apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Hot or Not? Walk In Tubs

031108_walkintubs.jpgA friend of ours just moved into a new apartment in Tokyo, and she noted that while her bathroom is teeny-tiny, she has a full soaking tub. "It's one of those walk-in tubs that in America is marketed towards the elderly," she explained. As a self-proclaimed half-hour soaker herself, she loves how it has all the capabilities of a jacuzzi but takes up less than half the space. What do you think? Take the survey after the jump...

[ Photo from Wasauna ]

Comments (22)

I'd take a soaking tub in any form. Maybe some people object because they look "geriatric?" But since I aspire to someday become geriatric myself, I'm not going to object to a tub that makes it easier to climb in and out.

posted by Molly Margarita on 2008-03-12 11:56:41
view Molly Margarita's profile

But what if you had to get out real quick?? That would suck if you had to drain the whole tub if you just forgot to get your magazine. And furthermore, I like to do stuff while my bath is running. You would have to sit in there the whole time your bath was running, right?

posted by Nicolewis on 2008-03-12 11:57:10
view Nicolewis's profile

If it could be partially sunken into the floor with access to get in and out then I would be more into it. Otherwise you have to stay in the tub while filling and draining it which is a turn off.

posted by twenty twenty-one on 2008-03-12 12:01:48
view twenty twenty-one's profile

While I think your friend is clever and resourceful, this is like asking if wheelchair ramps or adjustable hospital beds are "Hot".

Thumbs down on this poll, Grace.

posted by bepsf on 2008-03-12 12:03:15
view bepsf's profile

Hate these. Totally geriatric. Maybe when I'm 80 I'll want one.
Sunken tubs with little stairs get my vote though.

posted by kimg924 on 2008-03-12 12:18:04
view kimg924's profile

I disagree. The perception is that this is geriatric... and this perception is not shared outside of the US. Soaking tubs generally use less water than traditional American tubs, and hold their heat longer (because they are deeper, and there is less surface area for heat loss).

Apartment Therapy seems to focus on efficiency, because most apartments are small spaces. These tubs are efficient in many senses. I think it's an excellent poll question, and I would definitely rock one in my bathroom.

posted by Eric D M on 2008-03-12 12:27:49
view Eric D M 's profile

As I look at my "regular" size bathtub that is so shallow, a real soak is impossible, besides not being long enough to stretch out comfortably, this is looking pretty darn good.

posted by Aldyth on 2008-03-12 12:36:07
view Aldyth's profile

I often wish my bathtub was deeper instead of long, so i think this is a great idea! Do you think it would be hard to clean?

posted by Hollie on 2008-03-12 12:37:42
view Hollie's profile

Having been to Japan I understand the glory that is their soaking tubs. A shower usually occurs first to clean the body then a nice bath is drawn for a wonderful relaxing soak. They do tend to stay warmer longer due to surface area etc. I would rock that in a second if I had the choice.

NOT GERIATRIC - rather THERAPUTIC and I am all for that.

I say hot, since my lame little tub now is not much use for a decent soak.

posted by annaland on 2008-03-12 12:40:45
view annaland's profile

My grandmother says "hot!"

posted by nwlane on 2008-03-12 13:03:29
view nwlane's profile

Are there any square, deep tubs without a door?

this is not so hot.

posted by ryanpatrick76 on 2008-03-12 13:16:44
view ryanpatrick76's profile

I loathe this beast of a tub.

I always post on bathroom blogs because I work in Branding for TOTO, japanese manufacturer of airbaths and soaker tubs.

This thing is a disgrace to Interior Design, and I feel that a linen closet stocked with "depends" is needed if you have this ugly thing.

...I feel this way because on a daily basis someone visits my showroom raving about how cool they think these things are, and all I can do is roll my eyes in disgust.


Kiel

posted by KielOver on 2008-03-12 13:17:09
view KielOver's profile

One word: Ofuro.

Not this ugly thing.

posted by Allsunday on 2008-03-12 13:33:54
view Allsunday's profile

Someone please explain to me - you really have to get in and sit there while the water fills up around you to use this? And then after you have to sit there waiting for it to drain before you can open the door? That for me would take away any pleasure of the deep soaking ability.

I have a Japanese soaking tub now - and it takes a good while to fill up. No way would I want to have to be in it while it does so.

posted by potluck on 2008-03-12 13:52:36
view potluck's profile

If you need this sort of apparatus to bathe, then that's okay. Otherwise, it's a frivolous, extravagant waste of water for something that still requires a shower afterwards to get fully clean.

posted by ehy2k on 2008-03-12 14:00:08
view ehy2k's profile

Couldn't you use a step stool to get in after it fills up?

I wonder if there is any difference in how much water this uses vs a traditional bath.

I would rather sit in this thing and have my entire body covered than be half way lying down with my knees sticking out but I guess it depends on how big you tub is.

posted by payzlee on 2008-03-12 14:48:18
view payzlee's profile

Molly Margarita said it best..."geriatric" was the first word that came to mind. Uggghhh.

posted by STYLeyes on 2008-03-12 14:48:21
view STYLeyes's profile

All I can think of is the Infomercials advertising these things to people over 200 when I used to watch The Price is Right. If you are planning on staying in your home for good however, it might be a wise investment for the future.

posted by Volvoguy on 2008-03-12 16:42:15
view Volvoguy's profile

I'm all for soaking tubs. There are some beautiful designs for them, but this is not one. I don't find them frivolous at all. A good soak in a deep hot bath is extremely therapeutic for muscle kinks and just overall relaxing. But most of our bathrooms (and everything in them) have been (and continue to be) designed like they're a necessary evil. And a walk-in like the one pictured doesn't help.

Oh...and I'm not elderly, but the geriatric jokes really suck.

posted by btoddster on 2008-03-12 17:41:47
view btoddster's profile

Aesthetically, this is pretty ugly. But, I love the idea!

posted by PlanItGirl on 2008-03-12 18:41:28
view PlanItGirl's profile

Ugly design, ugly for the environment. It looks like it holds more water for a single use than I use in a week (okay, I'm stretching it, but just barely).

posted by dcaries on 2008-03-12 23:47:28
view dcaries's profile

Whenever I see the commercials for this tub, I think how much less space it would take up in my tiny bathroom - not to mention that at 5'2" I almost always bang my toes tripping into and out of the tub (its the original 1950's high tub) but since I don't see myself living in the same place into old age I guess i'll keep taking my chances that I won't be found unconscious or dead in my bathroom.

posted by bklyngal on 2008-03-13 10:17:55
view bklyngal's profile
Buy Text Ads