Well, what do you think? Did the readers get it right this time around?
Well, what do you think? Did the readers get it right this time around?
Uh-uh, not this time... this one totally tricked the majority of the crowd. Over a hundred of those playing along said the sixties, and over 80 guessers said the seventies but it is actually from 1952!
Only 32 readers said the fifties, meaning that this one was a nice tricky one. Here are some comments from the of the readers who got it right (pat yourselves on the back!):
Art: 50's. But I've been wrong all but once.
Moddog: Looks like the late 50s to me.
lookingupatleaves: 50s. I base this mostly on the style of the furniture and the fabric used for the drapes.
right angle:Based on fabric and the table, I voted 50s.
Maggie Ann: I'm going with late 1950s....
This photo came to me courtesy of Pam of Retro Renovation. She kindly sent me a scan of the photo from one of her vintage magazines, asking if I would like to use it for a Guess the Decade.

She followed up with some more info on the room and the book that it appeared in: The room was from a home in Johnson City, Tennesee, designed by architect Alfred Abernethy for his family. It appeared in "Living for Young Homemakers" with the tagline, Live High On a Low Budget.
Pam also added the following interesting points in her email to me:
In the postwar period, a proud America was defining its own sense of taste and style for the first time. While this home is very modern, it's also interesting to see the colonial touches - the other trend, reaching back to our pioneer heritage, that was very much a part of our newfound design identity. Another big trend during the period was "bringing the outdoors in," which you clearly see in the Hearth Room.
Also of interest is the color palette. While we tend to think of pastels when it comes to the 50s, "reassuring autumnals" also were very popular. These were taken specifically from brilliant New England fall colors. This interest in autumnals also came out of the 'outdoors in' trend - and even out of the desire to "instill a sense of warmth and security" during the Cold War.
As always, thanks to all who played along!
Photos: Thanks, Pam!
Oh, man!!! This was a good one! I was wrong, but it still was a good one. Nice job to all those who got it right!
view swanygirl74's profile
Wow - What a surprise!
view bepsf's profile
Hey...I said "a very avante gard 1949"! Only three years off...
view hdtex's profile
I guess I will have to accept the fact that there was an actual fifties, not just the fifties as interpreted by every decade since. I blame the show Happy Days.
view peacelily's profile
Wow, I guess it was ahead of it's time!
view charlenemcbride's profile
the interiors of houses in Johnson City, Tennessee still look like that... not kidding...
view samuels's profile
I never get these right, and this time I went looking for clues online. I ended up finding some really interesting rooms, but nothing close to this one. I didn't officially guess, but I was thinking 70's and that's what I went looking for.
I LOVE LOVE LOVE the cover of "Living for Young Homemakers", Janel. I really enjoy seeing images or sketches of the same room (or window or sofa with a different material) done different ways.
view TRUE BLUE's profile
it was that orange couch that threw me off -- looked late fifties, or early sixties, but to be safe I went with '60s. Early fifties and orange...
view mschatelaine's profile
it was the orange that threw me too
now that I look at the furniture I should have known better
view ohokrachel's profile
Wow, that totally fooled me. Love the furniture though...the lights hanging from the ceiling and the orange sofa made me think 60s.
view suzy8track's profile
Do NOT click the link for Retro Rnnovation. The site has been hacked and is sending nasties through your browser
view Chris - Annapolis's profile
I need to learn to just go with the decade just after my initial guess -- I guessed late 40s, possibly 50s -- and was just a scotch early. It turns out design really does move pretty slowly, and you don't see much turn-over across decades.
view Ulrika's profile
Amazingly, we have LIVING FOR YOUNG HOMEMAKERS magazine in our library. It's very cool.
view Mr. Dangerous's profile
Hi this is Pam from RetroRenovation.com. Thanks, Janel, for featuring this photo -- it was so much fun to fool everyone! BTW we have averted the hacker so check in anytime.
view 50s Pam's profile