apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


LA Good Questions: Warm LED Bulbs?

warmCFLSforhome.jpgDearest AT:LA, I recently painted my living room gray, which I love! But come nighttime my eco-friendly bulbs are making it look lavender (in a very goo goo ga ga nursery kind of way) ! Any suggestions on warmer glowing LED or Halogen bulbs that won't cast such florescent harsh light?Help!!

Thank you
Kristin

 
 

Kristin, compact fluorescent light bulb surprisingly can near the warmth of incandescent bulbs if you take into consideration the Correlated Color Temperature. CCT designated between 2,650 and 2,800 degrees Kelvin and labeled as "warm white" are best for interior home use and put out a more yellow-warm light that doesn't give you the pallor of gouda cheese. We had plenty of early trial and error learning about this ourselves a few years back when we started changing out all our incandescent bulbs, one by one. Personally, I'm happy with GE brand CFL bulbs readily available at Target (though 1/4 of the time I've had to return non-working bulbs for replacements). You can also mix and match a CFL with a low watt incandescent for multi-bulb overhead lighting if you want to meet half way...even one bulb matters (and kudos to you for looking for the eco-friendly choice).

Tags

Good Questions, CFL, lightbulb

Related Links

Share

Comments (14)

I buy Ikea's CFL's and their colour temperature seems to be pretty close to regular incandescents. I haven't had any problems with them.

posted by revolution9 on May 21st 2008 at 12:47pm
view revolution9's profile

I replaced all my 60w lamp bulbs with Lightwiz H20027S - I find them to be very warm.
I bought them here:
http://www.energyfederation.org/
Litetronics Harmony 20w Lightwiz H20027S

posted by greenlight on May 21st 2008 at 1:30pm
view greenlight's profile

you can learn about the details of lumens etc. here, that will help you select warmer tones
http://www.popularmechanics.com/home_journal/home_improvement/4215199.html?series=15
http://www.popularmechanics.com/home_journal/home_improvement/4215199.html?page=2
I hope those links are not expired

posted by greenlight on May 21st 2008 at 1:31pm
view greenlight's profile

I really like the n:vision brand from Home Depot. They have several different color temperatures to choose from, plus they're fairly inexpensive (as far as cfl's go.)

posted by mattab on May 21st 2008 at 5:01pm
view mattab's profile

Look for a Kelvin temperature in the 2000 to 3000 range to get a yellower light. I was given some cold cathode light bulbs that I liked much more than any regular CFL light bulb I've tried (I don't like flourescent looking blue-white light). I don't know where a good place to buy them is or even the brand of the light bulbs, but they look something like this:

http://www.1000bulbs.com/7-to-8-Watt-Compact-Fluorescents/9236/

Try searching any light bulb selling website for "cold cathode" but be sure to read the details to make sure it is recommended for the light fixture you want to put it in (some shouldn't be closed in) and that it has the right Kelvin temperature range. Also, these bulbs are much dimmer than CFLs (as in their Lumens are less) so if you need bright light in the space they might not be the right choice. The one I linked would give the amount of light that a regular 45 watt light bulb would give, which is great for a cozy atmosphere but not great for doing needlepoint.

posted by pantothenic on May 21st 2008 at 8:50pm
view pantothenic's profile

I second Mattab's suggestion of the n:vision bulbs from Home Depot. They're great. But don't get the n:vision daylight bulb -- it's the opposite of what you're looking for. That level is really harsh, bluish light. I thought it would be warm, like sunlight, but it's so not.

I have a Harmony bulb in the lamp by my bed -- it gives very soft, warm light. It came in the lamp, but according to Google, it's sold online by National Geographic.

posted by palindrome on May 21st 2008 at 9:39pm
view palindrome's profile

Actually, I think the Harmony bulb is what greenlight's first post refers to. I just remembered one keyword, not the brand/maker/model. But they're awesome. I want to put them in all of my lamps. They're probably too soft for overhead fixtures, but perfect for cozy spaces.

posted by palindrome on May 21st 2008 at 9:46pm
view palindrome's profile

This guide has reviews of a bunch of specialty energy-efficient bulbs and comparisons to the old-style bulbs they replace:
http://www.edf.org/cflguide

Here's an example of some that I got for my front hall...it was really hard to find good dimmable ones! The pictures are really helpful.
http://www.edf.org/page.cfm?tagID=634&bulbID=45

posted by envirokira on May 22nd 2008 at 4:15am
view envirokira's profile

I also have gray walls and faced this problem. I wrote about it on my home design blog, Strange Closets (http://www.strangeclosets.com). There are options that reduce energy (by aprox. 30%) but do are not CFL (Philips Halogena). They do cast a more yellow shade than my incandescents.

http://www.strangeclosets.com/2008/03/lighting-dilemma.html

T8
www.strangeclosets.com
When design takes priority, the result is often strange closets.

posted by t8 on May 22nd 2008 at 5:49am
view t8's profile

"I thought it would be warm, like sunlight, but it's so not."

Sunlight is actually much, much cooler and more bluish than bulbs used in the home. Daylight or 65k bulbs are meant to approximate the sun at about noon but in the context of a house they look very blue.

posted by chrisherbert on May 22nd 2008 at 6:10am
view chrisherbert's profile

What about cfls that work with a dimmer switch? I've had a serious problem with the ge ones with my dimmers - they flicker, or buzz, or don't work at all with a dimmer switch. anyone know of a brand that is compatible?

posted by lisanhough on May 22nd 2008 at 8:55am
view lisanhough's profile

While I contend that daylight is on the bluish side, it's perportedly full spectrum, which most other color temperatures are not. This means it's supposed to mimick the sun and give a more accurate color rendition, where as warm white, etc tends to veer towards the red/orange side.

I've noticed that gray-ish light or that green film that used to be used to control heat penetration will tend to suck out the colors in a room, making the room appear drab and dull.

posted by ciddyguy on May 22nd 2008 at 10:13am
view ciddyguy's profile

I'm a director of photography and gaffer (lighting technician) for film and video and I deal with these lights all day every day. Regular household incandescent (tungsten filamanet) bulbs have a color temperature of about 2800 degrees Kelvin, and have a "warm" orange color. Daylight is 6500-5600 degrees Kelvin and is much bluer. If you want to supplement the daytime lighting in a room with a lot of windows, go for the 65K "daylight" bulbs. If you want that warm orange cozy feel at night, try warm-white bulbs.

All fluorescent lights have an excess of green in their spectrum, which is part of what gives them that icky cast which is not flattering to skin tones. Some bulbs like the IKEA and NuVision bulbs (both of which I have in my house) have coatings which minimize the green "spike" in the spectrum. Look for lights with a higher CRI number -- the closer to 100 the better the color reproduction.

And for what it's worth, putting these bulbs in a warm-colored fixture or shade can create a cozy warm glow with little effort.

Now if there were only more choices for dimmable CFL's...

posted by nashdp on May 23rd 2008 at 6:07pm
view nashdp's profile