apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Good Questions: How Big is Too Big For an Overhead Light?

9.27room.jpgHello AT,

I need to replace an overhead light in our entry way. The problem is that 1)There is a pipe about 10" away (so the light would have to hang below that) 2) The space between the wall (which leads into the bathroom) and our entry open closet/shoe racks is around 55".

The ceiling height is 9ft.

My main question is: How big is too big?

I don't want a tiny little spotlight light like there is now, but I don't want the light to look awkwardly oversized for the space.

I'm loving this pendant shade from Nicolette Brunklaus, because it has some interest inside the shade. But at aprox. 12x15" is it too big?

9.27lamp.jpg

Any other suggestions for this space? I'm willing to spend up to $300, but cheaper options are definitely welcome!

Thanks! Stephanie

Anyone?

(Note: Include a pic of your problem and your question gets posted first.
Email questions and pics with QUESTIONS in subject line to:
editor(at)apartmenttherapy(dot)com)
Link To All Good Questions

Comments (11)

12"x15" isn't especially big, it's probably fine for the space. Make a mockup out of paper and a piece of string to see for sure.

posted by cindycindy on 2007-09-27 14:11:12
view cindycindy's profile

I think a suspended fixture like the Nelson Saucer lamp would be ideal for this.

posted by hejiranyc on 2007-09-27 14:13:31
view hejiranyc's profile

You can never be sure until you try someting -- and a good lighting store will let you return a fixture that you are not happy with.

One option is to get a paper lantern that is about the size you think you want -- they can be bought for $5 or less -- then try it on for size and go from there.

posted by Mid-C Frank on 2007-09-27 14:19:44
view Mid-C Frank's profile

hejiranyc - I was thinking about a Nelson Saucer as well. Thanks for confirming! (Stephanie)

posted by canadian in swedish clothing on 2007-09-27 14:23:51
view canadian in swedish clothing's profile

Mid-C Frank - being able to bring it back if it didn't work would be ideal. That would be a problem with the Nicolette Brunklaus lamp (from Rose and Radish in San Fran, I'm in Vancouver) I guess that''s why I'm hesitant about it.

posted by canadian in swedish clothing on 2007-09-27 14:30:05
view canadian in swedish clothing's profile

Oh... a really cheap but oh-that's-so-2004 thing to do would be to put up one of those Tord Boontje pendants. For some reason I am very fascinated by the "Icarus Light" (http://www.unicahome.com/catalog/item.asp?id=23935&PartnerID=FR), but the traditional Garland Light (http://www.unicahome.com/catalog/item.asp?id=13770&PartnerID=FR) still fascinates me for some reason...

posted by hejiranyc on 2007-09-27 14:59:57
view hejiranyc's profile

hejiranyc- haha... I don't think my boyfriend would approve, as that light is a splitting image of his hair in highschool. Shhh....

I don't mind the garland light, but I kind of wanted something a bit more substantial.

Thanks for your suggestions though!

posted by canadian in swedish clothing on 2007-09-27 15:09:45
view canadian in swedish clothing's profile

If that's a monopoint spot connection, you could also get an assortment of pendants and swap them with the seasons and moods (like they do with curtains - or really - window treatments in Sweden). You can even get a swag attachment to have the light in a different location (in otherwords on the other side of the sprinkler for instance) from the same box - or multiples off the one connection.

posted by dn on 2007-09-27 15:17:33
view dn's profile

Canadian, I'm afraid he wasn't the only one sporting a mullet in the 80's. Sssshhh....

posted by hejiranyc on 2007-09-27 15:45:37
view hejiranyc's profile

I think a Noguchi lamp would look nice here. They're a bit more free-form than the Nelson bubbles but nicer than the cheapo paper lanterns...

http://akaristore.stores.yahoo.net/model33x45x.html

http://akaristore.stores.yahoo.net/model15a21a26a.html

http://akaristore.stores.yahoo.net/16a.html

You could probably find a local dealer...

posted by deoxy on 2007-09-27 16:14:03
view deoxy's profile

Thanks for your comments- I am going to get a small Nelson saucer lamp with a ceiling medalion (if I can convince the boyfriend)- I saw the idea in Lotta Jansdotter's place featured in September's Blueprint magazine- I think it's a great contrast in styles!

posted by canadian in swedish clothing on 2007-10-06 02:29:20
view canadian in swedish clothing's profile
Buy Text Ads