apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Do You Leave Your Porch Light On?

062608_porchlight.jpgDuring an evening walk around the neighborhood, we could hear some kids a few steps ahead of us counting the houses that had their porch light on. "How come some houses do and some don't?" one kid asked, and the other kid replied, "Because the ones that don't are where witches and trolls live!" Well, while that may not be totally accurate, it got us thinking about the importance of porch lights. Do you leave your porch light on at night?

[ Photo from Cyanatic's Flickr ]

 
 

Tags

lighting

Related Links

Share

Comments (61)

Not very green. I'm a fan of the motion-sensor variety.

posted by patrick (the other one) on June 26th 2008 at 11:44am
view patrick (the other one)'s profile

I do. My boyfriend doesn't. We live in kind of iffy area next to a park so I just like to leave it on for safety. Terrible I know.

posted by emilyalane on June 26th 2008 at 11:48am
view emilyalane's profile

motion sensor light here.

posted by spossberg on June 26th 2008 at 11:51am
view spossberg's profile

I turn mine on if I am going to be gone during the evening hours or if I have company coming over.

posted by Seaside on June 26th 2008 at 11:52am
view Seaside's profile

solar motion sensor over here

posted by meenasyaz on June 26th 2008 at 11:53am
view meenasyaz's profile

i don't have a motion sensor light. we turn off our porch light at night. it is green, and it saves money. our former roommate used to leave it on all night long, pretty much every night (he usually came in long after we went to bed, and no amount of assertiveness on our part would change his habits). now that he's out, and we're still in the same place, the electric bill has decreased, even though all our other usage has stayed more or less the same.

posted by closertotheocean on June 26th 2008 at 11:54am
view closertotheocean's profile

There are no lights on our street so we do keep the porch light on with a compact fluorescent bulb.

posted by payzlee on June 26th 2008 at 11:56am
view payzlee's profile

solar/motion/half power here. When it gets dark, mine turns on at 1/2 the power level (and 1/2 the brightness) for an hour, then turns itself off unless it detects motion at which point it pops up to full brightness.

Only drawback is that the 1/2 power doesn't work with a CFL, so I have an old fashioned incandescent in there.

posted by ChzPlz on June 26th 2008 at 12:00pm
view ChzPlz's profile

ditto solar motion sensor

posted by DKinNY on June 26th 2008 at 12:00pm
view DKinNY's profile

No lights on our street either. Our porch is also our carport and I'm freaked about property theft. In northern CA and even in my city of Davis, people are stealing anything that isn't tied down. The big thing is to steal the cataletic converter - ever price a replacement? ouch! So the light stays on but I made sure it's a CFL.

posted by Renngrrl on June 26th 2008 at 12:02pm
view Renngrrl's profile

We have motion sensor lights on the driveway, and also a porch light and a lamp post. I almost always forget about the porch light, but I do turn on the lamp post most evenings in winter. Now, not so much - it still gets dark pretty late.

posted by laura c on June 26th 2008 at 12:08pm
view laura c's profile

CFLs are great for this. i agree that it can feel like an energy waster, but as someone whose commute includes a several-block walk through a rather dark residential neighborhood (ok, not in the summer at least!), i REALLY appreciate the houses that have theirs on in the evenings. it definitely makes me feel safer - like there are more eyes and ears on the street and i am not so completely alone and vulnerable. it would be great to have a timer to turn it off at midnight or something, though.

posted by akostalas on June 26th 2008 at 12:10pm
view akostalas's profile

No lights on our street. The only time our outside light is on is when we're out of the house or expecting visitors.

posted by Trilobyte on June 26th 2008 at 12:16pm
view Trilobyte's profile

People, a lot of times it just looks nice to have a light on. Use a low wattage one if you are really green. Turn it off at midnight. If you are on this website you are probably concerned with aesthetics. And there is nothing aesthetic about solar lights or motion detectors.

posted by I_Heart_The_Eastside on June 26th 2008 at 12:23pm
view I_Heart_The_Eastside's profile

front is motion sensor, back is regular. really should look into having that changed. or get little solar pathway lights so I don't kill myself on the stairs!

