apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Which Chicago Buildings Could You Live Without?

060906ugly.jpg

Okay, we're asking! AT reader Mike made a good point in the conversation about the greatest buildings, structures, and visual moments you all cherish in Chicago:

"Almost wish you'd ask about the worst buildings. Chicago has so many good ones, it's the bad ones that really stand out."

Tell us which ones really get to you...

 
 

(Image from The May/June issue of the Boston Society of Architects/AIA's ArchitectureBoston publication, via A Daily Dose of Architecture)

Tags

inspiration

Related Links

Share

Comments (13)

I like the design of Lake Point Tower, I just hate it's location. Montgomery Ward was right to try to keep all the buildings on the other side of LSD.

posted by Alyssa on 2006-06-09 14:45:21

Thompson Center
Marina City (just not a fan!)
River City (ditto)

posted by Virginia on 2006-06-09 14:56:43

The former Apparel Mart; which is now the Sun Times building. It is ugly, but nowhere near as ugly as it once was. There used to be no windows on the lower two thirds of the building, just a giant flat concrete wall.

Virtually all of the high-rise residential towers from the last 25 years, which were plopped on top of giant parking structures like a podium, with almost no ground floor retail. Just blank walls to the sidewalk and driveways for their cars. These are found mostly in River North. Especially; the ones from a few years ago; where they had the gall to put “townhouses” on top of the garages. (Like that would make them nicer?)

The hideous apartment building on the NW corner of Dearborn and Lake. It gives POMO a really bad name.

The telephone equipment building on Madison and Canal.

The blue building plopped on top of the vintage base SW corner of LaSalle and Madison.

I could go on and on… But you get the idea.

posted by Devyn on 2006-06-09 15:08:40

How could I have forgotten the Thompson Center? Blech. And I also forgot the ruined Soldier Field.

posted by Alyssa on 2006-06-09 15:30:21

One Inferior Place. Oops, is that supposed to be One Superior Place? Not by a longshot. Instead, a 502-foot-tall sun-stealing monolith, designed in all banality by Loewenberg & Associates for the block bounded by Superior, Huron, State, and Dearborn.

Godzilla called. He wants his gravestone back.

posted by Mike Doyle on 2006-06-09 15:55:13

The hideous block of apartment buildings in Cathedral Square near the holy name cathedral. Around Chicago Ave, Huron and Erie (west of Michigan Avenue. All generic creations and a sad attempt at "contemporary" architecture. The worst is the building where Roy's restaurant/blockbusters is. I remembered reading somewhere that somebody referred to it as the modern Cabrini Green. Yuck!


posted by Cyril - crewtag.com on 2006-06-09 15:59:04

Cyril, that building with Roy's and Blockbuster is none other than One Superior Place. You should read Blair Kamin's opinion of the building in "Why Architecture Matters". He's not a fan, either.

posted by Mike Doyle on 2006-06-09 16:08:48

Mid-Continental Plaza! It looms over Michgan avenue like a tombstone, filling a whole block with dreary verticality. I hate it. I've always hated it.

The recent conversion drawings for the building do offer some possible improvement; I wish they'd just take it down and build two new ones.

posted by mCrane on 2006-06-09 17:20:47

Thompson Center. i hurts my eyes just to look at it!

posted by bbt on 2006-06-09 17:38:18

I like Mid-Continental Plaza... I am worried the condo conversion is going to screw it up.

posted by Devyn on 2006-06-09 17:58:01

i really hate the smurfit-stone building.

i know it's had a few great movie cameos. they were all entertaining.

people argue that it's a very distinctive part of the chicago skyline, but i feel that it may be a bit too distinctive. from many angles it just sticks out like a sore thumb. especially at night. tacky.

posted by billy on 2006-06-09 18:48:10

I want to cry every time I see the "new" Soldier Field. That stupid spaceship looks so hideous atop Soldier Field. That place used to be so distinctive and such a great part of Chicago. Now it just looks like the aliens invaded...

posted by Vanessa on 2006-06-10 14:09:41

How about ANY building by Loewenberg & Associates? He's responsible for all of those hideous, generic, sand-colored high-rises in River North...

While I agree that the Thompson Center is generally ugly, it should be noted that those tomato-colored window panels were originally supposed to be white per Helmut Jahn's design. I can't remember whether economics played into the final decision (most likely), but blue and white would have completely changed the dynamic of the structure (in a good way), don'tcha think?

posted by MikeH on 2006-06-10 17:46:00

Feeds

RSS icon Chicago

+ City Feeds