Name: Polly
Location: Pacific Heights
Type:2 Bedroom Flat in an 1800's Mansion
Years Lived: 1
On the West Coast, we rarely come across architecture that dates back a hundred years, so when we had the opportunity to visit Polly's historic home, we jumped at the chance. The apartment part of a Broadway St. mansion that was built in 1898. After only one year its original owners sold it to William H. Metson, a well-known attorney in SF. Thanks to the care of all of its owners, this home still boasts impeccable craftsmanship with beautiful details.

Like most historical homes, the story of this home is shaped by the overall history of San Francisco and Northern California. The mansion was custom build for a whopping $289,000 in 1898, featuring 7 bedrooms, 9 baths, a billiard room, a wine cellar, a bomb shelter, 8 fireplaces…and most important of all: amazing views of the Bay Area.

Mr. Metson's younger sister, Josephine married a gold rush millionaire Jafet Lindeberg, a Norwegian who moved from Alaska to San Francisco after making his fortune. However, the 1906 earthquake was a turning point for the Lindebergs, and they ended up moving to the Broadway house and lived there for the rest of their lives. In 1959, the Lindebergs sold the property to its current owners, the Quayle family, for $100,000. Five years later, after Josephine passed away, William and Phyllis Quayle moved in with their four children, a number of pets, and a live-in house keeper. The house still belongs to the same owners. Marky, who grew up in the house, described it as a paradise and a museum with the Lindebergs' original furniture and decor on display.
"The relics of fabulous wealth of the former residents...many objects of finery and great artisanship, graced the home. It was lovely living there. I could always find a place of solace away from my younger brothers."
The new owners respected the original craftsmanship and care that went into the building. They kept it in a "vintage condition, " preserving such details like the beautiful carved woodwork unpainted and keeping the elegant stained glass and fabulous light fixtures that are now antiques.

This house tour features only a small portion of the house: just one floor of the magnificent mansion. With its unobstructed view of the Bay and Golden Gate Bridge and quaint details like the built-in window seats and beautiful fireplaces, Polly's home is not only a slice of history of San Francisco, but celebrates some of the best aspects of the Bay Area.
Polly hired an interior designer to help her preserve the rich history of her new home, but also to make it feel more modern. Choosing a warm color palette of oranges, browns, and grays helped balance the wood detailing and wall panels, and she used subtle pops of aqua to connect the rooms together. She leaned more towards keeping the decor simple as anything too ornate would compete with the original details of the apartment.
The house is one of a kind. It is a reminder of how much architecture has changed in the past century. In times when everything is templatized, it gives us a reason to appreciate design and craftsmanship that went into old buildings. The beautiful woodwork, flooring, and historical details present in every room make it timeless.

Apartment Therapy Survey:
Style: 1890's meets Hollywood Regency & Vintage Modern.
Inspiration: The house was built in the late 1890's and all the light fixtures, stained glass windows, and the wall paneling in the living room are all from that period. My goal was to marry the Victorian style with Hollywood Regency and make it more modern.
One of my biggest inspiration were the views of San Francisco from the apartment. The layout of the living room was specifically designed around them. I wanted my family and friends to be able to enjoy beautiful sunsets over the city.
The furnishings and the colors were inspired by the historical details of the apartment. Specifically the wood paneling, stained glass windows, and the moose head in the living room which has been there since the house was built.
Favorite Element: All the original details of the property. The amazing master bathroom, the views from the living room windows, the white and silver wallpaper in the master bedroom with all the original fixtures, the orange staircase, stained glass, the woodwork throughout the home, and the fireplace that matches the home exterior.
Biggest Challenge: The biggest challenge was trying to make each room warm, inviting and comfortable while trying to make sure the style of the furnishings didn't clash with the period elements.
What Friends Say: This is a beautiful place with amazing views of San Francisco. When is the next party?
