When people step foot into my funky home, one of the first things they ask is, "Where do you find all of this stuff?" After I tell them that most of what we own has been found at thrift stores, they then beg me to take them with me next time I go. But I assure the visitors in my home — just as I assure you now — that successful thrifting doesn't involve any black magic or top secret tricks. Just a few practices that when used consistently, pay off over time.
- Go early and often. I have set days where I head to the local thrift stores, and usually have a route that I travel, so I can efficiently get the most shopping done in one day. The biggest and best shops are first on my list. And you might be surprised to find a line outside the door, especially on sale days. When I set a schedule for myself, it keeps me motivated to head out and see what there is to find. Consistency is what results in great finds.
- Make thrifting pit-stops. If you have a busy schedule and can't arrange your time around arriving at the thrift store on certain days or when the doors open, then try to find gaps in your day where you will have time to stop in and quickly browse on your way to your next destination. I have map searched all of the thrift stores within a 50 mile radius of my home, and if I have some extra time between appointments, I always pop in and see if there are any treasures to be purchased. This is how I have come across some of my best finds!
- Be efficient. If you're in a hurry, or are worried other shoppers might find treasures before you do, quickly browse the shop upon entering, and if you have a cart, throw anything that strikes your fancy inside. Then, after you've covered the whole store, look through your cart and narrow down your findings to things you really truly love. This is the time to be selective. Edit! Put anything that you don't really love back onto the shelves. If you have extra time, really dig through the bins and study the shelves, because you never know what kind of treasure you will miss by quickly browsing.
- Be selective, but don't overthink things! Momma always said, "If in doubt, don't." But I can't tell you how many trips I've taken to the thrift store where I have found something I loved, only to talk myself out of it. I always return for it the next day, and, of course, it is never there. So my rule of thumb is that if I am really tickled with an item, and it is only a few dollars, I will buy it. If in a few months I decide I don't like it, I will end up donating it back to the store. (By the way, I believe thrifting karma is real!) A great thing about thrift store shopping and donating, is that it is part of a cycle that simply redistributes things that are already in existence.
- Master the art of editing. It's always funny going thrifting with friends who rarely thrift. You hear things like, "Wow! This is so cheap, we should get it!" I gently ask them if they have room for the item, what they would do with it, if they really like it, and then I remind them to be selective in what they bring into their home. Anyone can go thrifting and fill their home with stuff, and believe me, it's a slippery slope. But after a few months of practice, it's pretty easy to develop a sort of trained eye. Be willing to admit when you've made a mistake. Don't keep something in your home just because you used to like it or once spent money on it. If you're not happy with it, then donate it. And who knows, maybe your thrifting luck with improve with your generosity!
Image: Amanda Johnson

Comments (30)
Great tips! I would add "Don't be discouraged when you have days where you don't find anything." I am a big thrifter, and whenever I take along a friend who doesn't usually thrift, if they don't find anything they tend to get upset and feel like it was a big waste of time. Some days you find lots of great stuff, sometimes nothing! That's just how it goes!
I love this! There is an antique/ thrift store that I have been going to since I was sixteen and the ladies know me very well because I started going so well. I love buying gifts for others from there also. :)
I'm with you. It's so easy to get sucked in by "sticker excitement". I try to reason with myself, "If I would buy it at full-price, then I can take it home." It's a good mantra.
-anna
at the chateau
I think these are great tips, but practically useless if you live in area with terrible thrifting prospects. It doesn't matter when or how often I stop by local thrifting outlets there's nothing there but game show consolation prize furniture and baby items.
I read somewhere once that it's a good idea to go on a Tuesday - people donate on Saturday or Sunday after a yard sale, staff puts it out by Monday evening/Tuesday morning. Apparently that's when the fresh stuff is there :)
I always bring something to donate when I go to the thrift store. It gives me an excuse to go to the thrift store, it helps me cycle out things I don't want anymore and I feel like it brings me good luck for my thrifting!
