The light green in the deer blanket looks fresh and lovely! I also like the green in the mobile. But then, I am a bit partial to green. A peachy color would also be really nice with all the tones in the stuff you already have, and with the white trim.

I'm assuming the yellow in the curtain you drew is probably not the exact shade of the real curtain. A light yellow could work in the room as well, perhaps the shade of the yellow beads in the mobile. Or match the curtain's yellow leaf.

I would probably do the light green if it were my house, but a beige peach color could look great and very vintage.

I bet that vanilla color will actually look great.

I like the idea of the olive green or even a light mocha color.

I think a nice peachy-orange could work really nicely. The crib might fade away with a vanilla background. You could always do one wall peachy and the rest green, or vice versa...

I would consider leaving the vanilla and doing an accent wall in the chocolate. The way I picture the room, I would paint the wall with the windows the brown so you would still get a lot of reflected light in the room off the vanilla walls and the brown wouldn't be too "heavy" if it is offset by the contrasting trim (I'm assuming there is white trim on the windows?) and curtains.

You've chosen fun things to work with!

I agree about the crib fading away. I think an accent wall would be great behind the crib!

I think yellow, to make the room seem bright and cheerful. I am always stuck on paint color. I just bring a swatch of fabric to Sherwin Williams, where a wonderful woman helps me find the right shade of paint. She paints it on a card, dries it, so I can decide if I really like it. They have low VOC paints now, which is awesome. Get a sample from wherever you go to try if you're not sure. The more items you can bring with you the better: bedding, mobile, etc.

I love the white crib. Am trying to decide if I should paint mine white (it's an older crib, same style, in dark walnut). The white seems so much fresher.

Good luck!

I'm going pale for a pale robin's egg blue-one that has a hint more green to it.

All your other accessories are precious-that's one lucky baby!!

Our son's room matches your description of the layout almost completely, and his room is painted a deep chocolate brown. It's WONDERFUL! Everyone who comes over marvels about how great his room looks; it doesn't feel too dark at all. One note: it does have white wainscoting, so that probably helps.

Thanks all! There are some awesome suggestions here. I'm going to discuss them with my husband and see what we turn up.

I'll send a picture of the completed project. It will be great to have it done and ready for our little one! :)

Thanks especially to housefulloffur for reminding me that SW has those low VOC paints now. That's definitely the way to go!

Painting the crib definitely updates the look, but if I'd been able to find one in a nice dark walnut, I might have taken it. I love the look of the dark wood with a well-loved handmade quilt thrown over it.

Speaking of low VOC paint, Lowe's carries Olympic paint which is zero VOC and low odor. It's inexpensive and I really liked it.

Thanks, Chris, for the encouragement to keep the crib dark. It's being used only once a week by my visiting granddaughter, so I was torn about how much time to put into it. She's already 8 mos. old, so I know the time we'll use it is very short. I like dark wood also, but the other bed in the room is white iron. Don't know how to blend these two.

We look forward to seeing your finished room!

I would pick a light milk chocolate color or a pale creamy orange-like a creamsicle.