apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Semolina, Broadway Lights, Suntan Yellow, Wheatfield: The Color Odyssey

2005_1_19_colorpaint (2).jpg2005_1_19_colorpaint (3).jpg

Patience. Color is a fickle mistress. When we started painting this bedroom above with Semolina last week, we thought we had nailed a beautiful color, but the odd light in the room made it far harder than expected.

2005_1_20_colormag.jpg

We were trying to match the photograph above.

Semolina was great, but had way too much orange in it.

 
 

Near the windows, it was lovely, but down the hallway, under electric light, it turned bright orange (top pic).

2005_1_19_colorpaint (10).jpg2005_1_19_colorpaint (12).jpg

Next up, we tested Broadway Lights 298 (classic deck) and Suntan Yellow 2155-50. The Broadway had green in it, which we thought might make it better, but it didn't. We repainted the room with the Suntan Yellow (above). This was a shade lighter, but it still had the orange in it that freaked out under the electric light.

Copy of 20005_1_20_colorpaint (5).jpgCopy of 20005_1_20_colorpaint (7).jpg

Finally, Wheatfield 2159-50. On the third repainting of the whole room (a total of 6 coats) everything settled down nicely (above). Wheatfield looks like a straight beige, but in this odd mix of natural and electic light it is much more yellow and warm.

The lesson? Be patient, paint as much of the wall as you can to test and watch it in all lights before deciding. (Thanks, Mark for all the painting!) MGR

Tags

Color Chips

Related Links

Share

Comments (22)

I did the same thing -- painted my bedroom with Kelly Moore's Sourdough, which looked beigy-yellow but ended up looking way too French's mustard yellow in the walls. Finally found Benjamin Moore's Yosemite Sand, a warm, antiquey-looking comforting beige with yellow tones, much like what you ended up with in the picture.

posted by Jen on 2005-01-21 13:00:09

I did the same thing -- painted my bedroom with Kelly Moore's Sourdough, which looked beigy-yellow but ended up looking way too French's mustard sunny yellow on the walls. Finally found Benjamin Moore's Yosemite Sand, a warm, antiquey-looking comforting beige with yellow tones, much like what you ended up with in the picture.

posted by Jen on 2005-01-21 13:00:38

Benjamin Moore now sells little pots of paint - just enough for an 18" x 24" piece of foam core. This is great - just hang that foam core in your room, move it around and check it out at different times of the day before you settle on a color and start painting! I never specify a new paint color to a client before doing this test - it never fails!

posted by seema on 2005-01-21 14:29:46

I painted my sunny apartment lemon ice by Benjamin Moore. During the day against the white trim is very, very light indiscernible yellow. In the evening under incandescent light it turns to a warm lovely ocher. I love it. Always bring samples of the colors home and see what happens to them through out the day and night. Sometimes one could surprise oneself with the possibilities.

I once wrapped my room in red velvet flocked paper. Light would bounce around and give every thing a rose colored glow.

posted by evamn on 2005-01-21 14:30:47

I had used the Benjamin Moore little pot of paint for my bedroom, and that helped. Wish I had done that with the living room too.
I had painted my living room two different shades of yellow on different walls. On the swatches they looked very different. One looked like notepad yellow and was awful, I went over it with a million coats of white.
The one shade of yellow that remains, looks completely different at night, in the day and with certain types of light. Definitely thinking of getting those GE Reveal light bulbs.

posted by MRoman on 2005-01-21 15:28:38

i just painted with Behr's "Kansas Grain" and LOVE it! it's a warm creamy-yellow with a slightly peach cast (but not too overpowering). sunshine in a can!

posted by andrea on 2005-01-22 00:58:59

The GE Reveal light bulbs are great. They make a really a room look great!

posted by Bill on 2005-01-21 17:39:48

well, if this didn't scare me off from painting...

posted by chzplz on 2005-01-22 07:11:35

My sister moved back into her condo and we bought $60 worth of Benjamin Moore paint pots to figure out what to paint the walls. The first time she had painted when she bought it, some of the colors ended up being pretty far from what she wanted. It was eye-opening. Colors that she really wanted looked terrible on the wall and colors looked completely different from one room to another. A lilac which looked pretty on the wall in her bedroom just looked like a washed out white in her spare bedroom. She ended up going with yellow and green in both bedrooms, a combination we never imagined she would use. I would definitely recommend buying a small amount of paint first. Since Benj. Moore only puts a selection of their colors in those little pots, I wonder if those colors are selling substantially more since the pots came out. Any thoughts?

posted by Ruth on 2005-01-24 11:57:17

I love those Reveal bulbs but they break at the slightest touch. My boyfriend slightly tipped a lamp last night an the brand new bulb (last Monday) died. On a related note, he tipped the lamp because the room was in chaos as I was repainting a wall. I love the Glidden Pale Shadow, it's a white with a tinge of pink that changes in the light. Landlords and supers see white so no need to repaints, I see glowing walls that make me and everything in my apartment look soft and just better.

