There's a famous scene in an otherwise so-so film, The Godfather: Part III, where a baggy-eyed Al Pacino passionately delivers a memorable line…the only memorable line of the film…in his special brand of trembling emotion: "Every time I think I'm out, they pull me back innnn!" And that's a close approximation of how I'm starting to feel these days with my growing desire/hesitancy to rejoin a club I long abandoned years ago. You see, about 5 years ago I decided to opt out and ditch my cell phone. Yes, a Los Angeles resident who not only lives in a city where cell phones are deemed a necessity, but who also happens to head up a tech blog. Did I just blow your mind?
"Wait...you're telling me the managing editor of Unplggd doesn't own a cell phone? Someone get Mario on this!"
Or did I upset you with this bit of personal information? Because I'm usually greeted by one of these two reactions when asked/provoked into revealing that I don't own a cell phone: incredulous disbelief or simmering judgment. Or maybe it's because I'm always bumming off quarters for the pay phone. Some would see it befitting us few who willingly choose to live without a cell to don a scarlet symbol so all good people would be aware of our perplexing proximity (though certain AT&T customers live in a similar constant state of disconnect despite owning an iPhone *zing*)!
It's as if now the absence of a cell phone is the absence of one of our senses to some, perhaps now an extension of all our senses…except, increasingly, those senses related to common courtesy. It has been a long while since I carried one in my pocket regularly, yet in these 5 years the absence hasn't proven much of a handicap thanks to the fact my middle name is "Homebody" and nobody except our hungry felines want to reach me. My Fav 5 would consist of Emily, our two cats, our betta fish and my mum; I'm interested in a "don't call me, I'll MMS you" plan.
Have I been an American psycho for living without a cell phone for so long...or now, because I'm an Apple user considering an Android device?
But this chapter of my life is about to come to a close, and you can help me try and make that first wobbly first step back into the mobile connected world a solid one. For my finger-dialing muscles have atrophied, my text messaging typing skills have dulled to an accuracy rate that will surely result in high comedy via autocorrect, and my grasp of Hipstamatically-transforming snapshots of my breakfast burrito into Facebook-worthy images laughable at best.
My decision to return back to the realm of the mobile connected was born of two factors:
1) you, the readers out there, some of whom have asked us to expand our horizons and cover devices beyond those anointed by Steve Jobs and his iLoving minions (love you, Steve…call me!), and
2) recognizing the tech landscape has changed vastly in the last 5 years, with smartphones being where the most exciting and interesting advancements in social interaction between people and machine is happening (*cough* Angry Birds *cough*).
I may not own a cell phone, but I'm certainly not ignorant of how far mobile devices have come since retiring my final 120 x 144 pixel color flip phone. I've gone far too long without and now I, too, want the option of ignoring the people around me at the swipe of a touchscreen!
So what do you think, fair Unplggd reader? I've set my sights on eight Android models, each with their strengths and weaknesses. Shall it be the Motorola Atrix, with its blazing fast dual core processor? Or the gargantuan screen HTC Thunderbolt? Maybe the sunlight-friendly, power-efficient Super AMOLED screen of the Samsung Galaxy S II? Or should I just say, "Whatever, as if…" and just wait for the iPhone 5 and keep drinking this delicious Kool-Aid?
*Note: I don't care so much about voice (though, of course, I want to be able to hear and be heard with clarity when I do make a call), but I'm specifically interested in the extra bells and whistles offered by a robust data plan and features. It's the "smart" features and apps specific to the Android platform I'm hoping to cover and compare.
[Illustration: Kyle Bean]

Sprout Side Table
I don't know a single Android user that hasn't either switched to iPhone, or wants to and is waiting on iPhone 5 and about to switch, except for a couple of programmers/developers and a couple of people locked into Sprint or TMobile for one reason or another.
Only if the iPhone is Verizon. Friend with iPhone ATT, can never hear every word of the conversation. (Wish ATT coverage were better, a bundle would save us.) Relative with iPhone Verizon, loud and clear.
Definitely consider the level of radiation that these phones emit as well. A lot of studies are showing links between cell phone use and cancer.
