We've actually run into this problem quite a bit: buy a large bag of tealights, use a handful, then chuck the bag into the nether regions of who knows where. Seriously, we found at least 4 nearly-full bags of tealights when we were in the process of moving (and we're still not sure where we unpacked those bags either, come to think of it). So we may be a teeny-weensy bit biased when we saw the functionality behind Sagaform's Circle Tealight Holder.
It may look like a glorified chip n' dip, but we like the fact that you can hide extra tealights in the base...or use both the bottom and the cover as dishes for olives (as suggested by retailer A+R) and other appetizers.
Available at A+R for $22.00