Biggest Embarrassment: The kitchen was built when the house was divided into separate apartments, so it's the only room that seems out of place from the rest of the apartment.
Proudest DIY: Master bedroom closet, equipped with Container Store's help.
Biggest Indulgence: Repainting and carpeting a rented apartment.
Best Advice: Getting advice from a designer as well as being there when contractors are working on things, so you can make sure they get done the way you want them to.
Resources: Bob Stoltz at Carpeteria., Alex at California Carpets, Jonathan Adler stores, and Past Perfect.
Lighting and flooring: Original
Thank You Polly and Marky!


White Enamel Flatwa...
Oh I Love pops of orange.. and the pillows & headboard is exactly what I am looking for :-)
There are 2 weeks left til the New Year so there better be something very good to top this one as best house tour.
What a lucky son-of-a-muh.
Amazing bathroom! The views are great, and the apartment has beautiful historic details - though I would not want a moose head in my apartment. However, I would not have tried to put such modern furnishings into the space, and I am not a fan of the orange at all. I would prefer to see some antiques. And I would not have put that carpeting over the wood floor. To me, Hollywood regency does not fit this space, which would be better served by either an airier, more organic style or rich exotic colors and lush Victorian furnishings. That said, everything is certainly coordinated well and the decorator certainly sticks with a style.
Oh, and that Audrey Hepburn picture was just in another room featured on AT: http://www.apartmenttherapy.com/ny/fall-2009/the-fall-cure-send-us-your-photos-one-of-two-103727
I HATE Hollywood Regency, so...I really have to applaud the designer who put this together, as I think it is *superb*. It's beautiful, highly livable, and really captures the energy and style of SF right now. I would take this place in a heartbeat.
i feel like the decor is at odds with the architecture of the space. it feels kind of tense to me and not in the interesting way. though i actually like the decor and style a lot, i just don't feel it meshing with this particular space.
however i think the bathroom and bedroom work really well.
Fabulous! And you have a conservatory in the backyard??? Drool..........
Love and adore the mix of old and new. And I'm currently in love with the orange, grey and brown color scheme. Beautifully, beautifully done.
Kids, do not play with the Christmas lights in the bathtub! Kidding, but serious...
Seems a bit mish-mashy without reconciling the eclecticity . . . amazing views though obviously!
It's an amazing space -
- but something tells me that the bombshelter wasn't part of either the original 1898 build or the $289,000 pricetag - but a later 1950's addition.
I am mostly a fan of modern decor in historic homes, however I find this combination unsettling. The house is amazing and demands to rule it's Victorian patch. The decor is also very, very attractive but feels so out of place here. It would be exquisite in a simpler form of architecture, new or old.
Historic, not historical. Just fyi.
I see lots of Jonathan Adler inspiration. Beautiful home. Anyone else concerned about those lights by the tub?
LOVE the windowseat and the view. not so much the moose head but each to their own.
what are those ubiquitous things..Balloons? Cushions? Ceramic sculptures?
I don't mind modern furniture in a Victorian --- it can look very sophisticated. But the thing that throws me a bit on this place is that all the modern furniture feels like it was bought together at one moment in time to coordinate perfectly, and that doesn't feel right in this historic home. Much better when modern furnishings are collected over time and not so coordinated. AT ran a house tour of an Italian home a few weeks ago that totally mastered it: http://www.apartmenttherapy.com/chicago/house-tours/luciano-house-tour-097522
I love it but it doesn't seem to match the wonderful details of the house. The Audrey Hepburn art I believe was from Ikea, it's like cheap art and for such a marvelous home?
Come on, there are great underground artists in the world, there are so many options other than this Ikea reproduction. But it's your home not mine and you can do whatever you wish. :)
Yes, Ninacruz! That's at least part of the problem with running out to "decorate" instead of collecting things over time that you truly love ... including, and above all art.