I am all for HTC hardware. It's an added bonus to the fun that is Android. But iPhone 5 isn't bad either, obviously.
Go with the Atrix. Don't drink the kool-
One thing to keep in mind with iPhone on VZW is that you cannot do voice and data simultaneously. Don't know if that will be an issue for you or not.
Me, I have a DROID Incredible and I really love it. I have the latest gen. iPod Touch and after having used it, couldn't see myself moving to an iPhone. I much prefer the HTC-mediated UI (Sense) on the Incredible.
I've read not so great reviews of Motorola's Motoblur UI overlay. Not sure if Samsung's Android devices have a Samsung-designed UI overlay as well.
I have yet to use a "naked" Android device (i.e., one running only with Google's default UI).
Don't drink the Kool-Aid! I don't have a regular cell phone -- only a WiFi-enabled cell via my iPod Touch using either Line2 or Skype. And you know what? I don't miss having a "real" cell phone. I don't miss having to shell out $100 or more a month to AT&T or Verizon or any other carrier, either.
Actually, I dispute that commend abou Android users who can't wait to go to the iPhone. Most Android users I know are very loyal to Android. I have an iPad and have been an Android user since day one and have no interest in using an iPhone. I currently have the Galaxy S which has the best screen available and I love it. Android is easy to use, easy to root(if you so desire) and has more apps than you'll ever even come close to using.
iPhone, definitely. Android still has a long way to go, give it another 2 years.
Most of my close friends tend to own the iPhone, but those who own an Android handset show a similar loyalty-affection for their particular models.
I do note the Android users I know skew heavily male and in the engineering/computer sciences fields, while friends in the creative fields tends to skew overwhelmingly Apple. It's an interesting dichotomy reflecting how our choices in technology can (though obviously, not always) reveal who we are and what we do with these devices.
Hoping more Android users/supporters vote above...the iPhone 5 is running away with this already.
I've found Android phones (granted I haven't used all of them) to be the most non-intuative phones I've ever used.
Although, if you REALLY want Flash on your phone, then get an Android. But I recommend trying all the models you're considering before making a purchase. They're really all quite different.
Love my Samsung Android, have no desires to switch. I use the data more than the phone these days.
Disclaimer...I do Java development for a living...
I got my very first cell phone ever last year; it's a Droid, and I love it. My advice is, go try everything out! And then decide what works for you.
I can't remember who I'm paraphrasing, but it's been rightly said that the computer of the future is a phone, or the computer has morphed into a phone, or whatever. R&D is going there. UI innovation is going there. Squeezing the most processing power out of the smallest chip is going there.
I have an iPhone, but I also have an Android-powered tablet. More and more I find myself using the iPhone because it's cellular, not because it's an iPhone. I seek out the tablet for more leisurely activity and even some real work. I don't yet feel comfortable banging out code on my pocket computer. Soon, though, I'm sure that will be standard behavior.
I second SeattleJ. I LOVE my Android phone because I don't want to constantly plug my phone into proprietary software to update things like calendar appointments or even to create new events! I too couldn't be less interested in having an iPhone, Verizon or not. I am constantly stifled by my iPod touchs inability to do things that my Droid 2 does effortlessly or automatically.
I'd also like to point out that when it comes to scientific research, a link does not equal a cause especially in the case of cancer. And I wouldn't worry too much, something else will probably kill you first.
I don't have one yet but my next phone will be the HTC G2. One of the closest to pure Android.
I have a G1 now...contract up in August.
So I'm recommending the G2. Tmobile is a lot cheaper as well.
Perhaps because I am an Old Man, or perhaps because I have giant hands, I much prefer a physical keyboard to the touch screen keyboards, hence my iPhone aversion. I loved the keyboard on the G1 but the phone had terrible performance, teeny screen and poor battery life. The G2 fixed all those problems without ruining the keyboard, so for me it strikes the best balance of least evil carrier + keyboard + least corrupted carrier Android installation + decent screen/performance.
