apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Good Questions: New Carpet Too Small or Just Right?

RachelYellowRug.JPG

Apartment Therapy DC reader Rachel needs advice on her new carpet:

"I waited too long to buy PB's yellow moorish rug online, so when I found it on ebay, I snatched it up, even if it was a size smaller than I had initially been considering. So now that it's in my apartment, I'm wondering if it works. My initial thought was, wow, it is definitely too small, but now I'm not sure. Thoughts, AT peanut gallery?"


(Note: Include a pic of your problem and your question gets posted first.
Email questions and pics with QUESTIONS in subject line to:
dc(at)apartmenttherapy(dot)com)

 
 

Rachel,

We love the rug, but do feel it is too small for that room/location. The color and pattern are magnificent- is there another space where it might work in your home? Do our readers have opinions on the size of Rachel's new purchase?

(Note: Include a pic of your problem and your question gets posted first.
Email questions and pics with QUESTIONS in subject line to:
dc(at)apartmenttherapy(dot)com)

Tags

Good Questions, living room, carpet

Related Links

Share

Comments (68)

Yes, I'm sorry to say it, but that rug is too small. Don't worry you'll find something to replace it.

posted by itsthehouseshow on May 28th 2009 at 7:48am
view itsthehouseshow's profile

Hello -

Yes this rug is much to small, It looks like a 4x6, you probably want need to fo to a 5x8 rug to allow the rug to cover more space and not be over powered by the table.

cute rug tho!! :)

-Kiel

posted by KielOver on May 28th 2009 at 7:49am
view KielOver's profile

I defiantly think the rug is too small. i love it, but the table is too big and takes away from the rug.

posted by nytenglee on May 28th 2009 at 7:49am
view nytenglee's profile

Much too small. Nice though. Perhaps for a hallway or galley kitchen

I would 6X9 or nothing at all

Good luck

posted by Peter knockstead on May 28th 2009 at 7:50am
view Peter knockstead's profile

Too small - I would say you actually need three of them. Perhaps you could sew them together? Maybe even play it up with a dark grey or red x-pattern stitch. It does look nice and I can see why you wanted that pattern.

posted by home body on May 28th 2009 at 7:52am
view home body's profile

Too small, though I'm no authority on what the right size is.

posted by dazantz on May 28th 2009 at 7:53am
view dazantz's profile

I think it looks small (also due to the color contrast with your hard wood floor).

posted by RP on May 28th 2009 at 7:55am
view RP's profile

It's an adorable rug, one I would even consider! But yes, to agree with everyone else, I believe a living room rug should be atleast 5 x 8 and preferable 8 x 10. It should go under the couch a little bit, and you should be able to walk on it from the other side of the coffee table. This is more of an entry way rug of sorts.

Don't get rid of it, because its adorable -- unless you can find a replacement and sell this one! Good luck!

Laura
http://www.grafxnerd.net

posted by grafxnerd on May 28th 2009 at 8:02am
view grafxnerd's profile

too small ... sorry, that stinks.

posted by mlleErica on May 28th 2009 at 8:09am
view mlleErica's profile

There's an 8x10 one listed on eBay now.

http://cgi.ebay.com/POTTERY-BARN-MOORISH-TILE-YELLOW-RUG-8-X-10-NEW-_W0QQitemZ180357274256QQcmdZViewItem

posted by home body on May 28th 2009 at 8:09am
view home body's profile

Member of peanut gallery reporting for duty. It's a really pretty rug, but too small for that space.

posted by orchidday on May 28th 2009 at 8:13am
view orchidday's profile

And another seller has a 5 x 8 one listed on eBay too!

http://cgi.ebay.com/New!-Pottery-Barn-Moorish-Tile-Rug-~5x8~--Pineapple_W0QQitemZ260413708759QQcmdZViewItemQQimsxZ20090520?IMSfp=TL090520179005r20783

posted by home body on May 28th 2009 at 8:17am
view home body's profile

looks like a bath mat to me!

posted by tahitianpearl on May 28th 2009 at 8:17am
view tahitianpearl's profile

I would tend to agree with the other commenters that the rug is too small for this space, and I hope you can use it elsewhere! As for what size is appropriate, my suggestion is to go with something just a bit wider than the piece of furniture that will anchor it. For example, a living room rug might be anchored by a couch, while a bedroom rug might be anchored by the bed. As one other person mentioned, you want the rug to go just under the front legs of the couch (or the feet at the end of the bed). The overall size should be dependent on the size of the room/space and what other floor treatments you're using. If you're only using the one rug, you might want it to fit the ratio/dimensions of the open floor, but if you're using other accent pieces then you have some flexibility. Some of this is subjective opinion, but it's a good starting place until you find what works for you, your style, and your room. Hope that helps!

