apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Understanding High-Efficiency, Dual Flush Toilets

Since we're in San Antonio and this also happens to be bathroom and kitchen month here at AT, we thought we'd share a video clip illustrating the utility and efficiency of dual flush toilets as shown by Eddie Wilcut, the Water Conservation Manager for the City of San Antonio...
 
 

031109atlalowflowchart.jpgUsing a Russet potato as a replacement for you-know-what, Wilcut flushes the spud down a Caroma toilet with the full flush (1.6 gallon) AND half flush (0.8 gallon) for liquid waste to show how a dual flush system can efficiently dispose of waste. Since toilets make for almost 30% of residential indoor water use in the United States, it seems like a no-brainer in water tight times for new homes to all come with high efficiency toilets, alongside home owners being given an incentive to convert to dual flush models to replace aging and leaking units.

According to the Pottygirl site, the average person flushes the toilet nearly 140,000 times in their lifetime, and by switching over to a water efficient, a person can save up to 4000 gallons of water per year. You can figure out your savings yourself using an online calculation sheet. What you want look for is a WaterSense Labeled High-Efficiency Toilet. More details and resources about this important subject over at Pottygirl.

Tags

green ideas, bathroom - tubs, toilets, showers & sinks, toilet, dual flush, WaterSense, water efficient

Related Links

Share

Comments (24)

Yeah, as soon as I start excreting potatos, I'll be sure to get one of these.

posted by bromelia on March 11th 2009 at 9:27pm
view bromelia's profile

When we first moved into our current apartment, we both wondered what the heck was wrong with our 2 toilets. We didn't get why they flushed 3-4 times. To me it seems like MORE water is being wasted than a single flush toilet. Maybe it's just an illusion.

Anyway, we have SO many problems with our toilets. They are always needing to be unclogged, and we use super cheap or recycled TP (ie- nothing to it...) so it's not like it's the Charmin Extra Puff or whatever the heck it's called.

Does anybody else with these toilets seem to have issues? I know it's all for the environment, and I think that's great, but when the toilet doesn't flush right 15-20% of the time, it's hard to see the value.

But then again, I bet we just have really cheap toilets here.

posted by Erin Lang Norris/Yellow Canoe on March 11th 2009 at 9:44pm
view Erin Lang Norris/Yellow Canoe's profile

Bromelia, that's the only reason you can think of? You don't want to save the environment, water, or money?

The major complaint/fear about high efficiency toilets has been that they get stuck and don't flush as well. This demonstration takes care of that.

posted by webherring on March 12th 2009 at 6:01am
view webherring's profile

we have lots of water saving flushing systems in Europe, and believe me, they work well and are reliable. and it is a good idea to not use up loads of water for that.

posted by maike on March 12th 2009 at 6:08am
view maike's profile

I have had three of these Caroma potato flushers in my house for the past four years. They rock. I have not once used a plunger on any of them, and I have never had to flush twice! This is one of the things that really works.

... unlike my 'silent' garage door and my hands-free soap dispenser ;)

posted by CiaraCeasg on March 12th 2009 at 6:32am
view CiaraCeasg's profile

I am sure it uses a pressure assist system like the Sloan Flushmate (http://www.flushmate.com/). These toilets put out A LOT of flushing power with little water. The typical 1.6 GPF low flow toilets we see in the US have no assist and they are terrible. They stop up all the time and take two or three flushes to work properly, so I cannot wait until these dual flush, pressure assisted toilets become the norm.

posted by Jason on March 12th 2009 at 7:26am
view Jason's profile

Actually, here is a Kohler model that is LEED certified, pressure assisted and does only 1 GPF (not dual flush, though).

http://www.us.kohler.com/onlinecatalog/detail.jsp?from=thumb&frm=&module=Toilets&item=12860002&prod_num=3597&section=2&category=13

It IS a $1K, but Kohler is always a little high.

posted by Jason on March 12th 2009 at 7:32am
view Jason's profile

All the toilets in Australia are dual flush. I can't remember ever having a toilet that wasn't dual flush.

posted by uglyisbeautiful on March 12th 2009 at 7:41am
view uglyisbeautiful's profile

Not sure about the button thing.

We have a low-flow potty upstairs and have learned that you only flush one wipe-worth of toilet paper at a time. And you still have to hold the handle down (to get a longer, stronger flush) when you do that. If you have a double-wipe, you retain the second wad in your hand as you stand and flush, then as you see the first wad move down the pipe you drop the second in and release the lever.

And yes, this can be complicated at 3am. Especially if your timing is off and you have to get the plunger out.

