apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Rumor: Rats Eat Cars on the Upper West Side?

7-14-rats.jpgA colleague had to take her car into get fixed over the weekend. The problem, she found out, had to do with the wiring, which had been eaten out by rats. She and her husband park their car on Riverside Drive. The mechanic said that this was a common problem: rats crawling out of Riverside park and into car engines, eating up the wiring. Yuck. He also had a solution....

 
 

Mothballs.

Good, smelly mothballs will repel the rats from wanting to make a home in your car. You take mothballs, wrap them tight and attach them to the bottom of the engine mounts (four corners). The rats will remove the mothballs if left loose, so you need to tie them down.

Good luck!

Tags

Share

Comments (19)

I believe every bit of this ... years ago, squirrels ate the insulation from some of my engine wiring and I stalled 10 feet from my parking spot. $1000 worth of damage!

posted by robyn on July 14th 2008 at 10:08am
view robyn's profile

Mice ate the wiring inside the range in my first house -- came in through the dryer vent and ran amuck throughout the house before we discovered them -- so I totally believe this.

posted by madampince on July 14th 2008 at 10:27am
view madampince's profile

In the desert southwest, it's packrats that munch wiring - cars and houses. I'm not sure that mothballs would work on packrats.

posted by m_j_s on July 14th 2008 at 10:39am
view m_j_s's profile

My boyfriend and I walk along RSD at dusk several times a week, and numerous times I've seen rats running around under cars. I don't doubt this is true.

posted by kimdog on July 14th 2008 at 10:42am
view kimdog's profile

Same thing happened to my husband's car in Brooklyn, near the Navy Yard. The mechanic said he found a huge bone that they'd been gnawing on up there too. Yuck!

posted by jazhandz2 on July 14th 2008 at 10:45am
view jazhandz2's profile

but... mothballs!? i used them to encourage a skunk to nest under someone else's porch. It worked. However, for months the smell (toxic?) of the mothballs affected me and my apartment neighbors because the porch is right next to the stairwell. I can't imagine what a hot engine is going to do to them, and you!

posted by greenlight on July 14th 2008 at 10:47am
view greenlight's profile

Mothballs (napthalene) are highly flammable, and produce toxic gases when heated. I suspect that strapping them to the engine of your car is a pretty dangerous move.

Maxwell, I strongly recommend that you either amend this post with a very serious warning, or remove it entirely.

posted by Anna at D16 on July 14th 2008 at 10:57am
view Anna at D16's profile

My housemate couldn't get his Lexus started one morning. When he popped the hood, he found the source of the problem... which was still sitting in/on his engine after having munched through some wires. Rats are notoriously big-- and bad-- in Baltimore, and "flat rats" (road kill rats) earned the title of the city's worst eyesore in last year's Best of Baltimore Citypaper. *shudder*

posted by embaltimore on July 14th 2008 at 11:02am
view embaltimore's profile

Mothballs don't repel rats - they cause cancer in the females, and interrupt the breeding cycle. And as Anna pointed out above, this couldn't be a more dangerous bit of advice. More specifically, mothballs are often paradichlorobenzene, and the chlorine atoms can convert to hydrochloric acid. Hey, get rid of the middle man and just pour hydrochloric acid on your engine!

Next up, in the advice files - grease fire on the stove? Throw gasoline on it!

posted by nuni on July 14th 2008 at 11:15am
view nuni's profile

I didn't know this could happen but on February 10th of this year squirrels got into our attic and ate through the wiring and started a house fire. We had to move from the house we rented for almost 19 years. Would this prevent this in the attic of the house we moved into now?

posted by Tanya on July 14th 2008 at 12:21pm
view Tanya's profile

this is a story the new york times has covered, in the winter rats climb onto the engines of cars down on riverside drive by the park for warmth. however, when the cars are started in the morning the rats get killed by the heat and some motorists were only aware of the situation when the awful smell wafted into the passenger area. yes, new york still has a gritty side gang.

posted by patrickmc on July 14th 2008 at 12:55pm
view patrickmc's profile

Maybe, instead of driving with the mothballs in the engine (which sounds very dangerous and toxic) you could just make a mothball satchel, tie it up at night and (with a little reminder) take it off in the morning....Sounds like a hassel but worth the trouble if it keeps the mice from making home in your car and wreaking havoc....

posted by JennCurrell on July 14th 2008 at 1:13pm
view JennCurrell's profile

The same thing happened to a friend of mine who parks on the street in our neighborhood (East Village) and his mechanic also recommended moth balls. Apparently that is a common suggestion, since we also came across it in an old NY Times article on this subject:
link
It didn't seem like a great idea to me for all the reasons mentioned by other commenters, but he tried it and it didn't work anyhow.

posted by Tiny Banquet on July 14th 2008 at 1:44pm
view Tiny Banquet's profile

here in Switzerland, it is a member of the marten family -- an ugly nasty creature, and your insurance won't cover the damage... only thing to do is park inside...

posted by mschatelaine on July 14th 2008 at 10:17pm
view mschatelaine's profile

I love the fact that in the middle of this article is an advert for pest control - in Basingstoke, Hampshire, UK!! (a town of roundabouts!!)

posted by Violetsrose on July 15th 2008 at 3:10am
view Violetsrose's profile

I have heard crushed mint leaves repel rats. I have no idea if it's true, but it's safer than mothballs.

posted by meeva on July 15th 2008 at 1:17pm
view meeva's profile

why dont they just put mothballs all over the city to eradicate rats then?

posted by brownstone on July 15th 2008 at 4:52pm
view brownstone's profile

Mothballs are an old-fashioned toxic remedy (like cocaine*) as opposed to an non-toxic folk remedy (like lemon juice).

*just a point that just because something seems like kind of a "throwback" to a simpler era when people just used wholesome ingredients to solve major problems before the advent of chemiCOs and advertised brand names doesn't mean it wasn't chock full of hazard! Anyone who has ever whiffed a residual mothball on someone should be able to fathom that stuff ain't right. Nothing else smells like that!

posted by K T G on July 15th 2008 at 5:13pm
view K T G's profile

I live on the Upper West Side but had never heard about rats in cars -- until I drove 1,500 miles this summer and found what I thought was some dirt or leaves wedged in near the engine when I was filling the window washing fluid. When I nudged it with a stone, I found it had tiny ears and then a tail! It was a small mouse (or rat). My friends here tell me it couldn't be local and that I probably brought it all the way from NYC!
Anne B

posted by Anne B on July 16th 2008 at 3:55pm
view Anne B's profile

Feeds

RSS icon New York

+ City Feeds