apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


House Tour: London - A North London Sanctuary

jb.jpg

Architect's Name: Jennifer Beningfield
Location: London, UK
Size: 600 sq ft
Renovation completed: Fall 2007

Enter Slideshow

2-23-housetourlogo.jpg"Very calm and relaxing -- that was the brief," says London-based South African architect Jennifer Beningfield of Open Studio Architects in London, the genius behind London Urchin's Jewelry Box, the winner of the 2007 Smallest Coolest contest and this North London sanctuary...

jb2.jpg

Enter Slideshow

Jennifer's Openstudio Architects works on both public and private spaces. For this North London pied-à-terre, she gutted a wrecked Edwardian flat, turning what was a dark space into a clean-lined, bright one-bedroom apartment with seamless built-in storage, a massive custom-designed European oak kitchen in the convivial main space, and absolutely no clutter. The floors were also replaced with oak in a different cut to add interest and maintain harmony. The baseboards were removed and the ceiling moldings stripped, but the original fireplace was left in place, which the clients topped with a straight-edged mirror.

jb3.jpg

Jennifer helped the clients pick out Norman Foster sofas, an Arne Jacobsen table, and Artemide lamps throughout. She says that in both the design and the furnishings, she encouraged them to use "just a few materials, and basically all one color" in order to make the flat seem bigger than it is. The bathroom was designed with the same idea in mind, with French porcelain tiles in beige covering the entire surface and a large luxurious shower making up for the lack of a tub. And the bedroom is a study in pared-down comfort, with beige linens, soft sculptural bulb lighting and a built-in closet to hide clutter.

"The clients didn't want any ceiling lights or any bulbs showing," says Jennifer, adding that it was a challenge to light the north-facing flat, which gets no direct sunlight but feels bright and cheerful, even on a drizzly London afternoon. They decided to dress the massive windows in translucent shades. And they added soundproofing to increase the feeling of calm (many London apartment-dwellers suffer the stomping feet and other abrasive sounds of their neighbors in buildings without sufficient insulation). But you could still hear the birds chirping outside. "It's really a sanctuary," Jennifer says.

Enter Slideshow

- Kristin Hohenadel blogging from rue Vieille du Temple, Paris, France. If you have an idea for a European house tour, please write kristinh @ apartmenttherapy . com

Comments (46)

ERROR: unable to load page

Getting the above

posted by AT4H on 2008-03-17 16:40:42
view AT4H's profile

I know that monochromatic looks will make a space seem bigger then it is but that is just to blah for me.

N.

http://badhuman.wordpress.com

posted by http://badhuman.wordpress.com on 2008-03-17 16:50:32
view http://badhuman.wordpress.com's profile

I'm with badhuman.

Too sterile, yet still feels cluttered. :(

posted by Djluckyonline on 2008-03-17 16:53:45
view Djluckyonline's profile

Not loving this... looks like someone (without much style) just moved in. Agree with other posts, love minimal, this is blah.

posted by designerny on 2008-03-17 16:59:03
view designerny's profile

There is an error in the code above. You can access the slideshow here:
http://gallery.apartmenttherapy.com/photo/031708jenniferbeningfieldtour/_slide_/medium

posted by deneph on 2008-03-17 17:16:56
view deneph's profile

I do like the lights in the bedroom, though.

posted by Cassis on 2008-03-17 17:20:39
view Cassis's profile

is it illegal to hang art in london?

posted by andyh182 on 2008-03-17 17:21:39
view andyh182's profile

...although I guess they do prevent one from sitting up in bed.

Still. Pretty.

posted by Cassis on 2008-03-17 17:21:40
view Cassis's profile

AT4H - thats because its about 'minimalism'. The use of a single colored background and brief text is meant to make the error page look much larger than it really is. ;-D

Incidentally I'm getting the same message. :(

posted by Modfan on 2008-03-17 17:33:40
view Modfan's profile

When I saw London Urchin's flat I thought, Corr Blimey!

While this one has some similar elements it doesn't have the same effect for me. The kitchen wall setup with table and chairs reminds me of a judicial hearing room too much and the space seems a little cramped.

Some of the elements are gorgeous, like the kitchen unit and the orbs but as a whole the space is lacking something in my opinion.

I'm wondering if the furniture was part of the design process? If not, that may be why I'm not fully appreciating it. You know what (I'm thinking as I write this) I think if the furniture was different I would have been immediately overwhelmed.

posted by art on 2008-03-17 17:33:59
view art's profile

O.k. I can't shut up yet.

The mirror seems awkward.

I think this place was designed in a John Pawson minimalistic way.

