apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


One Entry, Two Budgets: Designing High & Low
Boston Home

07-20-High.jpg

Boston Home magazine asked two local designers — Lindasy Bentis and Kara Butterfield — to team up and decorate the same foyer using two very different budgets. This high-end look with a Ligne Roset coat stand, Random pendants, and a Baker Noir dining table cost a total of $14,927. Follow the jump to see a more affordable interpretation...

 
 

07-20-Low.jpg

Focusing on one big ticket item — a $1,370 Chandler table from Mitchell Gold + Bob Williams — and more modest accoutrements, this lower end look cost $3,449. Though we wouldn't buy either room soup to nuts, we love these high & low exercises as a refreshing reminder that any "look" can be achieved in a variety of ways, with a variety of budgets.

The main thing to remember: invest in a few, quality pieces that you really love, the rest will fall into place when time and money allow. Check out Boston Home's full article for the detailed list of all items used in both entries, including where you can buy them.

Related Post:
One Nook, Two Budgets: Designing High and Low
Blogging Boston Home, Winter 2009

(Images: Michael Piazza for Boston Home)

Comments (27)

I'll do the craigslist version . . . . .

posted by NorNor on July 20th 2009 at 3:49pm
view NorNor's profile

More of these please.
So interesting.

posted by kiljoywashere on July 20th 2009 at 3:51pm
view kiljoywashere's profile

No kidding.

posted by sally305 on July 20th 2009 at 3:52pm
view sally305's profile

Yes, more please, and let's go even cheaper while we're at it.

posted by visualingual on July 20th 2009 at 4:06pm
view visualingual's profile

i would also like to see more, and cheaper! i am having a hard time finding the perfect pendant for my entryway.

posted by erinpearce on July 20th 2009 at 4:40pm
view erinpearce's profile

ditto -- love the high, low -- can we have a super-low too?

posted by mlleErica on July 20th 2009 at 4:41pm
view mlleErica's profile

well i mean i have found a tons of pendant i love... i should say i'm having a hard time finding the perfect pendant in my price range of under $100! lol.

posted by erinpearce on July 20th 2009 at 4:41pm
view erinpearce's profile

Can you make the next one's "low-budget" in the $1,500 range or lower?

$14,000 is ridiculous for one room unless that room is a kitchen -- I renovated a 2000sqft home (electrical, plumbing, furniture, flooring, appliances, countertops, etc etc) for less than $25,000. (I'm in St.Louis, so prices are cheaper here, but still.)

posted by smegs on July 20th 2009 at 4:45pm
view smegs's profile

Metropolitan Home mag did a whole high/low edition, and it was really creative. Either way, it's usually to "high" for me- but what a great challenge for a designer!

posted by shockthebourgeois on July 20th 2009 at 4:47pm
view shockthebourgeois's profile

PS. http://megankhomeowner.blogspot.com

posted by smegs on July 20th 2009 at 4:47pm
view smegs's profile

Terrific! I actually like the more affordable one even better!

posted by Jane on July 20th 2009 at 5:11pm
view Jane's profile

love this!!!

can we have more of these? and (just echoing what other people are saying) an ever lower low-budget one?


LOVE it.

posted by emily! on July 20th 2009 at 5:21pm
view emily!'s profile

yes, love these comparisons & would love to see super low as well!

posted by timmy jr. on July 20th 2009 at 5:30pm
view timmy jr.'s profile

Oh smegs where were you when I needed you so badly!

posted by Kate (NC) on July 20th 2009 at 5:50pm
view Kate (NC)'s profile

Yeah, I vote more high vs low budget posts, if they are available. :)

posted by Erin Lang Norris/Yellow Canoe on July 20th 2009 at 9:22pm
view Erin Lang Norris/Yellow Canoe's profile

Holy cow, that's awesome!

posted by apf on July 20th 2009 at 10:30pm
view apf's profile

Though we wouldn't buy either room soup to nuts...

I've never heard this expression before, but I rather like it!

As for the rooms, it's notable that the expensive room looks so much better than the cheap one. The level of finish on good designer pieces simply can't be replicated on budget stuff. I do agree, however, that using a few good pieces to anchor an interior narrows the gap considerably.

posted by Blandwagon on July 20th 2009 at 10:48pm
view Blandwagon's profile

Swap out a few of the items in the less expensive version for much less expensive items.

Swap:
Metal floor mirror, $299, West Elm
for:
Hovet mirror, $99, IKEA (savings $200.00)
http://www.ikea.com/us/en/catalog/products/50038213

Swap:
Nelson bubble lamps, $329 each, Machine Age
for:
Light kit, $9.99 each and Paper lantern shade $7.99-$12.99, World Market (savings at least $300.00 each):
http://www.worldmarket.com/family/index.jsp?view=all&categoryId=3499204

Swap:
Chandler table, $1,370, Mitchell Gold Bob Williams.
for:
ANY pedestal table, there are oodles of them.
Espresso color, $259.99 (savings $1,110)
http://www.overstock.com/Home-Garden/Maddox-Espresso-Dining-Table/3342709/product.html

Swap:
Round jute rug, $149, Pottery Barn
for:
Sisal round rug, $64.99 (savings $84)
http://www.overstock.com/Home-Garden/Hand-woven-Khaki-Sisal-Wool-Rug-6-Round/2930132/product.html

