I want to say thanks for the many congratulations — and all the wonderful tips — that you left on my post about sick days at home. The felicitations weren't for being ill, of course, but for being newly engaged, which leads me to my next subject. I promise I won't make a habit of mentioning it — at Apartment Therapy we blog about the home, not getting hitched — but the two happen to intersect here. I'm referring to the wedding registry.
I have conflicted feelings about it. My betrothed and I are both established adults who have a stand mixer, a microwave, and a fancy wine opener. At the same time, we're still eating off Ikea dishes and our walls are a bit bare. There are a lot of small-ish things we haven't splurged on that would make our first home a lot homier. There are a few bigger things too.
Still, I feel guilty flat-out asking for stuff. Every time I think about it, it seems so uncouth, or at least clinical, what with the computer-managed request lists with prices helpfully listed for all to see. (In my brokest days, I was always relieved to see a garlic press on there.)
I started by asking my two best friends what they think about registries.
Rachel, who has exquisite taste, was full of advice. She even offered to research my registry for me after showing me her dream flatware of the moment. "You're getting married, people want to buy you gifts," she told me. "Even if they can't spend a lot of money, they want to get something for you."
When she got married, she devoted her registry to starting her collection of Eva Zeisel ceramics — her stash is the one in the featured photo — particularly those done in collaboration with her friends, the designers at Klein-Reid. I bought her an elegant little bud vase and was so pleased to give her something artistic and meaningful. (I love her and know her well, but my girl is particular!) It was so much more gratifying than selecting and shipping a generic household item. Her husband was totally on board with it, too.
My friend Alisiene, who also has supreme style, got married at 23 to an extremely attractive, older academic man in England. They took a charmingly personalized approach to their "registry."
"We sent a handwritten note with our invitations," she explains. "There was one list for our close friends and family, and another for acquaintances that had to be invited."
The note read: "We decided to create a wish list of things we would like to have for our wedding, if you choose to participate. If not, we love you the same. Please enjoy the spirit of this list."
Among the items they asked for?
• "A blues album by someone you think we should hear."
• "A vintage ice pick, preferably from the '30s, but the '40s or '50s would be fine too."
• "An old musical instrument, not necessarily of any value, that you think we should learn to play."
"The list took us months," she says. "But we got so many things that were so unique and you could tell that people enjoyed searching. It was like a treasure hunt."
I love both of these ideas and am starting to feel at ease with doing a registry — or at least some form of one. I have always enjoyed buying wedding gifts, and when finances have allowed, I've tried to be generous. Sometimes I've gone by the list, sometimes I've gone rogue, but I've always been glad to do it.
Weddings are once in a lifetime — well, at least we all hope they'll be — and if people want to give us things for our home that we'll love and cherish for a lifetime, I guess it shouldn't make me a blushing bride-to-be.
I'm curious to hear how all of you handled your registry. Did you have any qualms? What did you ask for?
Image: Rachel Ehlin

Commercial Flour Sa...
At first I thought it was tacky, but people were really anxious that I register so they'd be sure they were getting me something I wanted. We registered for silver and china (plus some lower-priced things like napkins for friends on budgets), and we use it every day, for every meal.
Oh, and if you're in need of art, ask for 20x200 gift certificates (20x200.com). There's a huge selection, and using the certificates couldn't be easier.
I've been married for 31 years so things were a lot simpler then. We had a smallish wedding (about 50 people in an historic church) and did a small registry at the gallery of a local artist (Don Drumm in Akron Ohio); in addition to his own work (mostly cast aluminum sculptures and objects for the home) it sold (and still sells) the work of crafts people around the US. We focused on things for our kitchen, including handmade stoneware (both our "wedding china" and other bits and bobs), wooden cutting boards and boxes, handmade kitchen utensils, and such. Since we were poor college students, we really focused on things that were affordable and helped to make our living situations ours. We still have almost everything we were given and still use it daily.
