apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Good Questions: Who Can Tame This Monster Armoire?

6-19-monster.jpgHello AT,

My boyfriend and I just bought an apartment that we are madly in love with.

The issue is that the apartment came with this monster piece of furniture that unfortunately is as useful as it is hideous. We don't have the heart to get rid of it (yet, although I'm working on the boyfriend), but it is dominating our bedroom with its bland Ikea-ness (seriously dominating. It is at least 10 feet tall).

Does anyone have any ideas for how to make it less horrible?...

(Note: Include a pic of your problem and your question gets posted first.
Email questions and pics with QUESTIONS in subject line to:
editor(at)apartmenttherapy(dot)com)
Link To All Good Questions
 
 

I'm open to anything from wallpaper to fabric to paint. I was toying with the idea of color washing it with this paint in "terra cotta," but I wanted to get as many ideas as possible before tackling it.

To give you a little bit of an idea of our style, most of our furniture and decorations come from my Middle Eastern great grandparents (Oriental rugs, mosaic tables, dark wood bureaus, etc) and we are repainting the bedroom in Mediterranean colors (adobe clay painted walls with majorelle blue trim and doors).

Thanks in advance,

Scout

Dear Scout,

There are many things you can do and the blandness of the piece will make it easier. Simple flat planes are easier to paint,cover or hide.

However, our first choice would be to simply get rid of it (sell it on our classifieds). Then you could build into the entire nook, make it flush with the wall and get an even better closet in that part of the room that would fit in and not stand out.

However, to address your question. We'd go for paint. Remove all the drawers and doors, take off the pulls, give it a light sanding, prime it and then paint it (small roller) with an enamel based paint. We'd leave the insides unpainted unless your feeling particularly ambitious. As for the sides, they can be treated the same way once the doors and drawers are all off.

Anyone else??

Tags

Good Questions

Related Links

Share

Comments (38)

Get rid of it, or take maxwell's advice and paint it the same color as the wall.

posted by MrGreen on 2007-06-19 16:09:32
view MrGreen's profile

Congrats on the new apt. Your ceiling is amazingly high!

How about putting a new veneer on the armoire? I have no experience with this, and I'm considering doing it myself on a similar Ikea piece, so I'd like to hear if anyone has done this.

posted by mrk on 2007-06-19 16:13:24
view mrk's profile

List it on Craigsist. If you make the price low enough someone will pay you to haul the thing away.

posted by boomer on 2007-06-19 16:14:11
view boomer's profile

My first thought, before I read Maxwell's suggestions, was to get rid of it and have a custom built-in created. Just look at how much space is wasted near the ceiling that you could use for off season storage.

posted by Mistral418 on 2007-06-19 16:15:51
view Mistral418's profile

can you push it back, flush with the back wall, and conceal it with ceiling to floor flowy drapes, which can be pulled to the side when you need access?

posted by Lourdes on 2007-06-19 16:16:52
view Lourdes's profile

mrk, ikea furniture is so cheaply constructed that it is not worth re-veneering.

posted by MrGreen on 2007-06-19 16:18:47
view MrGreen's profile

install mirrons on wardrobe's doors and paint it on same color of the wall

posted by ziiip on 2007-06-19 16:23:55
view ziiip's profile

Do you have a fireplace? ;->

Seriously though - I'll second the idea of hiding it behind drapes.

You can get them cheaply enough, use them elsewhere if you do later get rid of it, and the effect of the drapes in that spot could be nice. You could for for some nice red ones to pick up on the red in your gorgeous rug.

posted by boomer on 2007-06-19 16:24:53
view boomer's profile

Oh, my I didn't realize how tall that thing is. Get rid of it immediately. If you keep it it will still be sitting there in 20 years.

posted by MrGreen on 2007-06-19 16:26:35
view MrGreen's profile

I agree. If you take a lot of trouble to make it attractive, you will also be inclined to keep it for longer... bad idea.

posted by Kah on 2007-06-19 16:28:40
view Kah's profile

Good point, Kah, I didn't even think of that. It is so ugly, so dominating, especially just inside the front door like that. If you are going to have something so big in your space, it needs to be nice. Any effort put into it will just make it seem more valuable to her.

However, because she has such high ceilings, she has the opportunity to take advantage of buying a really nice old huge piece of furniture. The really big pieces are sometimes cheaper than smaller ones because they don't fit in most houses today. I could see her getting a really tall stand-up butler's desk with cabinets above, or one of those nice old halltree/bench things that's ten feet tall.

posted by MrGreen on 2007-06-19 16:35:36
view MrGreen's profile

I just bought a place too and understand that right now the cash flow may not be there to chuck this thing and start over! I think I would paint it the wall color, and get some pretty knobs for the drawers. You could also use etching cream on part or all of the mirror to make it seem less huge.

posted by Sarah122 on 2007-06-19 16:48:07
view Sarah122's profile

If you don't want to spend a lot of time making it look better get a pair of long curtains. Hang them from the ceiling via a hospital track and call it a day. I had almost the exact same piece of furniture in my apartment on 78th street and I tried putting fabric panels to make it look better but I was never satisfied.