I_heart_the_Eastide - solar lights and motion detectors can be hidden. There is no reason a person can't have both!

posted by Heather C on June 26th 2008 at 12:25pm
view Heather C's profile

We have a pretty dense tree canopy that blocks most of the streetlight, so we leave ours on. But it is a CFL. Our neigbors had their front door kicked in one night last month, so we're more worried about safety than the environment in this particular case!

posted by matt in kc on June 26th 2008 at 12:25pm
view matt in kc's profile

I like when they're left on, but I also like to conserve energy. I'll leave it on if I'm home alone, or if I'm expecting guests. I usually turn it off when I go to bed though.

posted by revolution9 on June 26th 2008 at 12:32pm
view revolution9's profile

This is one time where sustainability trumps the environment. The additional energy consumed by leaving a CFL on at night pales in comparison to the social and community benefits (above and beyond crime deterrence) of having porch lights on.

If you are really an enviro-nut -- use solar light sensitive fixtures.

posted by phaedrus on June 26th 2008 at 12:33pm
view phaedrus's profile

Porch lights are common where I live. Safety first! (I assume.)

You've heard of guerilla gardeners who plant vegetables along highways and wildflowers in abandoned lots? A band of guerilla energy savers recently went around replacing traditional porch light bulbs with CFL bulbs in my neighborhood and others nearby - whether people wanted them or not.

posted by raisinette on June 26th 2008 at 12:34pm
view raisinette's profile

I_Heart_The_Eastside - I totally agree. Solar lights give off a hideous bluish cast...not inviting. Ditto flourescents (although they're getting better at making them emit warmer light).

And timers don't address the whole idea of leaving the porchlight on...they're on, they're off. Seems commercial.

A low-wattage porchlight left on until late in the evening is a beautiful thing that makes neighborhoods more...well...neighborhoody. Hooray for porchlights!

posted by jennya on June 26th 2008 at 12:38pm
view jennya's profile

we have the porch light on from dusk till dawn, as my neighborhood is iffy with drug deals round the corner all the time. the neighborhood association encourages us to leave the light on as the bad guys usually avoid lighted area.

also because the light is on a dimmer, i had to use regular incandescent.

unfortunately.

posted by aspw on June 26th 2008 at 12:43pm
view aspw's profile

I leave the front an back lights on 24/7. I should get the solar sensors to turn them off during the day but I haven't yet. In the summer I could probably remember to turn them on and off but in the winter I leave in the dark and come home in the dark.

I leave them on for safety reasons and because I think houses with no light on in the evening look terribly unfriendly - plus it helps emergency personnel see your house numbers.

posted by ryanmarie on June 26th 2008 at 12:55pm
view ryanmarie's profile

You also have the option of using rope light, you know:

"Seventy-five feet of our LED rope light uses a little less energy than a 60-watt incandescent light bulb, which makes it very energy-efficient."

http://www.pegasusassociates.com/products/RopeLights/RopeLights.html

And as you probably won't be doing the whole home, it's not too expensive.

I did see a home with rope light all the way around at the eaves. It looks great. It looks like it's all dressed up for holidays or some incredible party.

And what it does is put light exactly where you want it for safety, all the way around the perimeter where you would easily be able to see someone sneaking about, from inside or outside.

As the light is done under the eaves, there's a bit less light pollution. It does not shine up.

The bulbs cannot be replaced, so if you get a dim bulb in ten years, you have a dim bulb...BUT, that is when you can replace that section of the rope (if it bothers you) with a new one, and start using the dim bulb one elsewhere. Garage. In trees or bushes.

And the rope light is infinitely more appealing than "security" lighting. It looks fun and festive and inviting and a bit magical.

It isn't a suspicious "HALT! Who goes there?" motion detector light that makes everyone who triggers it feel like a criminal.

posted by TRUE BLUE on June 26th 2008 at 1:02pm
view TRUE BLUE's profile

Hi guys - our building needs additional lighting along the narrow corridor that runs between our building and our neighbor's. We need it primariy to improve the safety of the corridor.

