this isn't shocking enough for Hot or Not!

I think this is a good idea that is poorly executed.

Garrett said what i was going to. It would be fine if the knob had a more flattering shape and a better finish.

I agree with all of the above. Or, simply put, "meh".

Why bother?

I'm with irc on this!

I'm actually quite fond of these (well, the one on the right anyway). It's a nice accent that I'd not thought of before. Were I remodeling and had extra cash to throw around, I'd definitely consider them.

These are not hot... but a quick search will find plenty of examples where wood is more skillfully integrated into the design. Try Finesse Fittings or Salice Paolo.