"In the US, we rarely come across architecture that dates back a hundred years..."
huuuuuuhhh??? maybe in THAT part of the US, although I doubt it. there are many, many homes that are over 100 years old in all parts of the US. Especially here in New England, there are houses from the 1600s and 1700s.
I know THAT is rare in some parts of the country...but over 100 years old? not THAT rare...
Absolutely fabulous, Polly!!!!! I'm so jealous of those amazing views. Give your designer a big, fat, and sloppy kiss because is wondrous and totally inspiring!
Other city bloggers, take note. This is what a house tour should be all the time. No more mediocre, please. There are to many great places out there.
That was supposed to "this is wondrous and totally inspiring!"
I love so many things about this but I do have one question--isn't the string of lights blocking the shower? How do you get in?
I'm not only jealous of the people who live in this apartment, I'm even jealous of the person who got to go in and photograph this apartment. What a treat!
Hundred years old? Big whoop.
Love,
The Entire East Coast And Half The Southwest.
Where did the kitty cats on the mantle come from, what are they made of??? So cute!!!!
An Historic. There, I fixed that for ya. Cool crib, though.
i hate you!!!
while i appreciate this home, i have to agree with an earlier comment in that it feels too staged, too perfect. i do however like the pops of orange and, of course - ohmygod - those views.
Oh. My. God.
Now THAT, THAT RIGHT THERE, is an inspiring space. Wow.
The bathroom is amazing - that shower...!!! The views, the furniture, the amazing class & style... I can't even articulate all the lovely.
Lars7208, you're right, there are plenty of hundred year old houses in SF. I was confused by that too. Even in more recently developed areas like LA, there are 100 year old homes. They aren't too rare. What is rare, though, may be the scale of this one and the fact that it still has details like an original moosehead.
Oh, and alisonk, whether or not you put "an" or "a" in front of "historic" depends on pronunciation, I believe. If you pronounce the h, you needed make it "an."
um Lars7208 and JosieDaisy - Did you ever hear about the big San Francisco earthquake and fire of 1906? Most of the city was burned - so yeah, a 100 year old flat in this part of the world is something to celebrate.
What is it - a competition?
Lovely place.
Goodness, it makes such a difference when the bones of a home are so attractive. You don't need much to make a stunning home, then.
am i mistaken or is this place no available to rent?
http://sfbay.craigslist.org/sfc/apa/1515038985.html
$6550? That is way too much money to pay for rent.
looks like the same place, but they painted over all the orange...
for an apartment like this in Pacific Heights, $6550 is not surprising.
Nice space. That is A LOT of Jonathan Adler!
Although I love this house, I don't like the marriage between the old architectural features and the modern furniture in the living room.
Loved the house itself but thought the choice of decor was unfortunate... and that string of lights in the bathroom is one of those things that make me go "hmmm". But hey, if the owner's happy that's all that matters!
It's so nice that so many of the important original elements have been left untouched -- the wood in the living room, those amazing light fixtures, the plumbing in the bathroom -- the conservatory! It's wonderful to see all the bones of the home in place (even after having been divvied up into apartments). The current decor is trendy and transient, and it may have had all sorts of furniture and decoration throughout the years (and likely will continue to have), but the structure itself retains its original character. That's great respect for historic preservation.
Very very nice!!! I think the old and new work very well.
And I love the little orange TV... how many otherwise attractive rooms are ruined by ginormous flatscreen monstrosities? Finally a TV I could live with!
I think the designer did an amazing job marrying the old and the new... just because a space has original (and specific) character, doesn't mean it can't transcend that style and become something else. I absolutely love it... wish I could live there!
On a separate note, where oh where is that orange and white rug from... someone please help me source it!
gorgeous!! so inspiring. Just what i needed to put me in a good mood. Anyone who says otherwise is just jealous. OK, but maybe a little too much Jonathan Adler :)
This is such an amazing space, but I can't for the life of me understand why you would spend all kinds of money on those obviously custom area rugs (you can see them in some photos following the lines of the fireplace hearths) to cover up those fabulous floors.
oh, and I forgot to add that I enjoyed hearing the history of the building in this post; a great addition!