Everything that needs to be is there while stuff that doesn't need to be should be taken out and/or replaced.

posted by art on 2008-03-17 17:39:16
view art's profile

deneph's link will get you there! thanks for that!

posted by art on 2008-03-17 17:41:04
view art's profile

Link should be fixed now...

posted by Kristin Hohenadel on 2008-03-17 17:46:23
view Kristin Hohenadel's profile

Oh dear, I have absolutely no sense of any personality from the people who live there. In fact, it just looks like no one has moved in yet. Why so stark and unfriendly?

posted by saskia on 2008-03-17 17:56:41
view saskia's profile

I love the kitchen, but on the whole seems a bit cold and not lived in.

posted by ms on b on 2008-03-17 17:58:18
view ms on b's profile

this looks like really fancy furnished corporate housing...that hasn't been rented in years...

posted by boomtown! on 2008-03-17 18:15:37
view boomtown!'s profile

Well, then, I guess we all agree. I'd like to go in there and splash some screaming scarlet paint on everything.

Is "screaming scarlet" a color?

posted by viola on 2008-03-17 19:12:36
view viola's profile

Gorgeous.

I'd like to see a bit more personality of the owners/tenants, and I don't quite understand twin beds in a one-bedroom apartment (for a couple? sleeping in the same room but separately?)...

All the same, it's an elegant and calm space. I'd love to move in (and add just a bit of art and colour).

posted by arza on 2008-03-17 19:27:05
view arza's profile

It seems very cold and unwelcoming; almost like someone just brought their furniture to a new place, and left their personality in storage. I could never live in a place like that.

posted by Melissa82 on 2008-03-17 19:28:31
view Melissa82's profile

I know this minimalism is meant to be calming but this looks like a budget motel. Snore.

posted by HFG on 2008-03-17 19:41:06
view HFG's profile

Overall, I like this one. I certainly see a Pawson/ Anouska Hempel influence. My only suggestion would be to go a tad more minimalist/monochrome (the dining room and chairs seem a bit off , as does the bowl in front of the mirror) or to go a tad softer (say, a gauzy sheer ripplefold curtain wall over the living room windows). When it comes to minimalism, every little detail matters. As it stands, the furnishing send some mixed messages and dilute the impact of an otherwise strong effort.

posted by RichardinLA on 2008-03-17 19:58:06
view RichardinLA's profile

The dining area reminds me of a conference room, and the sitting area feels to me like a waiting room in a standard office building.... not quite feeling like a "sanctuary" to me.

posted by saudoso on 2008-03-17 20:30:29
view saudoso's profile

is that a glob of toothpaste next to the brush? is so someone has justed ruined the minimalist scheme!

posted by anaguy on 2008-03-17 22:09:21
view anaguy's profile

I actually found it quite refreshing. It's like a warmer John Pawson.

posted by charlenemcbride on 2008-03-17 22:29:40
view charlenemcbride's profile

Carpers on this web site might (will) disagree, but minimalism as a design ethic need not appear as sterile as it does in this apartment. Free your imagination if you can stand it for just a moment, however, and consider the possibilities of this space as it immediately foregrounds the people who live there and their friends. At a party for example, the people who attend actually become the objects of interest and not another thing you've bought. Imagine that! The problem here, what art has identified as the "lacking something" in the space might be people.

Whether or not the owners intend for their space to function in this way who knows, but let's consider the space as it looks and see what we can do with it, 'eh?

posted by davidasposted on 2008-03-17 22:34:06
view davidasposted's profile

I am a minimalist junkie, but the problem with it is that you have to severely edit *everything*. Nothing can be casually left about like the tray and newspaper/book and random bowl. This place needs some colorful art to distract from the detritus of real life.

posted by alinia on 2008-03-17 23:19:08
view alinia's profile

Cold, uncomfortable and zero personality. It reminds me of a doctor's waiting area, but with less charm.

The lights over the bed are seriously annoying; how many heads have been whacked on them so far?

Rugs, artwork, even flowers or plants would be a big help here. Dull, dull, dull.

posted by Sydney on 2008-03-17 23:19:17
view Sydney's profile

Oh, but I love the shot of the bed. Makes me want to snuggle down with those pillows.

posted by alinia on 2008-03-17 23:19:49
view alinia's profile

needs art and color. but the bedroom is cozy. but if it's for kids, (twin beds) then they need some things of interest . i don't like clutter but what's the point of being in a waiting room and having the few things you like hidden away. my friend's home is so comfy and cozy, beautiful and cheerful and they have worn floors and paintings of hockey players on their walls! and it works!

posted by Joan in SB on 2008-03-18 01:11:09
view Joan in SB's profile

Davidasposted: I agree. But that's also true of padded cells.

posted by viola on 2008-03-18 02:38:18
view viola's profile

The idea of this as a sanctuary is what throws me entirely -- the coldness puts me on edge and I find the sitting room really confrontational with how you would have to sit straight on to your guests -- though I love that they don't appear to have a TV in there. Or they may have hidden it somewhere we don't see, since they have teabags in the cupboard but no kettle on the counter. When you move in Britain, the kettle is usually the last thing packed and the first thing plugged in at the new place. :)

I don't think I like the orb lights in the hall (the scale bothers me, much like the mirror bowl issue) and the separate bed thing is confusing (the London housing market is ridiculous, but if you can afford to have all this done, it seems you could afford another bedroom) but if the orb lights in the bedroom are on a timer/dimmer to come on in the morning, that would be brilliant.

