Hi, I have a question for the readers regarding lighting. I am updating my NY apartment, and am trying to decide on which lights would look good over a dining table. I will probably have 3-4 of them in a canopy over the table — attached are photos for both. My thought is that the cylindrical lights would go better with the table because I already have round lights for my island. However, the oval ones in the attached photo look really good — which one would look better?
Thanks,
Pearl





i think the egg shape is a more interesting design that would draw the eye up :)
view dosergirl's profile
I think the egg shape because they will continue the "smooth" look of your round ones, and are very pleasing on the eye!
view Margiefriend's profile
If your dining table is entirely rectangular, then go for the egg shape. If your table is oval or have large curves, go for the cylindrical ones.. In short, go for contrast!
view thevince's profile
This EuroHome pendant is sculptural, modern and looks different from every angle: http://stylenorth.ca/blog/2008/08/euro-home-chrome-glass-pendant/
view ChrisToronto's profile
Both are charming. This is a hard one. Maybe you might want to wait and decide for yourself, since you'll be the one living with the final choice.
view click212's profile
I don't know which but I agree with thevince.
I would suggest going with an odd number so 3 or 5 above the table though.
view Enamorada's profile
If these are Tiella, you can find these on ebay for cheap, but I'd go with the cylinder.
view cinema's profile
Sorry to be the party pooper but I hate multiple pendants on one canopy. If you are using a canopy, there should only be one lamp hanging from it because the large canopy required for the cluster of pendants catches your attention up and detracts from the lamp.
Have you thought about a Luce Plan pendant. I have the costanza and everyone always loves it. It looks simple but the up-and-down action amazes everyone:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/r5n5/2704399046/in/set-72157606381848306/
view rene's profile
I agree with thevince: contrast is key, so it is actually hard to answer without seeing the other pieces.
view Craig's profile
where can i get those pendant lights above???
view cscamp20's profile
I have the cylinder ones (from Tech Lighting). I like them but would never select that style again because they are incredibly difficult to clean. To put it simply---they get a cloudy film and the shape makes it hard to clean without a bunch of streaks and dust from the paper towel (or whatever is used to wipe it with) (you can't reach into the top at all). I think that either style would be the same. I would select a style that is not transparent----like a frosted glass or a solid color glass. I'm probably going to be replacing mine because of the cleaning issue. Does anyone have a trick for keeping something like this looking sparkley?
view designer4321's profile
how bout the oval pendant lights? where can i buy those?
view cscamp20's profile
Microfiber-dustmitt instead of paper towels? It's glass, so I would go with whatever I'd use to clean windows&mirrors.
view Lilli K.'s profile
Agree hard to tell without seeing more of the room and table, but I do love the egg-shaped ones.
view outonalimb_2008's profile
dont know what color you're thinking of, but the red shades on my pendant lights give my kitchen nook the lovely glow of an after hours porn lounge when they are the only lights on after dark. ... just something to keep in mind..
view teeze's profile
I have the egg shaped ones, with red inner egg and clear outer.
Mine are over the bar in the kitchen, and next to the stove.
Choosing clear was a mistake in that case, as grease from the stove shows up easily on the clear canopy.
When clean, they look stunning, tho.
The second problem is that they have a screw-in (looks like an oversized headphone jack with threads on the end, effectively) mount into the base (sold separately, of course), and the electrician has had to come over several times to try to make it actually work. The problem is that the design makes it hard to get both a good electrical contact and have it be easy to re-insert after taking down for cleaning. If you get a bad contact, the base gets /really/ hot, and the metal clips start to expand, making the light go out.
Eventually, the electrician had to take the base down, take it appart, and re-crimp all the metal contacts. It's worked well since then, but that shouldn't have been necessary.
I'd steer towards another mounting system, if you can.
view johan's profile
Thanks, Johan. What do you mean by another mounting system? Another canopy? Can you clean it without having to take it down?
view NewYorker's profile