As Abby noted, we noticed a lot of designers producing pieces that were made of recycled or repurposed materials at this year's ICFF. One piece at the show garnered some attention. It was a prototype designed by Nick Demarco, a student, called the "XS chair." (Video and survey after the jump...)
Interestingly enough, none of us AT:LA editors really had any comment on it when we saw it (we noticed it but sort of just kept walking...) However, over at the Freshhome blog, they described it as "...the most stupid piece of Eco Friendly Furniture..." (Ouch!) Read what they had to say about it here. What do you guys think of it?
It's definitely different, I think it would look kinda cool filled with fabric scraps and such.
posted by
nynnie
on May 28th 2008 at 7:33am view
nynnie's
profile
could be cool filled with something else. But still only cool in a kids room/ dorm kind of way. Its chunky and would be sticky to sit on. Who wants to sit on a pile of rubbish?
posted by
kollros
on May 28th 2008 at 7:44am view
kollros's
profile
That is terrible
posted by
Tarasa
on May 28th 2008 at 7:54am view
Tarasa's
profile
That looks comfortable *insert sarcasm
posted by
jzh797s
on May 28th 2008 at 8:13am view
jzh797s's
profile
I think it's great! It's exciting to see some new ideas injected into the design world instead of the same old shit. This one is filled with trash... but what if it was filled with bright pink fabric scraps? I would buy one!
posted by
Spinestein
on May 28th 2008 at 8:24am view
Spinestein's
profile
If it was filled with bright pink fabric scraps, the whole room would vibrate. Lame-o.
posted by
Palmetto
on May 28th 2008 at 8:26am view
Palmetto's
profile
I have seen this idea before. I think it was filled with just newspapers, so not really exciting or new. As to filling it with a more appealing material, way to miss the point. I mean, if there was a point that hadn't already been made the last time someone made it.
posted by
K T G
on May 28th 2008 at 8:29am view
K T G's
profile
Also, the Olympics voting: bronze is still a prize. When something is bad, that just doesn't line up for me.
posted by
K T G
on May 28th 2008 at 8:31am view
K T G's
profile
i think eco friendly furniture has moved away from this aesthetic a long time ago. it seems old fashioned.
posted by
shoepins
on May 28th 2008 at 8:37am view
shoepins's
profile
It's just a pile of trash.
posted by
bepsf
on May 28th 2008 at 8:42am view
bepsf's
profile
Wow... Amazingly ugly.
posted by
MariannaV
on May 28th 2008 at 8:43am view
MariannaV's
profile
eek! It looks like a really bad student project. IMO, not aesthetically pleasing and not so creative. ok idea poor execution.
posted by
scottytown
on May 28th 2008 at 9:21am view
scottytown's
profile
You're missing the point here-- this is the XS chair. Art maybe, furniture, no. He's more interested in making a point about our repulsive consumer culture than making furniture. Which is fine. But it's not great design.
This chair reminds me of an installation I saw at the Art Institute of Chicago where the artist had hacked open a stuffed animal and spilled its "guts," which were comprised of other stuffed animals, across the floor. Great art, bad toy.
I like the idea but the execution is bad: ugly and uncomfortable-looking. It looks like a pile of trash...
posted by
annki
on May 28th 2008 at 9:27am view
annki's
profile
It reminds me of that car ad where the guy throws trash out his car window and the guy next to him collects it all and then creates a giant trash tree made out of all the collected trash and leaves it on his car.
