apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Good Questions: Hearty Indoor Plant Suggestions?

7-14-planter-death.jpg

I was hoping the superb readers of Apartment Therapy could help me solve a decorating dilemma. My boss has a beautiful, heavy planter in her office and nothing will survive in that puppy. I can’t imagine that the fact that the temperature in our building is constantly in flux because the air conditioning/heat is turned off on the weekends helps our case at all…. We first tried succulents (a mix, and then when those died just hearty jade plants) and then we tried some low-light foliage of the kind that has thrived in my home for the last year. But give them one long weekend and they die. I’ve brought the foliage back to life a couple of times but they struggled and they look rather pathetic! Does anyone have any suggestions for plants that could survive or, even better some nonliving thing I could fill the planter with that would be sophisticated and pretty? Thanks! Laura

(Note: Include a pic of your problem and your question gets posted first. Email questions and pics with QUESTIONS in subject line to: newyork(at)apartmenttherapy(dot)com)

 
 

My guess is that whatever is in there is cooking in the sunlight...a shallow black stone planter that retains the sun's rays? — I think you need to get that puppy out of direct sunlight and go for a shade-friendly plant!

Who else has ideas/suggestions for Laura?

Tags

Good Questions, plants & flowers, planter

Related Links

Share

Comments (34)

You could try mother in law's tongue. Mine has lasted for years in varying degrees of light and minimal watering. Not only is this plant hearty, it's substantial in size with cool variegated foliage. It definitely makes a visual impact

posted by brusselsprout on July 14th 2009 at 3:03pm
view brusselsprout's profile

Make a little cactus garden!

posted by littlebrownbird on July 14th 2009 at 3:04pm
view littlebrownbird's profile

It looks like the soil you have in the pot could be the kind they use in hanging planters that dries out very quickly (seems to have little pieces of styrofoam in it). Try switching to something more organic that will hold the water a bit more.
Succulents really should do well in the sun and without a lot of water....

posted by misshoxie on July 14th 2009 at 3:07pm
view misshoxie's profile

are you changing out the soil every time you change out the plants? The soil might be the problem.

Otherwise go for something no one can kill--spider plants. Those suckers never die!

posted by caiti on July 14th 2009 at 3:09pm
view caiti's profile

Snake plant or Mother in law tongue - you could grow that stuff in an ashtray on top of a TV. I water mine maybe once a month.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sansevieria_trifasciata

posted by Amber in Norfolk on July 14th 2009 at 3:10pm
view Amber in Norfolk's profile

may I suggest a golden pothos? It's a vine, but they're pretty hard to kill. I have one that lives above my closet in front of some storage so it gets low light and since its high up I forget to water it frequently and its been doing great!!

posted by FromTheFuture on July 14th 2009 at 3:18pm
view FromTheFuture's profile

Does that planter has a hole or two on the bottom? It doesn't really look that way from the picture. That could be a major problem and the reason why the plants keep on dying

posted by Taniusik on July 14th 2009 at 3:23pm
view Taniusik's profile

Maybe the beautiful heavy planter doesn't have any drainage. If the plant is being overwatered and there isn't any drainage the roots will drown and the plant will die.

How about rocks and some lucky bamboo? Keep the water level just below the rock level.

posted by pbened on July 14th 2009 at 3:27pm
view pbened's profile

the pot doesn't look like it has any drain holes. I wouldn't direct plant in it or the roots of your chosen victims will be sitting in water and this is bad unless you are an aquatic plant suited for that. i would find a container that slips into that container and plant in that one, leaving a space between the two.

take the planter and dump out the existing soil and what not and wash the planter out (need to wash it in case there's a fungus amongus).

purchase a new 10" hanging plant such as a pothos or philodendron or some other hardy low light plant. pop off the hangers.

cut to size and insert a foam circle, (the same kind of foam that comes in sheets in any fabric store) put that on the bottom of the planter.

put your new plant (still in the basket it came in sans hangers) on top of the foam circle.

fill the empty space between the planter and the new plant with cut strips of the foam - this will secure the plant from being tippy.

take some floral tape and tape across the top of the plant with 2 strips of tape to keep it in there.

cover the top with decorative moss or mulch of some sort - this will hide the space between the pots.

with correct watering the foam saucer on the bottom will keep the roots in contact with moisture without having them sit in water. no too much water and not too little. have a watering schedule like every tuesday and friday....and just a cupfull will do! (most plants die of overwatering)

i hope this makes sense. i worked for an interior plantscaping company for years and this is how we installed plants. using this techinque also makes it easy to do plant change outs in case you have an accidental death.

good luck!

posted by larchgirl on July 14th 2009 at 3:29pm
view larchgirl's profile

Plants are 'hardy,' not 'hearty.'

