apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Should We Add a Rug?
Good Questions

091709goodquest1.jpgQ - We have a rather narrow, elongated dining room. We've put one of Crate and Barrel's high basque tables in it because my boyfriend adores the set, and are trying to decide whether it needs a rug (it seems a little bare in there)...

 
 

091709goodquest2.jpg
If so, any suggestions on how big it should be, since we don't have space to go 2-3 feet beyond the edge of the tables? Any suggestions as to what kind of rug? We have a kilim rug and a leather sofa in the rest of the living room, around the corner but in the same room.

Sent by Rachel

Editor - Suggestions for Rachel's dining room setup?

Got a good question you'd like answered? Send your queries and a photo or two illustrating your question, and we'll see if the Apartment Therapy LA team or our readers can help answer your question.

Tags

Good Questions, dining room, rug, Crate and Barrel

Related Links

Share

Comments (23)

I think a rug that small may clutter up the space since the living room is nearby and has a rug as well? I would round out the area instead by adding some cushions to the chairs and/or curtains to the window, hanging the art so it frames the table better and frees the top of the table for cute candleholders, bowl, flowers, etc. I think those elements would go a long way to warming up the area and making it seem less bare. If you do go rug, go neutral and solid but maybe some interesting texture.

posted by Polpol on September 17th 2009 at 6:57pm
view Polpol's profile

Personally, I wouldn't add a rug, especially in a dining area. Plus, the floors are beautiful! I would go with some nice window treatments to fill out the space. And maybe hang the art up on the wall so it's off the table.

posted by chaney on September 17th 2009 at 7:01pm
view chaney's profile

Yes, a rug will actually make the space look larger. In my opinion, you should get a rug that complements the Kilim, perhaps a solid color rug that matches one of the colors of your Kilim. If you get another patterned rug be sure it doesn't clash with the living room rug, or make the space holding both rugs look too busy.

posted by mei-ling on September 17th 2009 at 7:04pm
view mei-ling's profile

I think some drapes.

posted by tatiana9 on September 17th 2009 at 7:09pm
view tatiana9's profile

You need a tall painting with lots of vertical movement to hang over that tall vertical table of yours...think things like buildings, stripes, something abstract....in a bold color combination (doesn't have to be garish but maybe navy or burgundy, something that will be able to compete with that dark wood) ...you could also stand to hang a cafe pendant light with a nice frosted glass shade to add focus to that area. I love that table, just need to work it in there right. Also you should try a bigger piece of artwork over the couch...or maybe same art work but with a nice thick frame...that is a nice couch that really has some presence needs to have strong art above it

posted by ichi on September 17th 2009 at 7:17pm
view ichi's profile

while looking at my rss feeds with my husband, i got tothis post, and he said, "put some fur on that bare wood!" and he also said, "rug it." i agree.

posted by katiecupcake on September 17th 2009 at 7:38pm
view katiecupcake's profile

I don't think you need a rug. I'd do some lovely vintage crystal chandelier hung low above your cool, modern table. You can get rid of the framed piece, too. I don't think you need it. Just a great chandelier and you're there.

posted by medusa12120 on September 17th 2009 at 7:43pm
view medusa12120's profile

I'm not a fan of rugs in dining rooms. You're just making work for yourself. Floor-to-ceiling drapes will warm and soften the space and make your tall table seem more proportional. Big art, or a collection of smaller pieces, would add color and interest. Have you thought about moving the table away from the wall, maybe centered on the window? I think that the room wouldn't feel so bare if you did that. Good luck!

http://inspiredroomdesign.com

posted by farmhousemoderne on September 17th 2009 at 8:09pm
view farmhousemoderne's profile

No run necessary, but get the table away from the wall asap!

posted by slobound on September 17th 2009 at 8:27pm
view slobound's profile

I'd say move the table away from the wall, take away the artwork and add an eye-catching chandelier

no rug.

posted by abc123 on September 17th 2009 at 8:46pm
view abc123's profile

I agree, it does look bare. I'd suggest trying some curtains or pretty blinds first. Plus, hang up that picture, or maybe consider putting 2 or 3 hanging items up on the wall.