My biggest tip for thrifting is PATIENCE. I sometimes take a friend with me who never goes thrifting, and they always look close to tears of boredom by the time I'm done. Sigh. Amateurs!
I think it's important to carry of list of things that you would like to find, organized by room, plus measurements if you have them. Then when you find something you love, you can scan your list for where you might use it.
Example:
My office: two chinoisserie lamps, one french arm chair, one ottoman, one side table at least 20" tall x 20 wide.
My living room: one glass front buffet, not more than 60" wide, at least 30" tall, two tall-back arm chairs, one round cocktail table, 1 black coolie-bell lampshade
Bedroom: large baroque mirror
I hear wealthier neighborhoods generally have better stocked thrift shops and garage sales. I also hear rural neighborhoods generally have better stocked thrift shops. I notice that church or other charity thrift shops generally have nicer stock and staff than for-profit thrift shops.
I second the idea of bringing a list of things you want or need. That doesn't mean you shouldn't walk the whole store---just focus when you get to those areas that contain the items on your list. (My focus area this week is blue and green glassware, because that's what I need for a project at the end of the month.)
The local science museum had a large, well stocked thrift shop located miles away that was manned by volunteers from the "friends of the museum" group.
Yep, location matters! I find I have the best luck in my parents' small town in Indiana (where no one is looking for the stuff I'm looking for) versus here in Chicago (where everyone and their brother is looking for the same stuff I'm looking for). It's like a secret stash!
Would someone PLEASE tell me where you go for a good thrift in Denver other than Mile High? I have followed your advice with ARC and Goodwill and nothing, AND the sad thing is, what you do find is not inexpensive (read cheap). Even furniture on Craigslist is listed for crazy prices.
Good tips, all. I've had especially good luck with thrifting since I started commuting by train -- there is a good thrift store on my walk home from the station, so that I often drop in for a quick browse on my walk home. Frequent stops really pay off!
The other editing tip I would add is this: be realistic about your ambitions when buying "projects" -- if the item is not perfect as it is, will you actually get around to the painting/refinishing/recovering that will make it perfect. If you're already swimming in unfinished projects, maybe take a pass.
I second the "don't get discouraged if there's nothing you like on a particular trip." Some trips, there's just nothing even worth a peek, and then the next trip, there might be three totally awesome things. You never know!
moreshooz... I know your pain! I also have zero luck at Denver thrift shops. I have heard lore that some are better gold mines than others... but I still don't know which ones (Arc on south broadway is the only one I can think of.)
I have better luck at the second hand shops and antiques shops.
One of my favorites (Stagestop) closed a few months ago. There are a couple really good ones on South Broadway... near abouts Herman's Hideaway... but it's hit or miss.
Regarding the trips where you don't find a thing and the garage sales full of grubby plastic toys, my mother (who is a master thrifter) would always say "you have to kiss a lot of frogs before you find a handsome prince..."
Oh, I'm a sucker for the sticker price but I'm getting much better at fending off the temptation. One thing I do, and it really helps when it comes to editing or gaining an objective view, is to take pictures of your home. When you get to stand back from where you usually view it you get a different perception of your own place. Then you can start figuring our what works and what doesn't work.
I wish I could thrift but I work in a city office full-time (no op-shops anywhere around there) and the locals are only open until lunch on Saturdays and not at all on Sundays. It takes a lot of effort to be out of the house before 11 on the weekends!
I also don't have anyone who can lend me a trailer, a hitch on my car, or know how to drive a rented truck so Gumtree (Australia's version of Craiglist, I guess) is a bit useless for furniture as well. :(
Hopefully I'll have at least a little bit of luck when I move into my own apartment soon...
Great tips ,all things that I do ,My friends are constantly amazed at what I bring home. I have set days too and I usually set aside a good couple of hours on my 'best' day of the week when I go to all my shops . In one shop I always go to the back first ,I seem to find great things that others who just start browing in the front seem to miss. I have gone up to the counter with something and had comments such as 'Where was that?' !