posted by murrayw76 on May 28th 2009 at 8:18am
view murrayw76's profile

Could you try a larger rug under the smaller one? Layering rugs has been a trend lately.

posted by joelmurr on May 28th 2009 at 8:20am
view joelmurr's profile

Yes, it is too small, but you should be able to use it in a transitional space ... hallway, entry, beside the bed. And then you'll feel justified in buying a bigger one for the living area :)

posted by SunnyBlue on May 28th 2009 at 8:20am
view SunnyBlue's profile

Unfortunately, your rug is entirely too small. Rugs that small are meant for small hallway alcoves and vestibules, and the sides of beds to prevent warm feet from immediately hitting a cold floor in the morning.

A rug in the space should be large enough to extend at least halfway underneath your couch and other furniture or wall-to-wall if possible. The larger rug will make the room feel more spacious.

posted by John H on May 28th 2009 at 8:24am
view John H's profile

Way too small. If your floor were really pale, it wouldn't be such an obvious issue [though it would still be too small]. On your dark floor, no, no, no... It is sweet, though!

posted by visualingual on May 28th 2009 at 8:24am
view visualingual's profile

I think it should definitely cover more area from the couch to media cabinet/credenza as well cover more area from one end of the couch to the other. I agree that a 6x9 or 5x8 would work beautifully -- personally, I think an 8x10 would be too large -- when living room rugs stretch under furniture, I think it looks a little silly, like the rug was purchased mistakenly too large.

posted by drettagliata on May 28th 2009 at 8:32am
view drettagliata's profile

Hi, nice rug, but too small. The rug should extend from the front of the couch to the front of the furniture piece on the other side of the room. You could use it somewhere else perhaps. CKimT

posted by CKimT on May 28th 2009 at 8:33am
view CKimT's profile

I agree with the other commentators it looks to small. Pity as it is rather pretty.

posted by hrhprincessfiona on May 28th 2009 at 8:42am
view hrhprincessfiona's profile

Looks like a yoga mat, you'd be happier with something larger. Go with your gut on this one.

posted by jacksonlalonde on May 28th 2009 at 8:44am
view jacksonlalonde's profile

I think it could look cool on top of another rug, something light in color so it wouldn't appear so stark against the dark floors.

posted by Cheryl K on May 28th 2009 at 8:46am
view Cheryl K's profile

It does look too small. Maybe you could take it to a place that does custom rugs and have them add plain fabric along the sides in a matching colour, so that you get a larger size rug with the original just being a central part of it. Or use it elsewhere, as others have suggested.

posted by Swordspoint on May 28th 2009 at 8:48am
view Swordspoint's profile

Well, I guess my gut was right. I think I'm going to try the rug next to my bed and hold out for a big rug in the living room. Thanks for all the helpful feedback!

posted by REMdc on May 28th 2009 at 8:58am
view REMdc's profile

I think in a small space a rug will only make it feel smaller. No rug.

posted by nGoodTaste on May 28th 2009 at 9:04am
view nGoodTaste's profile

I'm definitely with the group.

Area rugs should be for the comfort of your feet, not the feet on your coffee table. It's a sweet little guy, though, and I'd love to stand on it while I did the dishes!

posted by theserovingeyes on May 28th 2009 at 9:09am
view theserovingeyes's profile

too small. :(

posted by CherryTreeLane on May 28th 2009 at 9:24am
view CherryTreeLane's profile

i'm in the "too small" camp.

posted by liam. on May 28th 2009 at 9:29am
view liam.'s profile

Question off subject. What color is that on your walls?...I am on a perpetual search for the perfect neutral!

posted by manesha79 on May 28th 2009 at 9:32am
view manesha79's profile

Yup, too small. 5'x8' is generally the smallest you can go in front of a sofa. I'd be curious to see how your rug would look possibly layered over a larger rug. It would make the patterned rug look like an inset of a larger rug.

Your floors do look great, though, and I think you'd be fine without anything.

posted by queenbee1230 on May 28th 2009 at 9:38am
view queenbee1230's profile

I think it is too small under that table, but it is a wonderful rug. Can you place it beside the table? Can you afford another, complementary rug and have two (or more)around the table? I think it adds cheer and a second small rug in another nature color would be fabulous.

posted by Sousani on May 28th 2009 at 9:52am
view Sousani's profile

Sorry, but I definitely think it's too small. Hope you have another spot for it as it's an attractive rug.

posted by squarefeet on May 28th 2009 at 10:16am
view squarefeet's profile

You have a wonderful new wall hanging! It would look fab behind the sofa! My brother bought me a too small carpet runner from Pakistan, so I sewed a channel of fabric on the back, ran a dowel rod through the fabric and put two hooks on the wall to hand the dowel in. It now hangs above my bed and looks great.