Without the handle we'd probably be hitting those buttons in some morse code sequence several times for one use.

posted by That70sHeidi on March 12th 2009 at 8:28am
view That70sHeidi's profile

THAT was funny. I hope you guys are enjoying my hometown!

posted by jlhanley on March 12th 2009 at 8:57am
view jlhanley's profile

I wanted a dual flush, but the options weren't attractive and didn't fit into my budget when I was remodeling. I've since found this kit that can be used to make a regular toilet into a dual flush, but have wondered how well it works. Has anyone ever used it?

http://www.dualflushtoilet.net/

posted by TheUpstart on March 12th 2009 at 10:37am
view TheUpstart's profile

Please forgive the crudeness, but what happens when you have a whopper of a poo? I would think it'd get stuck on that dry "shelf" area right above the well of water. Also, if you have a million sheet wiper - which in my family, is more common than you'd think - Could these toilets handle 2, 3, 4... wipes? Maybe I'll just stick with a brick in my tank for now.

posted by chusmabilly on March 12th 2009 at 10:49am
view chusmabilly's profile

We recently installed a Kohler dual flush - works great and never cloggs.

posted by karamel on March 12th 2009 at 11:53am
view karamel's profile

in australia, it's mandated by law that all new home constructions have dual flush toilets - I think this has been a law since the 80's. I want to install dual flush toilets in my home here in the US but i'm having trouble finding them in Lowes/Home Depot.

posted by auschick on March 12th 2009 at 12:54pm
view auschick's profile

webherring, I live in a country that has 1/4 of the world fresh water supply and 1/200 of the world population - pray tell me what I should be worried about.

posted by bromelia on March 12th 2009 at 12:58pm
view bromelia's profile

my in-laws have those sort of toilets in their home. we all live in san antonio and i think some time last year the city was giving them away and thats where they got theirs. im not completely sold on the "half flush" since most of the time it seems as though i can still see a hint of yellow in the water.. and it does sort of seem like a bottomless pit for number twos. i feel like im gonna get major splash back and since theres very little water to begin with most of that splast back would consist of your own pee and the slight amount left behind from the previous users half flush. ew. with all that being said, ive got a 1.6g at home and just replaced the plug in the tank with on that lets you adjust how much water each flush uses. ive got it set to use about a third less than normal.

posted by deeboyayay on March 12th 2009 at 3:52pm
view deeboyayay's profile

I live in a country that has 1/4 of the world fresh water supply and 1/200 of the world population

Wow. What country is that?


And it figures that Australia would be way ahead of the curve in water use. Even before the current drought, the continent overall seems pretty dry.

posted by Erika in Seattle on March 12th 2009 at 5:58pm
view Erika in Seattle's profile

Honestly, the half flush is completely sufficient. I used a dual flush when I studied abroad and we even have them in the local Pet Smart (I'm not a huge fan of chain pet stores, but they get a nod for that move).

posted by TheUpstart on March 12th 2009 at 6:29pm
view TheUpstart's profile

I live in a country that has 1/4 of the world fresh water supply and 1/200 of the world population

Wow. What country is that?


I am betting Brazil...

posted by Jason on March 13th 2009 at 1:24pm
view Jason's profile

bromelia, we ALL should be concerned about the health of the planet, and try to do what we can. You always seem very concerned, I have noticed, about painting wood...

We have Totos in our house. I like the dual flush feature, but I must confess, as a woman, I have discovered that the "liquids" flush also means no toilet paper, so I use the "solids" flush all the time. But even THAT setting uses less water than standard toilets, so it's an improvement either way. On rare occasions I do need to flush twice, but not often. Plus the style of these toilets is modern and more sculptural than a lot of them...

I think the Totos cost around $200 each, more than the low end Home Depot options, but not that much overall.

posted by SherryBinNH on March 13th 2009 at 2:33pm
view SherryBinNH's profile

Jason, bet again.

Sherry, I am very concerned about the planet. We compost and try to eat as much food produced within 50 miles from our home as possible. However, äs I watch the river flowing past our garden in the ocean 50 yards down the hill, I really don't see what difference it makes whether the water flows there directly or via our bathroom. The real concern should be the use of hormonal contraceptives that destroy river and marine life.

posted by bromelia on March 14th 2009 at 4:26pm
view bromelia's profile

TheUpstart,

I have 3 dual flush conversion kits installed at my home and they work great. I think I have save tons of money on my water bill. I looked to get the link for you and I saw that they have a $5.00 off coupon if you type save water in the coupon section of their web site. Good luck

posted by Water Response on March 14th 2009 at 6:46pm
view Water Response's profile

You mean USA doesn't have dual toilets in every home??? Everyone in Australia has one, and we flush our toilets just fine.

posted by annamac on March 17th 2009 at 5:51am
view annamac's profile

bromelia, if you're talking about Canada, I live in the same country and I'd rather see that water in our lakes and rivers than being used to flush your toilet.

Just because you think you can doesn't mean you should.

posted by webherring on April 8th 2009 at 8:14am
view webherring's profile

Feeds

RSS icon Los Angeles

+ City Feeds