Besides that -- I could never kill my pothos or philodendron! And I do not have green thumbs.

posted by Retrogrouch on July 14th 2009 at 3:37pm
view Retrogrouch's profile

I have killed just about every houseplant you can buy except for the coffee plant! This magical leafy little plant is almost impossible to kill... though none of mine have ever produced any beans.

posted by ShopgirlCA on July 14th 2009 at 3:38pm
view ShopgirlCA's profile

Stick a potato in it.

I'm not kidding! They are the hardiest plant, and can survive changes in temperature and odd watering schedules. If kids in grade school can do it for a science experiment, you can do it too.

Plus the leaves are quite pretty. And if you dig it up 2 months later, you might even get little potatoes!

posted by Harpy on July 14th 2009 at 3:42pm
view Harpy's profile

I'm a landscape designer (without green thumbs, alas)- I can't help correcting this when I see it; plants are 'hardy,' not 'hearty.' I'm sorry, it's just the way it is :)

I like pothos, mother-law's-tongue, and philodendrons.

posted by Retrogrouch on July 14th 2009 at 3:46pm
view Retrogrouch's profile

Also, "hardy" generally means the plant can withstand cold temperatures, like what you get outside in winter.

That said, some non-hardy houseplants are plenty tough. The snake plant that a bunch of people recommended is really hard to kill. But whatever you grow, it will require drainage.

posted by spanky on July 14th 2009 at 3:47pm
view spanky's profile

Oops - sorry for the almost double-post. I thought my browser was having trouble and tried again.

posted by Retrogrouch on July 14th 2009 at 3:47pm
view Retrogrouch's profile

Totally agree that a lack of drainage is likely the cause of all those deaths. larchgirl's idea sounds like a good one - that really is a decorative rather than functional planter, so it should be the outer visible planter, with functional pots hidden inside.

posted by Szig on July 14th 2009 at 4:08pm
view Szig's profile

As mentioned above- changing soil, ensuring the planter is drainging is important as well. Succulents really are hard to kill- as long as you basically ignore them, being careful not to over water. I know lavendar is typically an outdoor plant, but that is also very resilient and I don't see why you can't bring it in! It smells amazing!

posted by desireeg on July 14th 2009 at 4:13pm
view desireeg's profile

A lining of rocks at the bottom of a planter with no drainage can work in a pinch. The soil will work its way into the rocks eventually, so it's not a long-term solution. There is a product called "Better Than Rocks" that does the same thing, but I don't have personal experience with it.

posted by Graceless on July 14th 2009 at 4:32pm
view Graceless's profile

@Retrogrouch

Treat correcting someone's errors in usage, grammar, etc., as the Victorians treated farts: They politely ignored them as if they did not exist.

posted by muirwoods08 on July 14th 2009 at 4:38pm
view muirwoods08's profile

Also, don't plant indoor plants with small root systems in large containers, or they will "drown". (It looks like that's what happened in the picture). They like to be planted in pots only one size larger than the one they came in with the roots an inch at most from the edge of the container. You can sink a pot in a larger container, however. But remember the roots need air to breathe as much as they need water to drink.

Also, don't rely on your eyes alone, always check with your finger to see if the soil is getting dry before watering. Once a week may be enough, but if it's hot or the plant is in a very small container in bright sun you may need to water every day or so. So, don't overwater, but when you do water, make sure the whole plant is wet all the way through and it runs out the bottom into the saucer underneath the pot. You are aiming (except with succulents and drought loving plants) for a steady state that is continuously somewhat moist, but not wet.

To ensure this, don't water on only one side (so that the other side remains dry). If the soil does get bone dry, it will tend to repel water and never get wet again -- don't let this happen, but if it does, by immersing the the whole pot in quite warm water, which tends to be more readily absorbed, you might be able to save the plant.

Take your plants to the shower and wash them off every so often (unless the are African violets which hate wetness on their furry leaves).

Make sure your plants get as much light as possible -- light is their food. It's intensity drops off logarithmically with every inch they are away from the window. So keep them on the window sill or provide supplementary light. They also appreciate a movement of air.

Lavender indoors won't survive unless you can provide really cool conditions, especially at night, and bright sunlight.

posted by monarda on July 14th 2009 at 5:56pm
view monarda's profile

In my experience growing spider plants indoors in Florida, they are OK in a pot with no drainage as long as you water only every 10 days or so. Plus, they supposedly clean the air of 85% of toxins in 24 hours! I love them for both reasons.

posted by ClaraE on July 14th 2009 at 6:23pm
view ClaraE's profile

Peace lily (or Spathiphyllum).

It's the only houseplant I haven't killed. If it looks like it's going to faint, give it water and it springs back. And the foliage is deep and lovely.

posted by anmar on July 14th 2009 at 6:55pm
view anmar's profile

@muirwoods08:

Nicely correcting a grammatical or spelling error can be very helpful to the person making the mistake. Every time I write "definitely" I remember a high school friend teaching me the correct spelling. I'm sure it has saved me looking like an idiot many times.

