apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Good Questions: Would You Recommend Stainless Steel Adhesive Film?

6-29-stainless-steel-1.jpgHello AT,

We'll be renovating our kitchen and have to get all new appliances
except for the fridge, which is the only one in the right size and
good condition. But... the fridge is white and we were planning to go
stainless steel on all the new appliances.

Has anyone ever tried camouflaging their fridge with this dubious
sounding stainless steel adhesive which I found online...

(Note: Include a pic of your problem and your question gets posted first.
Email questions and pics with QUESTIONS in subject line to:
editor(at)apartmenttherapy(dot)com)
Link To All Good Questions
 
 

6-29-stainless-steel-2.jpg


I need a reality check, am I just going to waste my time trying to
penny pinch, or do you think it actually might look "good enough"
and be a smart way to save a couple hundred bucks in the short term.

Any advice is much appreciated!

Thanks-
Marcelo


PS... The particular fridge we'd be covering is completely flat in
front, with no door handles, and the sides of the fridge would not be
visible. And yes, we are on a budget. It's our first apartment and
we're going with ikea cabinets and outlet appliances, etc.. so while
we don't want it to look like a cheap craft project, we also aren't
expecting it to look like a million dollars.


Dear Marcelo,

The very word "faux" scares us, and cutting corners in a budget pinch is always acceptable, but you rarely get something you want and some corners are easier to cut than others. We don't think this is one of them.

Although we haven't used this stuff, we'd steer clear of it for a number of reasons. First of all, the stainless steel racket is rife with cheaters, the biggest of which are those that promise the "stainless steel look" without actually using stainless steel. This is usually a cheaper metal that is painted or veneered to look like stainless, but has a cooler, less attractive look and does not wear the same way. This is the type of thing the faux finish is made of, because actual stainless steel can't be formed into a roll. It's too rigid. Check out their words:

...SoftMetal is a metallic adhesive film looking exactly like any real metal surface.

The second problem is that we've never seen a perfect adhesive product of any kind. Whether it's windows, shelf liners or this, we think you're going to get some edge lifting or inconsistent adhesion or even wrinkles somewhere along the line.

Our advice then would be to leave your fridge white and accept it as an honest look, waiting until you find the perfect stainless fridge you want and then upgrade.

Anyone else???

Tags

Good Questions

Related Links

Share

Comments (27)

I agree on waiting and upgrading. Last thing you want is a pealing soft metal and maybe leaving a tacky residue behind.

posted by Jamie on June 29th 2007 at 5:35am
view Jamie's profile

Why not all white appliances? I find the all stainless steel look tiresome. In 3 years every one will know that you updated the kitichen in the early '00's.

posted by Mason on June 29th 2007 at 5:39am
view Mason's profile

Having driven myself crazy trying to fake stainless steel on miniature kitchen appliances a couple years back... I just don't see this film thing working. At best, with careful application, it's going to bear the same relation to stainless steel as wood-grained Contak paper does to wood.

At worst, you're going to pioneer a new "art" look in which "stainless steel" appliances are wrinkled like elephants.

posted by wende in the twin cities on June 29th 2007 at 5:43am
view wende in the twin cities's profile

i agree with mason.

every "luxury" building out there is basing their luxuriousness on stainless steel appliances and marble tiles.

YAWN.

be bold & design-forward & stick with the all-white appliances.

unless it's a sub-zero, you shouldn't be able to call it luxury, lol.

posted by christinanyc on June 29th 2007 at 5:48am
view christinanyc's profile

Your solution is here. This company specializes in creating panels where appliances can't take panels for people like you who want to change the color/finish of their appliance. Go to "appliance frame and panels"

http://www.frigodesign.com/php/index.php#

posted by susan on June 29th 2007 at 5:49am
view susan's profile

I used some of this on a kid's kitchen set- it looked pretty convincing for about an hour, then the adhesive started delaminating. Please do not use this on a real kitchen.

posted by superbad on June 29th 2007 at 5:58am
view superbad's profile

Stainless used to be an honest look for commercial quality appliances. It represented luxury, in that only people of a certain wealth would (or could) put commercial quality appliances in their home kitchen.

Now EVERYBODY has stainless, or stainless "look". It's no longer a symbol of professional quality... it's just a look now. Like Avocado or Harvest Gold. It's over. Seek out something truly unique and less trendy, or just stick with white. It's classic, and it will always work. And your fridge is already white.

posted by Jay on June 29th 2007 at 6:04am
view Jay's profile

I think it would be cool if you did one of those vinyl decals on your fridge! I like the look of stainless, but it does sound as though this product is going to look really fakey. I can't remember exactly where I saw the decals for appliances, I'll try to dig up a link, but there were some really funky ones that might work, depending on your style!

posted by bluestar on June 29th 2007 at 6:08am
view bluestar's profile

Maxwell hit it on the head with the statment about it not looking like SS when compared to actual SS on the other appliances. A friend did exactly what you describe (except it was her dishwasher that she tried to make look stainless). She did a really good job with the cuts and everything, but it was one cabinet away from the genuine stainless steel oven and it looked so fake -- it almost looked like one of those fake cardboard appliances that you seen displayed sometimes in Ikea.

posted by robyn on June 29th 2007 at 6:25am
view robyn's profile

I had an art professor back in the '80s (when there WERE no SS appliances etc to be had) who faced his entire kitchen in a similar product and told everyone he had a SS kitchen. Looked AWFUL! You could tell it had been applied onto the surface -- it was immediately obvious. He looked silly too...