Swap:
Pella coat stand, $230, Bowl & Board
for:
Adesso Marbles Chrome Coat Rack, $70 (savings $160)
http://www.homefurnitureandpatio.com/servlet/the-8733/MARBLES-COAT-RACK/Detail

Total savings so far: $2,154
Their inexpensive: $3,449
My inexpensive (without doing the rest): $1,295

You get to decide what you HAVE to have and what can be saved on. And exactly how MUCH saving or scrimping you can do. Some things will go on sale. Some things you may very well be able to pick locally at thrift stores, antique stores, via Craigslist. Like the terrarium type things or the bird or bird cage. Just look around:
http://www.outdoorlivingshowroom.com/products/view.aspx?family=369344

You can also go higher than the high, like with a Inuit stone carved bird:
http://www.bondandbowery.com/item/7097

You can mix in whatever you have, what you can afford, what you love. You can add on later. For instance, everyone should be able to handle the cost of the paper lantern. If it doesn't work in your space, a more costly round/ball item won't work any better.

You might love the look of the entry, but realize that the table, rug and tabletop items are purely decorative. The table isn't used for dining. Add up the cost of the entire grouping and see if you can afford that as a decorative object.

posted by #9 on July 20th 2009 at 11:18pm
view #9's profile

Decorpad.com does this and it's very cool. They have both a "look for less space" which is 2 rooms with 2 very different costs and and "look for less items". I love them.

posted by marid22 on July 21st 2009 at 10:04am
view marid22's profile

thank you, these are great, more high/lows please!

and um, #9, that's awesome that you took the time to find all that! (maybe AT should use #9 as a high/low blogging consultant LOL jk)

posted by Kpaige13 on July 21st 2009 at 10:12am
view Kpaige13's profile

been meaning to say: #9, good to see you back on AT again! Always loved reading your comments before!

and yes, like everyone else, I too love the high/low posts!

posted by fineur on July 21st 2009 at 3:22pm
view fineur's profile

I'd like to see a $500 or less version. It's not impossible.

posted by MCBfly on July 21st 2009 at 4:41pm
view MCBfly's profile

Less than $500? I might take on that challenge. After I've collected enough used dental floss to weave the round rug myself. Hey! It's UPCYCLING!

Thank you, fineur, it's good to feel somewhat useful again.

Although I'm back to looking around my own apartment and saying "Good golly, what a bunch of crap I have!"

posted by #9 on July 21st 2009 at 5:34pm
view #9's profile

I'll stick with the IKEA Hovet mirror, $99:
http://www.ikea.com/us/en/catalog/products/50038213

Target American Simplicity table, $229.99:
http://www.target.com/American-Simplicity-Pedestal-Table-Walnut/dp/B000U6HZWU/qid=1248229568

24" ball paper light with metal ribbing, $5.60 each and their light kit, $6.99 each, $25.10 total:
http://www.filmtools.com/24whitchinla.html

Set of three decorative bird cages, $35:
http://www.save-on-crafts.com/birdcages4.html

Bell jar top (put IN the birdcage), $9.99:
http://www.save-on-crafts.com/belljars.html

Silver coat stand, $52.00:
http://www.everythingfurniture.com/coast-coat-rack-3.html

Round braided rug, World Market, $9.99:
http://www.worldmarket.com/product/index.jsp?productId=3557934

A director's chair (I ran out of money) in a similar to the wood color of the table, plus a cover, $16.99 chair, cover $8:
http://www.worldmarket.com/product/index.jsp?productId=3708702

Total...
$496.06

I didn't include cost of plants. And I didn't really find a bird I liked a lot. This was kind of cool at $19.99:
http://www.stealstreet.com/product_p/ss-7586.htm

Takes the edge of the cottage cutesy birdcages. Goes well enough with the black, brown, white, silver decor. Could also use eggs in one of the birdcages. Rather than a bird on the table.

posted by #9 on July 21st 2009 at 10:35pm
view #9's profile

One more tip...do web searches, explore, sometimes you find items you really want at MUCH less than you would pay in the store.

Lumens, a light site, has a blog that only lists returned open-box, new items. And yes, there was a Nelson Saucer bubble lamp available...

List Price: $435.00

Lumens Web Price: $329.00

Lumens Annex Price: $230.30

http://lumensannex.wordpress.com/2009/03/05/saucer-bubble-pendant-by-george-nelson-2/

Here's the main link:
http://lumensannex.wordpress.com/

Much of the stuff lower down (posted earlier) is sold...but some isn't. I'm not hanging the box, so it doesn't matter if the box was opened and the item not right for the first person. The box can have a run-in with a combine be graffiti-covered, as long as the contents are intact.

And that is another great way to get the look you want at a much better price. Floor samples, returns.

posted by #9 on July 22nd 2009 at 7:50am
view #9's profile

This is great! Although, how much would we save if we did some DIY? I saw a DIY for the DWR lamps...

Hopefully we'll see more like this! Thanks Andrée!

posted by Heather C on July 22nd 2009 at 4:36pm
view Heather C's profile

Feeds

RSS icon Boston

+ City Feeds