I am loyal to T-Mobile because they have great (relative) customer service and let you get off the 2-year contract-upgrade treadmill (if you buy/bring your phone, you can get a plan w/ a lower monthly payment; most other carriers don't allow this). Also, the G2 gets the least crippled/modified/bloated Android installation out of the box (not counting the Google Nexus phones) and you can use your phone with international SIMs when traveling.
Scott Trudeau--you stated it much better than me! ;)
HTC EVO
enough said
Whatever you do, don't buy the LG. Had a friend lose his iPhone recently and had no insurance, so bought the LG because it was cheaper while he waited for the iPhone 5. Worst decision of his life. The thing keeps randomly rebooting and half the time it doesn't even tell you you have a message.
Everyone I know who has tried going to android hates it. iPhone is the best, no competition, although I understand the network in the US sucks.
The main problem with Android is it isn't designed for the hardware. If you want a good CHEAP phone (under $150) try the Samsung touch screen models that come with their own OS. I've had a couple and they are excellent value for money. Perfect if you don't need ALL the gizmos you get with a full on smartphone.
You know what, I'm pretty sure that phone pictured on the 'National Day of Unplugging' post is one of the one's I was talking about!
I voted for the Samsung Galaxy S II mostly because of the screen. I have the original S and love it. And I must say, this site is so attached to Apple products and I think you really do need a bit of diversity.
Seeing how much the Android has grown in the last year and a bit, I think it's a year away from really exploding. The problem I find is that people by default buy a iPhone because there friends have one or because of Apple's marketing machine. Personally I hate them, they are incredibly closed, jailbroken or not.
They all have there pros and cons. For example, Android Market has an amazing 57% of free apps on the Market compared to 28% on AppStore. And have you seen the money they want from Apple dev's? You can't bluetooth files over iPhone.
Android has it's cons however, like no proxy for different wifi connections, well actually no proxy at all.
Forget the iPhone voters. If you really wanna keep some of the more tech savy readers. There is really only one choice.
Everyone I know with an Android hates it and ends up using their laptop/iPod Touch/whatever instead of bothering with the Android.
I know one person with an HTC that I'm pretty sure is Windows based and he likes it, but has had to refresh it several times because the updates didn't work.
I should probably also add that the friend with the Windows phone is happens to be one of those people who can make ANYTHING work if it means not having to buy something new. His previous phone was a Motorola flip phone comprised of parts from three different phones. So he may be an unrealistic representation of the whole Windows vs Android vs iPhone thing.
Virgin Mobile paired up with a google voice number. The number goes to my cell phone and which ever phone I'm near. When I'm at my studio, home, vacation, on my wife's cell, It goes where I am so I rarely use my minutes.
If I'm not around any of those locations, it still rings the cell. My bill is under $5 a month. It's generally $2, but there is the minimum requirement of $5. I only use $2, and the rest bank up. And the best thing that this does over smart 'phones', It's a phone, and it works like one. No dropped calls. simple.
Go for the iPhone!!!!!! I have had a Droid for about 9 months now, and I can not wait to get an iPhone. I plan to run over my droid with my car 10 times to kill the stupid phone. I really, really dislike the droid.
Whatever you do, don't get a Motorola.
Like everything it depends on your needs. Now that I've an iPad, I don't think that I'd be getting a smart phone. I'd probably go for a pay as you phone for making calls and messaging and, maybe, a decent camera.
Firstly get a google voice number then you'll won't have to worry about your 'real' number.
From a user interface, the iPhone wins hands down. Android is a little clunky, I think that HTC sense is the best skin.
I had a Samsung Galaxy for a while but changed it out for the original LG Optimus as it's smaller. Personally, I don't want anything bigger 3-3.5 inch screen cluttering up my pockets.
Of course, you could always wait a little big longer and get the Pre3 !
To all those saying how clunky Android is, the great thing about Android is that there are heaps of UI "Launchers" that you can change. I just installed Launcher7 and it's almost exactly like Windows Phone 7. Trying doing that on iPhone.
I've only used iphones, so can't comment on android too much. Since this is a design website, I would think most people here at least recognize the superiority of APPLE designed products. Google, not so much.
