apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


AT Survey: Painting Wood Trim?

12-1-paint-trim-1.jpg

It's a dilemma most Bostonians face at one time or another — whether to paint original wood trim inside your apartment or home. If the older place you moved into has managed to survive this long with its natural wood trim intact, do you keep it that way after you move in? Purists and painters please weigh in after the jump...

 
 

12-1-paint-trim-2.jpg

When we moved into our 100-year old home, it not only had original wood trim on all of the doors and windows, it sported high oak wainscoting in the dining room up to our shoulders. But, like neon.mamacita in her home above, we painted everything white and have never looked back. The whole process wasn't without its share of agony though; since we're fans of all things old and original, we understand the other side of the fence very well.

Pics: neon.mamacita's flickr photostream

Tags

Surveys, painting, fixing & repair

Related Links

Share

Comments (14)

I don't think there is any harm in painting wood trim. Just make sure that it's what you really want first, because it's very hard to get off.

I think the after picture looks very nice. The change in color really lightens up that room.

posted by idiotdogbrain on December 2nd 2008 at 1:38am
view idiotdogbrain's profile

I'm torn. I do like the way white trim looks.... but I like the wood, too. And old original wood is so beautiful, and once it's painted, you can never get the plain wood back (or at least, not without a whole lot of trouble).

posted by Idril on December 2nd 2008 at 6:47am
view Idril's profile

Paint paint paint paint, get rid of that old ugly oak trim!!!

posted by catfishriches on December 2nd 2008 at 8:08am
view catfishriches's profile

no! don't do it!

posted by palest_green on December 2nd 2008 at 9:20am
view palest_green's profile

I lean against it (reminds me of the beautiful little duplex where I grew up) but I think there's a time and place, especially if it's damaged.

posted by whytephoenix on December 2nd 2008 at 10:16am
view whytephoenix's profile

I like wood. It's beautiful. I would never paint over wood trim.

Now, the wood "paneling" that's really plastic, or some sort of plywood that landlords just love. That I paint over every time I can convince the landlord I'm not destroying precious woodwork. Weirdly, this is frequently hard to do.

posted by pyewacket on December 2nd 2008 at 11:50am
view pyewacket's profile

I edited that comment badly, but you get the point.

posted by pyewacket on December 2nd 2008 at 11:50am
view pyewacket's profile

It totally depends on the place. Some places have intrinsic antique value (I wouldn't touch the woodwork in a pristine Arts and Crafts bungalow) but a lot of older rentals that have been rentals for a long time are so NOT pristine that painting is an obvious improvement. I think it's pointless to maintain old-and-ugly just because it's old, but there are some cases where it would be criminal to ruin something beautiful. (I suspect those cases are relatively rare, though.)

posted by SherryBinNH on December 2nd 2008 at 12:02pm
view SherryBinNH's profile

Since the trim in our house was already painted when we moved in, we didn't have to make the decision, but I think it was the right thing to do.

Though I am grateful that whomever did the painting, did not paint our china hutch - it's beautiful old dark wood that I would never want to cover with paint:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/extramundane/7978396/

posted by ace on December 2nd 2008 at 3:31pm
view ace's profile

Faced with the same decision in our home, we decided to compromise by leaving the main floor (all oak) as is and painting the kitchen and upstairs (all pine) white. It was typical for homes to have pine in rooms other than the LR and DR since it was less costly. I would LOOOOVE to paint our LR trim, though...way too dark!

posted by behren on December 2nd 2008 at 6:22pm
view behren's profile

I'm all for painting the cheap contemporary stuff, but definitely not the old good wood! That is amazing stuff that is truly an asset to the house it's in, that you just don't see anymore. Haha, clearly I chose A!

posted by ejbrammer on December 2nd 2008 at 6:53pm
view ejbrammer's profile

Paint it!!!!! Im so tired of landlords and homeowners COVETING and extolling the virtues of "original woodwork". I've passed over so many apartments that boasted original woodwork because, frankly, unless you are really going for the old timey library or victorian parlour look, the wood tends to dominate the decor. Please paint your wood.

posted by findermaker on December 3rd 2008 at 8:41am
view findermaker's profile

Not everything old is worthy of preserving. Paint where it works.

posted by quiltmaster on December 6th 2008 at 7:15pm
view quiltmaster's profile

I'm facing the same issue. My bungalow is Arts and Crafts and still holds the original DARK wood (crown molding, baseboards, mantel, and built-ins). I don't feel comfortable painting the wood so I am looking for any wall color suggestions. I have tried numerous colors and none work with the dark wood.

I would paint the wood but I don't plan on being here for more than 2 years and fear that I may ruin something a potential buyer likes.

Any suggestions?

posted by bungalowmadness on January 3rd 2009 at 1:55am
view bungalowmadness's profile

Feeds

RSS icon Boston

+ City Feeds