Another idea, would be to have it over the back of the sofa as a sort of throw. Or why not buy some heavy cotton, lots of stuffing and make a huge floor pillow!

When you buy your next rug try and go bigger than you think you need, so that the rug 'connects' the furniture on the room and goes under your sofa.

Lovely rug / wall hanging :)

posted by Finnifog on May 28th 2009 at 10:22am
view Finnifog's profile

I think your rug would look fab as a wall-hanging above your sofa.

My brother bought me a very pretty, too small rug - which is now a wall-hanging above my bed. Sew a channel of fabric on the back (I used linen thread as it's so strong), then run a dowel rod through it. Add a couple of hooks to the wall, and hang up your rug.

Other ideas are to use it as a throw on your sofa, or add a heavy cotton backing and stuff to make a huge floor pillow.

posted by Finnifog on May 28th 2009 at 10:28am
view Finnifog's profile

toooooo small

posted by Maebird on May 28th 2009 at 10:30am
view Maebird's profile

Nice...but too small.

posted by STYLeyes on May 28th 2009 at 10:30am
view STYLeyes's profile

It would be a nice size to put near a bed.

posted by mribaro on May 28th 2009 at 10:32am
view mribaro's profile

that is a perfect pop of color on the floor - but, you know... too small.

posted by creative*type on May 28th 2009 at 10:48am
view creative*type's profile

Rachel,
After you put this beautiful rug next to your bed, try a 'test run' on the rug size in your original room. You can use blue painter's tape on the floor to mark the size you're considering now. And then live with it for a few days, or send it in here for further Comment.
Or, if you have another rug available that's the size you're considering (don't worry about the color, motif, etc. -- you're just checking for size), then roll up that rug, move it into this room, and put it under your coffee table. Try not to look at the color and pattern; just see the rug for size. This exercise can be a lot of work but it can be very worthwhile if you're buying from eBay or a source that doesn't allow returns.

posted by MaeEast on May 28th 2009 at 10:55am
view MaeEast's profile

too small. Cute, though!

posted by minnesara on May 28th 2009 at 10:55am
view minnesara's profile

I agree, the rug is much too small for the space. If you are really set on keeping the pattern, you could always get a larger rug in a neutral sisal or jute and layer them as many designers do. It's a great way to keep the rug you love as well as adding more overall size under the coffee table.

posted by DialJforJake on May 28th 2009 at 10:59am
view DialJforJake's profile

That's not a rug - it's a bath mat...

Living Room rugs should be 8x10 at a minimum - preferably 9x12.

Perhaps this one will work better in the kitchen at the sink or next to your bed.

posted by bepsf on May 28th 2009 at 11:02am
view bepsf's profile

One way to make it look larger would be to add a border of Flor tiles around the edge. I saw it done on AT sometime in the not-too-distant past, and it looked really well-done.

posted by Sassyladie on May 28th 2009 at 11:21am
view Sassyladie's profile

It's too small.

posted by Midwestdiva on May 28th 2009 at 11:27am
view Midwestdiva's profile

I also think it's too small. I do think it would look nice in a frame on the wall behind the sofa though!

posted by Ms. Pants on May 28th 2009 at 11:36am
view Ms. Pants's profile

That's too small. Because that rug is thin and brightly patterned, you might want to check out Urban Outfitters. The rugs are inexpensive and look to be the right size (5x7) for your room.

posted by kevoncubine on May 28th 2009 at 11:49am
view kevoncubine's profile

what everyone else is saying, but in a haiku:

kudos on fab find
tho, small rug truly looks off
chin up, keep searching

posted by liddybird on May 28th 2009 at 11:49am
view liddybird's profile

bepsf-Living Room rugs should be 8x10 at a minimum - preferably 9x12.