I had to vote iPhone. I like where android is heading, but the form factors of the ones you're comparing are somewhat worrisome.
Phooey on the 'real keyboard' thing. You get used to anything and they add bulk to whatever device it is.
If I go android, I'd probably go with an HTC unit. I've had LG and Samsung phones and hated them, I'm not inclined to sample their offerings as a result. Motorola is in a similar boat, we had 2 razrs that dropped dead for no apparent reason.
Although I do have a cellphone, I commend you for going 'old school' for quite a while. I don't even like to admit to others that I do not text--actually I don't have a smartphone for easy texting. Using a smartphone will probably be addictive for me; it's an inevitability that I'll get one. Gotta keep up with the times.
Pre 3!
Thanks wildcat76. I've feared the same (the smartphone addiction). Being online for work and personal life is already enough of a time vampire. I think everyone starts off with the idea that we'll own the device, but for a great many people, the device ends up owning them!
@ gregory: You control you. If you don't have the willpower, wait and develop it.
For me, the phone is great for managing those time-sucking things, like email. I can triage all my junk/irrelevant mail and use the notification icons for things like bills to be paid, using inbox 0 approaches. Then when I sit at the computer I can focus on the other things.
Wow. No love for the Windows Phone 7? I stay away from cell phones because the cost is just too much. $100 a month is ridiculous. That said, I would like to own a Windows Phone 7 phone if I had the money.
An iPhone would be nice too, but there are too many annoying fanboys that I really don't want to be associated with. It's a nice phone though.
Android hasn't really reached a level of refinement I'm impressed with yet. It feels too clunky, unoriginal, and what it's copied feels like that, a copy.
VJ: I think my 5+ years forgoing a cell phone reveal willpower isn't really an issue. I was merely being honest that we all falter under habit and comfort, influenced sometime unconsciously by situation over time. No need to bust out the Kung Fu master pep talk, grasshoppa.
http://www.johnsphones.com/
I can appreciate the advantages Android has -- more flexibility, more options, etc. -- but there just doesn't exist an Android phone with hardware that even comes close to iPhone 4. And by the time there is, iPhone 5 will be out, and Android will still be a year behind. Also, while there are downsides to having so many restrictions on apps, the HUGE upside is that you're pretty much guaranteed that they work. And the recent Android virus that's been spreading around is a pretty strong argument against the openness of that platform, too. I'd like to have an Android to tinker with, but my iPhone is very reliable, looks and feels great, and has been way out in the lead while every Android phone plays catch-up.
"but there just doesn't exist an Android phone with hardware that even comes close to iPhone 4"
now, I can understand the debate on software user experience, but which hardware specs, exactly, are you comparing??
software experience is where its at; and hands down the iOS on the iPhone is the best. android lags slightly, but with the iPhone you know you'll get updates that will work with the phone whereas with android phones that aren't from google itself (nexus-s, nexus) the updates take some time (if ever) until it hits the phone.
avoid the atrix and the inspire 4g on at&t's network because att seems to be crippling their HSUPA upload speeds for their android phones http://www.engadget.com/2011/02/23/atandts-brewing-hsupa-gate-the-inside-story/
resale value helps too, the $199 you pay today would easily be recouped and sold in one year for $500 or two years for $200; meaning itll probably pay for your new phone by then.
if you're going android for sure, consider the new $199 lg optimus-v from virgin mobile. just because they offer non contract plans that start at $25 a month 300 minute with unlimited texting and data included
Virgin Mobile $25 a month for unlimited data and texting compared to the $100 a month everyone else is charging...how is this not the most popular plan in America??? They offer two Androids now.
You save over $900 a year! That's $1800 over the life of an AT&T contract! You could use that money to buy the latest iPad AND iTouch. Is it really worth the extra $1800 to have an iPhone over an Android?
The iPhone better blow it out of the water to beat those numbers.
virgin mobile plans-
--
$25 - 300 min
$40 - 1200 min
$60 - unlim min
-- all with data and texting unlimited AND taxes included.
and the phone is only $199 for an android 2.2 (newer android) phone? i mean wow! its all non contract so if you dont like in in a few months get rid of it and get your iphone.