I felt weird about creating a registry myself. I think it's good to keep a wide range of prices on the items you choose, so everyone can take part. As one salesman pointed out as we registered "everybody loves a wedding and everybody loves a baby" - everybody wants to get you something you'll love, so don't feel weird about it :)
I also had reservations asking people to buy us things. We had already lived together for 4 years before we got married. So we decided to only register for items that we REALLY needed or wanted to upgrade from IKEA, or randomness that we both brought into the relationship. BEST DECISION EVER! Every day about 3 months before our wedding was like Christmas. I love throwing dinner parties now, because I'm not so mismatched. We didn't do "wedding china" we live in NYC and aren't exactly china hutch people. So we focused on every day needs. But beware some guests go rogue and buy you something not only off the list, but so random your like..."why did you think of me when you bought this?" We have a bowl that is ceramic and has large pointy sharp birds on it. it was so expensive, 4 people went in on it. It was handmade, so could not be returned anywhere. So...we turned it into a bird bath in our backyard. at least we found a use for the ugly bird bowl!
We populated ours with all the things we wanted to buy during our engagement - like a new can opener, and new food storage containers, and more exciting things like an orange tree and a hammock. It was a great way to get all the little missing pieces, and helped us save money toward the wedding too (by not rushing out to buy these things). We used Amazon's universal registry, which was awesome.
You can also have your mom and bride's maids spread the word if you'd be happy to get handmade presents - we got a lovely quilt, a hand-carved bowl, and some artwork made by some of our guests.
I've seen what happens when you don't have a registry (if you don't specifically say you don't want any presents) and it isn't pretty! There is only so much room for crystal candlesticks and scented candles in one home...
I don't think registries are tacky, though I did feel weird putting things on our lists initially. People DO want to get you wedding gifts and a registry just makes their decision easier.
Although we had already been living together for several years, we too were eating with IKEA flatware and a hodge-podge of college dishes from Kmart, Target, and the like. So, we simply registered for beautiful, higher-end everyday dishes and flatware in lieu of formal china and silver; towels and knick knacks at Macy's (since that is the only department store for miles from each of our small home towns); and left the rest of our wish list in the hands of REI. It was so fun to get backpacking and camping gear that we couldn't bring ourselves to buy (because it adds up quickly!) and friends seemed to like having the alternatives.
I felt super awkward about it, too. I'm not used to people buying things for me, and asking for things seemed even worse.
That is, until my mother in law pointed out to me that, "people are going to want to buy things for you because they're happy for you and want to celebrate. So you might as well help them out by letting them know what you'd like."
If you're still feeling like you don't want to ask for gifts at all, try asking for something more personal, like asking people to bring a favorite book or CD (or MP3s :).
If you don't want to aggregate more "stuff", then you could also ask that people donate money to a charity instead of buying gifts.
A registry wasn't for us - I'm 31 and he's 34 and I've been to enough weddings to see people register for flat screen tv's and target gift cards to make me feel icky about the situation. About 1/2 of our friends and family had to fly in to attend and I really felt that was their gift to us! However, I think it should be just about the two of you - every single wedding is different, every circumstance is different and you should do what will make you happy and comfortable.
I like the convenience of other people having wedding registries, but didn't have one myself. I pretty much eloped both for the civil ceremony about 30 years ago and for the religious ceremony much later. I was delighted to be self-sufficient and free of financial strings. I had the "go ahead and laugh, at least it's paid for" attitude. Besides, I resisted conforming to sexist traditions, and also disliked formal tableware for my own home. No regrets, and it seems an improvement that even hardware stores offer registries now. Congratulations and best wishes!
We were young 'uns--24 & 26--when we got married 12 years ago so our stuff was pretty college-tastic. Our registry was pretty straight-forward things that we would need to set up home. If I had it to do again, I would have picked some items that were less utilitarian--the 9x13 Pyrex dish is servicable but I wish I had a pretty oven-to-table casserole. I know I could get one for myself but it is a want rather than a need and gets bumped down the list. But yeah, people are happy for you and want to get you stuff whether you have a registry or not.
