NY Good Questions: Which Credenza Should I Keep?

NY Good Questions: Which Credenza Should I Keep?

4869fde91c29cc6f3cf9d7f4f31c7a27ab180469?w=240&h=240&fit=crop
Maxwell Ryan
Feb 28, 2008

Hello AT,

Due to an unusual series of events, I've recently found myself in the company of three lovely credenzas.
Actually, I suppose they're dressers, but I am re-purposing them as credenzas.

Specifically, and the reason why I'm here, is that I plan on re-purposing *one* of them as a credenza for the dining room in my small rowhome, but I'm not sure which one.

I've set each of them up, snapped photos, asked people's opinions and considered each piece's pros and cons.

And what do I have to show for all this effort? Confusion and doubt.

At this point, I'm at credenza saturation and I kind of just feel like selling all three of them.

Or keeping all three of them.

I know you AT-ers aren't lacking in the opinion department, so tell me: What do *you* think? Which one is your favorite? Do your fresh eyes see something that I'm missing?

Each of them are all-wood construction with dovetailed drawer boxes and are in good shape.

Thanks! Mikaela

(Note: Include a pic of your problem and your question gets posted first.)
Created with Sketch.