apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Mistint Paint: An Affordable Paint Option

paint-can-11.jpg

A friend of ours, who lives frugally and walks lightly on the earth, decided it was time to paint his room. He didn't have a particular color in mind which made him very open and flexible when he stumbled upon the surprisingly dense selection of mistinted paint cans at the hardware store. Mistints are paints that are unused or returned by customers because they're not the right color match or finish. In this case, our friend bought a gallon of what he refers to as "slippery grey" paint for only...

 
 

$8 ! He's delighted with the result and likes the color so much that he's considering purchasing some more paint in the same "mistint" color. At the time he bought the paint, he said there were about 50 other cans of orphaned mistints at the hardware store. That's not a bad selection for $8/gallon!

Have you ever tried mistinted paint? Any advice?

image: Eco Home Furniture Design Ideas


Tags

painting, fixing & repair, mistinted paint

Related Links

Share

Comments (24)

I went to my local hardware store to buy a specific light pink paint and decided to check the mistints just in case. Turns out there was a very, very similar pink for $10 for the gallon. I absolutely adore the color, but one small problem is that there was no label whatsoever on the can, so I have no idea what the brand and color of the paint is. If I ever want to re-create it, I'll need to have a swatch scanned.

posted by phoneill on January 22nd 2009 at 1:55pm
view phoneill's profile

speaking of which...

i have 2 cans each of high quality paint (i think both are from Ralph Lauren):
a dark grey/almost black
a dark beige/brown
which have never been opened from September 2008...

i can't return them so... does anybody want them? (i'm in chelsea, manhattan)

posted by saya* on January 22nd 2009 at 2:08pm
view saya*'s profile

love the image of the paint cans. What is it?

posted by ljbmonkey on January 22nd 2009 at 2:08pm
view ljbmonkey's profile

My secret is out! While I have never heard of them being called "Mistints," I do know of them as "Oops" paints, which all major hardware stores carry. Home Depot often has a large selection for $5 a gallon.

My best advice is to pay close attention to the sheen (satin, eggshell, etc) of the paint and always ask if they can open up the paint can to see not only the exact color (I've been known to compare it to swatches of regular priced paints) but also the quality of the paint itself.

In my 3 years here in New York (and countless apartments) I have used Oops Paint numerous times!

Happy Painting!

posted by DialJforJake on January 22nd 2009 at 2:14pm
view DialJforJake's profile

i have the same situation as saya

I have 3 gallons unopened BM eco primer
2 gallons BM Aura chantilly lace
1 1/2 gallon of BM Aura million dollar red (half of an open container that was opened on monday) 1 unopened quart...

on on the LES...

posted by cherrybomb on January 22nd 2009 at 2:15pm
view cherrybomb's profile

i once purchased a whole 5 gallons of custom mixed paint... couldnt return it. i cried on and off over it for a few days since id pretty much wasted my money on something i wasnt even going to use. so months went by and i still had it sitting in my garage when i found that my church was looking to paint the new nursery a color pretty darn close to what id bought. turns out i hadnt wasted my money after all. :)

posted by deeboyayay on January 22nd 2009 at 2:17pm
view deeboyayay's profile

Saya,

I deal with that problem by posting in the "free" section on Craigslist. Somebody out there probably wants some free paint, you just have to find them :)

posted by jancola on January 22nd 2009 at 2:19pm
view jancola's profile

My house is painted in all BM mistints and leftover paints from my previous place.

I even took 2 mistints and blended them together to get the perfect bathroom colour! My friend who used to work at a paint store said as long as the sheen matches that's fine. She also said that "Decorator white" comes from all the mistints mixed together plus white.

posted by tam-tbag on January 22nd 2009 at 2:24pm
view tam-tbag's profile

i have often used mistints to great effect!

and when the paint store messed up their last can of sandwash paint for me back in October, i got my "patriotic" living room out of it!

:-)

posted by rouquinne on January 22nd 2009 at 2:32pm
view rouquinne's profile

cherrybomb,

I would totally take some of that off your hands. I've been thinking about painting my door red. I'm in Brooklyn. Can we PM on Apt Therapy? I couldn't figure out how.

posted by ooh_food on January 22nd 2009 at 3:16pm
view ooh_food's profile

We should create an ATNYC paint swap! I have a bunch of BM Aura in a light gray and a bunch of white primer. I would love to find some blue gray Aura.

posted by ooh_food on January 22nd 2009 at 3:18pm
view ooh_food's profile

I was in IKEA a few weeks ago, and they had cans of paint leftover from their displays for sale in the As-Is department. They weren't gallon size, but smaller (quart, I think?) and they were only $1.99. There were tons in all colors. I wasn't looking to paint anything so I didn't buy them, but that would have been a great deal!

posted by Aiekan on January 22nd 2009 at 3:20pm
view Aiekan's profile

I would so love a paint swap!!!!

