apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Before & After: Greer's Red Staircase

before.jpg

Our hat’s off to interior architect Greer Goodman who saw potential in the very, very, red staircase and hallway of her Providence, Rhode Island home. See what the staircase and hallway look like after her transformation...

 
 

IMG_1475.jpg

We're happily shocked to see what a great space was hiding beneath all that dark red. Bravo, Greer!

after.jpg

after2.jpg

Tags

painting, fixing & repair, stairs, red, before & after, Greer Goodman

Related Links

Share

Comments (44)

Beautiful. It isn't that it was too red, it was overdecorated and dated that made it ugly.

posted by alexis on August 5th 2009 at 10:51am
view alexis's profile

So they took an interesting space and made it look like average, boring American home. Ok, the red might have been a bit much (I kind of like that stuff though) but at least it had some personality. Now it just looks like something from a catalog.

posted by aemorgan on August 5th 2009 at 10:51am
view aemorgan's profile

That is one of the scariest befores I have ever seen. Thank goodness for the after.

posted by 76flaquita on August 5th 2009 at 10:52am
view 76flaquita's profile

Nice job. Mine was just as ugly, but in a different, more gold-and-brown kind of way -
before:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/46175655@N00/3639167814/in/set-72157620391287414/

after:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/46175655@N00/3654454298/in/set-72157620391287414/

posted by bullyproofvest on August 5th 2009 at 10:55am
view bullyproofvest's profile

From Granny shriek to sleek--I guess there is a landing, and did she entirely replace the window?

posted by jen_g on August 5th 2009 at 10:57am
view jen_g's profile

A really good example of bad wallpaper. Nice to see that the dark wood was left alone. The window looks great.

Nice job!

The pendent lighting fixture choice seems off to me I know this is a very common/popular and the go to pendent lighting fixture but style is wrong for this foyer.

Cute dog.

posted by LoriSF on August 5th 2009 at 11:00am
view LoriSF's profile

Wow! The before looked like a sinister funeral home. Amazing work refreshing the space!

posted by kellylc on August 5th 2009 at 11:02am
view kellylc's profile

That red junk isn't 'personality'. It's how a lot of people of a certain class and in certain regions decorate their homes. Just because you don't see it featured in design mags or whatever doesn't mean it's unusual or striking. It's just bad taste. I feel like the previous homeowner was trying to suffocate the house under all those layers.

It looks 100% better now.

posted by slowdown on August 5th 2009 at 11:15am
view slowdown's profile

@bullyproofvest - Beautiful makeover! And your KITCHEN!!!

posted by JuniperGreen on August 5th 2009 at 11:21am
view JuniperGreen's profile

i know i can't see the pattern up close, but it seems to me that the wallpaper could have stayed. take away those frightening curtains and stair runner, and add a few cool mod elements like that great light fixture in the after, and i think the space could have been cute.

i'm with aemorgan - it's very calm now, but it's just... white.

posted by lilalcarese on August 5th 2009 at 11:22am
view lilalcarese's profile

OMG...it looks like Cruella was the previous owner !!

posted by Marie-Eve on August 5th 2009 at 11:25am
view Marie-Eve's profile

An improvement, no doubt. But the only changes I see are a can of paint and refinished steps. What is so impressive?

posted by LaurenAdel on August 5th 2009 at 11:27am
view LaurenAdel's profile

I must agree w/ aemorgan--

The only things that the old staircase needed removing were the old carpet runner and the draperies - the wallpaper wasn't at all bad and the newel post needed a bit of touching up, but overall it was workable and had character.

Now it's bland with a clutter of "Family Gallery" mismatched and randomly-hung picture frames, a cheap plastic light fixture, a backpack on the newel post and kiddy gates.

posted by bepsf on August 5th 2009 at 11:30am
view bepsf's profile

I'm sort of with @LaurenAdel and some others. Its a great improvement from its original look, but other than some paint changes and removing the awful carpeting on the steps, the owners didn't do much else. I think so more modern changes to the staircase (maybe repaiting the steps in a unique way as a reflection of their personal style) would have made for a better wow factor. Still a great improvement, but I can't say my jaw dropped.

posted by ellearRVA on August 5th 2009 at 11:40am
view ellearRVA's profile

A bit on the boring side now, I think, in spite of the great woodwork. The "grandmother's" arrangement of small pictures up the steps is too small in detail and fussy. Enlarge some of those pictures and create a dramatic graphic that gives the space some excitement. Or make sure the very attractive dog always sits on the stair landing as a piece of living sculptpure.

