Slow Cookers vs. Dutch Ovens

Slow Cookers vs. Dutch Ovens

Mat Sanders
May 31, 2012

As we wrap up our coverage of soups on The Kitchn, we thought we'd share some of our best reviewed slow cookers and dutch ovens. While both make for great ways to create soups and stews, there are certain benefits that are unique to the different cooking processes offered in each.

Slow Cookers

With a dutch oven, you are able to place the system directly on the stovetop, making it ideal for browning meats before beginning cooking foods at low temperatures. Meanwhile, the slow cooker is really all about convenience. With this "long-and-low" method of cooking, you simply plug-in and combine ingredients to easily prepare delishous meals.

2a4220f7d6a4b32985d5a0e3338b916904ec6f81. w.94 h.71 s.centercrop All-Clad
Good Housekeeping rated this slow cooker the best on the market. The All-Clad 6.5 Quart Electric Slow Cooker with Ceramic Insert can be set to cook on high for two to eight hours or on low for up to 20 hours. All-Clad’s excellent customer service also offers to repair the machine if sent in at owner’s expense. $180

bdac7b975248da4c5020a17b8648f4cb1dd8752a. w.94 h.71 s.centercrop Crock Pot
The Crock-Pot Versaware Pro Slow Cooker SCV1600B-SS is one of the most versatile. You can actually place it on the stove to brown meats before plugging in and beginning the slow-cooking process. The insert can also be placed in the refrigerator for saving dishes and then right into the microwave for reheating. $100

c5522812357b62426fba629d01975da67c675c65. w.94 h.71 s.centercrop Amazon.com
The Cuisinart Programmable Slow Cooker PSC-650 is the best for the long cooking meats like brisket for long periods of time. With a unique lower-than-low setting for simmering, you can cook for around 24 hours. $100

Dutch Ovens

387891b8e1ad98b5f9a1a2daf5bcc1a10370d043. w.94 h.71 s.centercrop Le Creuset
This French cookware is often held up as the gold standard for enameled cast iron. Durable and designed to distribute heat evenly, it can last a lifetime if treated well. Le Creuset stands out from other brands for its rich colors, with new hues released seasonally. Shown: Le Creuset Round 5-1/2 Quart French Oven, $235.

4bfcce21739a311ac5b0c690ca4de7f89dbf8335. w.94 h.71 s.centercrop Crate and Barrel
The popular Mario Batali line is similar to Le Creuset in looks but cheaper in price. Availalbe through Crate and Barrel and online stores like Amazon.com, it comes in a limited color palette. Shown: Mario Batali Polenta 6-Quart Dutch Oven, $110.

a5417eca7d30a95b9a74ed5b24dafaf467b3520c. w.94 h.71 s.centercrop Emile Henry
Made from clay rather than cast iron, their products are crafted in Burgundy, France, where the local clay is said to have "superior heat retention." Their proprietary manufacturing process involves a very hard scratch-resistant glaze. Shown: 5-1/2 Quart Flame Top Round Dutch Oven Stewpot, $210.

Image: Le Creuset

Created with Sketch.