Is there like an "Advanced" search on Etsy that I can't seem to find? I have tried that site but have given up due to the frustration of not being able to narrow down the selection to what I am actually looking for.

I second that! I don't know of one.

I completely agree. Etsy is great, but it has grown past its search capabilities. I don't want to sort through 5,000 items to find one. I visit now only on referrals from others re a specific artist.

It's unfortunate.