posted by JWet on August 5th 2009 at 11:43am
view JWet's profile

I agree with the comments that the after is bland. Cruella De ville's funeral parlor was far more interesting.

posted by Seaside on August 5th 2009 at 11:45am
view Seaside's profile

This is just like in the women's mags when they take a good-looking woman who wears too much makeup and take some off. However, in this case, perhaps they should have left a little eyeliner.

posted by h144 on August 5th 2009 at 11:57am
view h144's profile

Wonderful! But now the frames in the hallway look a little sad. UPGRADE your frames and MATCH THEM to EMBRACE the gorgeous job you did on the stair renewal!!

posted by medusa12120 on August 5th 2009 at 12:01pm
view medusa12120's profile

ugh, bullyproofvest, I ache for the wood you covered up!

posted by michpc on August 5th 2009 at 12:05pm
view michpc's profile

Great job! Is there a blog so we can see more of this house?

posted by paperdollsforboys on August 5th 2009 at 12:05pm
view paperdollsforboys's profile

What an amazing, vast improvement.

Emily

posted by Emily Sneds on August 5th 2009 at 12:06pm
view Emily Sneds's profile

Did they replace the stained-glass window? I think that would have been lovely in the new white space rather than being choked by those drapes.

posted by Cassis on August 5th 2009 at 12:16pm
view Cassis's profile

What happened to the stained glass window. Is it just cut off in the picture?

posted by farleece on August 5th 2009 at 12:17pm
view farleece's profile

A vast improvement over what it originally looked like, but I must admit, it's a little bland now. Perhaps painting the risers a different color than white will add some punch to the space. I also wonder what happened to the stained glass window...it was pretty (but hidden under the dreadful red window treatment) and that would be where I would have taken my color cue for painting the risers.

posted by suzy8track on August 5th 2009 at 12:45pm
view suzy8track's profile

Cute dog.

posted by gryt on August 5th 2009 at 12:54pm
view gryt's profile

I can see where the criticisms are coming from, and have to agree with them to a degree. I really dislike beige walls, and felt that there was a lot of dynamic potential lost in the interior. Photograph walls like that need to be really filled-up to look good -- these are hung too sparsely and too carefully.

The idea that came to me was wallpapering the wall with sage green blowsy chintz -- like this

http://www.carletonvarneybytheyard.com/Carolina-Blue.jpg

or this

http://www.annafrench.co.uk/collections/wild-flora/bouquet/bou_05.shtml

With woven sea grass or sisal on the floor -- as a runner, as carpeting in the entry -- to modernize it. Then, I would add MCM pieces as contrast.

Sorry, couldn't resist adding my .02 worth...

posted by mschatelaine on August 5th 2009 at 12:55pm
view mschatelaine's profile

I like the white but the wallpaper could have stayed...I agree with aemorgan.

posted by angietq on August 5th 2009 at 12:55pm
view angietq's profile

bullyproofvest: love love love your place. I'm swooning over your kitchen-- can you give some source info? And the shelving in the sitting room-- is that vintage?

posted by PhillyLass on August 5th 2009 at 1:00pm
view PhillyLass's profile

I think it's 1000 times better, and while it isn't bold and highly designed, its a comfortable space that, I'd guess (based on the traditional style of the railing), fits the the house. But I have to agree with two points: 1/ the photos on the landing don't work whatsoever; 2/ did you really remove that lovely stained glass window?

posted by sheilasinn on August 5th 2009 at 1:02pm
view sheilasinn's profile

I'm with the Hideous before but nothing worth showing in the after. Taking the white paint off of the stair treads had to be awful.

posted by Jen C on August 5th 2009 at 1:26pm
view Jen C's profile

It doesn't seem like they really did much but remove the wallpaper and stair runner. Obviously it looks much better now, but now it's sort of generic.

posted by HeyNowTex on August 5th 2009 at 1:27pm
view HeyNowTex's profile

I don't think the stained glass window was removed.... I'm pretty sure the "after" picture is of a different window. In the stained glass picture, you can see the bottom of the window is almost touching the staircase/molding. The second window picture seems to have been taken at the top of the staircase.

posted by chikiyuu on August 5th 2009 at 1:37pm
view chikiyuu's profile

I'm not sure why having a gate in your home to keep your child off the stairs is something to be sneered at. I can't wait for the day I don't need one of those gates in my house anymore, but in the meantime it serves a purpose and I could care less what it looks like. When Babies R Us starts selling super stylish baby gates, maybe I'll pick one up.

