apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


2 Small Condos, 1 Large Lighting Difference?

_MG_1824.jpg

We've been captivated for quite some time with this view from our bedroom window. The difference in lighting from the second floor condo to the first floor condo is startling. What do you think is going on...

 
 

We have to wonder if this is a fishbowl view of the difference between traditional incandescent lighting (first floor) and eco-friendly compact fluorescent lighting (second floor).

We are definitely partial to warm, yellowy lighting so we favor the first floor condo's lighting. (It might be hard to tell from the photo, but the difference in lighting is dramatic. And we're sure that it's not the interior elements - paint, curtains, etc. - that are creating the white vs. yellow lighting.) Now we just have to work up the chutzpa to tell them we've been ogling their household silhouette at night and ask them to kindly settle the mystery.

What are your thoughts? Do you prefer the lighting in one condo over the other?

Tags

green ideas, lighting, compact flourescent lighting, incandescent lighting

Related Links

Share

Comments (25)

Clearly these condos are haunted. It isn't a question of incan./flour. but good/evil. :P

posted by amygdaloides on November 14th 2008 at 1:52pm
view amygdaloides's profile

One of them has set a fire and the other has a big tv.

posted by K T G on November 14th 2008 at 2:03pm
view K T G's profile

It could be the lighting fixtures. We have Mission-style fixtures with golden mica and golden opaque glass. It gives the whole room a golden glow at night, even with an environmentally-friendly bulb. It's amazing what a difference there is from the fixtures that were there before.

http://www.lightingforum.com/arroyo_craftsman/arroyo_craftsman_index.htm

posted by Lisa Hunter (Montreal) on November 14th 2008 at 2:58pm
view Lisa Hunter (Montreal)'s profile

Diminishing fenestration...

posted by gordon on November 14th 2008 at 3:15pm
view gordon's profile

I wonder how this building compares to others around it. How does "your" apartment look from across the street?

I think the incandescent/fluorescent could be the explanation, or just more/less lighting.

Of course the first floor looks warmer and more welcoming, regardless of type or quantity, but I've always preferred yellow light to white as well.

posted by lilithslair on November 14th 2008 at 3:23pm
view lilithslair's profile

The top floor looks like it's lit only by a tv and low lights.

posted by hyacinthine on November 14th 2008 at 3:40pm
view hyacinthine's profile

maybe it's the light fixtures/lampshades, although i thought incandescent vs. fluorescent at first. my mom has these cream colored traditional lampshades with warmer light bulbs. makes the whole room yellow (i always hated it). i prefer crisp white (or black) shades & bulbs (modern-ish). i can't stand fluorescent lights though. (i'm obviously picky :) )

posted by rstrtz on November 14th 2008 at 3:42pm
view rstrtz's profile

This reminds me of one of my favorite movies, Rear Window. Be careful of what you might see.

posted by Pixie on November 14th 2008 at 4:05pm
view Pixie's profile

poor old fluorescents... can't get no love.

ikea has a few of them rubber coated which just warms the light up a bit.

why I like fluorescents by the bed and in the bathroom: they brighten very slowly when switched on so no shocking there goes sleep forever moment when one turns them on, as one has to occasionally, in the middle of the night

fluorescent party lights are AWESOME... bright RED, GREEN, YELLOW, and the BEST BLUE EVER.... almost gives black light effects without the shame of HAVING a black light.

posted by Philip_Littell on November 14th 2008 at 4:17pm
view Philip_Littell's profile

I 'm a Cinematographer and Chief Lighting Technician for film and TV and I can tell you exactly what's going on, with the lighting at least. I can't say for sure what's happening with the paint colors and window treatments.

Film and digital cameras see color temperature and color spectrums in a more exaggerated way than our eyes do. They "see" more of the orange-warmth of tungsten halogen lights, the bluishness of daylight (and daylight-balanced bulbs) and the excess of green in the spectrum of fluorescent lights. These colors are somewhat visible to the human eye, but on camera they stand out much more.

It looks like in the apartment below you've got warm-ish household tungsten bulbs (2800K), perhaps made even more orange by warm-colored lamp shades, warm colors inside (like the yellowish blinds) and possibly dimmers on the lights. In the apartment above you've got daylight balanced bulbs in the room on the left (5600K), what appears to be a warm colored window shade in the middle room, and garden-variety cool-white fluorescents (4300K) in the room on the right.

