apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Which Wood Should I Use? Hardwoods vs. Softwoods
WoodWise

mr*sha*mme*r_wood_grain.jpg

Each species of wood exhibits a unique personality — some are easy going and fun to work with, others hardheaded and quick to snap. Woodworkers must psychoanalyze this manic material, turning character flaws into well-balanced furniture. To help you interpret wood’s many moods, I’ve compiled a little list of the most common species and their notable traits.

 
 

Lumber is split into two major groups: hardwoods and softwoods. Curiously, these classifications don't reflect the density or durability of the tree, rather the structure of its seeds. So while most hardwoods are in fact hard, somehow balsa is allowed to masquerade in the same category as ebony. That's as if I were allowed to play for the Yankees just because I knew how to spit. Below are some common hardwoods:

west_coast_hardwoods_ash.jpg
White Ash: Easy to work especially for steam-bending and laminating projects. Light grain finishes and stains beautifully. Fun fact: used to make baseball bats.

fence_fabric_birch.jpg
Birch: A highly affordable choice used in the production of plywood sheets and firewood. Also a favorite for woodturning and instrument making.

vandersteen_cherry.jpg
Cherry: An American classic. Salmony in color at first, but turns brown when exposed to sunlight. Prolonged contact with power tools can cause the wood to burn.

oceanside_aluminumMahogany.jpg Mahogany: A rich history of use in fine furniture. Currently difficult to come by due to preservation laws and logging shortages. Takes finishes and stains terrifically.

wood_magazine_maple.jpg
Sugar Maple: A very strong wood with straight grain and beautiful white coloring. Special varieties include curly maple and bird's eye maple.

wood_wonder_oak.jpg
White Oak: A highly durable wood with rich figuring. Can be tiresome to work with hand tools. Known for its use in Arts and Crafts style furniture.

edgewood_cabinetry_walnut.jpg Walnut: Spectacular grain coloring. Heartwood is a purple-tinged brown, sapwood is cream colored. Takes polish extremely well. My personal favorite.


Now for some softwoods...

lambethcustomdoor_douglas_fir.jpg Douglas Fir: Water resistant and commonly used as a building material. Given Santa's seal of approval for use as Christmas trees.

vicsalv_pine.jpg
Pine: Yellow colored with straight grain turns a rich amber over time. Softness allows for easy shaping, but wood is susceptible to denting.

bankshardwood_poplar.jpg Poplar: An affordable hobbyist’s wood, great for model-making. Few knots due to limited number of branches.

(Images: 1 Flickr member mr*sha*mme*r licensed for use under Creative Commons, 2 West Coast Hardwoods, 3 Fence Fabric, 4 Vandersteen, 5 Oceanside Aluminum, 6, Wood Magazine, 7 Wood Wonder, 8 Edgewood Cabinetry, 9 Lambeth Custom Door, 10 Victorian Salvage, 11 Banks Hardwood)


Johnny is currently blogging his experience as a student at Maine's Center for Furniture Craftsmanship. You can keep track of his projects on his blog, Woodlearner.

Tags

WoodWise

Related Links

Share

Comments (8)

Very helpful Johnny. Really enjoy your posts, very educational.

posted by Jeff Flemings on August 31st 2009 at 11:41am
view Jeff Flemings's profile

Gotta say...Woodwise is quickly becoming my favorite part of AT. I've already learn a good deal. Thanks!

http://www.donkeehouse.com

posted by bitdot on August 31st 2009 at 11:43am
view bitdot's profile

i love mahogany...and most dark woods, really. what gives different woods distinct coloration?

posted by cbauch on August 31st 2009 at 11:50am
view cbauch's profile

If you want to find out more about wood and who practices sustainable forestry The Forest Stewardship Council's website has a lot of really good information and resources for wood (building materials), paper and furniture that are certified FSC products.

http://www.fscus.org/productsearch/retailers/?category=1

posted by LoriSF on August 31st 2009 at 11:55am
view LoriSF's profile

any personal experiences (both good and bad) you can share from working with these different types of woods? Any pitfalls we should watch out for?

posted by elee on August 31st 2009 at 1:12pm
view elee's profile

We recently purchased a mango wood table (Basque collection from Crate & Barrel). We love the honey color and bench seating, but have noticed that it knicks really easily (we're talking a light toss of keys and setting down a purse on it made scrapes). Is there anything we can apply to make it tougher? The beeswax/orange oil polish restores the color the scrapes took off, and makes the knicks less noticeable, but they're still there...

posted by 925juliebean on August 31st 2009 at 1:59pm
view 925juliebean's profile

@925juliebean

The only thing that could harden it up is a coating of some kind. Lacquer helps quite a bit. I made a crib out of cherry, which is moderately hard, but you could still ding it without too much effort. After adding a layer of lacquer, it's hard as a rock.

@elee
with regards to most of the woods, the hardwoods all work very nicely, but some are harder to work than others. everything listed is pretty easy on your tools. its not until you get into more weatherproof woods, like teak, where your tools get worn down because of silica (i.e. sand) in the wood fibers that grinds your cutting edges down. mesquite is another particulary difficult wood to work. these basic domestics don't really have any downfalls when it comes to working them. finishing is another matter, and some of these woods (cherry, pine, soft maple) are prone to blotching when staining. two ways around this are to use more of a gel stain instead of a penetrating stain, and another is to do a very light washcoat of shellac which will help to seal up the pores, but of course the stain won't penetrate nearly as deeply.

@cbauch:
the color differences are just due to the heartwood of that tree. chatoyance, which causes things like pommele, curl, ribbon striping, etc., is due to the direction of the wood fibers themselves. figured wood is a whole other post though and can take up quite a bit of space.

posted by Brian K. on August 31st 2009 at 3:03pm
view Brian K.'s profile

Love the wood posts. I'd love to learn more about figured woods.

posted by jacasi on August 31st 2009 at 9:01pm
view jacasi's profile

Feeds

RSS icon New York

+ City Feeds