apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Good Questions: Dealing With Damaged Wood Floors?

9-22-damaged-floors.jpgHi AT, I'm renting an apartment in an old brownstone in Prospect Heights. I love the place, but the floors are really old. Because of this, I feel like the apartment always looks and feels much dirtier than it really is, even though I clean and vacuum consistently. Do you have any tips for how to clean the wood floors to make them look, if not newer, less unappealing? (pictures attached). Laying new tiles or carpet on top is not an option, as the landlord would freak out.

Thanks!
Brette

(Note: Include a pic of your problem and your question gets posted first. Email questions and pics with QUESTIONS in subject line to: newyork(at)apartmenttherapy(dot)com)

 
 

We have a similar problem with old, damaged wood floor in our rental. Who has advice for us?

Tags

Good Questions

Related Links

Share

Comments (16)

i had the same problem. mine look exactly like that picture above.

first i just did a regular mop job. then i used a bucket of soap and water and got on my hands and knees with a scrub brush. then i mopped again. then used "quick shine" to give them a shinier coat.

they aren't perfect, but they look so much better. i just make sure to mop regularly and use the quick shine every 8 weeks. and i have runners in heavy traffic areas.

posted by miked on September 22nd 2008 at 11:36am
view miked's profile

Just give it an extra coat of varnish. The old boards are actually lovely -- they just need sprucing up.

(With the landlord's approval you might even go a bit darker.)

posted by Lisa Hunter (Montreal) on September 22nd 2008 at 11:43am
view Lisa Hunter (Montreal)'s profile

i was very pleased with my safe stripper, wood stain, tung oil re-do. plenty of character of an old floor, rich color and
glowing sheen

posted by Kate (NC) on September 22nd 2008 at 11:46am
view Kate (NC)'s profile

Flor Tiles! carpet that's not permanant, and you can take it with you.

posted by kimg924 on September 22nd 2008 at 11:49am
view kimg924's profile

We got our old wood floors refinished and now people think they're new. Not sure if you're land lord would go for it or if you'd want to put out the $$ either, but Kate's idea above - stripping and restaining. If your landloard would let you go darker it could cover some of the stains. Or you could bleach too. Good luck.

posted by ammanda on September 22nd 2008 at 11:52am
view ammanda's profile

Murphy's oil works wonders for filling in scratches and discolorations. They have a light and dark oil for different colored woods. Careful though - your floor will be very slippery afterwards.

posted by Designa Gal on September 22nd 2008 at 11:54am
view Designa Gal's profile

You could use large bamboo mats that aren't too expensive. You can find them online, but in NYC I'm pretty sure Pearl River has some downstairs. Maybe try to match the floor color so that it gives the feel that even the uncovered parts of the floor seem newer/cleaner.

posted by home body on September 22nd 2008 at 12:02pm
view home body's profile

72" x 108" for about $100...

http://www.pearlriver.com/v2/FramesCat.asp?iGroup=326

posted by home body on September 22nd 2008 at 12:05pm
view home body's profile

I second the get down on your knees and scrub away! I would follow this with a good coating of the Method Good for Wood floor polish. It makes my old Brooklyn wood floors sparkle!

posted by ny_am on September 22nd 2008 at 12:07pm
view ny_am's profile

I actually like that look. A good clean and polish with Murphy's Oil soap or that orange glow stuff will do wonders. I got some wood floor conditioner for my old place and they really helped too.

posted by Laura on September 22nd 2008 at 12:16pm
view Laura's profile

The method floor polish/cleaner that comes with the O-Mop is also really good. Your whole house will smell like almonds.

posted by miked on September 22nd 2008 at 12:56pm
view miked's profile

Having the floors redone at my expense was the big splurge when I moved into my apartment in February. It was with the landlords blessing (his gain) and since my apartment is rent stabilized, I felt like it was worth it. My studio is quite small, and only half wood, so there was only about 200 sq ft of floor to do... but it was gorgeous 100-year-old, wide-plank white pine. WARNING: get someone reputable. Seriously, I made a mistake and had to have them redone. I ended up using Vincent Devaney who I found here on AT, and in one day had lovely, lovely floors- sanded, and resealed with several coats of clear poly. It cost $500 (not much more than a decent rug), and was worth every penny.