Ideally this lighting would be:
1) Not super-expensive, say $75 or less per light, or the condo assn. won't buy into it
2) I like ChzPlz's 1/2 power concept until motion makes it go full brightness, otherwise it will be on a timer to be on all night
3) Energy efficient
4) Doesn't look completely nasty (I'd like to avoid the regular motion-sensor flood lights if possible, but I'm afraid the assn is going to go with that unless I find a reasonable alternative)

Any specific recommendations? Thanks!

posted by bumblebeechicago on June 26th 2008 at 1:03pm
view bumblebeechicago's profile

I leave my porch light on because, believe it or not, the light has only been off for maybe five nights since I moved in three months ago, and both my car and my wifes car has been broken into twice each! My iPod was taken and my wifes GPS device (she needs it bad) was taken twice. My car was broken into and I woke up and chased them away. Supposedly my area is safe, and the police think that I am being targeted because I am the only one in the neighborhood that has any problems. Go figure, our house has a constant grey cloud over it and it is not because I leave my porch light on all the time.

posted by mozmun20 on June 26th 2008 at 1:04pm
view mozmun20's profile

Front porch-not a chance. The Master Bedroom is at the front of the house which means the light would be 10 feet from my head at night.
Back porch-most definitly. Anything to deter the car theives.

posted by truenic on June 26th 2008 at 1:21pm
view truenic's profile

A couple more things on the rope lighting for those who might be interested. Not finding the images I wanted to find, but here's one using the lights low on a deck:
http://www.whitelightledbulb.com/Led-rope-lights.jpg

A how-to on indoor lighting, using rope lights and a bunch of other stuff:
http://www.rd.com/familyhandyman/content/17643/

Someone's bar, which uses rope light (scroll down):
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=640633

Another low use display, along the base of a railing:
http://www.rope-lighting.org/index.php?action=recent;start=70

Indoor accent lighting:
http://affordablequality-lighting.com/

Scroll down here to see it used under the eaves right NEXT to a building:
http://www.freedomfarm.com/news/index.html

And this should work for Bumblebeechicago's condo area too.

posted by TRUE BLUE on June 26th 2008 at 1:23pm
view TRUE BLUE's profile

I am too cheap to leave the light on.

posted by plain jane on June 26th 2008 at 1:24pm
view plain jane's profile

Although I live on the 2nd floor I leave the porch light on my balcony on for security (CFL). The first floor is actually garden-level so if someone wanted to climb on my balcony and break in or just vandalize something it wouldn't be hard to do. I keep it on a timer so it comes on well after dark, but stays on at least an hour past when the bars close (there are 2 just down the street). I try and prevent some drunk from making a questionable decision at 2 AM and try to vandalize something just for fun.

Admittedly I am pretty security conscious having once been held at knife point in my car and just a year later coming home to a house that had been totally ransacked and everything I had of any value was stolen. Fortunately both these events were in 1987 but you never forget once it happens to you.

posted by dmstudio on June 26th 2008 at 1:32pm
view dmstudio's profile

True Blue - your rope light idea would be fantastic for the porches up in Chicago's Lincoln Square neighborhood! Unfortunately, both buildings along our corridor are 3 stories high, so there are no eaves close enough to the ground to hang the lights under. Maybe I can use it on my little porch though. Hmmmm. A new project, perhaps?!

posted by bumblebeechicago on June 26th 2008 at 1:38pm
view bumblebeechicago's profile

I hate motion sensor lights. They make a neighborhood feel less safe and friendly. I have to walk several blocks from the bus stop to my building and several of the houses along my path have motion sensor lights that turn on as I'm walking along the sidewalk . I don't know if they're miscalibrated or intentional, but it's not comfortable. There's a moment of alarm each time as I instinctively wait for the dogs to be set loose or an alarm to sound. Then I continue along my way. Porchlights that are simply left on are much better if you want to encourage a community that's friendly to pedestrian travel.

posted by lurker2209 on June 26th 2008 at 2:04pm
view lurker2209's profile

My boyfriend and I have conflict over lights. While I try to be green by turning lights off, I take lighting very seriously and like my main floor to be gorgeously lit at night. Nothing satisfies me more than a well-lit room. I also like leaving a lamp or two on if we're away. My boyfriend is always turning off my lights! My justification, whether it's right or wrong, is that I use 25W bulbs in all my lamps - A well-lit serial killer's den.