I'm going to do a mix of some leftovers to do the bedroom rather than buy new.

ooh food you can gmail me -- I am bombedpop there...

beware--the million $$ red shows orange-tinge, at least it does in the kitchen with landlord standard wood cabinets, we have to repaint another color me thinks--still deciding...

posted by cherrybomb on January 22nd 2009 at 3:35pm
view cherrybomb's profile

Cheerybomb,

I'd love to take all the red you've got - I have a huge red paint project I'm about to start! If you still have it, could I claim it?

Thanks! (Now, how do we go about emailing off AT?)

posted by jplee on January 22nd 2009 at 3:36pm
view jplee's profile

Another option is to look for a resource that sells recycled paint. This is paint that is dropped off for recycling that can be salvaged.

Where I live, the local program that helps people with disabilities get jobs does the work. They go through it and pick out the salvageable paint and strain it into 55 gallon drums. When they have enough, they pour it into 5 gallon buckets and sell it for $30.00 a bucket.

The color choices are limited, but it is good paint. I bought five buckets of an eggshell color to paint my whole finished basement. It had good coverage and was no different than any other paint I've ever used.

It's a green and frugal choice. Plus, the work was done by people with disabilities and all profits are used by the agency to provide services. Positively full of win!

posted by Aldyth on January 22nd 2009 at 4:18pm
view Aldyth's profile

I think there is need for a pre-cure paint swap. I have tons of paint I dont need. Anyone up for it in los angeles?

posted by chusmabilly on January 22nd 2009 at 6:10pm
view chusmabilly's profile

The last time I needed paint for the baseboards of my powder room, I checked the oops/mistint section of the store. I lucked out that there was a dented can of the same size and color of blank paint for sale for $2.50 that I was there to buy.

I've also bought donated mistints at Habitat's Restore. Unfortunately I didn't use a tinted primer with the dark burgandy color and ran out of paint. I grabbed a palm sander and "distressed" as a last ditch effort to save the paint job. It came out pretty good. http://condo-blues.blogspot.com/2008/05/how-to-create-distressed-wall-treatment.html

posted by Condo Blues on January 22nd 2009 at 10:52pm
view Condo Blues's profile

ooh, lots of tips! um, so craigslist to unload my paint? I will... do so immediately. and if no go, to the recycling!
*s

posted by saya* on January 23rd 2009 at 11:04am
view saya*'s profile

Sears is great for mistints. Make sure you ask for a discount if the can is dented. It can save you a few bucks.

posted by jen of the north on January 24th 2009 at 11:29pm
view jen of the north's profile

I am a BIG fan of an AT paint swap, and was actually considering suggesting such a thing recently since i had a bunch of paint samples left over from my recent bedroom paint job.

I wound up giving my samples away on freecycle, and got like 20 responses within 20 minutes of posting, so that was easy.

I would prefer to do something over AT though, since what i had was SAMPLES. I feel like all of us wind up buying small samples to put up on the wall and determine what color works best, and then what are you supposed to do with all those 1qt or smaller cans of paint? Plus, who wants to invest like $50 on samples? I'd love to give them to fellow AT'ers. It would be really really great if there was a database of samples listed by color ... so if i'm interested in a certian blue by Behr for example, i could see if someone on AT is offering it before investing in a quart sample! :)

posted by mh330 on January 25th 2009 at 10:42am
view mh330's profile

Thank you! I get mine from the oops pile (if you stalk it long enough, the right color is sure to turn up) but always felt like such a goober when I'd read about how people would agonize over paint chips for weeks and months before committing... I can see how when you have a specific idea in mind that would happen, but if you have a more flexible idea of what you want, oops paint is a cheap and green way of getting it!

posted by SeattleMama on January 25th 2009 at 2:42pm
view SeattleMama's profile

in addition to the free stuff on craigslist, there are brooklyn and new york city freecycle lists. (freecycle.org to find them, and other cities.) i gave away several paint cans that were left in my apartment that way. as well as a bunch of other random crap.

posted by stefica on January 25th 2009 at 3:45pm
view stefica's profile

I wanted some pale green/lime paint for a couple of small jobs. I couldn't get it in sample pots, so I've experimented with mixing artist paints to come up with the shade I want. I have some aqua house paint and all I need to do is buy a small pot of yellow and mix it with aqua to get the colour I want. Don't be afraid of mixing and coming up with new colors altogether.

posted by violetta on January 26th 2009 at 2:20am
view violetta's profile

I have finally made an account after months of browsing this and design sponge sites. I love apartment therapy! I am more of a reader than a writer but this sparked my interest because I just painted my living room with some "Aura Paint that I got for about seven dollars at a local paint store. It is amazing at the deals you can find in the mistint pile. I like to shop with the local family owned type places and they seem to have alot more of this stuff than I have seen at the chain stores. I cant believe I didn't do this sooner !!

posted by tinkermommy on January 30th 2009 at 12:22pm
view tinkermommy's profile