posted by kimdog on September 22nd 2008 at 12:59pm
view kimdog's profile

our floors were just as bad. we talked to the landlord about it and they offered to have their guy fix it, however we had seen his previous work so we declined. we suggested they contribute whatever they were going to pay their guy towards the cost of getting someone to do a better job and they agreed.
now that our floors our smooth, they are so much easier to clean. it seriously takes 2 hours a week less time to clean my apartment now. even if i only stay here another 2 years i consider the money spent well worth it for the time i will save.
also the floors look great now.

if the landlord wont allow you to lay carpet or tile, then he/she obviously cares about the condition of this place, they might jump at the chance of splitting the cost of floor refinishing with you.

as a plan b maybe you could ask the landlord how they feel about laying some ikea laminate flooring? it is a floating floor so it would not damage the floors underneath, and it is pretty cheap. i used it in my last apartment and it held up well.

posted by lauraWaHi on September 22nd 2008 at 4:39pm
view lauraWaHi's profile

Murphy's oil soap and a scrub brush. Really scrub HARD. This is nothing a little elbow grease can't fix. If all f your attempts fail, ask the landlord if he'd consider a light sanding, oiling, then a matt topcoat? Matt hides imperfections WAY better then luster or glossy.

posted by medusa12120 on September 23rd 2008 at 7:20am
view medusa12120's profile

I looked at the picture & just laughed – last night I was up late putting polyurethane on our living room floor, 150 year old wide pine plank in a Philly rowhouse, even more chewed up than yours! I used the Fine Paints of Europe water-based “Eurolux” Varnish Gloss, which dries enough to recoat in 4 hours – so I did the whole floor section in one day, and it looks great. The Eurolux lets off a lot of fumes for the first hour or two, so you want the windows open, fans on, and maybe a respirator. That said, it is SO much less horrible than solvent-based polyurethane, which cannot be recoated for 24 hours and will stink for weeks. Downside is the cost - $100 for a eurogallon. We have two little kids, so the health/convenience argument won out.

To start, I filled a bunch of holes & gaps where the tongue&groove had split off. Used carpenters glue tinted with acrylic paint in a squirt bottle to fill some of the damage in the grooves between the boards (okay, I'm anal -- and we own the place). Then I used a big hand orbital sander with 220 grit to rough up the floor, spent a little more time on the bad areas, vacuumed the dust and wiped the wood down with denatured alcohol – it evaporates very quickly and leaves no residue.

Then, I thinned the Eurolux a bit less than 10% water for the first coat, cut in around the edges with a good quality synthetic brush (new – not previously used for painting), then applied the Eurolux with a 1/2” pile lamb’s wool applicator block on a pushbroom pole (dampen lamb’s wool first). After 4 hours I lightly scuffed the surface by hand with 220 sandpaper, wiped it down with a tack cloth (go lightly so you don’t leave sticky residue), put down another coat thinned maybe 5%. Another 4 hours, scuffed & wiped, and put down the final coat full strength. They say it takes 48 hours to fully cure, but you can put stuff back on it gently after 24. Emmitt at the Fine Paints of Europe office in Woodstock, VT is very helpful, so call him with questions. I’ve also used their oil based paint on our front door, and it looks fabulous. http://www.finepaintsofeurope.com/

posted by Arkay on September 25th 2008 at 4:13pm
view Arkay's profile

i second the deep scrub Quick Shine recommendation. my floor is the same way, and if it's scrubbed and shining it looks much better than dull. (it's about making the imperfections looks good, not hiding them.) i do three coats of quick shine every 4-6 months and it looks great.

posted by cybeleny on September 28th 2008 at 9:31am
view cybeleny's profile