Anyway, I'd run out of paint the first go around on this wall and when I bought more it didn't match exactly so I had to repaint that whole wall. Lesson learned, buy extra paint and mix the cans in a 5 gallon bucket like the pros do.

posted by Alison on 2005-01-24 13:34:07

You folks ever hear of white? In smallish NYC apartments, white is the only way to go. I tried colors once upon a time--felt like I was living in a box of confetti.

posted by Todd on 2005-01-23 07:47:34

It sounds like you're less scared of color than you are of messing it up again. Color can be really overpowering if you don't know how to use it, but it can also make an apartment warm and cosy and inviting. Sometimes you can definitely mess up, but it's also fun to experiment and try to get the perfect balance of colors and textures. My apartment is tiny too, but it also has a big dose of clear, bright color so I feel energised and happy throughout my day, even if there's no sunlight.

I hate dull white apartments. I used to live in one with my ex-boyfriend, who wouldn't let me decorate. To me the place wasn't white, it was three-tenants-ago white with scuff marks everywhere. It was a non-choice -- he'd abdicated control over this particular part of his life to whatever was easiest to do and whatever hand-me-downs he could scrounge from relatives.

posted by mary on 2005-01-23 11:09:40

Color can be tricky and nowhere more so than in NYC
where the light is so grey. But all the more reason why
its important to get it right and rewarding when you do.
I think the Benjamin Moore pots help a lot and also realizing that even white is not just white. There are an
infinite variety of whites. For instance I painted all the
ceilings in my apartment with Ralph Lauren Picket Fence Semi-Gloss to bring sheen and light through the
rooms. The walls are RL Nigerian Peony(bedrooms &study) and Benjamin Moore Linen White (very warm and yellowy)in public rooms. Color is fun.

posted by Janet on 2005-01-23 12:09:10

Todd again. I'm not categorically against color. My pad is white on white on white, and I LOVE it. Especially the white gloss floors. Sparkle, sparkle. Plants and art provide the only color. BUT a few years ago when I was looking for an apartment I saw a place with an all-pink bathroom. A very pale pink--think that inner pink of a conch shell. I looked so good in that mirror I decided to always have a pink bathroom. My bathroom is pink. Pale pink--everything except the toilet. I couldn't find a pink toilet. I tried. I'm a straight man with a pink bathroom and I'm proud of it. Girlfriends love it.

posted by Todd on 2005-01-24 18:31:27

A trick I just got hip to (which helped me tons) is to "mix down" a color that I like. Perviously, I felt I was tied to the swatches available, i.e., if the color I liked was too intense, I should just go with the neighboring swatch. In most cases, this is not just a diluted version of the neighbor, but a different hue entierly. So, if you feel like you have the color you want, but it's just a bit too intense, have the paint store "mix it down" to 75% or 50% and see how that works!

posted by Graham on 2005-04-24 04:31:20

I am moving into a small home in FL and would like to go with the nautical colors of yellow, white and navy. I want to paint the walls yellow through the entire home. I have been sampling some yellows, such as Hawthorne yellow, hay stack, and squish-squash, they are too bright. I want a soft yellow that won't jump out at me.
Please help me.
Thanks
Tina

posted by Tina on 2005-05-16 10:06:52

I need help to ideas to paint my apparment. we will move to NY and our appartment is so smal. which colors are perfet?
we were thinking light yellow for the walls and the door franes in white, what do you think?
thanks for your answer. cyndy

posted by cyndy on 2005-07-04 17:30:18

I need to paint my two floor house; my husband likes a warm yellow ocher, which one you will recomend me from glidden paint and also the trim and the ceiling color under the roof?
thanks you very much for your prompt answer, dalis

posted by dalis on 2005-08-03 17:01:14

Is there a month for paint colors and peer suggestions? That would be cool. I'm sure a lot people needs help. You think small NYC apartments are difficult? At least most of them have high ceilings and big windows. My tiny 9'x9' bedroom in a long island house is even worse, small room + small window + dark brown wood paneling from the 50s = totally dark prison. I need to choose a paint color that works...need help...

posted by mimi on 2006-04-11 11:23:07

i usually paint small rooms benjamin moore linen white and all wood trim high gloss white, this color combination looks very clean and it looks great in any room or lighting. i lived in nyc apartment for 8 years and had white walls entire time. white walls made the place look harsh and old. a light tint of yellow can lift your spirits and makes a room to look sunny even on cold winter day.

posted by asya on 2006-07-23 15:26:08

Hi. I have a question about paint color... Anyone there to reply>???
Kathleen

posted by daly on November 2nd 2007 at 3:30pm
view daly's profile

yes

posted by nowstarter on April 15th 2008 at 4:22pm
view nowstarter's profile

Feeds

RSS icon New York

+ City Feeds