Seems like a publicity stunt to me. Everyone is so appalled by it they talk about it. This guy is just hoping to get his name remembered. Nice try, Nick Demarco.
posted by
robyn m.
on May 28th 2008 at 10:27am view
robyn m.'s
profile
I couldn't watch the video at work, and so... I just watched it. It looks like something he thought up the night before the assignment was due. His youth may account for the fact he was calling aesthetic solutions a "band-aid" while believing he'd construed a completely original concept also. It appeared initially as a statement against trash, but I hadn't realized the message was I'm going to sell you a shell and you can put anything you like into it. He used trash for "effect," is not entirely suggesting you put your own trash in it for real, and at once, suggesting that his idea over-rides the synthesis of recycled materials into new items by simply stuffing with trash, which you can use old clothes if you don't think the trash looks great. The sky is the limit!
posted by
K T G
on May 28th 2008 at 4:03pm view
K T G's
profile
You people are a bunch of boring yuppies. It's not a perfect project, but I admire it for at least attempting to set a different curve than the your average dime a dozen green-washed product.
posted by
Spinestein
on May 28th 2008 at 11:39pm view
Spinestein's
profile
Reset Password
Enter the email address you used to register and we will email you a new password.
Thank you, your account has been registered.
We have sent an email to the address you registered with for verification purposes. Please use the link in the verification email to activate your account.
Your Password Has Been Reset.
We have sent an email to the address requested with your login information.
It's definitely different, I think it would look kinda cool filled with fabric scraps and such.
view nynnie's profile
could be cool filled with something else. But still only cool in a kids room/ dorm kind of way. Its chunky and would be sticky to sit on. Who wants to sit on a pile of rubbish?
view kollros's profile
That is terrible
view Tarasa's profile
That looks comfortable *insert sarcasm
view jzh797s's profile
I think it's great! It's exciting to see some new ideas injected into the design world instead of the same old shit. This one is filled with trash... but what if it was filled with bright pink fabric scraps? I would buy one!
view Spinestein's profile
If it was filled with bright pink fabric scraps, the whole room would vibrate. Lame-o.
view Palmetto's profile
I have seen this idea before. I think it was filled with just newspapers, so not really exciting or new. As to filling it with a more appealing material, way to miss the point. I mean, if there was a point that hadn't already been made the last time someone made it.
view K T G's profile
Also, the Olympics voting: bronze is still a prize. When something is bad, that just doesn't line up for me.
view K T G's profile
i think eco friendly furniture has moved away from this aesthetic a long time ago. it seems old fashioned.
view shoepins's profile
It's just a pile of trash.
view bepsf's profile
Wow... Amazingly ugly.
view MariannaV's profile
eek! It looks like a really bad student project. IMO, not aesthetically pleasing and not so creative. ok idea poor execution.
view scottytown's profile
You're missing the point here-- this is the XS chair. Art maybe, furniture, no. He's more interested in making a point about our repulsive consumer culture than making furniture. Which is fine. But it's not great design.
This chair reminds me of an installation I saw at the Art Institute of Chicago where the artist had hacked open a stuffed animal and spilled its "guts," which were comprised of other stuffed animals, across the floor. Great art, bad toy.
view darling_aesthete's profile
I like the idea but the execution is bad: ugly and uncomfortable-looking. It looks like a pile of trash...
view annki's profile
It reminds me of that car ad where the guy throws trash out his car window and the guy next to him collects it all and then creates a giant trash tree made out of all the collected trash and leaves it on his car.
The tree is cooler.
view girlonthem00n's profile
Seems like a publicity stunt to me. Everyone is so appalled by it they talk about it. This guy is just hoping to get his name remembered. Nice try, Nick Demarco.
view robyn m.'s profile
I couldn't watch the video at work, and so... I just watched it. It looks like something he thought up the night before the assignment was due. His youth may account for the fact he was calling aesthetic solutions a "band-aid" while believing he'd construed a completely original concept also. It appeared initially as a statement against trash, but I hadn't realized the message was I'm going to sell you a shell and you can put anything you like into it. He used trash for "effect," is not entirely suggesting you put your own trash in it for real, and at once, suggesting that his idea over-rides the synthesis of recycled materials into new items by simply stuffing with trash, which you can use old clothes if you don't think the trash looks great. The sky is the limit!
view K T G's profile
You people are a bunch of boring yuppies. It's not a perfect project, but I admire it for at least attempting to set a different curve than the your average dime a dozen green-washed product.
view Spinestein's profile