And I didn't feel so awkward about the registry as I did about the shower. It was uncomfortably odd to open gifts that you've asked for in front of others.
As a wedding guest, I like gift registries. It's true - us guests want to give a gift to wish the new couple well. I appreciate registries with multiple price points though. I once read that a couple asked for $ towards their honeymoon, which was a foux pas to some, but not to me. Register away!
I will be getting married in the next year so this strikes a chord. I have always found registries self centered unless you are really young and broke. My fiancé and I are in our mid-twenties and still broke college students, but we have the basics. I would love camping gear, but I don't need it and therefore I can slowly buy it myself. I can't fathom asking for specific art pieces. We will likely register at a few charities. I will buy a $50 Heath plate when I have earned enough myself to splurge, until then I think it is a perfect way to balance out what is a very self-absorbed celebration.
Even better, register for a down payment for a house. HUD used to have a program for future home-buyers and Time Magazine did a story on it. Here's the link: http://moneyland.time.com/2011/08/10/best-wedding-gift-ever-a-house-via-the-fha-bridal-registry/. If you intend to purchase a fixer-upper and lack power tools, Home Depot and Sears have registries too.
My husband and I registered with Amazon when we married. We did not tell anyone unless they asked. We put a variety of items at different price points. Some silly, some indulgent. 1/4 of the guests asked and used it, the rest gave other great items.
I try not buy exclusively off a couple's registry, but it helps get a sense of what they might want or need if they have one.
I don't think of registries as being a bad thing at all. People want to get things for others, and this makes it easier to see what is needed, what fits individual style, and helps in cultivating stuff that falls in the "ours" category instead of "mine" and "yours."
Granted, when I got married, we were extra broke and spent just about everything we had on our wedding - the registry was very helpful in getting us the things we would have gotten otherwise.
I also figure when I go to a wedding, that they are paying a lot not just for the wedding, but for our meal, entertainment, and time with us. If we were important enough to be invited, I see getting a gift - especially from a registry - as a return on their investment. They invested in me by inviting me, so I can get them something that I know they want.
Not having a registry is honestly more self absored than having one! Your guest are spending their money and hoping you like the gift, why not take the guess work out of it! I find it very awkward when people have no registry. I would never go to a wedding without gift and with a registry, I know it will be an appreciated gift!
I'm all for registries! It makes buying a gift for a wedding or baby much easier and they are actually getting things they need or want. Also, if they already received the same thing, it makes exchanging (for something equally or more useful) super easy. My cousin and I have even emailed each other our amazon.com wish lists :-) Actually, those wish lists are pretty cool - the items don't have to be from amazon, they can come from any website.
Sorry for not being clear. I don't think that registries are a bad thing, I am just advocating putting them to charitable use. Doing a a charity registry both makes the world a better place and prevents us from accumilating stuff we probably don't "need".
Registering for donations to charities is also a great plan if you don't want or need more things. There are so many non-profits out there that need support and can really remind people of the things that are dear to your hearts.
I really like the second idea you posted in the article. I like one of a kind, vintage things that cannot be bought a big box stores. I do also like things that can. But I think I'd have a mixture of the two ideas.
And I totally agree registries are not bad, or rude. You are showing people what you like, just because there a 500 dollar item on there doesn't mean you have to get. I'm sure there's a 10 dollar item on there they'd like just the same.
Most guests want to give gifts, and it's a gift to many people that you take the challenges of selecting a gift out of the process by putting together a registry. People want to give you something they know you want and will use and will keep for a while -- you and your fiance know how to answer that best!
On that note, my now hubby and I (we got married this summer) had a pretty well stocked kitchen before creating a registry. But we decided to register for nice things that would either fill a need in our kitchen or replace our ratty hand-me-downs and other things that were falling apart. And wouldn't you know, the nicer kitchen stuff has enticed us to cook way more than we every did before.