Anyway...good job! It's not easy to get work done in a stairway. I think the makeover looks nice and fresh. I have similar red and white wallpaper in my foyer and stairway so I sympathize. I would actually be partial to keeping it if it were in better condition but the plaster needs repair in quite a few places behind the paper and it's ripped in a few spots -- doesn't look so hot close up. We'll put new paper up when we can afford it, I guess.

Have you considered a runner? It might be that little extra thing you need to add some more color/pattern.

posted by giggit on August 5th 2009 at 1:50pm
view giggit's profile

Yowza! The after shots are like a breath of fresh air. Nice work! One question though... what happend to the red drapes?

posted by s_boston on August 5th 2009 at 1:59pm
view s_boston's profile

Definite improvement!! And not boring, either.
The before looked like an 1890's brothel....

posted by sassydo on August 5th 2009 at 2:11pm
view sassydo's profile

Thank you for not painting the wood. I don't know what the obsession is lately with painting everything white.

posted by puck on August 5th 2009 at 3:02pm
view puck's profile

A lot of comments over a staircase! So I'm adding my two cents worth: The re-do makes me think this place was coached by a real estate agent for sale. Where's the little occasional table with the vase of super market flowers?
Don't we get in decoration ruts? Maybe the new neutrality is just a relief after many years of "I love red".
Personally, I'd like to see the first floor beneath the stairway elegantly wallpapered, because I'm guessing this was what they were aiming at with the puffy window treatment and match stairway runner.

posted by Vincent B. on August 5th 2009 at 4:03pm
view Vincent B.'s profile

I kinda liked the wallpaper, but I appreciate the desire to make things new and fresh, and very much "your own." Good job of getting the paint of the stair steps. Love the coffin window.

posted by SunnyBlue on August 5th 2009 at 4:29pm
view SunnyBlue's profile

That wallpaper was great . . . if you want your home to look like a frontier whorehouse that was the scene of a desperado shootout and subsequent bloodbath.

The space is now calm and harmonious, and looks to be inhabited by adults. It doesn't need "more color" - those of you calling for "more color" should take your Crayolas and color the walls of your own playpens.

About the only valid criticism I've seen in this thread pertains to the framed pictures, namely that the landing probably needs more of them (or, perhaps, one large framed picture to replace the teeny-tiny one that's there now).

posted by sunspot42 on August 5th 2009 at 6:14pm
view sunspot42's profile

I hope you donated those big red tasselled 80s curtains to your local bordello. Recycling is good :)

I can see why the wallpaper had to go - there are too many angles and walls surrounding the stairs to find an appropriate place to stop wallpapering. It would have been too much of a (questionably) good thing.

I like the fact that the dual wood tones in the stairs match the dual wood tones in the floors. I covet those floors.

posted by Blandwagon on August 5th 2009 at 11:19pm
view Blandwagon's profile

Wow people. This is someone's home. I know that posting your pictures on this site leaves you open to criticism, but come on. I'm sure it took alot of hard work and time and blood, sweat and tears to turn the Victorian nightmare into the calm, comfy home they have now. They are obviously proud of their home and accomplishment. And maybe they LOVE white paint! There is a difference between respectful comments and suggestions and outright meanness.

posted by Kit_Kat on August 6th 2009 at 3:32am
view Kit_Kat's profile

I love how fresh and clean it looks.

That red carpet was like a horrible, horrible Cosby sweater.

Anyway, it looks like a gorgeous, welcoming home now. Well done!

posted by teacupcake on August 6th 2009 at 8:45am
view teacupcake's profile

The red looked(no pun intended) Bloody awful. I half expected Herman Munster to jump out from the corner. Nice update

posted by blinketyblank on August 7th 2009 at 11:50pm
view blinketyblank's profile

I don't understand why you were "shocked" to see the walls, woodwork, stairs, bannister, windows, etc. remained intact after removing carpet, wallpaper and window treatments. It's rather common.

posted by karen in kc on August 9th 2009 at 5:54am
view karen in kc's profile

Feeds

RSS icon Boston

+ City Feeds