apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


NY Good Questions: Any Info. On This Sofa?

6.11couch.jpgDear AT,

I just purchased this sofa on Craigslist and was going to reupholster it.

After doing a bit of web digging I’m having second thoughts!

The sofa has fabric ticking carrying the word ‘Dunbar’ and a tag that says “Dunbar Furniture Corp of IND”.

Based on a few sites, I beginning to think that this sofa might be worth more than the $175 I paid & I’d hate to impact the value by changing the upholstery!...


 
 
(Note: Include a pic of your problem and your question gets posted first.
Email questions and pics with QUESTIONS in subject line to:
newyork(at)apartmenttherapy(dot)com)
Link To All Good Questions

Does anyone know much about these sofas?

Should I refrain from recovering it?

Thanks! Wendy

Tags

seating - sofas & armchairs, Good Questions

Related Links

Share

Comments (19)

I have no idea, but its a beautiful piece. Congrats.

posted by MarieE123 on June 11th 2008 at 5:30am
view MarieE123's profile

If you don't plan to resell it then I would go ahead and cover it in whatever is going to make you happy, after all you're going to be the one living with it.

ps. $175 is a great price for such a nice looking couch!

posted by jick on June 11th 2008 at 5:32am
view jick's profile

there's more info here:
http://www.collectdunbar.com/hear_our_story_page3.html

posted by ange_lune on June 11th 2008 at 5:41am
view ange_lune's profile

Whoa, apparently I need to go into the upholstery business...

Since the seat and back rest cushions are separate it would be easy enough to make them. For the rest of the couch you can make a tailored cover. It would set you back two weekends, a bottle of wine and about 12 yards of fabric. Take a trip to the garment district and look in the fabric stores, remember always haggle, and you'll come out with something real nice.

Good luck!

posted by Imblebee on June 11th 2008 at 6:26am
view Imblebee's profile

I agree with boomer. It looks like furniture from the 70s to me.
1970s NOT 1770s.

By reupholstering it the impact you will make on its value will be whatever you pay to reupholster it. If you pay $1,000 to reupholster it that impact will be on your wallet but I doubt that you will ever be able to get more than $200 to $300 for it...even after you reupholster it...but if you like it -- do it.

It doesn't look like an antique to me so it's "used furniture."
What sites/links did you look at that lead you to believe it's a valuable sofa?

posted by Mr. Dangerous on June 11th 2008 at 6:32am
view Mr. Dangerous's profile

Boomer--

Dunbar is one of the best quality furniture makers in America - They don't use staples, pine, etc...

It is definately worthwhile to have this piece reupholstered - even if the OP spends $1500-2000 on the work, the sofa would be far better quality than anything that could be purchased new for the same money.

posted by bepsf on June 11th 2008 at 6:38am
view bepsf's profile

"Be aware though, that generally speaking it will be cheaper to buy a new sofa than to recover one."

This is completely incorrect information.

Shop around, hunt for a good price on fabric, and you could probably have that couch recovered for $500 t0 $800 in labor, plus fabric. Great quality fabrics can be found online and at remnant shops for $10/yd. That couch will probably need 15 yards @ 58" wide, including welting.

Good quality upholstery does not have to cost you $1500-$3000 (price of a new couch).

Been there, done it on two couches and two arm chairs.

posted by kimg924 on June 11th 2008 at 8:41am
view kimg924's profile

My advice. Regardless of what it costs make sure you feel comfortable with your decisions and who you choose to do the work.

Make sure the fabric you purchase is either backed or gets backed. This is a knit backing that helps strengthen the fabric and prolongs wear. Also, you should spend the money on new cushion fills. Unless the sofa has been reupholstered in the past few years with new fills it doesn't make sense to spend the money and upholster over old filling materials.

Definitely make sure the frame is in great shape. Also, this is a great time to make any minor design changes to the frame if you want. If you want the upholstery to last have the sofa and cushions covered in muslin prior to upholstery. This is an added expense but well worth it.