@blackstar The charitable registry is a great idea, but I'd balance it with at least a small gift registry. Some people genuinely want to celebrate you and your marriage by giving you a gift -- gift giving is hard-wired into some people's brains as part of the celebration. Whenever friends of mine have a charity registry, I'll donate to one of their chosen charities and still buy at least a small gift for them.
I would always want to give some kind of gift to celebrate a wedding and from the guests point of view, it's great to have a guide so you know that you're buying something the couple will find useful. I'll sometimes go "off-list" for something that is meaningful in my relationship with the couple but only when I'm confident that I understand their tastes and needs.
The one thing that drives me crazy is when people register for the "expected" stuff just because that's the thing to do (I'd have to say that's more of an American phenomenon than a British). I was at a bridal shower earlier this year where the couple had registered for, and received, stacks of baking tins, pans and appliances. Neither of them cook and they pretty much just eat take-out pizza nearly every night.
I love the Amazon registry. My spouse and I are both pretty practical people and would feel weird having tons of houseware stuff that's too upscale for our tastes and not the kinds of things we actually use.
We did an Amazon registry and put the sorts of practical things we would like to have but hadn't yet been able to afford; a light fixture for the room that still had hanging wires, some art/decor pieces, a few hiking/camping items, some books and CD and things, etc. We did make ourselves a rule that we would at least pick interesting practical stuff and not list some of the boring things we wanted like white switchplates, because having being somewhat interesting is kind of the point of gifts, right? Sure, we got a light fixture for our wedding, but it's a cool one, and people often compliment us on it, and then we can tell them it was a wedding present from my coworkers.
We didn't register for appliances or anything because we know few people with that kind of cash and it would just feel weird and entitled to us. I don't think there was anything on our list over $100, and most were quite a bit less. We did have a few people who bought us an expensive assortment of several of our items, which was a nice and very generous surprise.
(Oh, and along the lines of the practical wedding gifts, I've had many friends, usually who were younger folks, who registered for everything their house needs, including a toilet brush and/or plunger. I've had great fun buying these items and sending along a funny message about how you'll always think of us fondly when you clean your toilet. In one case a friend won a bet with a spouse who insisted that no one was going to buy them a toilet plunger for a wedding gift.)
My daughter has been in and attended multiple showers and weddings this past year. Yet, when she bought her first condo, not one of the married couples brought a housewarming gift, but the ALL of the single women did.
She didn't expect housewarming gifts, but just because you're not getting married doesn't mean you couldn't use a couple of nice wine glasses....
I gave (2!) shower gifts, a generous wedding gift, and a housewarming gift to a couple who broke up after 13 months.
Sorry for the rant.
When we get married, we'll probably use something like myregistry.com or make our own list like the British couple from the article. We love vintage stuff, but the boy has an insatiable need for tools (which he really does use) and I have an incomplete collection of blue and white currier & ives china I'd love to flesh out. Plus, Etsy is my friend!
I like registries as long as the couple keeps it tasteful. I was put off when I opened an invite for an upcoming wedding and three store registry cards fell out of the envelope before I could read the invitation. The couple registered for so much stuff (that I know they wouldn't buy for themselves or anyone else) it was obnoxious. Meanwhile, the wedding is on a Friday at 3 pm at a budget place... Just keep it classy whatever you do.
You can always just put 'no gifts, please,' on the invitation - why is it that so many people are so unwilling to break with stupid traditions? How many of you women are taking your spouse's last name? How many of you are getting wedding rings (and how many of the men are?) I swear! If you're a grown-up and you've been living on your own, asking for wedding gifts is just greedy. It's not about the gifts, it's about the pledge. Nothing more, no matter what 'people' think. Why are people so da--ed conservative in this country?
Texaninexile - It isn't a matter of being "stupid" or "conservative". Did anyone mention changing names or what they are doing for wedding rings? Not sure what provoked your comment, but really, there is no need for drama here on a home blog about products and design.
Whether a birthday, housewarming, marriage, etc, I'm always glad to give a gift to a loved one. And I'm grateful for some kind of guideline when there is a registry. I felt strange about registering at first, but really, there is nothing controversial about this.