Virgin Mobile Plans
I love my my touch 4G.
I think "all Android users I know switched to iPhone" is the new "nobody I know voted for Nixon", because Android is just crushing Apple (and Blackberry!) in growth:
http://mashable.com/2011/02/01/nielsen-smartphone-marketshare/#
"According to its December 2010 survey, Nielsen estimates a three-way tie between Android, RIM and iOS for smartphone OS market share.
When it comes to future market share predictors, however, Android is the big winner. Nielsen estimates that 43% of users who purchased a smartphone in the past six months chose an Android device. In comparison, 26% of new purchasers chose an iOS device and 20% chose a BlackBerry."
I've only known one Android user that switched to iPhone. I've also talked people who were set on getting the iPhone into getting Android. As for me, I've been a G1 user since day one and upgraded to the G2. I love how easy it is to customize Android phones. All iPhones look the same.
I went from Blackberry to a Motorola Droid X and love it! I have yet to find anything my droid can't do. Yes, it is a little clunky, but that huge screen is so worth it. Want to read a book? watch a movie? You'll appreciate those extra inches. And with Verizon you have much better coverage than AT&T. Everybody I know that has a Droid phone loves them as well. Definitely my vote!
HTC Desire. The best phone out there bar none (why isn't it on your list?) and this comes from a former iphone user.
I was an iPhone user for three years, until I realized how badly both the phone and ATT sucked. I'm now obsessed with my Droid Incredible, it's 100 times more intuitive, user friendly, and customizable than the iPhone.
Wow! I was always in awe of the fact that you were sans mobile, but had a feeling the day would finally come. Welcome to the cult.
I gotta say - iPhone5. It's just too fun.
Everyone says "don't get the iPhone," or they say "don't get the Droid." It really boils down to what you want to do on the phone. If you end up going to a lot of websites that use flash, don't do the iPhone, obviously. I've heard that even on the Verizon iPhone it is constantly dropping calls... they need to improve their antenna. A loyal iPhone user will tell you that they've never dropped a call before, and it's amazing.
However, a loyal Droid user will tell you the exact same thing. I myself lean more towards the Droid. Even as a Mac user I am constantly annoyed by people saying "Don't you wish you had an iPhone?" No. I don't. I don't have a smartphone, but when I get one, it will be a Droid.
I have a mytouch 4g, aka HTC glacier, and I really like it. Wait for the new HTC Desire. A friend bought it last year in HK and loves it.
+1 on the Windows Phone front.
It is definitely without a doubt a superior user interface when compared to both Android and iOS devices. The HTC device rolling out to Verizon in a couple of weeks was already released in Europe and is a great phone, with the best HW and best experience combined.
Gregory: What made you decide to go back to a cell phone after all these years?
Dana V: I'll be happy to address that very question once I adopt a specific handset. But the quick and short is the technology has come far enough since I put it down to make it worth reconsidering from a professional (and personal) standpoint. I'm also keen to expand our coverage to the Android platform, though our survey reveals our readership is as "biased" as our staff of Apple users.
Hmm. I'm one of those that just has a basic 'dumb' cell phone (let me chime in with the ATT sucks sentiment - if our family plan weren't so cheap I'd be with anybody else), but from my observations of others it really depends on your personality which phone is better. Most who just want to use the phone casually seem to like the iPhone best. However, a friend of mine and my uncle are devotees of the Android phones. One's a major tinkerer and the other's a retired machinist who builds his own race cars. See a common thread? They love the control the Android gives them & the keyboards on their models because they prefer touch-texting.
Android beating RIM & Apple - Jan 2011
Based on the Jan 2011 Smartphone Subscribers, Android has grown 7.7% over the previous 3 month period, whilst Apple has only grown .1%. OK now I'm coming across as an Android fanboi and I hate that.
I had this debate about 18 months ago, when I finally caved. I went Motorola Droid about a week after it came out... I and haven't looked back. At that time, I was comparing against the iPhone 3, the two pluses in my book were I love the hard keyboard on it and that I access to Flash if I need it.