The key is to do it NICELY, which Retrogrouch did.

posted by HeatherAB on July 14th 2009 at 7:34pm
view HeatherAB's profile

Mother in law's toungue. i have one I've had since my first bit of grad school and I haven't killed it yet, despite neglect, transplant, 6 moves, and cats snacking on it. Everything else has given up, including Peace Lily, but it lives on. I secretly wonder if it has sold itself to the Nefarious One...

posted by Bee T. on July 14th 2009 at 7:48pm
view Bee T.'s profile

@HeatherAB

Not this time.

posted by muirwoods08 on July 14th 2009 at 8:43pm
view muirwoods08's profile

@muirwoods08

Sorry to butt in, but, go buy yoself some bizness!

posted by jacqueline87 on July 14th 2009 at 11:26pm
view jacqueline87's profile

As long as the planter is not receiving full, direct sun on it, tillandsias, aka "air plants," would be a great choice. Fill the planter with a few interesting looking stones of different sizes. Select a large specimen tillandsia and some other, smaller sizes to fill in. All you will have to do is mist them on dry days and take them to the sink for a 5 minute soak once every 1-2 weeks. No moving the planter or worrying about drainage! Plus they're available in the coolest shapes and colors and are super design-y looking.

posted by selina on July 14th 2009 at 11:31pm
view selina's profile

Oh dear--I had to laugh, that is one saaaad looking photo. It looks like you're sacrificing greenery to a malevolent god, poor things. :)

posted by Mlle Kate on July 14th 2009 at 11:44pm
view Mlle Kate's profile

Mother in Law's Tongue (Snake Plant) needs a deeper pot, so that won't work. I would recommend a succulent mix with new dirt.
Good luck!

posted by Alexuma on July 15th 2009 at 12:50pm
view Alexuma's profile

First off, that looks like a BOWL to me, not a planter. But if it is a planter, you need to prepare it correctly.

I'd empty it, scrub it thoroughly (in case of pathogens killing the plants), and do the following. Put a thin layer of acquarium carbon or pure charcoal (nothing with chemicals in it) on the bottom. (Half inch, maybe?) Over that, put some gravel. (Another inch or so.) These will help keep the plants from drowning if there is no drainage.

Over that I would put good quality potting soil with (if you can locate them) some hydrogel crystals. (Some places sell them to put in clear vases with food coloring -- they swell up with water and look like ice chips. But their real purpose is to even out watering -- they soak and hold the water and release it to plant roots slowly.) Soak them FIRST so you know how much space they take up fully loaded. (I'd guess a teaspoon or less would be more than enough for this planter.)

Then pick some healthy plants suited for the light level, and that the nursery or florist think are low maintenance. That window ledge looks like the worst possible setting. Variable light, extremely hot and drying in the sun, chilled by the AC the rest of the time, no plant's natural setting... With the SHAPE of the pot, I'd look for something mounding or maybe something from a hanging planter. Water just enough as needed -- feel the soil. Might be once a week, might be daily.

OR... Scrub the pot and fill with beautiful river rocks or nice chunks of quartz or other crystals from a rock shop...

Good luck.

posted by SherryBinNH on July 15th 2009 at 5:01pm
view SherryBinNH's profile

http://www.flickr.com/photos/greenscaper/sets/72057594128052747/
None of these plants are top watered. All of them are sub-irrigated. All of them grow in planters like the one shown above. It's easy once you understand the major benefits of watering by capillary action.

posted by Greenscaper on July 16th 2009 at 5:58am
view Greenscaper's profile

rabbits foot fern would be attractive in that bowl with drainage fixed.

it's our office go-to plant

posted by markbright on July 20th 2009 at 11:46am
view markbright's profile

I'm going to assume that the plants get a few hours of direct light per day, and that the blinds aren't drawn all weekend or something. An off-the-wall suggestion would be venus flytraps. Just keep the potting mixture moist, and you should be good to go. I had a couple flytraps that were sitting in a window with a northern exposure, and they did fairly well for almost a year before I moved them outside. They're fairly tolerant of neglect, as long as they stay damp.

posted by lifeblack on July 30th 2009 at 11:51am
view lifeblack's profile

Actually venus flytraps is a very good suggestion, if the planter is a dish and doesn't have any drainage, they would do well in a sunny window like that and wouldn't mind cold temperatures.
Pitcher plants, sundews, and bladderworts would also be a nice addition to the venus flytraps and would grow well in that window.
The dish should be cleaned out and scrubbed and the soil replaced with a mix of 1/3 sand, 2/3 peatmoss.
It should be kept moist at all times.

posted by Kimberly Sevilla on August 28th 2009 at 4:39pm
view Kimberly Sevilla's profile

Feeds

RSS icon New York

+ City Feeds