I like the the communality of registries - it's nice to know that, although I could never afford to give the couple an entire set of, for instance, their desired flatware, the single place-setting I can afford will combine with other place-settings from other guests to help the couple get to the full set.
It's kind of like a Christmas list: people are going to want to give you stuff, and this is your chance to help them get you the stuff you really want. A well-written list can really help everyone. As for poorly written or selfishly greedy registry lists - well, toasters are available in almost any price range.
@Texaninexile, Couples are free to choose from the mentioned, and other, wedding registries options according to what is pleasing and meaningful to them. You're free to choose whether to participate in others' registries. I agree that this country is too conservative in some areas, but don't see wedding registries as a problem. OT, if you really want people to rethink their choices, then angry insults only backfire. Try making your own life so good they'll want to copy in hopes of becoming happier.
Many sources I read while planning a wedding last year said any mention of gifts in the invitation was rude. My now-husband was opposed to a registry because he felt it was tacky, and I was half-excited and half-apathetic about one. Excited because it's common practice and the only accepted time you get to ask for gifts, but apathetic because having once been the struggling, single girl when everyone else seemed to be getting married, I used to (and still empathize with anyone who may) think, "geez, I'm spending all kinds of money on the shower, the dress, the transportation, the hotel room, and whatever else, and I'm still expected to buy a gift off this expensive-@$$ list??" Initially I wanted to ask our guests to share a funny or meaningful story about us at our wedding in lieu of a gift, but I eventually learned (at the Christmas before our wedding) that it makes some people uncomfortable to *not* give a gift, and they may give you something really weird if they don't know what you want!
So we decided on a modest registry at Target because it would accommodate most budgets, and did not mention it in the invitation. We only told guests if they inquired, and most guests are polite enough to inquire. We also registered at a china replacement service for missing pieces from my and my fiance's grandmothers' collections, which had been passed on to us (and just happen to complement each other perfectly!). I thought it would be a nice way to have our grandparents present in spirit with us at holiday dinners to come. Even though the crystal and silver pieces were pricey, it went over well with the guests because the intent was to honor family (the whole point of a wedding), not to capitalize on feelings of obligation to give a gift. I think this approach worked because of the high-low range, with the "high" items actually being personally meaningful, not just expensive for the sake of being expensive. We got a few random gifts we didn't know what to do with, but it was worth it to avoid seeming presumptive by putting tacky registration cards in an invitation.
@blackstar BTW, I agree with your thoughts about charities, but I also have to point out that aside from having grandmas at holiday dinners like I mentioned above, I think about the friends who gave us our little hand-held vacuum whenever I use it, when we BBQ we always think about my husband's dad, and a girlfriend subtly crosses my mind every day while I brush my teeth and see the little pottery piece she made that is hanging on the wall. It's kind of nice to have little reminders of people I care about injected into random points of the day, which I wouldn't get if they had donated to charity.
I've been the bride and the guest and am approaching an age when I'll be the mother at the event. This is easy. Do a registry (whatever kind you like) but SEND THANK YOU NOTES. Guests love giving you the gifts, they really do, but they love it because they want to delight you. Let them know they did, and there's not a shred of tacky/weird/awkward/rude in the bargain.
I attended a wedding recently. The couple had registered at myregistry.com and asked for 13 things. The #1 item asked for was money for a honeymoon. Even though they are young and not established at all. Not only that--the groom sent an email to all respondents of the email RSVP stating if you did not feel comfortable using paypal you were welcome to make a "donation" when arriving for the ceremony. I have been married almost 30 years, so am I just old-fashioned?? Or is this over-the-top tacky?
whitexb, honeymoon registries are becoming more and more common. A lot of people wouldn't find it problematic at all. I imagine the groom was *trying* to be helpful (giving the benefit of the doubt here!) but yeah, the email is super tacky to me.
No, I think Texaninexile has a point; there are an awful lot of assumptions on this blog about gender roles and the "normal" way to do lifecycle events. NONE of that belongs on a decorating blog.