I understand how you feel about rugs that are floating in a vast sea of hardwood. Still- this seems like too hard and fast of a rule. Everyone's living room size and furniture arrangements are different. 8x10 might look huge in some spaces!

posted by StudioStarter on May 28th 2009 at 11:50am
view StudioStarter's profile

too small : (

posted by angietq on May 28th 2009 at 12:36pm
view angietq's profile

Much too small. Go with a 6x9 or larger - or do without. This looks a little silly.

posted by ChrisGal on May 28th 2009 at 12:40pm
view ChrisGal's profile

You should also ignore the person who says a living room rug needs to be an 8x10 minimum. It's all about proportion and an 8x10 would look like crazy wall to wall nastiness in your space.

posted by kevoncubine on May 28th 2009 at 12:42pm
view kevoncubine's profile

too ugly

posted by Vicadin on May 28th 2009 at 12:42pm
view Vicadin's profile

Inspired to do my own Haiku response (sorry for the rip-off Liddybird):

Moorish rugs do sing
Good choice for a rockin' home
Don't fail buying small

posted by FallingAcorn on May 28th 2009 at 1:26pm
view FallingAcorn's profile

You might take it to a carpet place and have a border of similar textured plain color added around the edges. (Although that might be cost prohibitive, if on a budget.)

Or layer it on a plain color bound carpet remnant. (Discount stores around here sell those for ~$30.)

posted by SherryBinNH on May 28th 2009 at 2:08pm
view SherryBinNH's profile

I too think the rug would be a lovely wall hanging, where it would contrast nicely with your grey walls. I don't mind envelope-pushing with rug sizes and I would consider laying down more rugs of the same size for a sort of large-format FLOR look but as it is, there isn't enough rug there.

posted by 1GH on May 28th 2009 at 4:38pm
view 1GH's profile

Layer a rug underneath for a "trim," just big enough to reach the couch and the same length on all sides and it should expand the visual field so it doesn't look too small.

posted by asked you first on May 28th 2009 at 5:39pm
view asked you first's profile

C'mon, people! Let's think outside the box!

Just move the rug -- so it's only partially under the left side (in the picture) of the table. Move it away from the couch and toward the console.

I think that will balance the room better, and the rug won't look quite so "chintzy".

posted by mdorothy on May 28th 2009 at 8:12pm
view mdorothy's profile

this peanut votes too small. till you find it larger (here's hoping) maybe try it in a different spot. craigslist has a "wanted' category. i've used it and actually scored a couple things i was looking for.

posted by cometz on May 28th 2009 at 9:47pm
view cometz's profile

…if you have to ask :)
I once heard an interior designer say that a rug should be at a size where the couch can have 2 legs on a rug 2 legs off. Which makes sence cause the point of a rug is for warmth underfoot.

posted by annamac on May 29th 2009 at 12:33am
view annamac's profile

@bepsf, my 5x8 rug visually separates the living area from the sleeping area in my studio apartment. An 8x10 would blur the borders and combine the spaces, and a 9x12 would qualify as wall-to-wall carpeting. So, for me, a 5x8 - 6x9 size works best.

@REMdc, why not pounce on one of the larger versions of your fab rug listed on eBay? You could always sell the wee one.

@Vicadin: asshole much?

posted by rosenatti on May 29th 2009 at 2:17am
view rosenatti's profile

Another really off subject question- where did you get your table? I've been looking for that exact kind and I can't find it (well, I can, but they've also been really expensive).

posted by MiniEnglishRose on May 29th 2009 at 8:56am
view MiniEnglishRose's profile

way too small

posted by KHale on May 29th 2009 at 10:57am
view KHale's profile

Yes, unfortunately too small. But I disagree that you shouldn't have a rug at all. I think a similiar rug or the same rug larger would be darling! Good luck ... oh, and rosenatti ... I concur with your comment about vicadin. Why go out of your way to be rude? Feel better about yourself, vicadin?

posted by SweetRosieBrown on May 29th 2009 at 8:04pm
view SweetRosieBrown's profile

I'm with everyone else-Too small !!

posted by gek on May 31st 2009 at 3:36pm
view gek's profile

Me too! I also want to know where you got the gorgeous table....

posted by ekaterina on June 1st 2009 at 7:44am
view ekaterina's profile

Paint is Duron herbivore.

As for the coffee table, it was a Crate & Barrel find from about 3 years ago.

I'll make sure to submit a new photo when I've settled on a larger rug - I've definitely appreciated all the feedback.

posted by REMdc on June 1st 2009 at 10:26pm
view REMdc's profile

forgive me if this was already suggested -
My thought was to get a second run, same size and a solid color of one of the colors in the rug. Place the table centered on the seam between them. Looks like a choice, not a mistake and you can have a rug that goes under the couch (the solid, I'd think).

posted by Loosetooth on June 6th 2009 at 12:06pm
view Loosetooth's profile

Feeds

RSS icon DC

+ City Feeds