On the lookout for an eco-friendly pillow? We've heard a lot about buckwheat and organic wool pillows, but reviews vary depending on what type of sleeper the reviewer is (stomach, back, side) and how firm they like their pillow. Everyone's different. So how to choose! First, you need to know the options and what they're best for:
1. Latex: made of 100% latex, which is naturally hypoallergenic and resists dust mites. Available in standard, queen and king sizes.
- Best For: Side and stomach sleepers. Side sleepers should stick to the contoured shape, as the pillow's firmness helps support the neck and keep the spine aligned. Stomach sleepers should go for the soap shape, which tends to be softer and flatter.
- Care: Hand-wash the latex in warm water with mild soap, blot with a towel, and air dry. Case can be machine-washed.
- Average price: $69-$89
2. Buckwheat: as covered in this review by Emily, buckwheat pillows are filled with buckwheat hulls and, if you're used to fluffy pillows, may take a bit of time to get used to. Buckwheat is also great for air circulation and keeping your head cool, especially in warmer weather. Look for ones with an organic wool outer layer to muffle the 'crunchy' sound.
- Best For: All types. A zipper lets you fill or remove the hulls to your desired thickness. You could even make your own.
- Care: Rinse the hulls in cool water, drain, and air dry. Machine wash the case.
- Average price: $75
3. Kapok: is a silky fiber harvested from ceiba trees (a tropical tree). After the ripe pods of the tree are harvested, the seeds are removed and the fluffy fiber is then thoroughly cleaned and dried. It is 8 times lighter than cotton and feels very much like down (without the accompanying allergies).
- Best For: Back sleepers. This material is very fluffy and offers minimal resistance.
- Care: Machine wash gentle cycle in warm water. Cool dry with tennis balls for fluffing.
- Average price: $50
4. Organic Wool: A pure wool pillow is great for regulating temperature and moisture as the wool fibers naturally wick moisture away from your face so you remain at an even temp all night. Wool is also naturally mold, mildew, and fire-resistant.
- Best For: Side sleepers, due to the firmness of the wool, although you can find differing degrees of firmness.
- Care: Spot clean with water and vinegar. Air outside in the sun or fluff in a dryer with tennis balls to freshen.
- Average price: $70
5. Organic Cotton: organic cotton pillows are made without perfumes, formaldehyde, or dyes, are very soft and will compress over time.
- Best For: Stomach sleepers, because you can squish it.
- Care: Cotton will shrink if you wash it, so wash in cool water on a gentle cycle, or spot clean with water and vinegar.
- Average price: $45
6. Millet: Similar in performance to a buckwheat pillow, the hulls from millet are smaller and circular, making for a smoother and softer pillow (also less noisy) than a buckwheat pillow.
- Best For: Side or stomach sleepers
- Care: Rinse hulls in cool water, drain, and air dry. Machine wash case.
- Average price: $70
To buy any of these pillows, check out these top sources:
- Good Night Naturals
- Pure-Rest Organics
- White Lotus
- The Clean Bedroom
- Allergy Buyers Club
- Amazon
- Pristine Planet for comparison shopping
Tell us your sleep position first and then give us your review!
Related Posts:
• How To Wash a Pillow
• Pillow Search: 3 Reasons To Like Buckwheat
• Revisiting Buckwheat Hull Pillows: Make Your Own!
• Experience and Reviews Sleeping on Wool Pillows?
• Latex Pillows: Any Experience?
(Images: all pillows via A Happy Planet. Originally published 2011-01-07)


Shaw's Original Fir...
Im sorry, but the buckwheat pillow sounds awful!
http://www.oflifeslemons.blogspot.com
I actually made myself a buckwheat-filled pillow and I absolutely LOVE it. I'm a side sleeper and have a hard time finding *just the right* pillow that stays lofty but isn't too high. I find synthetic poly-fil pillows are the right height but too hot, and I couldn't bring myself to spend the $70+ for a nice organic buckwheat pillow I found online. I crafted my own pillow with organic buckwheat hulls from http://l-oma.com/ and put in a fat layer of organic wool to make my pillow extra comfy...ordered crib-sized organic wool batting from www.woolenmill.com and folded it up so it filled the pillowcase evenly. I have a sewing machine so I stitched up a small cotton ticking pillowcase for the hulls, then a larger pillowcase to hold the hull pillow and the folded wool batting. Love love love my pillow and sleep much more deeply at night.
@SarahLemons: I use the Bucky Duo pillow which is a 2-chambered pillow with buckwheat on one side and millet on the other. The Millet side is less noisy so you get all the benefits of a buckwheat pillow without the noise. I've been using it for a year and I'll never go back!
I used a buckwheat pillow recently while on a trip to Japan. I didn't find them all that noisy, and it was incredibly comfortable! It's on the budget for next month. :)
LOVE my buckwheat pillows! Fully customizable ... if my neck needs more support, I adjust it so that the bulk of the pillow is under my neck, etc. My only complaint is that the cases were zipper-free! Why on earth would anyone create a buckwheat pillows sewn completely shut ... knowing that the hulls should be rinsed in water & air-dried & the case should be washed? So, a seam ripper is required for every wash? Argh! Next time I clean them, I'm going to sew zippers in the cases. Thankfully, now Sobakowa sells buckwheat pillows in removable cases.
@Cambria
@Spirilla
Thanks for some great ideas ... I was toying with the idea of dividing one of my buckwheat pillows into two or three small pillows. But, after reading about layering buckwheat with other natural fillings, I may create one of them instead. Love Spirilla's creation! Wonder if a similar pillow with buckwheat-filled chamber surrounded by down/feather would be comfortable or weird.
Has anyone successfully reused down/feather pillows (gone flat) to create something else? I've reused fabric; but, never feathers/down.
@Cambria ... forgot to answer your question about sleep position. I'm often a side-sleeper (sometimes a stomach-sleeper).
I have a Buckwheat pillow and it's great! I'm a side sleeper and use it, mostly, to wrap myself around it; nice and firm. My head pillow is a duck feather.
I've slept on everything and nothing compares to buckwheat imho. About a year ago I bought my first buckwheat pillow... I was so impressed with it that I started to manufacture them myself: http://hullopillow.com/