Back in May, Karen asked the Apartment Therapy readers for suggestions on what colors to use for the exterior of her historic home in Jamaica Plain. She was also thinking about using multiple colors — switching up the shades for the first and second floors. Well, the job is finally done, and she was kind enough to send in a fantastic "after" photo …

Here is what Karen had to say about the project:
We struggled all summer with the right way to paint the exterior and finally, a week before the painter was ready to start, had to make a decision. Luckily, a house in an adjacent neighborhood, that I had admired for years, had just completed their renovation and exterior painting, so I simply left them a note, asking their colors. And I lucked out and found a sympathetic home owner who was more then happy to share (and commiserate on the process)! First floor clapboards: Gloucester Sage (kind of an olive green/gray) Second floor shingles: Princeton Gold Trim: Abingdon Putty Doors, windows, deck floors: Wenge Now we just have to hope the lilacs, forsythia and groundcovers along the driveway grow back in the Spring! Thanks for posting and for all the ideas from the readers...they were definitely helpful in the process.
Looks wonderful — thanks for the followup, Karen!
ORIGINAL POST:
• Exterior Paint Color Suggestions for Historic Home?
(Images: Karen)
(Re-edited from a post originally published 11.08.10 - NM)
Comments (41)
wow subtle yet huge change!
I do not like two colors together but it works with this house. The lower section color makes it feel grounded and the upper yellow is very nice color.
Wow I didn't even notice those upper banisters before the color change. Well done.
Before I saw the after, I thought "yellow" - so I was happily surprised. Breaking up the height of such a tall house with a different color on the ground floor makes the house look stately - I don't know that I would have thought of it or gone that way -- but now that I see it done that way, I like it (balances the color of the roof). Spring/summer plantings and flowers will bring your scheme to life. Best wishes!
Personally I would have gone with the green for all the levels, but this looks nice too. It's nice to see someone in this area trying to draw attention to the age of their home rather than mask it with weird siding or boring neutrals.
I like the two-tone, which is what I suggested - the house does appear far more grounded w the green first floor.
Great balance created with the colour change and now you really notice the details of the home which were lost in the sea of white before.
Two-tone! I would never think to do that. It looks gorgeous!
Love it!
Worth the struggle! Looks great.
In Jamaica Plain?.... Why not rally 'round the RED, green, and gold!! Add that third color up top!
I freaking love this so much.
Great job. It looks amazing!! I also second the feeling of relief that siding was not the answer!!
Please tell me this is not a one-family home but an apartment block... it's huge!
(p.s. nice paint job)
Looks great! So glad to see people appreciating their wood siding :-). I also love that you had the gutters painted to match.
lucica, if it's original, this is likely a two family...smaller apartment on the first floor, and larger on the second and third. Variations on this are very common in the area. Perhaps Karen lives in one unit and rents the other.
It's lovely but... one home? How many people live here?!
applause applause!
In the first photo, you can see two mailboxes, so it's at least a two family.
The two-tone makes the house look less monolithic. Well done!
Nice... THAT HOUSE IS HUGE... How many units are in it?
Love the color on the first floor. The home is a bit of a beast so I can see the desire to go with two-tone.
LOL
Is there a name for that style house? My best friend grew up in the exact same model and I've always loved it.
The yellow is so sunny. Are the colors historically accurate for the home? We have a 1905 foursquare, all brick - so no exterior painting, but I am trying to be period inside.
Beautiful! Great choices.
Looks great!
Two tone is not my thing but love the house! Enough of a voyeur to want to see what it looks like inside too. Nicolex
Love it, well done!
nice looking house now!
Ugh. Am I the only one who does not like this?
This is very San Francisco. Most house in SF are painted a varity of colors; not just 2 which is why I love the house in SF.
You did a nice job.
@Mandr0id: No, you are not alone. While I like the two-tone idea, and I like the bottom color, I think the yellow is hideous.
great relevance to apartments :-P
Unfortunately, I think the "Before" photo is far more attractive. At least the homeowner is happy!
The before color is better.
Wow, the top of the house really stands out!
Why it's a 'triple deckah' love them soooo/a lot of our grandparent in the eastern part of MA lived in them..mine did..in Jamaica Plain, on Wyman St...and I had an apt. in Dorchester in one..huge and two porches, front and back..huge inside and wonderful.
you know..it'a not a true triple decker, the kind I was going on about..but close and gorgeous..great job and surprisingly, the colors work very nicely.
I like it but I was hoping for something more colorful.
Love it love it love it!
I think it's stunning.