apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Good Questions: New Shades to Replace Honeycombs?

SoyeShade.jpg

ATDC reader Soye needs help choosing new shades:

Hi AT! I ordered these honeycomb blackout shades because I was having trouble sleeping due to strong spotlights on my apt. building at night. While they do the job, and are also nicely insulating, it bothers me that I cannot control the angle and quality of light during the day, it is either on or off and I live in a sunny top floor apt. Also, it looks so bare after my previous plantation shutters (very broken down) that were an architectural feature and gave me nice variation of light, and I miss that.

The store is willing to let me change, my options are wooden venetian blinds in either light wood to match my furniture, or bright white to match the trim that I plan to paint soon. Down side - they don't completely block light, and also require more cleaning.

Should I live with the honeycombs, which are very zen and modern, and get a thin linen curtain to soften the light during the day when they are pulled up, or shall I go with the venetian blinds?

A third choice would be to get plantation shutters again, the wide kind, but they are twice as expensive, and I'd have to wait until I repair the window trim.

I would appreciate opinions about what would look best with my room. (the color will eventually be white). I have lots of modern light wood furniture, nice light parquet floors, and these two windows are the only ones in a large 15 X 17 foot bedroom.

Thanks, Soye

 
 

Soye,
We love the idea of plantation shutters, but understand your concern about price. If the honeycomb shades function well for you at night, then we would probably get some lovely curtains to allow you to soften the light when the shades are open during the day. We also vote a definite YES on painting the window trim a crisp bright white.

Readers- what would you recommend for Soye's shade dilemma? Let us know in the comments below...

Tags

Good Questions

Related Links

Share

Comments (13)

If you opt to stick with the honeycombs - they do have the top down bottom up feature that can allow the black out shades on 1 side and a sheer or opaque fabric on the other end of the blind. You could adjust to whichever density you prefer :) Picture this - but with black out on one end.
http://www.3dayblinds.com/Products/ImagePop.aspx?l=http://img.3day.com/web1/categories/honey/ult/phe_3d00076.jpg

posted by ut0piaseeker on November 20th 2008 at 11:36am
view ut0piaseeker's profile

I would buy whatever you think will work best aesthetically and then buy some black out roller shades to fit inside the window and behind your other choice for daytime looks.

posted by home body on November 20th 2008 at 11:56am
view home body's profile

I agree with homebody. I've installed plantation shutters for a client who still was bothered by the light coming through the closed slats. We installed blackout roller shades underneath and it's perfect. You don't even see them when the shutters are open because they are hidden behind the frame.

posted by LilyC on November 20th 2008 at 12:08pm
view LilyC's profile

Yes, rollershades if you have the room, or curtains, in addition to whatever blinds you like. A single window treatment isn't the only option.

posted by nashdp on November 20th 2008 at 12:19pm
view nashdp's profile

I vote for the natural venetian wooden blinds, layered beneath proper draperies.

posted by bepsf on November 20th 2008 at 12:34pm
view bepsf's profile

I've got the honeycomb blinds throughout my condo and can't wait to get rid of them for the same reason (already there when I got the place.) As soon as I can afford to replace them all with wooden blinds I'll be very happy.

posted by mattab on November 20th 2008 at 12:56pm
view mattab's profile

you're going to think this is jerky.... but here goes:

I too suddenly have big security lights from the new apartment bldg next door flooding my bedroom... I could black out but it gives me claustrophobia and impedes airflow (hate air conditioning)

so I've decided to pretend it's moonlight

and make it PRETTY

I have felt curtains that glow when light hits them... okay keep those...

now outside the part of the window that stays open I have hung a bunch of bushy and variegated hanging plants very close together... they break up the light and cast beautiful shadow shapes

I am also negotiating with the owners of the new bldg to tone down the lights a little with weaker bulbs (fat chance? well, I'm trying...)


if the spots are from yr own bldg, talk to your landlord about redirecting them or mitigating them in some way

if all else fails, I am willing to hanging a flashing neon sign outside my window and go for FILM NOIR

posted by Philip_Littell on November 20th 2008 at 1:19pm
view Philip_Littell's profile

ut0piaseeker - Good point about top-down shade options, but the photo above sure looks like the honeycombs Soye already has are the top-down variety.

I've had this problem in two different places -- but it was the ridiculously bright and unfocused DC streetlights, not a neighbor's security light, that needed to be blocked out. For street-facing rooms, I've used plantations hsutters (picked up on sale). But a similar and much cheaper option is to use wide-slatted wood or fake-wood venetian blinds. (I think HD sells "GranWood" or something like that.) The faux-wood version end up looking a lot like shutters, and do a better job of blocking light than the shutters I've got.

Another (perhaps more expensive) option might be the venetian blinds that have cloth "slats" and a sheer fabric attached to the outside, like the Hunter Douglas "Silhouette." Blinds.com has them and calls them "Horizontal Shadings." They go from sheer sort-of lightdiffusing to something more light-blocking (although they don't really block all the light). Smith and Noble also makes their part-honeycomb, part-venetian blind "Trilogy" shades.

posted by pilgrim on November 20th 2008 at 1:52pm
view pilgrim's profile

You can get the wide (2") venetian blinds in white. I have these in my bed room and they block light well (we, too, have a spotlight shining in on us courtesy of our neighbors). These also have a very similar look to plantation shutters and are a fraction of the cost (and are no more difficult to clean).

Another thought -- grass/bamboo roman shades with a black-out lining. We have those in our living room and I love the look (up or down) and the light control is wonderful.

posted by averillh1 on November 20th 2008 at 2:25pm
view averillh1's profile

If you really want to block light with blinds, you can get the kind with cloth or ribbons running down the front. Nice look & it blocks any holes.

I have two-inch wooden blinds in my bedroom - they were my affordable choice instead of plantation shades. The look is similar with a significantly lower price - particularly if you have standard size windows.

posted by mear on November 20th 2008 at 3:42pm
view mear's profile

i would agree with mear - 2" blinds will work with tapes (the technical term for ribbons) which will block out the light. The faux wood just like the wood but cheaper and the tapes look really clean! I have had them installed in a number of clients homes and everyone is impressed about how nice they look. And you can totally manage the light - which is perfect for your needs.

The Silhouettes mentioned above are another option but these tend to be a bit pricey...although I have access to a lesser known brand which are priced lower (Not 3 day or Next Day) with the same functionality.
Good luck!

posted by RA of ra redoes rooms on November 22nd 2008 at 1:03pm
view RA of ra redoes rooms's profile

I hope this isn't weird, but if you decide to go with the 2" slat venetian blinds, I happen to be selling two. I bought them for my DC row house, but they're just a little wide for my windows. Maybe they would work for you. My add is on the AT DC classifieds.

posted by clairedc on November 23rd 2008 at 10:28am
view clairedc's profile

I like the idea of keeping what you have and adding drapes to soften during the day.

posted by marge2 on December 1st 2008 at 12:18pm
view marge2's profile