Our front porch light is on during evening hours until we go to bed. It's one of our rituals, turning off the front light, then up to bed.

posted by theserovingeyes on June 26th 2008 at 2:07pm
view theserovingeyes's profile

Last year when I was 7 months pregnant my house alarm went off at 3am. My husband was away on a business trip and I did not have a single light on in the house. I was completely terrified and I couldn't see if there was anyone outside or inside. I now leave the front and back porch lights on, a light in my foyer and the stove light in my kitchen. All CFL's of course!

posted by rikki on June 26th 2008 at 2:09pm
view rikki's profile

I leave mine on all night, every night. But in my transitional neighborhood it helps to keep the drug dealers and hookers away.

posted by Donald in Pigtown on June 26th 2008 at 2:31pm
view Donald in Pigtown's profile

I don't have control over my porch light, weirdly. I spent about 20 minutes looking for the switch when I moved into my apartment. But my porch light is on every night, apparently all night. Bummer for the neighbor whose bedroom window is at a 90 degree angle to our porch.

posted by BetterBombshell on June 26th 2008 at 2:34pm
view BetterBombshell's profile

Bumblebeechicago:

I don't know the style of the buildings, or what windows might face that corridor...but there is the option of a simple wood molding, that runs the length of the corridor. Painted the same color as the wall, doesn't have to be fancy, onto which the clips or hooks can be mounted for the lights.

They could be mounted up high enough so they are not messed with, but low enough to shed light on the area.

They have so many advantages, they don't stick out, you don't need to wire anything along that corridor, other than having a place to plug in the one end. They could probably be set on a timer, or coordinated with an "on at dusk, off a dawn" thing.

Because if they decide to put in separate lights, they are going to have to run the electrical somewhere...and that means they either have to tear up the exterior (expensive) or run an electrical pipe along the corridor between lights (unsightly to ugly).

Also, as you saw, it does not have to be above, it can be below, like along the base of the corridor.

If the area is narrow, really narrow, they could do something like HANDRAILS!!! And light up below the handrails on each side.

If you do a project, Bumblebeechicago, we want to see before and after!!! I LOVE projects (er, when they are done by someone else).

posted by TRUE BLUE on June 26th 2008 at 2:45pm
view TRUE BLUE's profile

ours is on... low-wattage CFL (7W or so... ikea is great for low-wattage CFLs) for the reasons mentioned above: safety, aesthetics, neighborhoodiness, etc... considering what could be lost while not having it on, it's not a hard sell for us. other neighbors, however, have installed ginormous metal-halide lights -- the kind that should be hung 50 feet in the air -- in the same place as their old incandescent bulbs... not good. really, a porch light looks and works best when not overpowering.

posted by redneckmodern on June 26th 2008 at 3:05pm
view redneckmodern's profile

wait so CFL are the coiled bulbs? are they really a lot better than regular bulbs? and why?

posted by piratemptress on June 26th 2008 at 3:23pm
view piratemptress's profile

we leave ours on, especially if we are going to be gone. The tiny amount of energy does not make me feel guilty since I am using a CFL.

posted by sar3j on June 26th 2008 at 3:28pm
view sar3j's profile

It's on only if I'm expecting someone (myself included).

Reducing my electric bill and reducing my impact on the environment are part of it.

But another part of it is that I just don't like the light pollution. I REALLY can't stand it when my closest neighbors leave their outdoor lights on all night.