I view upholstering a sofa like having custom window coverings made. Don't skimp on the fabric, or the labor. Also, like painting your home, the most important thing is the prep work. Make sure you have your fabric backed and for best results make sure you have the sofa first covered in muslin.

Good luck,

posted by SBDesign on June 11th 2008 at 9:30am
view SBDesign's profile

Ed Wormley designed for Dunbar. Check 1st dibs.com to search for similar designs/prices to see what originals in great condition go for.

posted by kdel on June 11th 2008 at 10:24am
view kdel's profile

hmmm...looks like the dream sofa I've been looking for (no kidding--i really think that might be a wormley, a sofa I've wanted for years and haven't found. i can't believe you beat me to it on craigslist!!!!!). any chance you want to resell it?!?! if not, honestly, just get it nicely reupholstered and enjoy it. lucky duck!

posted by Raisa on June 11th 2008 at 11:19am
view Raisa's profile

ps i am dead serious about reselling it to me if you're interested...and for a lot more than $175.

posted by Raisa on June 11th 2008 at 11:20am
view Raisa's profile

fishing.... any upholsterer reccs in seattle?
I'm dying for help.

posted by DahliaCactus on June 11th 2008 at 11:57am
view DahliaCactus's profile

Thanks for all the info on this sofa! When I bought it I thought "Dunbar" was a furniture maker local to Vancouver, where an area of the city is known as Dunbar. Glad to find that I'm wrong!

If I keep it (not sure I can afford to keep a sofa that could cover a few mortgage payments - kdel, the prices on 1st dibs.com are insane), I am going to have it recovered. The cushions are filled with down, which I imagine would be really expensive to replace. Can the upholster clean/supplement the down to to restore full loftiness?

posted by Gursk on June 11th 2008 at 1:07pm
view Gursk's profile

I agree that having it reupholstered will bring you basically in the same range of getting a new couch. Sure, you CAN get it done for much cheaper, but you also CAN get a couch for really cheap too. If you're going to go through the trouble of refinishing such a quality frame, I would recommend against cutting corners and doing it at IKEA prices - you will get what you paid for.

posted by amt230 on June 11th 2008 at 1:30pm
view amt230's profile

Gursk,

I don't know about cleaning and supplementing the down and due to the age it might not make sense. Look into a down/feather envelope that will wrap a foam core. This will keep costs down and shouldn't be that expensive although it is all relative. I would assume that a good quality upholstery job would cost around $2K give or take depending on the fabric and what upholsterers charge in your area. But, you can look at it as an investment. A good upholstery job will last at least 10 years. If you decide to recover it sooner you won't have to deal with replacing the cushions or repairing the frame, etc. 10 years at $2K is only 55 cents a day. How could you go wrong!!!

posted by SBDesign on June 11th 2008 at 2:49pm
view SBDesign's profile

check out the Dunbar website: www.collectdunbar.com
for more information on their furniture and Wormley

posted by notsocooldad on June 11th 2008 at 5:00pm
view notsocooldad's profile

Thanks for the ideas on the cushions Boomer - they are currently all down filled & require plumping daily to look as they do in the picture. I couldn't have submitted one of them in their deflated state. :)

posted by Gursk on June 11th 2008 at 6:06pm
view Gursk's profile

I have a couple of Dunbar occasional chairs; they're nice pieces and I had no hesitation about recovering them.

You have a nice couch; make it nicer by making it just what you want. It's not an investment (as such, I doubt it would ever pay off).

posted by swanroad on June 11th 2008 at 6:31pm
view swanroad's profile

Since we have some knowledge folks discussing cushion construction, I've another question. I'm getting ready to purchase a good sofa for the first time. I have some physical limitations that mean I need a higher and, most importantly, a firmer seat (i.e. more supportive). Should I choose down, high density foam, or down/feather envelope around a foam core? Any insights would be greatly appreciated.

posted by kushkush on June 13th 2008 at 6:31pm
view kushkush's profile

Feeds

RSS icon New York

+ City Feeds