Just make sure the curtains are darker because they'll be in a high traffic area.

Best of luck.

posted by rikki on 2007-06-19 16:48:21
view rikki's profile

Get rid of it.

If your apartment didn't come with this thing and you needed storage space, would you say to each other, "We really should consider getting a 10-foot-tall mirrored IKEA monstrosity for our clothes"? No? Get rid of it!

posted by Anne in Chicago on 2007-06-19 16:49:19
view Anne in Chicago's profile

Its is from the PAX line? If so then you can purchase different doors. For a quick & cheap fix I like the curtain idea.

posted by Nicole on 2007-06-19 16:49:34
view Nicole's profile

I thought what this guy did was cool: http://ikeahacker.blogspot.com/2007/02/kullen-gets-glam.html

posted by Harley on 2007-06-19 16:58:15
view Harley's profile

If the dresser was not included in the purchase, then your seller is responsible for removing it. Did you ask your lawyer?

posted by len on 2007-06-19 17:02:35
view len's profile

if none of the above suggestions work...what about custom vinyl appliques. http://www.whatisblik.com/ or maybe covering the wood panels with a wallpaper design you like...here are some places:
http://www.flavorleague.com/
http://www.walnutwallpaper.com/
http://www.cavernhome.com/Cavern.html

posted by joanna bean on 2007-06-19 17:45:20
view joanna bean's profile

Instead of paint, which can be labor intensive between sanding, cleaning and priming, (and still end up looking kind of bland) why not try wallpaper? Find something with a great pattern and turn it into a piece of art; you can even try decoupage and use different papers.

posted by liz100 on 2007-06-19 17:48:02
view liz100's profile

trash it

posted by right angle on 2007-06-19 18:15:00
view right angle's profile

keep the boyfriend

posted by right angle on 2007-06-19 18:16:59
view right angle's profile

If its Ikea (and you need to keep it), you should follow Nicole's advice and see if there is a door style that better suits the room. This is probably the cheapest solution for the most improvement. You could go with something like the high gloss lacquered white doors. Spend a little extra for the hardware on the outside - the combination of the lacquer and nice hardware could make the armoire look very "ligne roset". With nice hardware and delivery I am guessing this could be done for somewhere in the mid $200-$300 range.

Ideally, if you are not loving the Ikea choices, the smart thing to do is to get rid of it. You wouldn't force yourself to dress in the previous tenant's castoff clothes, so you certainly shouldn't feel obligated to dress your new home with her ugly castoff furniture. Throw it out and replace it with something you can live with.

posted by RichardinLA on 2007-06-19 19:08:16
view RichardinLA's profile

alright, I'm not arguing that its attractive...but think about all of that storage space...

I say paint it to match the wall....maybe somehow getting rid of the mirror (removing or covering would help)

posted by Jess2nola on 2007-06-19 19:27:00
view Jess2nola's profile

It looks in the photo as if some of the drawers are already askew on their tracks. This is the armoire's way of sticking out its tongue and telling you that it does not want a high-quality paint job (assuming you could get IKEA's usual foil-over-MDF to prep properly -- Curtis could, but I'd fail embarrassingly, expensively, and time-wastingly). It wants to go live in a new home with someone who will be grateful for it. In fact, selling it will attract more pleasing storage in roughly your price range, whatever that may be.

If you're determined to keep it, you need to do the full Curtis treatment. Don't just paint it to match the walls: add trim and texture to make it a Moroccan extravaganza. Otherwise, you'll just have a painted-out 10-foot-tall ugly armoire staring at you.

posted by wende in the twin cities on 2007-06-19 19:39:08
view wende in the twin cities's profile

If you can't hide it and you can't get rid of it, try getting some thin moulding pieces that you can put on the front to give it some kind of architectural feel.

Look at the bright side - there's no way you can make it worse, no matter what you do. LOL

posted by boomer on 2007-06-19 19:55:32
view boomer's profile

Oh, I forgot - get some frosted vinyl film to cover the mirror too.

You can get some great Eames vinyl with the classic "Jacks" pattern here. That would soften the harshness somewhat.

http://www.decorativefilm.com/OnlineCataloguePage1.htm

posted by boomer on 2007-06-19 19:59:59
view boomer's profile

Thanks guys for the suggestions. I totally agree that burning it (we do actually have a fireplace) is the best idea, but our remodeling budget is currently running dry, especially since the blue paint we want for the trim is so insanely expensive (to anyone who read my previous question re: majorelle blue, I found it. And thanks.).

We are both pretty handy (I was a theatre carpenter for awhile in high school and college, so I can make stuff that is sturdy, but looks kind of crappy), though, so we might look into building something. Do you think we should build something freestanding or simply attach doors to the front of nook, and use the existing walls as the rest of the unit?