Also, leaving the porch light on attracts bugs.

posted by nausved on June 26th 2008 at 4:08pm
view nausved's profile

CFL = Compact Fluorescent Lamp/Light (or Canadian Football League)

Snopes on the true and false questions for CFLs:
http://www.snopes.com/medical/toxins/cfl.asp

I'd highly recommend that everyone read that section.

Broken CFLs require special handling and disposal. They should not be disposed of with household trash.

Which is one reason my dead CFLs are still in the socket. I don't know what to do with them.

posted by TRUE BLUE on June 26th 2008 at 4:11pm
view TRUE BLUE's profile

Solar lights up the path to the door for safety (they don't really illuminate the stairs much, but they remind me where they begin and end). If I'm expecting someone (housemates and/or guests) or forget, the front porch CFL stays on.

posted by thursday on June 26th 2008 at 5:14pm
view thursday's profile

On, but on a timer. On at sundown, off at bedtime.

posted by ddg425 on June 26th 2008 at 5:41pm
view ddg425's profile

I have a back-lit address light that I leave on all night in case there's an emergency and the ambulance/firetruck/police have to find my house in a hurry. I leave it on from dusk to dawn.

posted by Snoozy on June 26th 2008 at 9:18pm
view Snoozy's profile

as an animal control officer that works nights, I really appreciate it when people leave their porch lights on, or have back lit address numbers like the one above! I hate not being able to find addresses when there is an injured animal waiting for me.

posted by tomahto on June 26th 2008 at 9:36pm
view tomahto's profile

Tomahto, you mean animals that don't belong to the people AT the house? Otherwise they should be taking it to a vet, if it's theirs.

One of the skunks got hit and killed late Wed or early Thu. I'm kind of hoping it wasn't one of the mama skunks. I'm not sure the babies are quite old enough to have learned what they need to know to fend for themselves.

Last year one of the mama raccoons was hit. It was awful. I found her in the middle of the road, at night, on the unlit part of our street. I stop to make sure they are dead. As I can't think of a more horrible way to die...slowly, painfully, with the cars and trucks barreling towards you on both sides.

She was still alive.

And I wasn't going to leave her there.

So I picked her up and carried her to the side of the road as gently as possible. And I am ashamed to say that I did NOT call animal control right away.

Because the last time I sat with another dying raccoon, they took HOURS and HOURS to get there, while this little animal writhed in pain and agony.

I picked up that one when the officer came and scooted it carefully into the carrier contraption he had brought. He wanted to know how much wildlife training I had. None. I think it was too far gone anyway, or maybe it knew I wouldn't hurt it.

I went out early the next day and found that she had made it through the night, and that is when I called it in. THIS time animal control came out real fast.

They would not let me pick her up again, they used that rope-on-a-pole thing.

And later that day, my heart was broken again, when I heard her babies trilling for her. And there was nothing that could be done. No way of explaining to them that mama wasn't coming back.

posted by TRUE BLUE on June 26th 2008 at 11:39pm
view TRUE BLUE's profile

I have motion sensor lights with CFLs at the front and back of my house. It's all about safety.

posted by Aldyth on June 27th 2008 at 4:51am
view Aldyth's profile

The switch for my building's front porch light is in our flat and we have been advised by the HOA that it must stay on 24/7. Fine with me but still funny. It was taped on when we bought the place and we got an email immediately when it was thought we had turned it off but it had actually burned out.

posted by Cynthia in SF on June 27th 2008 at 4:53am
view Cynthia in SF's profile

I live in a very dark area and for some reason my city does not have adequate street lighting. For safety reasons I keep the lights on. I feel very strongly that all residents should be required to keep their front porch lights on or have sensor lights installed around their property. There have been numerous situations where lack of lighting have brought about real safety concerns for the neighborhood. A properly lit neighborhood has less crime, less accidents and less problems overall - period.

posted by H.B. on June 27th 2008 at 6:42am
view H.B.'s profile

Where have all the stars gone?

Our neighbour's light floods our bedroom all night, but we haven't got the guts up to mention it yet. I'd be happy to buy her a new fixture that directs the light downwards.