I love this place so much it *hurts* a little. Really, really gorgeous. Obviously the history of the home, the way it has been preserved, the views and everything are spectacular and I love that AT posted this. I think the furnishings are great. Maybe not my personal style, but still great. You did a fantastic job and I hope you love every moment you are living in such beauty! My only complaint is that a more detailed list of resources would be helpful : )
What an amazing bathroom! A lovely house, but I agree that something is just not right with the styling. I feel like some editing could have taken place with the furniture. With so much to look at with the interior details, cleaner lines and fewer pieces would open up the space and extend out into their lovely views. I do like the bench seating around the window though...
The apartment itself is stunning...I agree with posters that the style of the interior feels forced and is competing with more than complementing the fabulous shell. The scale and placement of the furnishings is good and I'm not bothered by all the lucite but why all the pattern? Dots and peeping faces and faux baroque-y modern things on upholstery and cushions and rugs...it just ends up looking very cheap. That kind of "busy" uber-decorated look seems to work better where there isn't so much architectural detail. There's so much to work with (or against) here - the wood paneling, the moldings, the leather built in seats and the amazing lighting fixtures. And what is up with the xmas lights? Is that seasonal? It looks like the tenant was constrained by some rules (if you see the craigslist listing) - 70% of floor space must be covered by carpeting and it looks like the moose is there to stay. I thought the use of carpeting throughout was also a bit weird so that explains that. I would have loved to see this place with simple, modern, luxe furnishings. Oh well.
That said, the bedroom succeeds admirably.
alisongilb, the rug is from ikea.
i like it a lot. the string of lights in the bathroom seems like maybe it was a styling choice for the shoot, honestly. same story with the... balloons?
either way, i love the moose and i love the bedroom.
I'm pretty much with juliaonhamilton on this one. In my mind, there's a reason that big graphic patterns go better with a more modern, clean-lined space. In this place, I want to look at something, but what? The beautifully detailed architecture, the gorgeous views, or the giant orange circles on the pillows? Can't look at it all at the same time, so it gets overwhelming and makes me a bit tense. Like at a crowded shopping mall.
Lucky Bums!
I love the windows and the colors and i like the way the lights are drapped.I am not to fond of the moosehead because I love animals.What a wonderful place.
Are you kidding me? Those views of SF are crazy beautiful!
As soon as I saw the first photo, with the dead moose head, I had no need to look at any other photos.
Dead animal heads are not decor!
What happened to Polly?
She moved in about a year ago and spent all that money decorating and painting it, but has already moved out?
Did Polly submit to AT for this house tour or the building's owner who now has it listed for rent? If the latter, shame on them for taking advantage of AT and us. If the former, why is Polly submitting a house tour after she's already moved out and with no mention of that?
I think I may be in love.
finehowaboutyou.blogspot.com
are you kidding me? this place is amazing. who cares if it's filled with jonathan adler and pier one. take out all the furniture and throw a mattress on the floor .... it's still an incredible place.
This place is amazing. It's a very unique space. I love the old and new and think it was done well. I also don't mind that it looks "too perfect". To me that just means that the designer did their job. I think it's admirable to bring in professional help when needed.
"Hardly OSHA friendly"
What would the US Department of Labor, Occupational Safety and Health Administration have to do with someone's shower?
It's not exactly a workspace...
Wow. House decorated by Jonathan Adler. Love his stuff, but is it too much of a good thing?
As noted in the text above, the mansion has been divided into three flats. Polly apparently lives in the first floor flat and the owner of the building (Phyllis Quayle) lives in the top floor flat. The remaining flat is the one advertised for rent on Craigslist.
I actually live a block away from this house (in an apartment that doesn't face the Bay!) and I was very interested to get to see the interior of another of the flats. I love all the original woodwork, but I agree with those above who have said the furnishings are incongruous vis a vis the bones of the space. Overall, I don't like it.