While I like ss appliances (and have them), I think that the next thing is to use colour on appliances, like the SMEG refrigerators. Have you thought about taking them to an autobody shop, and having them painted -- fire-engine red or bright turquoise perhaps? I have investigated that before, and if they are not too busy, they are open to the business, and the charge is reasonable. That is what i would do with white appliances...

posted by mschatelaine on June 29th 2007 at 6:48am
view mschatelaine's profile

I agree that it would be better to go with white appliances.

However, this is actually a high-quality, inexpensive product. It is easily removable. If you spend the time to install it properly, it would be a perfectly-acceptable way to delay purchasing a new refrigerator.

It should be pointed out that your fridge is one of the largest energy consumers in the home after hvac and hot water. If your refrigerator is older and energy-inefficient then it would be penny-wise and pound-foolish to delay replacing it.

posted by MrGreen on June 29th 2007 at 6:54am
view MrGreen's profile

Don't like WHITE?

Buy black appliances for the same money. You don't NEED stainless steel.

posted by John on June 29th 2007 at 6:54am
view John's profile

There was a Domino article once where a young decorator wallpapered their fridge. It looked great, although I suspect it will get very dirty over time.

You might try papering over the front of your fridge with a fun white and silver paper - there are tons of great choices at FlavorPaper. Then you won't have to worry about the sides not being covered, and it will make the fridge blend in with the other pieces. Or make a pattern with Blik or some other type of decal in a gray color. Both of these alternatives should be much easier to remove than this stainless paper stuff.

posted by eeeck on June 29th 2007 at 6:54am
view eeeck's profile

In the interest of saving money AND if you do really, really want a stainless steel-looking appliance, I suggest you try using the stainless steel effect contact paper first. (Okay, I know a lot of people on this board won't agree with me, but I understand what it's like to a) work with a budget and b) really, really want something NOW.) I've used it myself in the past and IF applied correctly, it doesn't wrinkle and it comes off very easily when needed - no sticky residue or peeling off of paint. Hope that helps.

posted by tara1979 on June 29th 2007 at 7:13am
view tara1979's profile

i don't like stainless steal because you get fingerprints all over it - i feel like i'd be cleaning it every time i went to get something out of the fridge.

posted by elizabeth in AL on June 29th 2007 at 7:27am
view elizabeth in AL's profile

There's this product that let's you paint on a stainless steel finish. I haven't tried it but you can also order a sample to check out before committing. A kit for a fridge costs $130-150. Maybe someone out there has tried it?


http://www.liquidstainlesssteel.com/Home/tabid/36/Default.aspx

posted by dorothy on June 29th 2007 at 7:31am
view dorothy's profile

Stainless steel does get fingerprints all over it - what's the attraction?

posted by Monkeyme on June 29th 2007 at 7:40am
view Monkeyme's profile

I love retro style fridges but I've heard that SMEG is all style low quality. Are there any other companies that do this look?

posted by LaDonnaNichole on June 29th 2007 at 7:43am
view LaDonnaNichole's profile

Or how about putting metal bulletin boards on the fridge, large ones, with stainless accents (metallic frames the mimic stainless, stainless magnets, etc) to disguise some of the overall whiteness of the fridge and tie it into the other appliances?

Weighing in on the stainless kitchens: they're pretty but I finally realized that, with pets, polishing stainless appliances just isn't how I want to spend my life (so yes, I'm embracing white appliances with my kitchen reno, and keeping stainless to an accent... just the range hood and accessories)

posted by Rucy on June 29th 2007 at 7:56am
view Rucy's profile

I would skip the adhesive product. I am also unsure about stainless looking sharp 5 years from now. If you want stainless for the other appliances, perhaps you could consider painting your fridge with green or black blackboard paint (search on AT for a post about that). Looks great, cheap, and adds some funky variety to your kitchen.

posted by KBinBC on June 29th 2007 at 9:07am
view KBinBC's profile

I'm with bluestar on the vinyl decals whatisblik.com or similar place. If you think your white fridge looks really out of place with everything else then maybe you can find a decal that helps camoflage the white, or maybe do something fun, like the space invaders decals.

Dunno if this is even possible, what about blackboard paint?? (you dont say if the fridge is full height or under counter, under counter it may not be practical!)

