I have come to a real crossroads in my life. I blog about tech stuff but what is really going on? We all want the economy to come back, but do we really want it to be on the backs of more indentured servants? How many times do we have to do that before we realize that a lot of people are in a lot of pain so that we can have little rushes of materialistic pleasure that only support our turning away from the unified truth that we are all one organism? Since when is the heart happy when the liver is dying?
Do you think a company like Apple doesn’t know what is going on at their factories? I feel like someone like Steve Jobs, who has experienced so much success from his own type of ruthlessness, just doesn’t have time to care.
I have a friend who works for ILM and I asked him about Jar Jar when that movie came out. He basically said that everyone except George Lucas and Ahmed Best knew how Jar Jar would be received. Everyone just had to nod and smile to keep their jobs. I have another friend who said “What? You mean a reclusive billionaire has lost touch with his audience? How unexpected.”
Before it starts to sound like I am pointing fingers at the rich folk, I want to acknowledge that not only do I want to be "rich folk", but I also don’t really think they are the core problem. We all are.
It’s every fanboy out there who thinks that Apple, Sony, Nintendo, Foxconn, Microsoft, Toyota or any other company is going to make the world a better place. Following an outside source for your happiness is the problem.
We have come to believe that people’s complaints are evidence that they deserve scorn and ostracism. There are comments all over the web suggesting that people who have killed themselves building our technology somehow deserve what they got. Read any forum and you will see comments about how hard someone’s job in the States is versus someone in these Chinese factories. As if they should just grin and bear it. This is the opposite of what compassion is: when you know someone’s pain and you tell them that it is how it should be, rather than having the light go on in your head that something is wrong across the board. Somewhere along the line we decided that emotion leads away from dollar signs and the security and sense of accomplishment they represent. I don’t know how we came to view survival of the fittest as a method for engaging each other when it was originally used to describe our evolution through nature.
Suicide should be an obvious sign of something systemic being off. I have felt those pains and inclinations and I can say with certainty that they are not arrived at casually. You want to tell someone how to live their lives then get out of your armchair and deliver the message personally, troll.
I am on the list for an iPad 3G, but I am not going to get it. I am not making a huge stand because my company is about to release two iPad cases for public consumption. I am pissed because I spent many months developing these products and this recent news is just killing me. I can’t afford to drop this line because I turned away some other work to complete it. The thing is, if we boycott all the companies that hurt people, places and things in the process of delivering our goods to us, we will be left with a few organic peas and recycled tire sandals to feed and clothes us.

I used to be more activist minded when I was younger. I ran a small clothing company that used only sustainably sourced materials (hemp and organic cotton) and I ruthlessly hunted down the most ethical methods to bring these products to market, looking for perfect, domestic factories where everyone was treated respectfully. I met all my retailers and insured that they were running perfectly perfect businesses as well.
It was a nightmare. This was back in the 90’s when these practices were significantly less accepted than they are today and believe me when I say that it was like finding needles in haystacks all around the world to get anything done. All materials and methods were way overpriced because of their small scales of production and, along the way, very little money was made. You just can’t run a sustainable business that way. The business also has to sustain itself. When I read about my contemporaries in magazines, it all sounded so ideal and noble, but the reality that everyone lived was very different. Few of those companies are still around and many of the suppliers have turned to other activities.
I had a teacher who told me that you must always have one foot in the known and one in the unknown in innovation. You jump too far ahead and you break ties with your foundation. I think this holds true for all evolution. If we just drop all business everywhere, then we will crash hard. We may come out just fine but a smoother transition is to be had through appropriate change. It can’t be too incremental because the crash can come just as easily if we don’t change quickly enough.
Comments (7)
Apple is always the first place people go when speaking about the environment at Foxconn but, people never mention products like the Kindle, PS2 & 3, Xbox 360, etc. It's not like these other products are not known worldwide. The fact is that a big part of the tech gadgets that we enjoy were made at or have parts manufactured at Foxconn. Acer, Amazon, Android, Apple, Asus, ATI, Cicso, Dell, Hewlett-Packard, Intel, Microsoft, Motorola, Nintendo, Nvidia, Nokia, Palm, Sony/ Sony Ericsson, Zoostorm, all have products being made there.
If you're going to take a stand and boycott, you have to do it completely. You can't just Not by an iPad but get the new Android phone.
I really wish people would read the whole article before commenting.
"It’s every fanboy out there who thinks that Apple, Sony, Nintendo, Foxconn, Microsoft, Toyota or any other company is going to make the world a better place. Following an outside source for your happiness is the problem."
and
"I am on the list for an iPad 3G, but I am not going to get it. I am not making a huge stand because my company is about to release two iPad cases for public consumption."
Both of your points are directly addressed in the post. This article is about trading tech for humanity, not about apple specificaly- apple is not in the title and not even in the front page- as it turns out they are the straw that broke my camel's back and so are highlighted. I also did not say people should boycott. I also did not say that I am boycotting.