Our lights go on occasionally for an hour or so of evening friendliness, but that's it. And they're CFLs.

posted by luna on June 27th 2008 at 6:49am
view luna's profile

PERFECT timing for me--my partner left yesterday for a month and I've been wondering whether I should leave the light on outside for safety. I also love the soft light it sheds--but felt I should turn it off to save if I'm asleep. What the heck--I'm leaving it on, for safety and beauty/neighborliness.

posted by jen_g on June 27th 2008 at 7:09am
view jen_g's profile

we use to have a motion sensor one (not solar) when we first moved here but there are always cats, dogs, cars, birds, ect that pass by its range that the light was constantly flicking on and off and it got annoying really fast. we changed it and only turn it on when the pets go out at night to do their business.

posted by witchbaby on June 27th 2008 at 9:35am
view witchbaby's profile

I'm in an apartment and the light on our landing is pretty much always on.

posted by goldfixe on June 27th 2008 at 9:46am
view goldfixe's profile

I have a light sensor. I leave the light on as a service to my neighbors.

posted by Carol in Denver on June 27th 2008 at 10:05am
view Carol in Denver's profile

We have a motion sensor light over the garage and a porch light with a CFL bulb. We turn the porch light on when it gets dark (and leave it on until we go to bed) because it attracts the June bugs and keeps them from tap-tap-tapping against our living room windows.

posted by ehat on June 27th 2008 at 10:14am
view ehat's profile

I despise motion sensor lights. Probably because they are usually hooked up to blinding horrid floodlights that completely eliminate any night-vision and they don't adequately light so that night-vision isn't needed.
I use a CFL and it is on all night. I like knowing that no matter what time I get home there will be a light on. It just says "home" to me.

posted by pbblythe on June 27th 2008 at 10:32am
view pbblythe's profile

I live in a rural area and only turn on outside lights if I'm expecting company. So . . . make sure you call first!!

posted by williamsweyr on June 27th 2008 at 1:10pm
view williamsweyr's profile

My husband and I used to turn the lights off right before bedtime, but that was before we started living in our present location.

We live along a mountainside and in my neighborhood there are NO street lights (thanks to L.A. and Sherman Oaks) and NO SIDEWALKS. The neighborhood is fairly well to do, minimal car traffic and no buses. And yet there are burglaries here and there all the time. If you go out for a walk during the evening, without street lights and if there were no outdoor lights on in the private homes, it would be pitch black. And with no sidewalks you are forced to take your evening stroll right along moving cars. I have almost hit some idiots while driving more then once, because they were wearing dark clothes and were not carrying a flashlight during their evening strolls. In the six years I have lived in our home we were burglarized (as was the house a few doors down) and my car was broken into (the passenger window was shattered all for a crappy 4yr old cell phone). All this in one of the largest metropolises in the U.S. with one of the biggest populations, in a very well populated and developed area of L.A.

So YEAH we leave our lights on the entire night. We use CFL's and don't think twice about it. Safety for my husband, my kids and me comes first. I agree with H.B. in one of the previous posts, all of my neighbors should be required to leave their lights on at night, since the city doesn't provide this safety feature to the residents.

posted by MariannaV on June 27th 2008 at 5:11pm
view MariannaV's profile

7watt cfl, turned off at midnight or bedtime, whichever comes first.

posted by Miriam on June 29th 2008 at 12:22pm
view Miriam's profile

we have a little rope light up around the inside of the front porch (not visible unless you are standing on the porch) but it creates a friendly glow.

otherwise we just flip the light on the way out in the evening, and turn it off when we get in.

posted by Kalei on June 29th 2008 at 2:17pm
view Kalei's profile

CFLs on all night front and back. Iffy neighborhood. Christmas Day drive bys and strange men urinating on the porch.

posted by BonivaGScott on June 29th 2008 at 8:05pm
view BonivaGScott's profile

Feeds

RSS icon Los Angeles

+ City Feeds