Friends have a magnetic calendar that covers half their fridge Its functional (track your day as you pour your cereal) and would cover the white if you really dont like it.

posted by Clairepetrol on June 29th 2007 at 9:29am
view Clairepetrol's profile

My sister went with all stainless a year before I bought my condo. She hates them. She has to clean them all the time. I went with all black, which I love, and she was so jealous.

I was looking at MLS listings on the internet and one kitchen really stood out. It was all stainless except the fridge, which was white. Talk about something that really stood out. I could not believe that somebody was trying to sell an upscale condo with all stainless except the frig. It really looked bad and cheap. So rather than leave it white, maybe do something fun and funky. Go to Ikea and get some stainless note boards and rubber cement them to the frig!

posted by gttim on June 29th 2007 at 10:23am
view gttim's profile

I was looking through the catalogue of a high end bathroom fittings maker and was stunned to realize how dated much of what is in there looks dated already.

The larger lesson here is that good, classic design trumps fashion for anything that you need to live with for a long time - color schemes, stainless... By the time most folks can afford something, it is on its way out. Fashion is fun - but it gets dated fairly quickly, so use it in ways you can update.

posted by Taureg on June 29th 2007 at 1:37pm
view Taureg's profile

I laugh at Chicago real estate listings because they all sound like this, "shows like a model, granite countertops and stainless steel appliances..." Thanks to clever marketing, what constitutes a stainless steel appliance is much different than it used to be. Guess what, unless if it's a luxury property the stainless steel appliances are black GE fridges, micros and dishwashers with stainless steel film on the fronts. Probably the same stuff as this. If you want to try to get that look I would go for it. But measure very, very carefully and cut just as carefully. Then, I would paint the surface you are going to cover with contact cement. But you've got only one chance to lay the film out, once it sticks it's stuck. Of course your appliances will be wearing this film for the rest of their life.

posted by art on June 29th 2007 at 3:57pm
view art's profile

Thank you for all the advice!
Your voice was heard and I have definitively said NO to FAUX!

Mostly, I want all stainless because it will be an open kitchen and the rest of the apartment has an art deco vibe (a curved wall, molding, and hopefully there will be a beautiful stainless steel art deco ceiling fan which I'm in love with.) I want the appliances to set back, and stainless steel seemed like a good way to blend with the rest of the apartment.

I also agree with some of the anti- stainless steel thinking, that it might be overdone and passé 5-10 years from now. I often wonder if I'm just another sucker trying to get a generic condo look on the cheap, or whether I really do believe stainless steel will look better within my overall design of the apartment.

So I'm on the fence. I took MrGreen's advice and compared the energy cost of the current fridge with a new one, and I'd save about 50-60 bucks a year with a new one. I'm thinking, for now, that stainless steel will prevail. Maybe I might even be able to craigslist the old one for a couple of bucks...

Everyone who writes comments here is so friendly and wonderful... thank you so much!

posted by saudoso on June 29th 2007 at 6:23pm
view saudoso's profile

I just brought this stuff and it looks pretty good and cleans up easily. Only problem is it is VERY diffucult to apply; I finally gave up and took it to a window tinting place to have it put on. I did put it over magnetic panels so it I get tired of it or it doesn't hold up I can take it off without any problems.

posted by dee on July 10th 2007 at 8:38am
view dee's profile

I have had stainless appliances and they look great if you like high tech (which as a former bistro owner, I DO). They look and ARE very functional for people who really DO cook. They are NOT, however, elegant-looking, so when people put stainless appliances (especially the less expensive typical appliance brands with the black plastic handles)...in elegant kitchens with granite topped mahogany furniture (whoops...I meant to say cabinets)....it's like "what's wrong with this picture? Elegant furniture-quality cabinets should be paired with appliances that are covered with the same wood as the cabinets. Since people don't usually cook in this type of kitchen, a stove is probably not necessary. Have your microwave inside a cabinet. You can do your cooking (which is impossible to do without making at least a little bit of a mess), outside on your gas grill (you DO have one, don't you?). If you have $60K that you don't know what else to do with... and still want an elegant kitchen, serve food from your local deli when the weather won't permit outdoor cooking/entertaining. As for me, I have a very functional kitchen with a 2 foot by 4 foot Boos chopping island, above which hangs my colorful LeCrueset and Chantal cookware. For a refrigerator, I splurged on the JennAir cabinet style with freezer drawer on bottom in the floating white glass with straight stainless handles...no black plastic anywhere. We live in the heart of West LA with lots of well- known eateries but enjoy cooking and dining at home almost all the time except when traveling to other cities to visit loved ones. So, no I would not spend money to make white appliances "look stainless".... or even buy stainless to begin with... anymore.

posted by sandesigns on October 2nd 2007 at 9:25am
view sandesigns's profile

Feeds

RSS icon New York

+ City Feeds