I also do not have to do anything completely. Where does that even come from? Some long ago ideal where everything is black and white? Has that ever really existed?
I am specifically saying that change needs to happen and that I believe it should happen in aggressive increments, which, by definition, all but precludes full-on boycotting.
I am going to keep my [1st gen i]phone longer and not buy the 4g when it comes out- maybe do a bit of research to find a more ethically produced phone if it exists. I am not throwing out my ipods and I will continue producing iPad/Macbook cases. CHUNKY INCREMENTS.
Why don't you ask yourself what your comment's ultimate point is. Is it to suggest we do nothing because there is too much intertwining of business with our productivity? Where does your comment lead?
Boycott is a hard action and difficult to maintain in the long run. Going worldwide with it is basically impossible, considering how lazy and inconsistent most people are (especially when it comes to extremes). Boycott requires clear goals, one enemy to be pointed at, very strong will and constant renewal of the anger that drives it. It`s not impossible, but still extremely hard.
Instead of forming an angry mass movement and pointing at one or two big companies, I suggest something else:
Just SLOW DOWN.
Don`t buy gadgets you want, but don`t really need;
Use your tech trinkets until they break, and treat them with care;
Stop buying new clothes / bag / shoes every week, your cabinet is full already;
Look at "made in..." to know the country of product`s origin;
Start visiting local markets and groceries, avoid big supermarkets;
Share things you don`t need every day: why buy a big drill you`d use twice a year? Borrow it from a neighbor.
And so on, and so on... There`s no point in boycott, revolution or whatever you call it. Instead slow down your own consumption. It`s not as radical and "righteous", but since it`s based on compromise, it just might work. Globally.
Great to see a post like this on a site like this. We all need reminders of what's beyond our self-imposed blinders. I've boycott Wal-Mart ever since I saw that expose indy film on them. Now, I know they're not the exception, but rather the rule. Currently, I still boycott them mostly because I'm lucky enough to afford better right now. Anyway, I do what I can, buy what I think is better for the environment, blah, blah, blah. However, as a Consumer Society, if the Producers aren't changing, the Consumers kind of have to go with the flow. The Producers are sort of starting to get the message, but they're still out to make money, not save the world. Just like Mordazy says, I console myself with the idea that if I'M buying conscientiously and doing what I can, then there are at least a handful of other people out there doing the same, and so on.
Mordazy- great way to describe it. Slow down. I think this is exactly what it takes. The hunger we display for our products is out of control.
Conchascafe- we do what we can- this is a great point. I can't do everything, but I can do something.
Peter - I did read your article and since your response, I've read it several times.
The first part of my response, "Apple is always the first place people go when speaking about the environment at Foxconn...", was said because that was the first and only company you spoke about in direct relation to factories.
I get that you mentioned them because as you say, they were YOUR camel's straw. I just find it strange that they are the limit with a lot of people when it comes to Foxconn, even when newer products like the Android phone are being made there but never get linked in a negative Foxconn article.
I don't think your comment of,
"It’s every fanboy out there who thinks that Apple, Sony, Nintendo, Foxconn, Microsoft, Toyota or any other company is going to make the world a better place. Following an outside source for your happiness is the problem.",
would say to someone who may not be familiar with Foxconn that some of these companies have products made there as well so, it could still seem like it's just Apple but, I guess that's a matter of opinion and it might just be how I read it.
As for the boycott, that was just a residual response from many of the comments I've seen in regards to this that say people should stop buying Apple products because of Foxconn. Usually from people who weren't going to buy them in the first place.
That's not what you said so, I shouldn't have tacked that on. My apologies.
Complete boycotts have worked for some things but, the Tech monster is way too big and we are way too integrated in it for that. I guess getting educated about where the things we buy come from and what they actually cost is the first step.
Hey modernguy,
I am a little fired up about this issue so I came on a little strong in my response to your comment- sorry about that. I really feel an imbalance in the world right now to where the intellectual obviousness that we read about has finally turned into something physically tangible. I would hate to think that the things I write about would be construed as anything naive or idealistic because I have lived among and visited many cultures over the years.
Apple's level of cooperation that it engenders within its own culture and outside its walls is something that I find both admirable and terrifying in that they are able to deliver what they set out to but they also seem to "enable" people to forget about what is real and meaningful. Their use of the word "Magical" is another place where I think their coolaid is getting a little syrupy.
My overall message is about the imbalance, however, and that is something that is going to bite everyone in the a$$ if we do not make honest changes. This extends way beyond electronics as every product we buy tends to come from overseas. From personal experience, I can tell you that manufacturing here is very difficult because you get charged for every tiny little detail as it all represents actual time. You can't blame American manufacturers but the customers generally only care as much as they are able to afford- they will often get quite nasty when prices get "realistic", actually.
This self importance is founded in an old paradigm where there was always someone "below" us; a worker who was supposed to fulfill our whims and thank us when we were ungrateful for the service. Our delusions are crashing down now and all we have to yell at for our discomfort is our ignorance.
Anyway, thanks for the input- you've helped to flesh out the story.