright and clean white. Since then we've put in additional lights/switches, done lots of updating, and the switches and plates are easy to match and look clean.
I've found that just using a dish drying mat is way better and more aesthetically pleasing than a dish rack (and cheaper!). I have a dishwasher so the things I have to handwash are usually either delicate or too big and awkwardly shaped for the dishwasher. This means they are also too big and awkwardly shaped for a dish rack as well. Plus it takes up virtually no space, I can just roll it up and throw it under the sink when not in use.
And I can throw it in the washer when it needs to be cleaned. Hand washing off the gunk that builds up on dish racks is not fun.
When we moved in we really need a rug at the door to save the hardwood floors from dirt being tracked in so we went to the big box store and bought something. It has two qualities - being brown you don't notice it as much on the hardwoods and it can be hosed off (we have dogs).
I have been considering Flor tiles for a few months now and you just helped me make a decision. I think I will get some for the front and back doors..... Thank you!
Thinking about a boot tray too but there isn't really room.
I live in a tiny home (RV) so everything in the home eventually winds up on display. So I pay attention to the smallest details and I will pay to get things that match my decor perfectly, from a wooden dish rack that matches my woodwork to a stapler the same colour as the curtains. It just all pulls the space together and makes it feel more like a home than an RV.
It's such a victory when I find a small trash can that fits my space, pretty organizers for my narrow bathroom cabinet (http://travelswithmiranda.uskeba.ca/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/IMGP3988.jpg), etc. I might have been able to find non-matching things that are cheaper, but I know I won't be eager to replace any of these splurges.
The only thing I won't splurge on is the doormat because my cats seem to think it's the perfect place to hack up hairballs!
....on the other hand: I've had the same IKEA plastic cutlery organizer for over 10 years and I won't replace it any time soon because it is the only one that fits our oddly sized drawer perfectly.
we completely remodeled out kitchen almost 2 years ago & in an effort to get as much stuff off the counter, i splurged & bought the large Knife Dock from The Container Store. i caught so much grief about how expensive it was but, like this article says, it makes all the difference any time i open that drawer. i LOVE the functionality & how it looks & have NEVER 2nd guessed that purchase!
the 2nd item was our faucet. i searched forever for something minimalist. i finally found a faucet i loved in a local showroom but was too shell shocked to lay down the $2K+ they wanted for it. my husband did a lot of online searching & found it for a bit cheaper. i was still hesitant. then a friend said you have to remember you're going to touch this multiple times every day. it may be expensive, but if you love it you will never regret it. she could not be more right! 2 years later, i still love that faucet & it gets lots of attention for it's originality.
as sprayfaint said, you just have to prioritize what you can live with for now until you get what you really want, and what you absolutely cannot live without & adjust that list! we've held off on plenty of things because we realized they just weren't as important in the larger scheme of things.
http://www.apartmenttherapy.com/dish-rack-24268 is the rack!
We don't have a dishwasher, so a drying rack is a necessity. We have a nice stainless steel one that's dipped in rubber to about a 3rd up. It looks cool and the rack never slides around. Our kitchen sink has an extension on the counter that the rack sits on, so it doesn't have to be on the counter itself.
i love and can't do without my rack sack kitchen trash container. i also have a smaller rack sack bathroom container. i have a very small house and don't have to use valuable floor space for a trashcan. i first saw these in Canada when visiting relatives. http://www.organizeit.com/rack-sack-kitchen-trash-can-system.asp
well worth having and using each day.
We finally have a dishwasher as well, but I also bought a folding dishrack with an absorbent pad to put underneath as we do still hand wash things like our wine glasses, knives, and other stuff that isn't a good idea to throw in the dishwasher. I love it because it folds flat and once everything's dry and put away, I just fold it up and slide it into the cupboard under the sink!
We just shelled out for a SimpleHuman trash can that has the bin on one side for recycling. I've wanted it forever, but never pulled the trigger. It's amazing how much better our kitchen looks with that one thing, and so far, I get happy every time I step on the thing to open it.
A nice trash can is something I plan on spending some money on when I move in the fall. For years I've hated the cheap, plastic trash can that we got because we thought a trash can was a silly thing to spend money on. But it's ugly and a pain to clean and it's something that we use and look at every day. It's one of those things around the house that you certainly don't *need* a fancy version of, but one that can collectively create a much more pleasing living environment.
For us it was a doorbell! When we moved in we had an electric doorbell that didn't work and replaced it with a really cheesy electric doorbell that failed on our first Halloween. Disaster! Now we have the doorbell I've always wanted, one with a screw like a bike bell (our house is small enough to hear it from everywhere, but probably not ideal for big place).
Which brand of light bulbs do you recommend? Thanks.
@foddefafa and others who want to buy a nice expensive trash can: I splurged on a beautiful retro stainless steel can with a swinging-door opening in the lid for my kitchen. After a week, I hated it. The closed lid turned the garbage into a swampy, stinky mess, which spewed its odor into the kitchen every time I dropped something into the swinging door. No more closed-lid garbage cans for me. I ended up clearing out the cupboard under the sink and got a nice short, plastic can with no lid. I have to empty the trash daily (sometimes more if I'm cooking) but no more smelly kitchen. The beautiful retro can went to the charity shop.
I recently splurged on an amazing simplehuman compost pail. We live in rural area where no garbage pick up is available, (mostly due to the wildlife in the area) so it's important to have a solid compost pail that doesn't smell and is easily transportable by car (ie - doesn't tip over or the lid falls off mid-garbage trip!)
Madame P-where did you find your doorbell-- one with a screw like a bike bell ???....my house would love to have one also!
Denacho,
Thanks for the shout out! Thrilled to hear that you enjoy our product.
Pro tip: the knife dock is also available online from us (the manufacturer) with free shipping at www.knifedock.com. :)
I bought a Cape Cod Doormat and love it! It removes all the debris from our shoes and my floors are so clean. The mat is beautiful too, I get compliments all the time. I love that they are handmade in USA! Thanks!