apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Best of Three: Modern Toasters

2007-11-30-moderntoaster.jpg
Best of Three. All white, all designed by big names for well known manufacturers, all priced similarly, so which to choose for a high style toasting experience? Tell us your top pick for design longevity and value - Survey, prices and links below the jump...

Comments (16)

i love the look of the Jasper Morrison one, but you seem to get more bang for the buck with the Krups model.

posted by Morgante on 2007-11-30 17:43:22
view Morgante's profile

A toaster should never cost more than ~$20-$30. This is just so wrong in so many ways. Go to Target and get a stainless steel Black & Decker and you're fine.

posted by Talloush on 2007-12-01 00:23:03
view Talloush's profile

I would feel very pretentious if I owned a toaster named Alessi.

Can I vote for my $34.99 Hamilton Beach Toastation? Its sleek curved handle and dual toasting system make me feel, uh, like eating toast.

posted by NashvilleJen on 2007-12-01 02:01:13
view NashvilleJen's profile

I have the Jasper Morrison one, and I love it. It's quiet, discreet, and takes up very little counter space.

posted by kschaff on 2007-12-01 09:15:18
view kschaff's profile

that's what we all need...discreet toasters. Unless it folds your laundry and takes out the trash too, I'm with Talloush - toasters should not cost anywhere close to $150.

posted by Danio on 2007-12-01 16:16:00
view Danio's profile

Dualit 2 slot toaster.

posted by hdtex on 2007-12-02 10:23:30
view hdtex's profile

I bought a DeLonghi toaster oven about 10 years ago when I lived in NYC and never used my oven again there. When I moved back to CA, I have a kitchen that is easily 4 times the size and I STILL use the toaster oven instead of my big one. I've read that they are no longer as well made as my old white one when I was looking for a stainless one for my parents' newly remodeled kitchen--bummer. I think I'd get them the Krups if the ratings were more than just cool looking. I think the Alessi one is gorgeous, but I'd want it to do more than just toast. The cheapo ones like proctor silex seem to only last about a year.

posted by kaanswfm on 2007-12-02 14:45:33
view kaanswfm's profile

I agree that a toaster should not be costing $150. I mean, it's just toast, right? How good can it be?

posted by mstina on 2007-12-03 09:51:50
view mstina's profile

$150-$198 is a lot of scratch for a toaster. i reckon people plan to display these *modern toasters* proudly on their Carrera marble countertops? If they perform as well as a $50-$70 Cuisinart toaster, then go for it...

posted by Fjorder on 2007-12-03 09:58:04
view Fjorder's profile

I second the $30 Black and Decker toaster oven vote. I used mine for 4 years before giving it to a room mate a couple of years ago. It's still going strong for him.

posted by quercus on 2007-12-03 11:04:39
view quercus's profile

I've got an Oster toaster oven. I don't remember its cost exactly, but it was about midway between the $30 Black and Decker and the $175 Krups. It's bigger than either one. I use it more as an oven than as a toaster, as we're not big on toast in this house. But its great for DH who is a sweet potato fiend and will happily eat them every night of the week. Unless I'm cooking something in the big oven already, I just toss a sweet potato into the toaster oven and its usually done by the time the rest of dinner is. It's big enough that I could do a small chicken if I wanted or a small roast of some kind.

posted by RoseCampion on 2007-12-03 13:20:17
view RoseCampion's profile

If Rowenta makes toasters like they make clothes irons, I will take one! The iron was a bit spendy, but worth every penny.

posted by hejiranyc on 2007-12-03 14:23:52
view hejiranyc's profile

Why own a toaster when we all have oven/broilers? Let's reduce, people.

posted by fueledbycoffee on 2007-12-03 16:23:40
view fueledbycoffee's profile

My $40 Black & Decker is now 15 years old and still going strong. I pull it out each morning, do some toasting, and put it away after it cools. Its not pretty but it works quite well.

posted by SeanG on 2007-12-03 17:57:36
view SeanG's profile

After reading a large number of reviews, The Jasper Morrison toaster is not well made/built. Unfortunately I dropped my 15-year old toaster and the handle is broken. I now open the toaster with a knife... not good.

posted by SeanG on 2008-05-20 21:37:06
view SeanG's profile

I ended up with a Breville toaster and so far so good. It works and its small.

posted by SeanG on 2008-05-28 17:48:34
view SeanG's profile
Buy Text Ads