You could also try some tablecloths.

posted by apf on September 17th 2009 at 8:51pm
view apf's profile

option A: separate the table and chairs from the floor with a rug or floor cloth
( http://www.thekitchn.com/thekitchn/kitchen-furniture/ugly-kitchen-floor-change-it-with-a-floor-cloth-094617 ) in a light color with a simple/subtle pattern.

option B: play up the similarity between the woods by lifting the artwork away from the tabletop (at least a few inches higher than the backs of the chairs) and add a centerpiece with some sort of plant or flowers in a white vessel.

posted by itesser on September 17th 2009 at 8:53pm
view itesser's profile

Definitely bare. Add drapes & artwork (preferably something with some texture to it, as opposed to flat) as above, plus some placemats (table cloth probably too big), and see how it looks then. If still bare, then add a rug.

posted by KarenH on September 17th 2009 at 9:05pm
view KarenH's profile

It needs a rug, from a visual perspective, but I think that a rug would be inadvisable given the purpose of the room.

I can see two options. One, put a large graphic (painting, wall decal, whatever) on the wall that abuts the table. This will draw the eye away from the floor and into the middle of the room. Or two, shift the dining set into the centre of the room and stencil a simple design around the edge of the floor, about a foot away from the wall. This will provide the visual framing of a rug without the nuisance and impracticality of an actual rug.

posted by Blandwagon on September 17th 2009 at 11:18pm
view Blandwagon's profile

It needs a rug. Really, how messy could you be that a rug is such a horrible inconvenience under a dining table? My 1 year old eats at the dining table with us, and the rug is really not a problem even with her dropping about 20% of her food as she tries to eat it. I'd get something in a light-ish neutral (one of those jute deals, maybe? nothing TOO light, that's just asking for trouble, but something with a little texture and bright enough to pop and create definition in the space), or maybe pull the red from the kilim. Or I could even see moving the kilim over there, and getting a bigger rug for the seating area. I agree a solid (or a really unobtrusive pattern) would be best. I also agree about a bigger piece of art for that wall, or maybe a clustered grouping of smaller pieces if you want to include the one you have there now.

posted by hyzen on September 17th 2009 at 11:43pm
view hyzen's profile

A rug would only look good if it's big enough (2 to 3 feet beyond the edge of the table isn't enough) and if you'd center the table on the rug.

I'd go for some colorful drapes (floor to ceiling).

posted by fineur on September 18th 2009 at 4:03am
view fineur's profile

I don't really have any advice on the rug question, but I do think you should move your table out into the centre of the space, having it squashed up against the wall like that just makes the room (or half-room) look even more like it's not big enough. Unless you actively pass throught that area many times every day carrying large bulky objects then I think this will make a big difference to your space. The table centred with the chairs pushed in should provide enough of walk-around space for normal day-to-day passage.

Oh, and I also agree with the suggestion to add some kind of colourful window treatment.

posted by idontdobeige on September 18th 2009 at 5:37am
view idontdobeige's profile

A rug, if only to protect those floors from the high traffic chair scraping dining area.

posted by sdnyc on September 18th 2009 at 9:57am
view sdnyc's profile

It looks a little cold. I would add a rug. I think something neutral would work.

posted by jeffnyc on September 18th 2009 at 9:58am
view jeffnyc's profile

Rug it. Use a simple solid that you can throw in the wash when someone spills wine on it. This would also allow you to slide the table out from the wall when using it, as its current position seems a little elbow-bumpy.
I also support hanging the picture that is currently resting on the table.

posted by kiljoywashere on September 18th 2009 at 9:59am
view kiljoywashere's profile

put the table against the wall with the window or even better- like everyone else said center it in the room if you have the space. you have too much brown in similar hues. add carpet

posted by DosChalupas on September 18th 2009 at 3:54pm
view DosChalupas's profile

Suggest centering the table under the lighting, no rug, hang window treatment from ceiling height, hang big artwork. Add seat cushions to break up line of brown. Reflect colors from artwork in the textiles. Replace hanging light with something more modern.

posted by MihoH on September 19th 2009 at 12:29am
view MihoH's profile