apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Good Questions: Is This Chair Worth This Price?

9.18chair.jpgHello AT,

So I recently moved into my first studio and am slowly trying to fill it with stylish/ fun/ not-insanely-expensive things. I absolutely fell in love with this Ikea chair and I think it would work perfectly in my space. However, it seems a bit pricey to me, especially considering where it's from. $349 for an armchair from Ikea? Is that crazy? Or am I?

Thanks! Jennifer

(Note: Include a pic of your problem and your question gets posted first.
Email questions and pics with QUESTIONS in subject line to:
editor(at)apartmenttherapy(dot)com)
Link To All Good Questions

Anyone?

Tags

Good Questions

Related Links

Share

Comments (37)

You need to sit in the chair. I didn't think it was comfortable at all, and for $350, it seemed like a lot of money to spend at IKEA.

posted by SPHH on 2007-09-18 10:40:03
view SPHH's profile

What about this one that just got posted?
http://newyork.craigslist.org/brk/fur/424951369.html

posted by giggleuma on 2007-09-18 10:41:52
view giggleuma's profile

See how comfortable it is as Ikea stuff is very iffy in that aspect. It is only half the price of some really good chairs from places like Room & Board... I would probably get a cheaper chair or no chair at all and save up for good one. I wouldnt spend $350 at Ikea for a chair.

posted by jgee on 2007-09-18 10:47:43
view jgee's profile

I would also like to add that in my first apartment, I went out to Ikea and bought a bunch of stuff and I sat in the chairs I got just a few times in the 8 months I was there because they were so uncomfortable.

posted by jgee on 2007-09-18 10:49:13
view jgee's profile

Yeah-- it's crazy. Do a little scouring and some reupholstering; I scored a little sofa-type recliner (?), a midcentury number, from a yard sale for $5, then had it reupholstered for $350.

posted by sadia on 2007-09-18 10:52:00
view sadia's profile

I've sat in the chair at the Ikea showroom and it's quite comfortable. I'm in love with it too - but couldn't justify the price at the time. I have no idea how comfortable they'd be after a few months, I've found that some ikea stuff doesn't age well. Although, the more expensive stuff is usually better quality. As with anything you get what you pay for.

As a side note, it doesn't seem like this chair fits with Ikea's "flat pack" rules. Do you have to put it together?

posted by korijane on 2007-09-18 10:53:25
view korijane's profile

that chair is from the stockholm collection - ikea's "higher end" furniture. the frame is hardwood and the upholstery is finished well so the price reflects that. the quality is comparable to any chair in a similar price range and shouldn't necessarily send you running to crate and barrel.

posted by Cake on 2007-09-18 10:58:26
view Cake's profile

For $350, you can get Roche Bobois on CL, though this isn't quite your style.
http://newyork.craigslist.org/mnh/fur/422828640.html

$300 gets you another chair of better quality than IKEA:
http://newyork.craigslist.org/jsy/fur/423842745.html

Today's CL listings are very, very "Paris Apartment," but wait 10 minutes, and that'll change.

What IKEA is best for is cabinetry -- it's hard to do large amounts of shelving with specific dimensions by CLing or thrift store shopping. I wouldn't hurry to buy upholstered furniture there.

posted by wende in phoenix on 2007-09-18 10:58:38
view wende in phoenix's profile

This chair is part of IKEA's new Stockholm line. Their goal for this collection was better quality construction, therefore, the price is higher. I've heard good things on other home decor sites.

posted by Lisa from VA/lsaspacey on 2007-09-18 10:58:57
view Lisa from VA/lsaspacey's profile

Some people are not big fans of second-hand upholstery (myself included), and there is no guarantee any of that will still be comfortable in ten months time. And besides, as sadia points out, even a five dollar chair ends up being more than this once recovered.. not to mention the time invested to find and upholsterer, find the right fabric, etc.

And how, exactly, are y'all sitting on CL chairs to check for comfort before you buy?

Jennifer--
You used the phrases "works perfectly" and "love it" so I say go with it. Ignore the Ikea nervous nellie naysayers.

posted by patrick (the other one) on 2007-09-18 11:05:22
view patrick (the other one)'s profile

As others have said, the Stockholm collection is an upgrade in quality to match the price increase.