I wish I could thrift more often but being prisoner in a corporate job ties one up pretty tight! I go whenever possible. Sometimes I'll just pass by one on the way to the grocery store and make my BF make a U-turn just to stop by for a few minutes. It doesn't ever really have to take really long. Just a quick peek, you never know what you will find with just a quick peek. But on days I have more time and can actually make a thrift store my destination, I yelp some review on local thrift stores and hit all the popular ones in the morning (weekends of course). Even though I don't go as often, I do find little treasures here and there. I haven't yet found my mid-century night stands yet though!
I always carry a tiny measuring tape in my bag. Has come in handy many times. Sorry folks, but I "make the rounds" alone - I can be totally focused. I agree with making the quick run thru and then browsing. You can even find me in a good old fashioned junk shop pulling out a cardboard box under a shelf and going through it - never know what you are going to find.
It's so easy to get distracted, when thrifting, that I finished mentally designing my house and now when I go hunting I have a purpose I'm trying to fill (bedside tables, shelving for the library, brooches that fit a specific theme, etc).
I also, frequently, took a lunch hour break from the corporate office tower to go to a local thrift shop. I'd set a time and dollar limit for myself but there was nothing like the thrill of the hunt to ward off the bad job blues. Over a few short months I was able to assemble a beautiful complete bar set, with many mother of pearl handled bar tools, for less than than the cost of two cafeteria lunches.
That's what I'd like to see a discussion on: Thrifting/Flea friendly cars! When I finally do trade in my Beetle, I need something big enough for junking, comfortable enough for road tripping, and great gas mileage for all that + commuting. Will add the Ford Focus Wagon to my list ^_^
You've listed some great tips.
Does anyone know how Goodwill operates these days since they have an online store? Friends & I have noticed that a local Goodwill (nestled among very upscale suburbs) doesn't have the great selection that it once had. We suspect that great donations are set aside instead of being put on the floor for sale. I've even heard people say not to donate to Goodwill ... I've been meaning to find out why.
@IaayIzzy: I agree about not getting discouraged. There are many people that hate to shop & think it can take goo-gobs of time ... especially thrift shops & places like TJMaxx HomeGoods that have a little of everything. But, it doesn't have to if one avoids getting sensory overload. One can read a book for indepth research, leisure (like a novel) or by section skimming it like an encyclopedia (flip through to sections that are applicable). If I'm hitting a bunch of shops or in a hurry, I skim (i.e., look over the store in general & then walk through briskly focused on specific categories (ceramic, linens, kitchen, solid wood, etc.)) instead of taking everything in. That way I get in & out of stores & don't feel discouraged if I don't find anything.
@Amanda: I grew up in the Chi-town burbs & miss the shopping ... so homesick & green with envy! Your tips about pit-stops & knowing your 50 mile radius are genius ... so true! A few years ago, I got familiar with local shops by keeping a list in my glovebox & started keeping my eyes peeled for them. Knowing what streets have clusters of shops makes pit-stops oh so easy.
More than anything, the smell of most thrift stores keeps me from wanting to spend more than ten minutes browsing. I can't wash that icky smell off me fast enough.
@lifeabundant
I'd always heard not to donate to Goodwill because their higher-ups rake in so much cash. Looking at these links though, it looks like a regional thing, and partially understandable (the the legal requirement in the second)... I don't know too much about it, but this is what I found.
http://taxdollars.ocregister.com/2010/08/02/goodwill-charity-exec-earns-354605/61979/
http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=105x3822635
you can always "thrift" online, too! like here at Junk and Howe: http://goo.gl/SpKBj
I can't stand to thrift store shop with other people, they never move fast enough!
Another pc of advice I'd give is: learn what your budget can handle in frequency of visiting the stores. If you hit a circuit of stores on different days of the week. Even though it's "cheap", I rarely leave without something & those little somethings add up suprisingly quick! I can't tell you how many weeks I've been surprised to find that my purchases ($5 here, $10 there) have added up to $100s!