apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Good Questions: What do with this fireplace?

121707_fireplacequestion.jpg

AT:LA reader Henry writes:

After first removing the existing faux marble tiles, how would you proceed considering that the grey carpet is being replaced with hard wood floors? Would you re-tile in slate or a lighter color? Would you add a mantel?
Advice please!

 
 

Dear Henry,

This one's a bit tricky for us, particularly because the fireplace is floating on the wall--although we think that aspect definitely lends itself to a very modern and sleek fireplace that you could frame with anything from slate to concrete to stainless steel (check out European Home's gallery for examples). You also wouldn't need to retile up the wall or install a mantel.

But if you're aiming for something a bit more traditional, we happen to love the look of The Alhambra fireplace from Chesney. Although there might be a need for some kind of step in front of the fireplace if you were going for this classic option.

Anyone else have suggestions?

Tags

Good Questions, fireplace, Chesney, remodel, slate

Related Links

Share

Comments (14)

Are they light or dark wood floors?

posted by no accounting for taste on December 17th 2007 at 9:17am
view no accounting for taste's profile

Totally depends on the vibe you are shooting for. Could be stone, slate, cement, drywall, plaster, steel (raw or stainless) or even wood.

posted by patrick (the other one) on December 17th 2007 at 9:38am
view patrick (the other one)'s profile

I think it would look cool if you just stripped the marble tiles off, left it the normal finished drywall on the side, and painted the wall a bold color. It depends on what your decorating scheme is for the rest of the house, but I think just paint is probably easiest (also coordinates well with what seems like a lot of glass).

posted by elchan on December 17th 2007 at 9:54am
view elchan's profile

Great windows - looking out on a chain link fence.

Get rid of the fence.

I'd have the fire place be plain white wall board, no mantle.

Hardwood floor.

I love your windows!!!!

posted by kathy o on December 17th 2007 at 10:04am
view kathy o's profile

Check the builing codes, but, I think you have to have a non flamable material surrounding the fireplace. I think a lighter stone would be better, but not all the way up the wall. Also, I don't like the way the stone flooring goes all the way across to in front of the door. I would use it only as a "hearth" and even raise it a bit, and have a separate piece of matting/carpet on the inside and outside of the door.

posted by msbeachwood on December 17th 2007 at 10:16am
view msbeachwood's profile

One huge piece of travertine...

posted by hdtex on December 17th 2007 at 10:45am
view hdtex's profile

I recommend painting the wall bright white, not using a mantel, and maybe adding a black granite floating shelf under the firebox (as a modern hearth).

I say avoid stainless, I think it’s a fad on it way out. In two years it will be as cool a suburban tract house.

posted by cericericeri on December 17th 2007 at 10:58am
view cericericeri's profile

If those tiles were actual marble, I'd be tempted to just keep it as is. I kind of like the look. But seriously, if you're going for wood floors, I like the look of slate for this, because it's natural and potentially kind of colorful and variegated but still modern. And then I'd probably do a very simple mantel.

posted by Curtis on December 17th 2007 at 11:22am
view Curtis's profile

depending on the shade of your hardwood flooring (lighter, darker, variegated) you could choose a variety of materials for the fireplace.

I would avoid adding a mantel, and suggest adding a raised portion of the floor directly in front of the fireplace as a kind of extended hearth (something deep enough even to perch on?) with wood storage underneath or to the side.

I like the idea of stone, still somewhat rough-cut, on the fireplace and the hearth. It would be nifty if the raised hearth stepped down on the side to the doors in the picture - you could have some very attractive wood storage next to the doors. If you were to do that, I would push the material all the way across the doors to the wall, and not leave that 18" or so gap between stone and wall.

posted by bloo_mountain on December 17th 2007 at 11:59am
view bloo_mountain's profile

Thanks for all of the creative suggestions. We haven't moved in yet so it's a bit of a clean slate... and these posts have expanded our ideas. The chain link is def. on the way out. And hopefully we can find an affordable alternative to the wobbly screen and sliding door to the right. We haven't selected a wood floor yet but are hoping to find a medium honey brown color that will work on a slab foundation. For the fireplace -we're double-checking but I think you have to have approx. 18inch of non-flammable material in the front. Right now we are leaning toward slate or something similar because as curtis notes it's "natural and potentially kind of colorful and variegated but still modern." And ideally, it will anchor the space a bit more than plain white walls.

posted by zufrieden on December 17th 2007 at 1:09pm
view zufrieden's profile

stainless steel and white marble

posted by benja-dena on December 18th 2007 at 12:43am
view benja-dena's profile

Do not put more tile down afterremoving what's already there.

I would go with terrazzo floors or really white/light floors or really dark/black wood floors.

I love the straight lines of the architecture. To compliment them, I would build a solid-line mantle above the fireplace.

posted by orangejuce on December 18th 2007 at 4:38am
view orangejuce's profile

I'd open up that section of the wall and put in a cylindrical steel chimney /smokestack (ideally, a facade around the exisitng one) and fill in the rest of the space with clear glass. If you want a mantle, a thick glass shelf would look good, I think. Keep the firebox flush with the wall.

In any case, I'd try to work in more clear glass rather than keep it closed up.

Good luck!

posted by genjenn on December 18th 2007 at 11:49am
view genjenn's profile

We specialize in supply imperial wood vein marble,grey wood grain stone,golden wood vein stone,etc.

It is excellent materials to for wall and flooring decorations due to its unique natural wood vein.

Size: 15*60cm,20*40cm,30*60cm

Thickness:1.3cm

Surface: acid,polished

Packing: wood crates

Email:zengerstone@gmail.com
http://www.china-stone-marble.com

posted by Zenger Stone on February 11th 2009 at 9:23pm
view Zenger Stone's profile

Feeds

RSS icon Los Angeles

+ City Feeds