Sit in it. If you like it, get it. I don't believe that it being from IKEA makes it any less quality than similarly priced chairs at other outlets.

posted by shani-o on 2007-09-18 11:07:46
view shani-o's profile

I bought this chair shortly after the Stockholm line was introduced. The construction and upholstery are of a good quality. I find the chair comfortable and sometimes even move it in front of the television to play video games. The chair is used a fair amount and still looks like new. Overall, I am really pleased with it.

If I recall correctly, the upholstered part came as one piece and all we had to do was screw on the legs

posted by avere on 2007-09-18 11:09:16
view avere's profile

Hmm, not exactly sure how a $299 CL chair, not in your style, is any real bargain either.

Plus, when "regular" upholstered armchairs (new) are typically $500-$800 and up, this Ikea price looks better and better. Yeah, um, it may not last 100 years. But I daresay an $800 chair (new or used) will, either.

posted by patrick (the other one) on 2007-09-18 11:09:52
view patrick (the other one)'s profile

Having seen that chair in person at IKEA a few weeks ago, I have to say that the fabric is quite attractive in person. It really caught my eye in more than one room display.

The chair is relatively comfortable. I don't know that you would spend the whole night on it watching TV, but it doesn't seem as if that is the purpose of a chair of that style anyway.

As on "occasional chair" it will probably work just fine.

posted by Marie on 2007-09-18 11:12:43
view Marie's profile

If you live in a major coastal city (NY, San Fran, etc) be VERY vigilant about buying upholstered furniture on craigslist. There's a bedbug epidemic afoot, and some people aren't very scrupulous about destroying or throwing out infested items. This isn't to say you shouldn't go to CL for something like this, just ask pertinent questions before you make a decision. For instance, if they're getting rid of a lot of stuff, and they're not moving, then what's up with that? Was this kept in a bedroom? Try to find out as much as you possibly can about the item and the seller.

As for my chair opinion, I say if you love it for what it is, buy it. If you're just in a rush to furnish your space affordably, don't, because others are right, you can do a lot better for much cheaper by going secondhand.

posted by the opoponax on 2007-09-18 11:24:39
view the opoponax's profile

I didn't find it comfortable, and I'm a major IKEA fan. I do agree they're best at cabinetry and shelving and fabric. I've had to stop myself and focus on *slowly* getting B&B Italia through CL...screw-on legs won't last 20 years...but perhaps who cares? You love it! I bet you'll be happy.

posted by sfwriter on 2007-09-18 11:35:46
view sfwriter's profile

I didn't find it comfortable, either.

posted by Joan A. on 2007-09-18 11:38:20
view Joan A.'s profile

Oh what a bummer - now we have to worry about bedbugs in furniture?

posted by Pixie on 2007-09-18 11:45:15
view Pixie's profile

What about reupholstering companies - are they constantly spraying for bedbugs?

Kill me now!

posted by Pixie on 2007-09-18 11:49:49
view Pixie's profile

If you can find a HomeGoods near you, they have similar styled chairs for $200.

posted by priscilla on 2007-09-18 11:50:02
view priscilla's profile

So it would work perfectly, great.

Its a little pricey for IKEA, but its amongst the better quality items, so that justifys the price. I think that $350 for a chair like that its too expensive. I bet you could go somewhere else and spend more for something that isn't quite what you are looking for.

I say go for it. You will live with it for a long time, and if it would work great in your room, its not a waste of money.

posted by nightwind on 2007-09-18 11:55:15
view nightwind's profile

"I absolutely fell in love with this Ikea chair and I think it would work perfectly in my space."

First of all, forget that it's from IKEA.

Then:
1. Look at it in person if you haven't already.
2. Sit in it.
3. Examine the construction.