Oops, my mistake. The Craigslist posting refers to this very article on AT.
Seems like a classic tale of someone not "getting to know" their space before they start to "stage" it. I agree with some of the other posters....It does not seem to be a real home. We don't know anything about her. Does she curl up for tea and look out at the view, or does she invite friends over for martinis? There was nothing personal about this home. Some of the greatest house tours are where you feel like you really get to know someone just by looking at their ideas, decor, and overall sense of style. As Americangypsyliving stated, "You could just throw a mattress on the floor...." I think I would have preferred seeing just a mattress and the beautiful bones of this space, than the other contrived things she put in this home. That would have been more interesting than this 'showroom'.
Gorgeous house with original details....especially gorgeous views with a conservatory thrown in...what a very lucky occupant! I love the bathroom with the original tub and the fireplaces, not to mention the fabulous stained glass windows. The furnishings seem a little at odds with the character of the home, but the beauty of the place itself overrides it. In fact, if it didn't have any furniture...I would still love it!
From the Criagslist ad "This article was written and the photos were taken before the previous tenant moved out so it shows the flat with her furnishings. The fabulous flat is now vacant! ;-) "
I think the owner posted this to help rent out the apartment. :(
Wow. Just gorgeous. I love the modern feel against the old charm. The lighting is amazing. Why would anyone ever move out of this?!?
If you ever decide to get rid of that moose head, please please please, call me. I will gladly take it off of your hands. Having so much trouble finding those here in the Bay Area.
All I could think of while looking at this site was that it's a good thing it is a rental. Otherwise, someone with this taste would have moved in and just had to take out some of the light fixtures, and they would be writing in to AT to see if they should paint the woodwork and modernize the fireplace.
I am so happy that all of that is intact with the marvelous views! If I lived there I would feel so fortunate and would probably decorate it in a completely different way, but that's what makes the world go around!
I love orange but this just looks like they ordered EVERYTHING from Jonathan Adler...not much inspiration. Even Jonathan Adler himself would think there's too much of his stuff in this home.
The moosehead was mounted when the house was brand new in 1898, from what i understand. Notice the wood wall behind the moose...an oval shape to facilitate the oval shape of the moosehead. Bullwinkle was part of the original design and is now over 100 years old just as the house is...
Given San Francisco burned down after the earthquake in 1906, a home from before 1906 is rare.
Every time I am in San Francisco I look at mansions like this one and wonder what they are like on the inside. It's nice to see a glimpse of this home, although I think a floor plan would have helped orient the space and allow the viewer to distinguish between common areas and private rooms.
It is true that the great earthquake and fires of 1906 destroyed much (but not all) of the city. It is also true that 1906 was more than 100 years ago now. So anything built in the years immediately after the fire could now be a century old. Sorry to state the obvious, but...
On an unrelated note, the string of lights in the bathroom absolutely ruined that room for me. It just looks dumb and gimmicky--not at all what that apartment needs.
I don't know how many times this needs to be said in order for people to truly get it: CHRISTMAS LIGHTS ARE FOR CHRISTMAS TREES AT CHRISTMAS TIME. They are not design-not even in a dorm room, where they are often employed. Otherwise. that bathroom is to die for, but then, I'm a sucker for subway tile :)
Gorgeous and heartless.
that orange rug..i've seen it from ikea in a round shape - do they make a square or rectangular shape?? i would buy it in a second!
~ Agree with Thorndale. FABULOUS VIEW! How I miss SF.
I can't say I'm truly in love with the way this place is decorated, but wow, people! You'd think she had really done something awful to the place after reading your comments. Geeeez! Get a grip!
I agree that the fairy lights are overdone. What's the point of all those darn fairy lights? And the style seems quite matchy-matchy, which is at odds with the space.
That said, I find it easy to be picky when things rub me the wrong way!