Are there any cost-cutting shortcuts for planting a green roof on my urban townhouse? My urban townhouse has a flat roof, and I'd like to green it up. Are there viable green-roof shortcuts that would have some insulating and stormwater-attenuating benefits? I was thinking of placing flats of plants around the roof rather than constructing a full planting bed. I'm hoping to avoid the expense of a full engineering study to determine the roof's weight-bearing capacity.
Sent by Rachel
Answered by: Mark Schrieber, Envi
Many green roofing manufacturers offer modular products that can be laid down in the manner you describe. These products are similar to plant flats, allowing for easy installation; they're lightweight, come pre-planted, and are more flexible than installing a permanent green roof system. A green roof constructed of modular units will still have all the benefits of a permanent, built-in green roof, including stormwater management, insulation, and reduced heat island effect.
Although a modular green roof will weigh less than an intensive green roof system, I still recommend you have an engineer complete a review of the roof structure to ensure it can accommodate the extra load. The cost for an engineer's site visit shouldn't be too much (I would expect $500–$1,000) and will be worth it for the peace of mind. If an engineering consultation or necessary retrofits to your roof structure prove too expensive for a green roof to be viable, try a white roof to achieve similar insulating benefits...
Including recommendations for modular green roof systems
Green Home Guide is an online residential resource from the U.S. Green Building Council. Find thousands of green home ideas, advice, and green professionals at Green Home Guide.
(Image: Flickr member Greenforall.org licensed under Creative Commons)
Comments (3)
Please have an engineer do a site visit. See if you can just get an opinion, rather than paying for a full-scale report (it's the report and the having to substantiate findings that costs you).
Also, note that the modular systems described above ARE like plant flats, except that they don't contain regular soil (very heavy) - rather, it's a soil medium (much lighter) that the sedums, etc. grow in. You have to account for a much heavier load when whatever you put on the roof is wet.
It's possible a white roof with planters (if you have access) around the edge is a better solution - then you can actually grow things. The perimeter of a roof is much stronger than the middle...
we didn't want an engineer to visit, either. our roof is not a solid-green roof - i'd say it's about 3/4 full - but we've done a good job of making the best with a limited budget. we've laid a waterproof tarp down first and tacked it down well, then planted sedums in a bark, crushed stone, sand and vermiculite mixture. we basically followed the instructions here:
http://www.readymade.com/blogs/readymade/2009/09/25/weekend-warriors-how-to-build-a-green-roof/
ours is 2 years old and we're real happy with it.
we installed an extensive (12" deep) green roof garden on our roof for less than $10,000, including seeds, growing medium, irrigation system and engineer. a full how-to is available here:
http://auachicago.wordpress.com/2009/04/03/advice-for-beginning-rooftop-growers/
and some photos of the garden here:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/pedalpowered/sets/72157621970823615/