apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Good Questions: Should I Re-Upholster This Couch?
Washington DC

GoodQuestionCouchDC.jpg

Hello AT DC, My mother is giving me part of the 3-part sectional that is now in her family room. It's all the fugly couch you can get. It's rusty orange chenille-like fabric with burns from an iron, but yet it has lasted the test of time (over 25+ years). What I like about it are the modern lines and low profile. My best friend also said it was THE most comfortable couch he ever slept on...

(Note: Include a pic of your problem and your question gets posted first. Email questions and pics with QUESTIONS in subject line to: dc(at)apartmenttherapy(dot)com)

 
 

Having said all this, I'd like to get it reupholstered. I've taken a look at the frame and springs (from a rip in the underside of the couch) and they seem pretty sturdy (the seat does not sag at all). The seat cushions are in great shape, while the back cushions have seen better days.


So what do you all think? Spring for the re-up cash or get a new sofa from R&B or Gus Modern? Have any suggestions for re-upholsterers in DC/Baltimore? A custom slipcover might be taken into consideration, but I don't want anything frilly.
cette-fille

Thoughts or advice for cette-fille?

>>To All AT Washington Posts

Tags

Good Questions, upholstery, Washington DC

Related Links

Share

Comments (19)

I'd only do it if I could have the entire sectional - as it is with the angled corner/back on the right it looks goofy on its own.

posted by bepsf on September 11th 2008 at 11:36am
view bepsf's profile

If it's between this couch and a Gus Modern, go for the Gus Modern!

posted by MayaB on September 11th 2008 at 11:39am
view MayaB's profile

Doesn't seem worth the considerable cost of reupholstering. The design is nice, but nothing you couldn't find new, or better new.

posted by IzzyIzzy on September 11th 2008 at 11:43am
view IzzyIzzy's profile

http://www.flickr.com/photos/photoinformal/2640146911/in/set-72157605995660886/

i have a similar couch, same age, and found fabric for$5/yard. it looks perfect, now. have them make a "cushion armrest" to take up the odd-looking corner space.
if skilled, they may even be able to make it look more symmetrical.

posted by maude on September 11th 2008 at 11:43am
view maude's profile

Reupholstery is expensive. Maybe more expensive than the couch is worth. And I agree that that slanted arm looks odd without the rest of the sectional.

posted by Lisa Hunter (Montreal) on September 11th 2008 at 11:45am
view Lisa Hunter (Montreal)'s profile

Buy a new one.

posted by SWEET CHOCOLATE on September 11th 2008 at 11:52am
view SWEET CHOCOLATE's profile

that was nice of your mom. or maybe it was really mean. new couch.

posted by jaime5 on September 11th 2008 at 11:56am
view jaime5's profile

I can't answer whether to do it or not, as I struggle with my own old sofa--old, comfy, well built, and great lines also, but I know the reupholstery would cost more than a new one. (Yet I haven't seen one like it, not do I relish throwing it to the dump when I get the new one).

Here is a recommendation I got from someone in the business:
http://www.arlingtoncountywebsite.com/josegoncalvesinteriors.htm

The next one I used twice and thought they did a great job:
http://www.manta.com/coms2/dnbcompany_w4y8c

posted by ValHalla on September 11th 2008 at 11:58am
view ValHalla's profile

usually reupolstering can cost as much or more than buying a new sofa. i had a friend whose mother gave her a sofa. she then paid a fortune to have it slipcovered and it became an albatross. (a constant burden). she had put so much money into though, that she endured it unhappily for many years to come. she wished she had just bought a new sofa.

maybe consider a slipcover if you keep it, but i wouldn't invest money in reupolstering.

posted by dM on September 11th 2008 at 12:23pm
view dM's profile

Hi I recently inquired about having a Queen Anne chair reupholstered. I called 2 businesses and was quoted between 750-1100. Unless it's a family heirloom or an antique it was recommended buying a new chair. Try craigslist, I have found some great things there.

posted by wndrwoman534 on September 11th 2008 at 12:26pm
view wndrwoman534's profile

If you can afford to reupholster it, you can afford a new(er) couch, and I would vote new couch.

posted by aladywhoknows on September 11th 2008 at 12:42pm
view aladywhoknows's profile

reupholstering would be the more green option. just sayin.

posted by mstrex on September 11th 2008 at 12:55pm
view mstrex's profile

You could drape it in kilims or oriental rugs (like Freud's famous couch) if you want to keep it and not spend $$$ on upgrades.

posted by Lisa Hunter (Montreal) on September 11th 2008 at 1:13pm
view Lisa Hunter (Montreal)'s profile

Thanks AT! I went with my gut feeling and let her keep the couch (she is going to get a new sofa anyway)!!!

I just searched on Craigslist (like wndrwoman534 suggested) and got a new(er) Mitchell Gold Shelter Arm sofa from Crate and Barrel. I would have bought a brand new Mitchell Gold, but even the sofa I liked was still too expensive when they had their sample sale. Also, I tried out a Gus Modern sofa and it was not as comfy as I hoped. I then considered the Loring sofa by Room&Board. However, I could not justify buying a sofa without trying it out first and I wasn't taking a trip up to NYC just to do so.

The sofa buying process is so time consuming!!!

posted by cinema on September 11th 2008 at 1:13pm
view cinema's profile

time to RIP

posted by hdtex on September 11th 2008 at 2:28pm
view hdtex's profile

I agree buy new, I would only reupholster if something had a unique and hard-to-find shape that you simply couldn't part with.

posted by Nivio on September 12th 2008 at 2:34am
view Nivio's profile

I presume if you could have afforded a new sofa your mother wouldn't offer this one. You can make a slip cover from sheeting and save for a new sofa. Your mother won't expect you to keep it forever and she is probably glad of the space.

posted by hrhprincessfiona on September 12th 2008 at 7:01am
view hrhprincessfiona's profile

I vote for reupholstering! Speaking from experience, it's very hard to find the perfect couch! It sounds like you have (free, comfortable, and still has life left in it), and I think the cost of reupholstering is well worth it. Good luck!

posted by Yuliz on September 12th 2008 at 8:16am
view Yuliz's profile

i had the exact same couch in my house when i was growing up! i'd know the rust color and the subtle pattern anywhere. i think our got burned with a curling iron. honestly, it was one of the best napping couches of all time, thus i vote for reupholstery if the cushions are in good shape.

posted by mariah on September 24th 2008 at 7:55pm
view mariah's profile