After doing these 3 things, do you still want the chair? If so, then it's worth the cost -- regardless of where it's from!

posted by Anna at D16 on 2007-09-18 13:01:11
view Anna at D16's profile

It's a great chair (I was at Ikea yesterday) and would buy it if I had a need for it. I noted that there were also slipcovers for it on sale, which had a very cool looking graphic drawing of a simple leaf on a black background (they also sell yardage with the same print on it).

posted by gathering browse on 2007-09-18 13:41:03
view gathering browse's profile

Anna - I completely agree with you. If you are in love with something saving a little is not going to please you - it will always be the second runner up chair. Save up for it and go for it!

posted by melissaw on 2007-09-18 13:46:02
view melissaw's profile

I couldn't bring myself to pay that much for an IKEA chair, but then I wasn't in love with it. I figured that if I were going to spend that much on a chair, I might as well broaden my search. As it was, I found 2 chairs on CL which I will be reupholstering. (And, yes, you do sit in them and look them over for damage BEFORE you decide to buy them--a good seller will always let you take a bit of time to inspect the merchandise. A bad seller, you walk away from.)

posted by harlie on 2007-09-18 13:46:46
view harlie's profile

i recently saw the chair was there. NOT worth the $$. Fabric doesn't look or feel "expensive" and if you're going to pay that much for a chair, it should...

posted by megm on 2007-09-18 14:09:52
view megm's profile

Pretty nice for the price, fabric quality is decent and suprisingly comfortable, as i don't really care for armless chairs. wide enough i could reach my arm over the back, pull one leg up to sit sideways to watch TV. i do have an armchair ,ottoman and sofa bought specifically high enough (first good furniture i ever bought) that i can rest my head back to read, knit, sit sideways (5"2', 120lbs). with armchair and sofa, i would consider as an extra occasional chair for a guest (and i get the big chair.) i've never bought upholstered items from Ikea, but if you love it get it and don't agonize over it. Consider your time searching craigslist or the odd thrift store, picking up the chair, purchasing fabric, finding a good upholsterer, lugging it to the shop, waiting for the work to be done, lugging it home.

posted by carolynapplebee on 2007-09-18 14:44:46
view carolynapplebee's profile

Don't buy it until you check it out in person, as others have rightly said. I saw it and sat in it. Yes it's a beautiful fabric, but it wasn't comfortable for me, so I wouldn't pay $5 for it. Maybe it would be comfortable for you - everybody's different. Good luck on finding the right chair!

posted by bean on 2007-09-18 15:14:39
view bean's profile

i thought it was pretty comfortable... and i love the three different slipcover patterns-- especially the black and white one!

posted by saya* on 2007-09-18 15:57:25
view saya*'s profile

just order one off target - they have such good deals!

posted by laurams10 on 2007-09-18 16:03:55
view laurams10's profile

You are paying for what you get, and I think that's a good thing. This is high-end for ikea, so the construction is better than their base models. It isn't as high-end as some other retailers, but you know that going in.

Friends and I sat in this a few weeks ago, and we actually remarked at how comfortable it was.

Good luck.

posted by brittanykate on 2007-09-18 16:55:25
view brittanykate's profile

I love that chair.
Good luck with the decision.
:)

posted by alisa k on 2007-09-18 17:22:52
view alisa k's profile

I agree with the person who said to be wary about buying upolstered furniture on Craig's List - because of bedbugs.
I wouldn't buy any used furniture anymore.

AAs for the IKEA chair, I think it is pricey for IKEA. And you can get a similar chair, in your chioce of fabric, at Lazyboy, for not much more.

posted by GothamTomato on 2007-09-18 17:51:01
view GothamTomato's profile

Wasn't there just a post the other day about chairs that are a very similar style? There were some Target chairs in a kind of funky fabric for $200 or so. I haven't personally sat on the Ikea chair, but I do think that's a little pricey for Ikea. Still, if you like it, maybe you should go for it! I know all too well the feeling of falling in love with a piece of furniture, and no amount of convincing can sway you otherwise sometimes. :)

posted by Jen on 2007-09-18 19:11:24
view Jen's profile

if i'm not mistaken, ikea has a great return policy, worst-case. which i would imagine applies to all items. just keep the wrapping, even it's only a slip of paper slipped into crevice. ;)

posted by moonbeam on 2007-09-18 23:26:53
view moonbeam's profile

Has anyone actually heard of bedbugs appearing in used furniture?

posted by Pixie on 2007-09-19 07:19:40
view Pixie's profile

or any furniture?

posted by Pixie on 2007-09-19 07:19:53
view Pixie's profile