And no, there's no city-wide ordinance against hanging art here! ;-)

posted by shimelle on 2008-03-18 04:16:51
view shimelle's profile

I like minimalism, but somehow, this doesn't quite work for me... I think it is the Hempel touches that do it; that and the Mart Stam-like chairs (are they Mart Stam but with curved arms?) that I complained about on a different thread -- we owned some at dining chairs for over a decade (actually, over 15 years I now realize) and they were miserably uncomfortable as dining chairs (great side chairs in an office though).

Also, I do not get the sense of perfect repose in this space that I do in a truly minimalist space -- I think that the volumes are off -- i.e., to me, it feels as if the ceilings should be higher to pull off such a look. (plus, the bedroom just feels weird to me).

If you are going to be minimalist, the few things you choose should be supremely comfortable and satisfying.

LondonUrchin's space was so much more successful -- the use of bold colour and texture -- for example, the Hans wegner dining table and chairs, contrasting the period feel of the space, etc.

posted by monika1 on 2008-03-18 04:47:52
view monika1's profile

London or Dullsville? I trust AT to vet these things and this was waaaaaaaaaaay below your standards. For shame.

posted by ChrisToronto on 2008-03-18 09:21:30
view ChrisToronto's profile

so glad you all feel as i do. i was wary of opening the comments and seeing lots of, 'ooh, love it!'

my remark is, wouldn't at least one houseplant be a welcome addition here?

no houseplants here just emphasizes the lack of feeling of life in the place.

posted by *heather leaf* on 2008-03-18 09:40:19
view *heather leaf*'s profile

So funny--my immediate reaction on seeing the first photo was "it's as if London Urchin designed a corporate conference room." I fell head over heels for L.U.'s own pad but this one doesn't do it for me at all.

posted by beamish on 2008-03-18 10:32:27
view beamish's profile

Feels more like a board room at Wernham Hogg than a sanctuary. It also feels like this reno fights the original character of the place instead of working with, or complementing it.

posted by sparklish on 2008-03-18 11:19:43
view sparklish's profile

I'm a minimalist but this place looks unfinished, especially the livingroom. I don't like where the fireplace is situated and I don't like where the kitchen is situated in relation to the fireplace. This is not so great for my tastes. But if the owners lovet, so be it.

posted by orangejuce on 2008-03-18 14:16:27
view orangejuce's profile

i think it looks gorgeous, i especially love the lights.
though it does look a bit unfinished. it needs some sort of color or art on the walls!

posted by terka27 on 2008-03-18 17:33:03
view terka27's profile

Point taken, viola!

posted by davidasposted on 2008-03-18 18:35:15
view davidasposted's profile

I feel depressed now...

posted by mille100piedi on 2008-03-19 13:04:47
view mille100piedi's profile

It's John Pawson, but much cheaper looking.

posted by bunny on 2008-03-20 12:49:29
view bunny's profile

...and it's a shame, since I was so ready to like it.

posted by bunny on 2008-03-20 12:50:36
view bunny's profile

I really like the way the kitchen was composed--the large oak block incorporating many functions (including hiding dirty dishes). It does seem as though it's very architect-sanctioned styling/decor, which often tends to be very severe and monochrome. Perhaps the clients are not quite in the space yet?
Or afraid of changing anything that the architect dictated? For example, our architect had some decided ideas about colors (or rather, non-colors of gray and black) that we rejected, not wanting to live in a prisonlike environment. Architects make great bones for spaces, but they often seem afraid of color and 'decoration', as if it is too frivolous.

posted by karyn on 2008-03-20 13:47:32
view karyn's profile

I think this is beautiful. It's like a very imaginative hotel suite. It's not how I would arrange my own space, but it's very beautiful and confident. Would love to spend a couple weeks there while vacationing.

posted by lolax on 2008-03-28 02:15:36
view lolax's profile

No matter what the 'look' I think the space should be inviting and comfortable.
This simply isn't.
None of the rooms are.
Inventory what you have and decide what changes need to be made to make it work.
The schizophrenic kitchen aside, it doesn't really need drastic changes.
But art, and revisiting the lighting schemes, for starters will go a long way.

posted by paulmuscat on 2008-04-03 00:55:10
view paulmuscat's profile

L.O.V.E. the lights in the bedroom! Who makes them? Where did you get them? How are they installed?

Can anyone tell me how to recreate this in my own home? Where can I get similar wall-hung orbs in various sizes?
I live in NYC and need something cheap.

Thanks!

posted by thebear on 2008-06-28 21:12:51
view thebear's profile
Buy Text Ads