For the record, the "rubber coating" on the IKEA bulbs isn't responsible for the warmer color of those bulbs. It's the phosphors used in the bulb that make the light less green. You can get warm colored bulbs without the rubbery coating, while some other rubbery-coated bulbs look every bit as sickly green as the cheapest cool-whites.

posted by nashdp on November 14th 2008 at 4:35pm
view nashdp's profile

nashdp comes through on the white balance knowledge!
word them up!

posted by antimatt on November 14th 2008 at 5:00pm
view antimatt's profile

Forget "Rear Window;" it's Edward Hopper!

http://images.worldgallery.co.uk:80/i/prints/rw/lg/8/0/Edward-Hopper-The-night-window--1928-80728.jpg

posted by nashdp on November 14th 2008 at 5:26pm
view nashdp's profile

OMG I love knowing other people are just as fascinated at the apartments across the street as I am!!

posted by sdnyc on November 14th 2008 at 5:41pm
view sdnyc's profile

I'm glad you're not my neighbor

posted by wild-er on November 14th 2008 at 7:00pm
view wild-er's profile

I'm with wild-er...

posted by muirwoods08 on November 14th 2008 at 8:59pm
view muirwoods08's profile

I think the fluorescent vs incandescent bulb seems the most logical explanation. My first thought when I saw it, though, was that the top unit had an aquarium in there somewhere and not many other lights on.

As for ogling the neighbors - I do love the "Rear Window" aspect of this as well. Once upon a time I lived in the city (SF) and always left my curtains open under the guise that if people were allowed to look in my apartment they shouldn't mind me looking into theirs!

posted by ubercasa on November 14th 2008 at 9:48pm
view ubercasa's profile

In the top floor they are watching TV and in the lower floor they are reading. Makes sense to me.

posted by artistkim on November 14th 2008 at 10:05pm
view artistkim's profile

I have compact florescents, and my light looks like the lower windows rather than the upper.

posted by LindaJeanne on November 15th 2008 at 10:44am
view LindaJeanne's profile

looks like the top one keeps things dark except for the glow of the tv or computer.

posted by mariegael on November 15th 2008 at 3:39pm
view mariegael's profile

"I have compact florescents, and my light looks like the lower windows rather than the upper."

Fluorescent lights come in a variety of color temperatures, ranging from warm-orange through bluish daylight.

Your lights may appear a warm yellow-orange to your eye, but will photograph very differently. Try taking a photo of your compact fluorescent lights with a digital still camera, with the white balance set to tungsten (the "indoor" setting, usually with a light bulb icon). You'd be surprised how they appear a yellow-green on camera. Especially if you compare it to the light of regular incandescent bulb, which will be more of an orange color.

The top apartment looks like it has daylight bulbs on the left and cool-white bulbs on the right. Not the warm compact fluorescents.

posted by nashdp on November 15th 2008 at 8:20pm
view nashdp's profile

I LOVE YOUR CURIOSITY

posted by susief1225 on November 16th 2008 at 10:00am
view susief1225's profile

Definitely those horrid fluorescent fixtures on the top floor. And thus why I'm not switching from incandescent. It's more important to me that I actually enjoy spending time in my home.

posted by Daily Nuance on November 16th 2008 at 8:08pm
view Daily Nuance's profile

The top apartment is a secret "under-the-sea" themed nightclub owned by Suge Knight, and the bottom apartment is is where a little old lady rocks back and forth in her rocking chair in front of her fireplace, polishing her axe and devising new places she can hide the dismembered bodies of her victims.

posted by justbekky.com on November 16th 2008 at 11:32pm
view justbekky.com's profile

could the windows just be tinted differently?

posted by khanzen on November 17th 2008 at 6:44am
view khanzen's profile

I have compact fluorescents in almost all of my fixtures. There is very little color difference, esp. once you get used to it. I like that my electric bill has dropped by a third and that I'm not trashing the planet.

posted by KarenAnne on November 22nd 2008 at 12:18am
view KarenAnne's profile

Feeds

RSS icon Boston

+ City Feeds