The new doors idea is a great one. I hadn't known what line it was from (I only really go to Ikea when I move apartments), but now that I know that I can get something with a little more depth I am much happier. That way when if paint it it won't be quite so stark.

I also might look into the wallpaper/fabric idea. Does anyone have any experience attaching wallpaper to MDF? Is there anything special I would need to do to make it stick?

As you can tell, I am still making up my mind so please continue with the suggestions!

posted by stufankjian on 2007-06-19 22:48:30
view stufankjian's profile

You should get rid of this armoire and custom build in this nook.

posted by loki on 2007-06-20 04:40:12
view loki's profile

I know it's tempting to throw it away, but that's quite a waste if it is, after all, useful.

I say, go for the wallpaper. I wouldn't be shy to cover the mirrored door with wallpaper either. The mirror gives the Ikea origins away immediately. Not sure how to go about it, but have heard it's relatively easy. I'm sure the wallpaper vendors can guide you there.

I've personally seen an armoire like this totally and utterly transformed by gold leaf. It's looks fantastic, but then again, I loooove bling.

Oh, and of course, change the knobs out with something more charming from a flea market...

posted by Jennie K. on 2007-06-20 06:34:00
view Jennie K.'s profile

I agree with Maxwell: paint it the same color as the wall. For best results, use Kilz primer before applying the paint. This is a very useful piece of furniture; there is no need to get rid of it if you can spruce it up.

posted by Terry on 2007-06-20 08:12:02
view Terry's profile

there is so much wasted space above and to the left of that thing. it turns my stomach to look see so much wasted space. get rid of that thing. that nook can be perfect for a way better customer built closet/storage space.

posted by powkang on 2007-06-20 09:16:25
view powkang's profile

I would push the armoire back, then put a curtain across the entire nook - it'll hide both the armoire and all the other clutter you have back there. you could hang them a little lower (just above the armoire) if ceiling to floor curtains sound like too much. then, when you have money, sell the armoire for a few dollars on craigslist and build a custom closet.

posted by everythingistaken on 2007-06-20 09:55:03
view everythingistaken's profile

It's amazing how many have suggested "getting rid" of it when the possibilites are endless. Try all options; paint, wallpaper, maybe removing the top doors and installing shelves-this could make a nice music center. You could paint the outside in several rich colors and glue some faux suede fabric inside-very jazzy. Can you maybe move this piece to the kitchen and use it for storage? Then you can paint it in a suble color as a background and decoupage it. You can make it as soft or loud as you want.

posted by schnauzer on 2007-06-20 10:39:48
view schnauzer's profile

How about taking off the doors and putting some shelves in it instead?

posted by wwoolsey on 2007-06-20 10:49:54
view wwoolsey's profile

I suggest using tape (or finding stick on shapes) to create a pattern on the doors and drawers; the pattern you create could be a good way to incorporate your Middle Eastern decor. Then paint over the entire piece and remove the tape (keep in mind when you choose the piant that the light wood color will be your "pattern"). Switch out the drawer pulls for something more along the lines of your decor. As for the mirror maybe you could use one of those sticky screens that are sold for windows in a nice pattern and cover it...or just deal with the fact that you have a ten foor mirror in your home. It's very Design on a Dime, but it seems like you're up for it :)

posted by hammocks on 2007-06-20 11:03:37
view hammocks's profile

The question is: can it be re-positioned in the room? That seems to be the real problem. A floorplan would really help here.

I don't think it's ugly at all, just awkward where you have it. But based on your rug, maybe your style isn't modern or minimalist. Maybe that's the problem.

In any case, if you can push it back, then re-paint it with a gloss paint and add new knobs (from eBay) that coordinate with your style and other pieces, then I think it could work. Consider reversing the lefthand door and maybe the middle door. Don't throw it out unless you can afford custom built-ins to fill that space, or some other better alternative. Also, don't store anything on top of it.

posted by Suzanne on 2007-06-20 12:30:09
view Suzanne's profile

découpage

posted by Alan on 2007-06-20 13:51:05
view Alan's profile

Scout, it's horrible. Get rid of it. It's the wrong size and scale and is turning what could be a nice architectural feature into a nightmare.

My first thought was to look for an amazing antique piece that would fit INSIDE the nook, not stick out. If you can't afford that right now, a less expensive option would be to put up a curtain (either a regular rod or a hospital track) and put Elfa shelves from the Container Store behind it. Just think of how much fun you would have finding a great fabric for the curtain.

If you want to spend the $ on construction, you can hired someone to put built-in storage up top, bringing it as far down as you want. We have this above our fridge. We have a pair of doors that are painted the same color as the wall, and a couple of shelves inside. Great for storage. Lowering the ceiling would also make the nook more cozy, and you could make room to install lighting in the ceiling.

Congrats on the apartment!

posted by greer on 2007-06-24 20:33:07
view greer's profile