Living Room Before: A drab wall color and motel style pleated curtains make this room depressing even without the clutter. Poorly framed photographs crowd the mantelpiece while a clock in the living room means this can never truly be a place to relax (you and your guests will literally be "watching the clock").
Living Room After: Swapping the dull curtains out for white curtains that allow for privacy while still letting the sun filter through means that you can still throw a deep color or pattern on the walls (here, grasscloth adds texture but paint would be another, cheaper option) without losing the brightness of the room (The Aina or Merete curtains from Ikea are both good options). Painting the fireplace white makes it pop as the room's focal point. Atop the mantel, candles and simple vases don't detract from the fireplace while the photographs have been culled and reframed (if you're going to share photographs in the living room, treat them like art: pick your best, blow them up and/or crop them and put them in simple frames to reveal their beauty.). Replacing the clock with a mirror works to bounce light around the room; its resemblance to the sun reinforces the brightness. A few good pieces of furniture -- a simple couch, a basic coffee table (the only new pieces), an end table with a lamp with a big, simple shade, bright chairs -- and a sprinkling of colorful accessories (Ikea, Ross, PIer One, and Target are all good places to find simple accessories) complete the transformation. Notice how nature, in the form of a bowl of oranges, a terrarium, a easy care plant in a simple pot, large leaves in vases, help bring life into the room. The oranges and the orange throw pick up the orange of the chairs and really pop against the blue walls. Keep the palate simple; the orange chairs, which were already there, provided a jumping off point for choosing the other colors. White, grey, and varying shades of deep greyed blue act as neutrals against the bright orange while gold (in the mirror, a frame, a pillow, the andirons) and silver (the candlesticks) act as bright complementary accents.
Dining Area Before: A dated lamp fixture, those drab walls and pleated curtains and a table piled high with stuff do not invite relaxing meals.
Dining Area After: A new simple light fixture (try the Eden from CB2 for a good modern light fixture that won't put a dent in your budget) puts the spotlight on the table and the meal. Simple art, a colorful vase of flowers and new curtains keep the focus on the purpose of this area.
Bedroom Before: Clutter's not the only issue here. Old bedding, no night tables or bedside lamps, an open closet and a desk don't invite relaxation. The lack of curtains means this room gets no privacy and too much light.
Bedrom After: Neutral walls, white curtains, a nightstand (with a drawer to hide a book, medicine, hand cream, glasses and other necessities) and a lamp on either side of the bed speak to this room's new focus on relaxation and rest. A lidded basket under each nightstand adds extra storage.
Bedroom (other side) Before: Piles of clutter, a chair heaped with more stuff and dark walls make this room depressing. The wood furniture is not only depressing, but provides little storage.
Bedroom (other side) After: A bright white credenza adds storage, floor to ceiling curtains let the windows read as "modern" rather than "bunker," and a comfy chair set up across from the TV is not only a place to curl up with a book or put on shoes but speaks to the reality of kids piling into the master bedroom in the morning to hang out with their parents and watch morning cartoons.
Images: Laure Joliet









Shaw's Original Fir...
Hoarders are scary people. I'm morbidly fascinated by the TV shows, but they also upset me and tend to make me purge something soon after viewing! I can see accumulating too much stuff -- I have leanings that way, myself. What I have never "grokked" is the whole business of piles and stacks and filth. (Especially the animal hoarders -- or those with non-working plumbing or decaying food lying about...)
But how can you lose with hoarder "before" and "after" scenarios? Any improvment seems huge. Actual design improvements are beyond huge!
do they do updates on these shows cause all that time and money went into these places and people but how many stay that nice seriously
I loves those shows and fantasise about getting my mother on one. Honestly, she's worse than most of the ones I've seen; furniture stacked to the ceiling with tiny pathways through rooms like a labyrinth. As a result of growing up that way my own house is tidy and minimalist, but I am constantly purging anyway. I keep downgrading my bookcases to a couple of wall mounted shelves to keep my storage/display areas limited. I love the grasscloth wall treatments in the after photos above and the grey sofa is so nice.
