apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


I Cook! Kitchen Smackdown!

This was really tough. Finding the top entries was easy for our panel of French Chefs, but the middle was crowded, and they hated cutting so many people who were really close.

All of the kitchens had character, good ideas and most of all LOVE put into them, but the finalists separated themselves by not only being inspiring to cook in, but by showing off some sharp design. Modern was the style of the day, despite some absolutely lovely traditional kitchens.

SMACKDOWN TIME:
Voting begins now and ends at 1pm tomorrow - Lunchtime.

Vote for one (click through to see more of each), comment if you wish, and remember that everyone wins something (even the ones that didn't make the final cut), while the winner and runner-up get something more special... MGR

2005_3_23_john.JPG


Tags

Competitions

Related Links

Share

Comments (26)

first vote!...angela's orange won me over =)

posted by Miya on 2005-03-23 13:32:08

They are all nice kitchens but John's is the one that I would want to spend my time cooking in. Nice job.

posted by John Schneider on 2005-03-23 13:35:24

Hard choice. My vote is for John and runner-up would be Anita. John's is an amazing design, especially because in seeing the before pictures, I would have thought, Great kitchen! The fact that he had the vision to improve it and do it so well, means a lot. On the other hand, I really love Anita's design, especially with a smaller space. It really seems to make the most of it, being nice looking and functional at the same time. Kudos to everyone who put their kitchens up for comments. Brave folks.

posted by michele on 2005-03-23 14:11:19

I don't know why but I like Aida's the best. Go go go!

posted by sara a. on 2005-03-23 16:43:50

All beautiful but aida's gotta be it, because of the clock moon in the blackboard sky. I also really liked some of the old-fashioned kitchens (how soon we forget everyone's names but particularly the one with the sink in the separate room--a beautiful kitchen).

posted by martha on 2005-03-23 17:30:01

For me it came down to a battle between Aida's and John's. Though love Angela's bright orange making for a cheery kitchen, but don't agree on best overall. Aida's got some clever storage design. Ultimately I voted for John's for it's beautiful, clean, open and cheery look and layout. And yeah I still envy JP's space. This was a tough competition.

posted by jimkk on 2005-03-23 17:58:24

Only one has apple tiles!

posted by ryan on 2005-03-23 18:05:16

It's interesting to me that the kitchens overall are way better than the bedrooms. It'll be interesting to see the entries for the apartment competition.

posted by charlene on 2005-03-23 19:09:20

Great functionality and spark in Anita's kitchen. Nice bright color accents, and lots of work space fro such a small kitchen. Pull-out shelves - brilliant!

posted by dorio on 2005-03-23 21:40:39

Great functionality and spark in Anita's kitchen. Nice bright color accents, and lots of work space for such a small kitchen. Pull-out shelves - brilliant!

posted by dorio on 2005-03-23 21:41:24

Did we find out the name of the orange that Angela used?

posted by me on 2005-03-23 22:32:27

nice work, anita

posted by William Hsien on 2005-03-23 23:52:44

I love Angela's and Aida's and I think there are some other really, really nice ones, but I absolutely DESPISE one of the kitchens, so I can't name more favorites for fear of incriminating myself!

posted by Fiona on 2005-03-24 00:44:01

Aida's is a grat example of efficiently and attractively used space. i also love the clean and no frills look of it.

posted by temucino on 2005-03-24 09:42:58

Interesting red apple tiles and stainless steel all around is the bomb!

posted by Calyx on 2005-03-24 09:44:45

You never forget your first love
*sigh*

posted by jamie pup on 2005-03-24 09:51:47

It is apparent that all kitchens listed above are designed with passion. However, I feel that anita’s kitchen outweighs others by bringing a sense of intimacy and playfulness into the kitchen through colors and tactility. By drawings a contrast between the smooth surface of the countertop and the rough texture of the tiles above, anita’s kitchen sophistically integrates the industrial and the traditional aspects of modern kitchen

posted by jane on 2005-03-24 12:33:27

go nita

posted by may on 2005-03-24 12:50:18

...then there's the emotional reaction to a space, which will vary from person to person. My absolute favorite kitchen did not make the final cut, but of the kitchens that did, I'd be happiest in Angela's. (Wanna have me over?) Though maybe I'd like to spin around a few times in JP's magnificent space.

posted by Joan on 2005-03-24 12:52:11

one word "HOT"~!!

posted by C W² on 2005-03-24 13:28:32

John's vision and hardwork paid off!
Beautiful Kitchen.

posted by Luciene on 2005-03-25 13:19:25

Hey! When I click to see more pics of each kitchen, I get "File not found"!

Is this just me?

posted by aulaire on 2005-12-28 09:57:38

Loved, loved, loved the playfulness of Anita's Group Effort.

posted by Peach on 2005-12-28 11:22:22

Me too, aulaire. I've been getting File not found with almost all the older posts I was trying to view.

posted by Peach on 2005-12-28 11:23:38

A really hard choice, because John's kitchen has many things in common with our own reno (i.e., the glass-in-aluminum framed upper cabinets, the wood cabinets, the island). However, I LUST after JP's marble and love his sensuous use of lighting -- the 4 skylights overhead, the lightwell washing light down the sink and counter area. I think I have just talked myself in JP's; now if I could only figure out how to vote...

posted by Monika on 2005-12-28 16:31:20

Please visit our copper sinks website http://www.china-sinks.com, I am sure you will feel eye appealing.

[img]http://www.china-sinks.com/KST-4425A.jpg[/img]
[img]http://www.china-sinks.com/KSA-3322.jpg[/img]
[img]http://www.china-sinks.com/RCS-3-10.jpg[/img]
[img]http://www.china-sinks.com/RCS-3-03.jpg[/img]

Tomfan
Email: tomfan@xmgranitetiles.com

posted by Tomfan on 2006-01-01 15:33:07