I like Peter Walsh and his book, It's All too Much. That said, I don't watch hoarder shows because I feel bad for the hoarders. I doubt that those hoarders cleaned up by a TV show can stay clean afterward. The underlying causes of their hoarding aren't treated.
The “after” rooms are pretty -- but as someone who is close to a hoarder, it’s a ridiculous concept for a show. It’s a deep, psychological urge that isn’t going to be changed along with bed linens and wall colors. A hoarder can look at these rooms and think they are beautiful, but that doesn’t mean they can maintain them. Hoarding is not “messy” or “disorganized” or “lacking style.” It’s a very real condition.
For the record, the hoarder I know has a great sense of style. With significant help and prodding, she has redone rooms in her house with results equally as dramatic as these photos. But the hoarding quickly takes back the room. It’s very sad and frustrating, considering how much she loves and appreciates the fixed up spaces.
I'm going through this now with my mom and her 50+ years of accumulation. She has the WWII mentality and has a hard time separating her emotions from items that are broken, decaying, and have outlived their use, not to mention having wall to wall furniture. We're trying to ease her into parting with things but we'll let her keep things that are in good shape. She doesn't understand that she's letting her belongings control how she lives. It's an ongoing process.
I think it's a form of abuse to put these people on TV. They need serious help and to "cure" themselves, they need to declutter themselves.
I totally agree with deignhotdog. Hoarding and plain old clutter are very different. Hoarding is a debilitating illness. I've watched a couple of hoarding shows and it's heartbreaking to see the pain of everyone affected.
Clearing the clutter from a Hoarder's house against their will can cause severe emotional damage and has been known to lead to suicide. Hoarding is a very real mental illness associated with OCD and cannot be cleared away with paint colors and a professional organizer.
my old apartment building manager was an animal hoarder. really sad and awful. :-(
these makeovers are dramatic- but like others, i wonder how long until they go back to how they were.
I agree, I would really like to see a follow up of these people to see if they actually keep it nice.
I feel the same way as many others here - I find hoarding shows fascinating, but they're not in the best interests of the hoarders. Addressing hoarding is a long, slow, quiet process. TV is all about short, fast and loud. They really don't mesh.
These improvements are lovely. I, too, am curious to see where the hoarders are afterward. Does the show provide ongoing psychological help and support? I really can't wrap my head around hoarding. I know a friend of a friend who is a hoarder and I find the person incredibly frustrating; even in other people's homes, she will instruct people on how not to rip the wrapping paper on gifts she has brought so she can take it home and reuse it. I think to some degree, everyone who has lived through the world wars has the inability to part with things. I've seen it with my own grandparents. But hoarding is beyond even that. I get extremely frustrated with the hoarder I know because she really is a perfectionist in many ways and yet cannot control her hoarding even when it burdens and annoys others (and I barely know the woman).
My husband and I tried to help my MIL with something that seemed similar to hoarding before Alzheimer's killed her. I'd guess that the cause of hoarding in the elderly often is some sort of senile dementia. If a gerontologist were to assist as appropriate, e.g., with drugs, then helping elderly loved ones who hoard probably would be more productive and less stressful for all involved.
I've watched these shows as the people dig through their piles of stuff. It's hard for me to understand them not wanting to let go of the things they didn't even remember they had. It seems like it would be better to just get rid of most of what's buried or hidden BEFORE they go through all and become re-attached.
I just finished watching my first episode of Hoarders. It wasn't enjoyable because it's virtually hopeless. I liked watching Mission: Organization and Clean House because happy endings seemed more likely. Even there, I'd guess Clean House guests have a high relapse rate.
Love the color of the walls in the living room and love the grass cloth in the bed room.
Maybe the people who benefit most from these shows are not the extreme hoarders, but people like me who appreciate inspiration about how to make my life feel better. Reading "Does this Clutter Make My Butt Look Fat," by Peter (Enough Already) Walsh, helped me make my studio kitchen feel good. Moved non-kitchen stuff out, leaving room in the kitchen cabinets for kitchen stuff. O Beautiful for Spacious-ness! His point, if you jam too much stuff it, looking at it and being around it feels bad. Obvious, but elusive.